Effects of Contrast Sensitivity on Colour Vision Testing

Assessment of visual function and the neuroretina in subjects diagnosed with congenital anomaly of color vision

This cross-sectional and observational study includes 50 eyes of subjects with color blindness and 50 eyes of control subjects. Visual function (visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and color vision) and neuroretinal structure were assessed in all subjects using optical coherence tomography (OCT). Significant thinning of the retinal nerve fiber layer, ganglion cell layer, and retina were observed in the color blindness group. Significant thinning was also recorded in layers that involve photoreceptor nuclei (between the outer limiting layer and the Bruch membrane and between the outer plexiform layer and the outer limiting membrane). OCT evaluation based on retinal segmentation is a rapid (5-10 minutes) non-invasive technique and seems to be a good biomarker of color blindness.

Testing a Popular Smartphone Application for Colour Vision Assessment in Healthy Volunteer Subjects

We aimed to compare the Ishihara pseudoisochromatic colour vision test with a colour vision test from a popular smartphone application (EyeHandBook [EHB]) using digital image processing to simulate colour vision deficiencies. Three digital versions of the Ishihara and EHB slides were created: full colour; 32 bit- greyscale (removing all colour information); and blue channel (to simulate red-green colour vision deficiencies). Twenty healthy volunteers were shown each colour-edited plate. The answers they reported were compared with what would be expected for that colour-simulation scenario based on the answer key provided in the Ishihara booklet ("expected" answer). There were nine plates that had comparable patterns between the EHB and Ishihara test. We found no significant difference in the overall proportion of "expected" answers for the full colour (p = .35), 32 bit-greyscale (p = .39) and blue channel (p = .22) conditions. There were significant differences between the proportion of "expected" answers among six individual colour- edited plates (p < .05 for each). Colour vision assessment from the EHB is distinct from comparable Ishihara plates. Clinical scenarios that require serial assessment of colour vision may benefit from using the same modality consistently rather than exchanging between the two tests with the assumption of equivalence. Refinement of digital colour editing techniques beyond 32-bit greyscale and RGB channel splitting is necessary in order to accurately simulate colour vision deficiency.

Comparison of a Smartphone Application with Ishihara Pseudoisochromatic Plate for Testing Colour Vision

The Eye Handbook (EHB) is the most frequently downloaded smartphone application with diagnostic tools for eye-care providers. However, limited data exists validating the EHB test to gold standard colour vision testing. EHB and Ishihara colour vision tests were evaluated and compared under simulated colour vision loss through use of image processing software. Images of both tests were processed through ImageJ to 32 bit-grey scale and blue channel under split RBG channel to model total colour vision loss and red-green (R-G) deficiency, respectively. Two colour plates differentiated R-G deficiency from total colour blindness in EHB compared with eight Ishihara plates. Without colour information, correct numerals were identified in 3.5/15 EHB plates converted to 32-bit greyscale, versus 1/16 in Ishihara. We conclude EHB may underestimate colour vision loss severity in persons with normal contrast sensitivity compared to Ishihara. Eye-care providers need to be aware of the potential inconsistency compared to standardised methods, including limitations in differentiating patients with R-G colour deficiencies from total colour blindness.