Order and Disorder in a Liquid Crystalline Bilayer: Pulsed Field Gradient NMR Studies of Lateral Phase Separation

Liquid Disordered-Liquid Ordered Phase Coexistence in Lipid/Cholesterol Mixtures: A Deuterium 2D NMR Exchange Study

Model membranes composed of two types of long chain phospholipids, one unsaturated and one saturated, along with cholesterol can exhibit two coexisting fluid phases (liquid disordered ([Formula: see text]) and liquid ordered ([Formula: see text])) at various temperatures and compositions. Here we used 1D and 2D ²H NMR to compare the behavior of multilamellar dispersions, magnetically oriented bicelles, and mechanically aligned bilayers on glass plates, all of which contain the same proportions of dipalmitoleoylphosphatidylcholine (DPoPC), dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC), and cholesterol. We found that multilamellar dispersions and bilayers aligned on glass plates behave very similarly. These samples were close to a critical composition and exhibit exchange of the lipids between the two fluid phases at temperatures near the [Formula: see text] to [Formula: see text]-[Formula: see text] phase boundary. On the other hand, when a short chain lipid is added to the ternary long chain lipid/cholesterol mixture to form bicelles, the phase behavior is changed significantly and the [Formula: see text] phase occurs at a higher than expected temperature. In addition, there was no evidence of exchange of lipids between the [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] phases or critical fluctuations at the temperature where the bulk of the sample enters the two-phase region for these bicelles. It appears that the addition of the short chain lipid results in these samples no longer being near a critical composition.

Quantifying the molar percentages of cholesterol in supported lipid membranes by time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry and multivariate analysis

The uneven cholesterol distribution among organelles and within the plasma membrane is postulated to be critical for proper cellular function. To study how interactions between cholesterol and specific lipid species contribute to the uneven cholesterol distribution between and within cellular membranes, model lipid membranes are frequently employed. Although the cholesterol distributions within membranes can be directly imaged without labels by using time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS), quantifying the cholesterol abundance at specific membrane locations in a label-free manner remains a challenge. Here, partial least-squares regression (PLSR) of TOF-SIMS data is used to quantitatively measure the local molar percentage (mol %) of cholesterol within supported lipid membranes. With the use of TOF-SIMS data from lipid membranes of known composition, a PLSR model was constructed that correlated the spectral variation to the mol % cholesterol in the membrane. The PLSR model was then used to measure the mol % cholesterol in test membranes and to measure cholesterol exchange between vesicles and supported lipid membranes. The accuracy of these measurements was assessed by comparison to the mol % cholesterol measured with conventional assays. By using this TOF-SIMS/PLSR approach to quantify the mol % cholesterol with location specificity, a better understanding of how the regional lipid composition influences cholesterol abundance and exchange in membranes may be obtained.

Diffusion NMR and bicelle morphology

This minireview focuses on diffusion NMR studies in bicelles. Following a discourse on diffusion fundamentals, and a comparative overview of fluorescence and NMR-based techniques for measuring diffusion, the pulsed field gradient (PFG) NMR diffusion method is introduced, emphasizing its specific advantages and limitations when applied to diffusion measurements in macroscopically oriented lamellar systems such as magnetically aligned bicelles. The utility of PFG NMR diffusion measurements in bicellar model membrane systems for examining lateral diffusion of membrane-bound molecular species is demonstrated, along with certain features of lateral diffusion that such studies illuminate. Further, those aspects of bicelle morphology that have been resolved using PFG NMR diffusion studies of various molecular weight soluble polymeric species are reviewed. The discussion concludes with an outline of future prospects for diffusion NMR studies in bicelles.

