Chemically induced resistance to heat treatment and stress protein synthesis in cultured mammalian cells

Induction of cystine transport and other stress proteins by disulfiram: effects on glutathione levels in cultured cells

Disulfiram (Antabuse) (DSF) has been reported to protect rats and other animals from the effects of hyperbaric hyperoxia at 4 to 6 ATA (atmospheres). In contrast, DSF and diethyldithiocarbamate (DDC), its metabolite, accelerate the toxic effects in rats of 100% oxygen at 1 to 2 ATA. We have examined the effects of DSF and DDC on glutathione (GSH) levels in bovine pulmonary artery endothelial cells and Chinese hamster ovary cells. Increases in intracellular GSH occurred 8 to 24 h after addition of DSF to the culture media. These increases in intracellular GSH were associated with increases in the rate of uptake of cystine into the cells. DDC was a less effective inducer of cystine uptake and increased intracellular GSH levels than was DSF. At the concentrations used, neither DDC nor DSF caused significant decreases in intracellular superoxide dismutase levels. Exogenous sulfhydryl compounds including GSH and cysteine partially blocked the induction of cystine transport by DSF or DDC, suggesting that the induction might be mediated through a sulfhydryl reaction between DSF and some cellular components. The increases in GSH in the cultured cells were not significant by 4 h of exposure. In contrast, other stress proteins including heme oxygenase are induced by 2 to 4 h after DSF addition. In previously reported in vivo studies, DSF treatment protected against hyperbaric oxygen damage after as little as 1 to 4 h pre-exposure. This suggests that effects of DSF exposure other than GSH augmentation may be responsible for the protective effects seen in vivo.

Induction of the 72-kD heat shock protein in human skin melanoma and squamous cell carcinoma cell lines

Heat shock proteins (HSPs) or stress proteins comprise a characteristic group of proteins synthesized in cells exposed to heat or other environmental stimuli. Of the many HSPs, the 72-kD heat shock protein (HSP72) is the most stress-inducible one. In the present study, we examined the effects of heat, chemicals (azetidine and sodium arsenite), ultraviolet (UV) light, and gamma-ray irradiation on the induction of HSP72 in cultured human skin melanoma cell lines (P-39 and G-361), a human skin squamous cell carcinoma cell line (HSC-1), and an SV40-transformed human lung fibroblast cell line (WI38VA13) as a control. In these cell lines, heat treatment induced HSP72 more rapidly and intensely than did chemical exposure. Compared with the SCC cell line, the two melanoma cell lines produced less HSP72 with heat treatment. UVC irradiation (20 J/m2) induced HSP72 only in the WI38VA13 cells. After gamma-ray irradiation, no HSP72 induction was detected in any of the cell lines examined. These observations suggest that, in cultured cells, inducibility of HSP72 depends not only on the inducer but also on the origin of each cell line.

Effects on the expression of heat shock proteins by step-down heating and hypothermia in rat hepatoma cells with a different degree of heat sensitivity

Thermosensitization induced by pretreatment at supra- and subnormal temperatures, rate of protein synthesis and expression of the major heat shock proteins under such conditions was investigated in relation to intrinsic heat sensitivity of rat hepatoma cells, i.e. Reuber H35 and HTC. The high degree of heat susceptibility of H35 cells was reflected by a high degree of thermosensitization after pretreatment by heat (step-down heating) at temperatures of 42-44 degrees C for 30 min or cold for 16 h at temperatures ranging from 0 to 25 degrees C. Sensitization under step-down heating conditions was found to be paralleled by a delayed recovery of protein synthesis. Despite an increased relative rate, enhancement of the absolute rate of synthesis of the major heat shock proteins, HSP28, HSP60, HSP68, HSP70, HSP84 and HSP100, was less pronounced during step-down exposure. Comparable results were obtained during recovery of sensitized H35 cells at 37 degrees C after exposure to heat following pretreatment at 0 degrees C. Furthermore, clear differences in the regulation of the specific HSP synthesis, depending on the particular treatment protocol, were observed.

