The future of peripheral nerve neurostimulation

Electrical Stimulation Induced Current Distribution in Peripheral Nerves Varies Significantly with the Extent of Nerve Damage: A Computational Study Utilizing Convolutional Neural Network and Realistic Nerve Models

Electrical stimulation of the peripheral nervous system is a promising therapeutic option for several conditions; however, its effects on tissue and the safety of the stimulation remain poorly understood. In order to devise stimulation protocols that enhance therapeutic efficacy without the risk of causing tissue damage, we constructed computational models of peripheral nerve and stimulation cuffs based on extremely high-resolution cross-sectional images of the nerves using the most recent advances in computing power and machine learning techniques. We developed nerve models using nonstimulated (healthy) and over-stimulated (damaged) rat sciatic nerves to explore how nerve damage affects the induced current density distribution. Using our in-house computational, quasi-static, platform, and the Admittance Method (AM), we estimated the induced current distribution within the nerves and compared it for healthy and damaged nerves. We also estimated the extent of localized cell damage in both healthy and damaged nerve samples. When the nerve is damaged, as demonstrated principally by the decreased nerve fiber packing, the current penetrates deeper into the over-stimulated nerve than in the healthy sample. As safety limits for electrical stimulation of peripheral nerves still refer to the Shannon criterion to distinguish between safe and unsafe stimulation, the capability this work demonstrated is an important step toward the development of safety criteria that are specific to peripheral nerve and make use of the latest advances in computational bioelectromagnetics and machine learning, such as Python-based AM and CNN-based nerve image segmentation.

Electrical Stimulation Induced Current Distribution in Peripheral Nerves Varies Significantly with the Extent of Nerve Damage: A Computational Study Utilizing Convolutional Neural Network and Realistic Nerve Models

Although electrical stimulation is an established treatment option for multiple central nervous and peripheral nervous system diseases, its effects on the tissue and subsequent safety of the stimulation are not well understood. Therefore, it is crucial to design stimulation protocols that maximize therapeutic efficacy while avoiding any potential tissue damage. Further, the stimulation levels need to be adjusted regularly to ensure that they are safe even with the changes to the nerve due to long-term stimulation. Using the latest advances in computing capabilities and machine learning approaches, we developed computational models of peripheral nerve stimulation based on very high-resolution cross-sectional images of the nerves. We generated nerve models constructed from non-stimulated (healthy) and over-stimulated (damaged) rat sciatic nerves to examine how the current density distribution is affected by nerve damage. Using our in-house numerical solver, the Admittance Method (AM), we computed the induced current distribution inside the nerves and compared the current penetration for healthy and damaged nerves. Our computational results indicate that when the nerve is damaged, primarily evidenced by the decreased nerve fiber packing, the current penetrates deeper inside the nerve than in the healthy case. As safety limits for electrical stimulation of biological tissue are still debated, we ultimately aim to utilize our computational models to determine refined safety criteria and help design safer and more efficacious electrical stimulation protocols.

Electrode Spacing and Current Distribution in Electrical Stimulation of Peripheral Nerve: A Computational Modeling Study using Realistic Nerve Models

Electrical stimulation of peripheral nerves has long been used and proven effective in restoring function caused by disease or injury. Accurate placement of electrodes is often critical to properly excite the nerve and yield the desired outcome. Computational modeling is becoming an important tool that can guide the rapid development and optimization of such implantable neural stimulation devices. Here, we developed a heterogeneous very high-resolution computational model of a realistic peripheral nerve stimulated by a current source through cuff electrodes. We then calculated the current distribution inside the nerve and investigated the effect of electrodes spacing on current penetration. In the present study, we first describe model implementation and calibration; we then detail the methodology we use to calculate current distribution and apply it to characterize the effect of electrodes distance on current penetration. Our computational results indicate that when the source and return cuff electrodes are placed close to each other, the penetration depth in the nerve is shallower than the cases in which the electrode distance is larger. This study outlines the utility of the proposed computational methods and anatomically correct high-resolution models in guiding and optimizing experimental nerve stimulation protocols.

Evolving Techniques and Indications in Peripheral Nerve Stimulation for Pain

Peripheral nerve stimulation is the direct electrical stimulation of named nerves outside the central neuraxis to alleviate pain in the distribution of the targeted peripheral nerve. These treatments have shown efficacy in treating a variety of neuropathic, musculoskeletal, and visceral refractory pain pathologies; although not first line, these therapies are an important part of the treatment repertoire for chronic pain. With careful patient selection and judicious choice of stimulation technique, excellent results can be achieved for a variety of pain etiologies and distributions. This article reviews current and past practices of peripheral nerve stimulation and upcoming advancements in the field.