Structural investigation on the adsorption of the MARCKS peptide on anionic lipid monolayers - effects beyond electrostatic

The presence of charged lipids in the cell membrane constitutes the background for the interaction with numerous membrane proteins. As a result, the valence of the lipids plays an important role concerning their lateral organization in the membrane and therefore the very manner of this interaction. This present study examines this aspect, particularly regarding to the interaction of the anionic lipid DPPS with the highly basic charged effector domain of the MARCKS protein, examined in monolayer model systems. Film balance, fluorescence microscopy and X-ray reflection/diffraction measurements were used to study the behavior of DPPS in a mixture with DPPC for its dependance on the presence of MARCKS (151-175). In the mixed monolayer, both lipids are completely miscible therefore DPPS is incorporated in the ordered crystalline DPPC domains as well. The interaction of MARCKS peptide with the mixed monolayer leads to the formation of lipid/peptide clusters causing an elongation of the serine group of the DPPS up to 7Å in direction to surface normal into the subphase. The large cationic charge of the peptide pulls out the serine group of the interface which simultaneously causes an elongation of the phosphodiester group of the lipid fraction too. The obtained results were used to compare the interaction of MARCKS peptide with the polyvalent PIP(2) in mixed monolayers. On this way we surprisingly find out, that the relative small charge difference of the anionic lipids causes a significant different interaction with MARCKS (151-175). The lateral arrangement of the anionic lipids depends on their charge values and determines the diffusion of the electrostatic binding clusters within the membrane.

Lateral diffusion in sphingomyelin bilayers

Sphingomyelin (SM) is an important lipid of eukaryotic cellular membranes and neuronal tissues. We studied lateral diffusion in macroscopically oriented bilayers of synthetic palmitoylsphingomyelin (PSM) and natural sphingomyelins of egg yolk (eSM), bovine brain (bSM) and bovine milk (mSM) by pulsed field gradient NMR (PFG NMR) in the temperature range 45-60 °C. We found that the mean values of lateral diffusion coefficients (LDCs) of SMs are 1.9-fold lower compared with those of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), which is similar in molecular structure. This discrepancy could be explained by the characteristics of intermolecular SM interactions. The LDCs of different SMs differ: egg SM is most similar to PSM; both of them have a 10% higher LDC value compared with the other two natural SMs. Besides, all natural SMs show a complicated form of the spin-echo diffusion decay (DD), which is an indicator of a distribution of LDC values in bilayers. This peculiarity is explained by the broad distributions of hydrocarbon chain lengths of the natural SMs studied here, especially mSM and bSM. We confirmed the relationship between chain length and LDC in the bilayers by computer analysis of a set of (1)H NMR spectra obtained by scanning the value of the pulsed field gradient. There is a correlation between lower LDC values and SM molecules with longer acyl chains. The most probable mechanisms by which long-chain SM molecules decrease their lateral diffusion relative to the average value are protrusion into the other side of the bilayer or lateral separation into areas that diverge with their LDCs.

Phase equilibria in DOPC/DPPC-d62/cholesterol mixtures

There is broad interest in the question of fluid-fluid phase coexistence in membranes, in particular, whether evidence for liquid-disordered (l(d))-liquid-ordered (l(o)) two-phase regions or membrane "rafts" can be found in natural membranes. In model membrane systems, such phase behavior is observed, and we have used deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy to map the phase boundaries of ternary mixtures containing 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC), chain-perdeuterated 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC-d(62)), and cholesterol. For both this ternary model system and the binary DPPC-d(62)/cholesterol system, we present clear evidence for l(d)-l(o) two-phase coexistence. We have selected sample compositions to focus on this region of fluid-fluid phase coexistence and to determine its temperature and composition ranges. The deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance spectra for compositions near the l(d)-l(o) phase boundary at high cholesterol concentrations show evidence of exchange broadening or critical fluctuations in composition, similar to that reported by Vist and Davis. There appears to be a line of critical compositions ranging from 48 degrees C for a DOPC/DPPC-d(62)/cholesterol composition of 0:75:25, to approximately -8 degrees C for the composition 57:14:29. At temperatures below this two-phase region, there is a region of three-phase coexistence (l(d)-l(o)-gel). These results are collected and presented in terms of a partial ternary phase diagram that is consistent with previously reported results of Vist and Davis.