Binding activity of glucocorticoid receptors after heat shock

The response of glucocorticoid receptors (GR) to heat was measured by the change in ligand binding activity both in control cells and in cells made tolerant to heat by a prior mild heat exposure. The study was prompted by earlier data showing that one of the heat shock proteins (HSP90) is an essential component of the GR complex and that treatment of mammalian cells with hydrocortisone induces resistance to heat damage. The GR rapidly loses binding activity after commencement of heating. There is a 50% loss of activity after 4 min at 45 degrees C, 8 min at 44 degrees C, or 17 min at 43 degrees C. The reduction in binding is due mainly to a reduction in affinity of binding to the ligand. The ability to bind glucocorticoid recovers quickly after heat treatment. Activity returns to levels 60-80% of normal by 2 h after a heat treatment that initially reduces binding to less than 20% of normal. However, complete restoration of binding activity takes approximately 3 days. The recovery of binding activity does not require protein synthesis. Pretreatment of cells with hydrocortisone, using conditions that induce heat resistance, reduces the activity to 10-20% of control, but residual receptors display a heat sensitivity similar to that of control cells. There was evidence for a limited degree of protection of GR from heat damage in thermotolerant cells.

Possible involvement of ubiquitin function and ATP requirement in the development of thermotolerance in mammalian cells

Thermotolerance under chronic exposure to moderate hyperthermia at 41 degrees C was hardly induced in the mouse temperature-sensitive mutant ts85 cells, in contrast to the parental wild-type FM3A cells. Thermotolerance was induced at a reduced level in the mutant cells compared with the wild-type cells by incubation at 33 degrees C (permissive temperature), but not at 39 degrees C (non-permissive temperature), after a brief exposure at 44 degrees C. Under conditions where protein synthesis was inhibited by cycloheximide at 41 degrees C, significant amounts of thermotolerance developed in FM3A cells. FM3A cells depleted of cellular ATP by treatment with 2.4-dinitrophenol and 2-deoxyglucose were not sensitized to thermal cell killing at 44 degrees C, when drug-treated cells were washed and exposed to hyperthermia in drug-free growth medium, where cellular ATP rapidly recovered. However, the cells deprived of ATP under the treatment at 41 degrees C failed to develop thermotolerance, indicating a requirement of ATP for thermotolerance development. The decay of thermotolerance was not affected by ATP levels after it was developed. The degradation of abnormal cellular proteins which contained amino acid analogues was promoted at 33 degrees C relative to normal protein degradation in FM3A and ts85 cells. Both normal and abnormal proteins were degraded at a reduced rate at 43 degrees C. Pretreatment of cells at 41 degrees C decreased the rate of degradation of abnormal proteins at 33 degrees C by 20% in FM3A cells and by about 100% in ts85 cells. Pretreatment of cells at 41 degrees C increased significantly the conjugation of 125I-labeled ubiquitin to cellular endogenous proteins in extracts of FM3A cells, but decreased the conjugation in extracts of ts85 cells. The data presented here, in conjunction with the observations by others that the ts85 cell is a mutant defective in the ubiquitination of cellular proteins at nonpermissive temperatures, suggest that the ATP-dependent ubiquitination may be crucial for the development of thermotolerance.

Defect in the development of thermotolerance and enhanced heat shock protein synthesis in the mouse temperature-sensitive mutant ts85 cells upon moderate hyperthermia

The effect of exposure to moderate hyperthermia on the induction of thermotolerance and heat shock protein (HSP) synthesis was investigated using mouse FM3A cells and the temperature-sensitive mutant ts85 cells. The thermal sensitivity of the two cell lines was markedly different; the mutant ts85 cells were more sensitive than the parental wild-type FM3A cells to heating at 41 and 44 degrees C. The shift-up treatment of FM3A cells for 3 h at 39.5 degrees C from 33 degrees C induced thermotolerance development to subsequent heating at 44 degrees C, with little if any enhancement of major HSP synthesis. On the other hand, the similar treatment of ts85 cells at the non-permissive temperature of 39.5 degrees C induced significantly enhanced HSP synthesis, but could not induce thermotolerance. The exposure to 41 degrees C also induced thermotolerance in the wild-type cells, but failed to induce tolerance in the mutant ts85 cells. These results suggest that enhanced major-HSP synthesis is neither a sufficient or necessary condition for thermotolerance development upon moderate heat shock. The mechanism of thermotolerance is discussed by relating the observed defect in thermotolerance development to the known defect in ubiquitin-dependent protein degradation system of the mutant ts85 cells at non-permissive temperature.

Uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation does not induce thermotolerance in cultured Chinese hamster cells

Two uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation, 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) and carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP), were tested for their ability to modify the survival of cultured Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) and Chinese hamster V79 cells treated with hyperthermia. The uncouplers were used under conditions that inhibit oxidative ATP synthesis, as judged from measurements of cellular ATP levels. Incubation of CHO cells in glucose-free Hanks' balanced salt solution (HBSS) containing 1 mM DNP for 1 h at 37 degrees C followed by reincubation at 37 degrees C in complete growth medium for 3 or 16 h, showed no substantial changes in the 45 degrees C heat survival curve as compared to heated cells not exposed to DNP. Thus, DNP treatment of CHO cells did not induce thermotolerance. Carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP), tested under similar experimental conditions, did alter cellular heat resistance. The major change in the 45 degrees C survival curve of CHO cells pretreated with CCCP was an increase in the width of the shoulder: the Dq value increased from 14 min to 24 min, for the control and CCCP-treated cells respectively. The D0 value did not change appreciably. In contrast, heat-induced thermotolerance (10 min, 45 degrees C + 16 h, 37 degrees C) was characterized primarily by an increase in the D0 parameter from 4 min (unheated cells) to 17 min. Similar results were observed with CCCP-treated V79 cells. The data demonstrate that heat resistance induced by 1.2 microM CCCP was manifest as an increased cellular capacity to accumulate and/or repair hyperthermia damage, rather than an induction of thermotolerance, and that this effect probably was not related to the action of CCCP as an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation.

A role for reduced oxygen species in heat induced cell killing and the induction of thermotolerance

A model suggesting a role for superoxide (O2-) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) in heat induced cytotoxicity and development of thermotolerance is proposed: (1) Heat shock increases cellular generation of O2- and H2O2 in proportion to the severity of the heat shock. (2) Heat induced generation of O2- or H2O2 in excess of the ability of the antioxidant enzymes to remove these toxic species causes heat induced cell injury and cytotoxicity. This damage is caused by lipid peroxidation, leading to disruption of the cytoskeleton and calcium metabolism. (3) The flux of O2- and H2O2 generated by heat shock induces the synthesis of additional antioxidant enzymes. Other treatments which induce thermotolerance also cause oxidative stress and induce the antioxidant enzymes. The ability of various agents to modify heat induced cytotoxicity and development of thermotolerance is reviewed in light of this model.

Thermotolerance induced by heat and ethanol

The effect of ethanol and heat on the thermosensitivity of 3-day-old larvae of the fresh water snail Lymnaea stagnalis is investigated, especially with regard to the kinetics of thermotolerance, the effect on protein synthesis and the pattern of proteins synthesized. Both stress factors, in a mild dose, induce a state of thermotolerance with the following characteristics: (i) it is not accompanied by an enhanced synthesis of HSPs, (ii) it needs only 10-30 min to develop maximally, and (iii) it decays within 60-90 min after it has been triggered. At a higher dose both factors induce an enhanced synthesis of the HSP 65, HSP 70, and HSP 87, and also a more stable state of thermotolerance beside the thermotolerant state present shortly after the trigger. It appears that the synthesis of HSPs is enhanced only when the overall protein synthesis is depressed. The data are discussed in relation to the putative functions of heat shock proteins. It is suggested that the constitutive levels of the HSPs provide the rapid protection against heat. An induced level of HSPs is necessary for the extension of the thermotolerant state.

Thermotolerance induced by 2,4-dinitrophenol

The capacity of 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) to induce thermotolerance in 3-day-old larvae of Lymnaea has been investigated. Induction of thermotolerance is dependent on the DNP concentration, the duration of treatment, and on the pH of the medium. Optimal conditions for the induction of thermotolerance are 10 min, 2.5 mM DNP at pH 4.7. Thermotolerance has been expressed in percentages of survival. Thermotolerance is maximal at 15 min after DNP treatment and decreases subsequently. DNP suppresses protein synthesis. Recovery starts 20 min after treatment, when thermotolerance is decreasing already. DNP does not induce the synthesis of the typical heat shock proteins (HSPs). It is concluded that DNP induces a state of thermotolerance of short duration, which is not accompanied by HSP synthesis.