Occipital Nerve Stimulation

Although the first publications on clinical use of peripheral nerve stimulation for the treatment of chronic pain came out in the mid-1960s, it took 10 years before this approach was used to stimulate the occipital nerves. The future for occipital nerve stimulation is likely to bring new indications, devices, stimulation paradigms, and a decrease in invasiveness. As experience increases, one may expect that occipital nerve stimulation will eventually gain regulatory approval for more indications, most likely for occipital neuralgia, migraines and cluster headaches. This process may require additional studies, at least for approval from the US Food and Drug Administration.

Peripheral nerve stimulation: a percutaneous minimally invasive approach

We report on the use of a new percutaneous technique for peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) treatment of chronic pain. A 56-year-old woman was diagnosed with algodystrophic syndrome, now called Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, type 2 (CRPS2), due to a lesion of the right medial nerve despite surgical revascularization, angioplasty and stent insertion. After a successful 10-day trial of PNS via a percutaneous quadripolar lead in the interscaline space, an implantable pulse generator was implanted in the abdominal subcutaneous tissue and connected to the subcutaneous lead via an extension. After one year of follow-up, the patient was still experiencing good pain relief. We conclude that this novel percutaneous PNS technique offers the advantage of being a minimally invasive approach that can be easily adopted for the management of chronic pain.

Repositioning of supraorbital nerve stimulation electrode using retrograde needle insertion: a technical note

INTRODUCTION

With growing interest and acceptance of peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) approach, there is now an increasing need in developing clear procedural details to resolve frequent complications and minimize associated tissue injury. Migration and suboptimal positioning of PNS electrodes are one of the most commonly observed complications of PNS approach.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We present a simple technique for repositioning a supraorbital electrode using retrograde insertion of introducer needle that allows one to place percutaneous (cylindrical) PNS electrode into appropriate anatomical location with minimal additional injury to surrounding tissues.

RESULTS

This approach has been successfully used in multiple cases. An illustrative case of electrode revision with proposed technique is described in detail.

CONCLUSION

This technically simple approach to repositioning of cylindrical supraorbital electrodes using retrograde needle insertion eliminates the need for a more elaborate and invasive procedure. The technique can be used for electrode repositioning in most PNS applications.

Peripheral nerve stimulation for neuropathic pain

Peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) has been used for treatment of neuropathic pain for more than 40 years. Recent resurgence of interest to this elegant surgical modality came from the introduction of less invasive implantation techniques and the wider acceptance of neuromodulation as a treatment of medically refractory cases. This article reviews the literature on the use of PNS for neuropathic pain and describes current indications and hardware choices in frequent use. Published experience indicates that neuropathic pain responds to PNS in many patients. PNS works well in both established indications, such as post-traumatic and postsurgical neuropathy, occipital neuralgia, and complex regional pain syndromes, and in relatively new indications for neuromodulation, such as migraines and daily headaches, cluster headaches, and fibromyalgia. Future research and growing clinical experience will help in identifying the best candidates for PNS, choosing the best procedure and best hardware for each individual patient, and defining adequate expectations for patients and pain specialists.

Stimulation of the occipital nerve for the treatment of migraine: current state and future prospects

Migraine is a common disabling malady. Despite the development of therapeutic agents such as the triptans, a significant number of patients continue to suffer. The evolution of peripheral nerve stimulation for headache management, may significantly improve the management of those who suffer from moderate to refractory migraine symptoms.

Peripheral nerve stimulation for the treatment of neuropathic craniofacial pain

Treatment of neuropathic pain in the region of head and face presents a challenging problem for pain specialists. In particular, those patients who do not respond to conventional treatment modalities usually continue to suffer from pain due to lack of reliable medical and surgical approaches. Peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) has been used for treatment of neuropathic pain for many decades, but only recently it has been systematically applied to the craniofacial region. Here we summarize published experience with PNS in treatment of craniofacial pain and discuss some technical details of the craniofacial PNS procedure.

Occipital neurostimulation for treatment of intractable headache syndromes

Intractable migraine and other headache syndromes affect almost 40 million Americans and many more millions worldwide. Although many treatment protocols exist, mainly designed around medication regimens, there are estimated to be at least 3-5% of these headache sufferers that do not respond in a meaningful way to medications and whose lives can be severely restricted to darkened, quiet rooms, heavy doses of narcotics, failed personal relationships and an overwhelming sense of hopelessness. In this article, we describe current neuromodulation-based approach to the management of intractable headache.

Anchoring of Suboccipital Lead: Case Report and Technical Note

Suboccipital stimulation is a relatively new method of neuromodulation for treatment of intractable occipital headache and occipital neuralgia. The most common complication besides an infection is a lead displacement. Anchoring of a lead at the entry place partially solves the problem. Migration of electrode's tip is a major problem so far. A case report of electrode migration and a technique of retrograde lead insertion and subcutaneous anchoring of the tip by means of contralateral incision and suturing of lead is described.

Interventional modalities in the treatment of complex regional pain syndrome

Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) applies to a variety of conditions in which symptoms such as allodynia and hyperalgesia predominate along with hyperpathia and vasomotor/sudomotor disturbances. The incidence of CRPS in the chronic pain population varies and is difficult to determine, though it appears to affect women more than men. Treatment is multidisciplinary, and recovery of function and the reduction of pain are the main goals of treatment;this article addresses some of the interventional modalities that are used.