The liquid-ordered phase in membranes

A range of physiological processes has been imputed to lateral domain formation in biological membranes. However the molecular mechanisms of these functions and the details of how domain structures mediate these processes remain largely speculative. That domains exist in biomembranes and can be modeled in relatively simple lipid systems has contributed to our understanding of the principles governing phase behaviour in membranes. A presentation of these principles is the subject of this review. The condensing effect of sterols on phospholipids spread as monomolecular films at the air-water interface is described in terms of the dependence of the effect on sterol and phospholipid structure. The thermodynamics of sphingomyelin-cholesterol interactions are considered from calorimetric, densitometry and equilibrium cholesterol exchange measurements. Biophysical characterisation of the structure of liquid-ordered phase and its relationship with liquid-disordered phase is described from spectroscopic and X-ray scattering studies. Finally, the properties of liquid-ordered phase in the context of membrane physiology and permeability barrier properties are considered.

Application of pulsed field gradient NMR with high gradient strength for studies of self-diffusion in lipid membranes on the nanoscale

This work demonstrates the feasibility of noninvasive studies of lipid self-diffusion in model lipid membranes on the nanoscale using proton pulsed field gradient (PFG) NMR spectroscopy with high (up to 35 T/m) gradient amplitudes. Application of high gradients affords for the use of sufficiently small diffusion times under the conditions when the width of the gradient pulses is much smaller than the diffusion time. As a result, PFG NMR studies of partially restricted or anomalous diffusion in lipid bilayers become possible over length scales as small as 100 nm. This length scale is important because it is comparable to the size of membrane domains, or lipid rafts, which are believed to exist in biomembranes. In this work, high-gradient PFG NMR has been applied to study lipid self-diffusion in three-component planar-supported multibilayers (1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycerol-3-phosphocholine/sphingomyelin/cholesterol). The degree of lipid orientation in the bilayers was determined with (31)P NMR. A special insert was designed to mechanically align the multibilayer stack at the magic angle with respect to the direction of the constant magnetic field to address the detrimental effects of proton dipole-dipole interactions on the NMR signal. This insert is an alternative to the conventional method of magic angle orientation of lipid membranes, the goniometer probe, which is not compatible with commercial high-gradient coils because of the lack of space in the magnet bore. Macroscopic orientation of the multibilayer stacks using the insert was confirmed with (1)H NMR spectroscopic studies and the comparison of results obtained from identical experiments using a goniometer probe for orientation. Diffusion studies were carried out at three different constant magnetic field strengths ( B 0) over a range of temperatures and diffusion times. The measured diffusivities were found to be in agreement with the data obtained previously by techniques that are limited to much larger length scales of diffusion observation than high-gradient PFG NMR.

Domain formation in model membranes studied by pulsed-field gradient-NMR: the role of lipid polyunsaturation

The effects of increased unsaturation in the sn-2 fatty acyl chain of phosphatidylcholines (PCs) on the lipid lateral diffusion have been investigated by pulsed-field gradient NMR. Macroscopically oriented bilayers containing a monosaturated PC, egg sphingomyelin, and cholesterol (CHOL) have been studied at temperatures between 0 degrees C and 60 degrees C, and the number of double bonds in the PC was one, two, four, or six. For PC bilayers, with and without the incorporation of egg sphingomyelin and CHOL, the lateral diffusion increased with increasing number of double bonds, as a consequence of the increased headgroup area caused by the unsaturation. Addition of CHOL caused a decrease in lipid diffusion due to the condensing effect of CHOL on the headgroup area. Phase separation into large domains of liquid-disordered and liquid-ordered phases were observed in the ternary systems with PCs containing four and six double bonds, as evidenced by the occurrence of two lipid diffusion coefficients. PC bilayers with one or two double bonds appear homogeneous on the length scales probed by the experiment, but the temperature dependence of the diffusion suggests that small domains may be present also in these ternary systems.