The relationship between dorsal horn neurotransmitter content and allodynia in neuropathic rats treated with high-frequency transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation

OBJECTIVE

To examine the relation between axon terminal neurotransmitter content in the dorsal horn and allodynia in neuropathic rats treated with high-frequency transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation (TENS).

DESIGN

A completely randomized experimental design. Two groups of rats received a chronic constriction injury to the right sciatic nerve, and 2 groups did not. The rats were either treated or not treated with TENS.

SETTING

Research laboratory.

ANIMALS

Adult male Sprague-Dawley rats (150-165g).

INTERVENTIONS

TENS was delivered daily for 1 hour to the chronic constriction injury rats or to the uninjured rats through self-adhesive electrodes applied to the skin innervated by the right dorsal rami of lumbar spinal nerves 1 to 6.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Thermal and mechanical pain thresholds were assessed bilaterally in the hind paws of all rats twice before the chronic constriction injury surgery (baseline) and then 12 days after the surgery. An analogous time frame of assessment was used for rats that did not have chronic constriction injury surgery. Thermal and mechanical allodynia were expressed as difference scores between the pain thresholds of the right and left hind paws. These values were normalized to differences that existed between the 2 paws at baseline. The amino acid content of dorsal horn axon terminals was assessed bilaterally with high-pressure liquid chromatography, and values were normalized to wet weight.

RESULTS

The mean level of thermal and mechanical allodynia did not differ between the TENS-treated and untreated rats with chronic constriction injury. However, there was a significant relation between the dorsal horn, axon terminal content of glutamate (adjusted R(2)=.45, P<.01) and glycine (adjusted R(2)=.51, P<.005) and the magnitude of mechanical allodynia present in TENS-treated chronic constriction injury rats, but not in any other group. As axon terminal glutamate and glycine decreased in the right dorsal horn and increased in the left, mechanical allodynia was reduced or absent. When this trend was reversed, mechanical allodynia was more severe. Daily TENS also reduced the mean axon terminal content of aspartate, glutamate, and glycine bilaterally in the chronic constriction injury rats from the level observed in untreated neuropathic rats (P<.05).

CONCLUSION

The variability in responsiveness of mechanical allodynia to daily TENS treatment in neuropathic rats is related to the axon terminal content of glutamate and glycine in the dorsal horn. These findings may help explain a similar variability in humans when TENS is used to treat neuropathic pain.

Peripheral nerve neurostimulation

There is a renewed interest in the use of PNS for the control of intractable pain caused by peripheral mononeuropathies and sympathetically mediated chronic pain syndromes. Technical advances in neurostimulation hardware, specifically lead design and surgical advancements with percutaneous and subcutaneous techniques, fuel this interest in part. The use of multipolar electrode arrays placed percutaneously in the region of peripheral nerves or in their dermatomal distribution without the need for extensive surgical dissection should help to support the use of PNS as a reasonable alternative to potentially destructive surgical procedures for chronic pain control.

Spinal cord stimulation: patient selection, technique, and outcomes

Spinal cord stimulation, as with neuromodulation procedures in general, is a nondestructive, screenable, and reversible treatment option. Because there are no long-term side effects that have been reported; spinal cord stimulation is generally preferable as a first step when other less invasive treatments have failed to produce acceptable control of the pain.

A-fiber sensory input induces neuronal cell death in the dorsal horn of the adult rat spinal cord

Excitotoxicity due to excessive synaptic glutamate release is featured in many neurological conditions in which neuronal death occurs. Whether activation of primary sensory pathways can ever produce sufficient over-activity in secondary sensory neurons in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord to induce cell death, however, has not been determined. In this study, we asked whether activity in myelinated afferents (A fibers), which use glutamate as a transmitter, can induce cell death in the dorsal horn. Using stereological estimates of neuron numbers from electron microscopic sections, we found that stimulation of A-fibers in an intact sciatic nerve at 10 Hz, 20 Hz, and 50 Hz in 10-minute intervals at a stimulus strength that activates both Abeta and Adelta fibers resulted in the loss of 25% of neurons in lamina III, the major site of termination of large Abeta fibers, but not in lamina I, where Adelta fibers terminate. Furthermore, sciatic nerve lesions did not result in detectable neuron loss, but activation of A fibers in a previously sectioned sciatic nerve did cause substantial cell death not only in lamina III but also in laminae I and II. The expansion of the territory of A-fiber afferent-evoked cell death is likely to reflect the sprouting of the fibers into these laminae after peripheral nerve injury. The data show, therefore, that primary afferent A-fiber activity can cause neuronal cell death in the dorsal horn with an anatomical distribution that depends on whether intact or injured fibers are activated. Stimulation-induced cell death potentially may contribute to the development of persistent pain.