A comparison of the reproducibility of the parameters of the ¹³C-aminopyrine breath test for the assessment of hepatic function

The evaluation of the repeatability of the 13C-ketoisocaproate breath test for assessing hepatic mitochondrial function

The ¹³C-ketoisocaproate (¹³C-KICA) breath test (BT) has been recently proposed as a non-invasive test for assessing hepatic mitochondrial function. Results of the ¹³C-KICA BT can be expressed as different parameters. However, the best parameter for expressing the ¹³C-KICA BT result is uncertain which hinders use of the BT in routine clinical practice. We have investigated the repeatability of different parameters of ¹³C-KICA BT. Thirteen healthy adult subjects (5 men and 8 women) underwent a ¹³C-KICA BT on two occasions separated by a gap of approximately 30 days. There were no significant differences between the repeated measurements for all the test parameters over 30 days. Furthermore, the Bland Altman statistics showed no fixed or proportional bias for any of the test parameters. The cumulative ¹³C-dose enrichment over 60 min had the lowest within-subject variability of 12% compared to all other test parameters. The cumulative ¹³C-dose enrichment over 60 min could be a very useful parameter for the ¹³C-KICA BT to detect impaired hepatic mitochondrial function in patients with chronic liver diseases.

13C-aminopyrine demethylation is decreased in cirrhotic patients with normal biochemical markers

This study determined the rates of (13)C-aminopyrine metabolism in patients with varying degrees of liver cirrhosis as defined by clinical scores. Twenty-five cirrhotic patients and 18 healthy subjects underwent a (13)C-aminopyrine breath test. The cumulative per cent dose recovery (cPDR) of (13)C on breath expressed as a percentage of the administered dose at 2 h was significantly lower in cirrhotic patients than in healthy subjects (median: 1.7% versus 9.0%; p<.0001). Significant inverse associations between cPDR at 2 h and the model for end-stage liver disease score, Child-Pugh score, international normalised ratio and bilirubin (all p<.05), but not alanine aminotransferase or alkaline phosphatase were observed in the cirrhotic patients. Taking each biochemical marker independently, cirrhotic patients with normal biochemistry had a significantly lower cPDR at 2 h than healthy subjects (all p<.05). Differences in (13)C-aminopyrine metabolism were evident in cirrhotic patients with less severe disease and may mark hepatic dysfunction when conventional biochemical markers appear unchanged.

¹³C-methacetin breath test in the evaluation of disease severity in patients with liver cirrhosis

AIMS

The non-invasive (13)C-methacetin ((13)C-MBT) breath test has been proposed as a measure of metabolic liver function that improves the diagnostic efficacy of serologic and biochemical tests in assessing hepatic functional capacity and liver disease severity, The goal of this study was to establish the clinical utility of this test in quantifying hepatic metabolic function in patients with liver cirrhosis of varying severity and to compare (13)C-MBT measurements with the AST/ALT ratio, APRI score, and other routine liver tests.

METHODS

Routine liver function tests including serum bilirubin, aspartate aminotransferase activity (AST), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), AST/ALT ratio, the APRI score, the percentage of dose rate (PDR) and cumulative percentage of dose rate (CPDR) of the (13)C-MBT were evaluated in 52 cirrhotic patients of alcohol etiology (Child-Pugh A/B/C 10/28/14) and 37 healthy controls.

RESULTS

The (13)C-MBT differed significantly between healthy controls and cirrhotic patients at all time intervals measured. It also proved the ability to differentiate patients with liver cirrhosis based on severity of hepatic impairment corresponding to the Child-Pugh classification A vs. B vs. C. The ROC curve analysis suggested that the best prediction is provided by time intervals between the 10th - 20th or 10th - 40th minute of PDR.

CONCLUSIONS

The (13)C-MBT offers a reliable means for quantification of hepatic metabolic function over the complete range of functional liver impairment. It is non-invasive, easy to perform and completely safe.

Clinical utility of 13C-liver-function breath tests for assessment of hepatic function

13C-Liver-function breath tests have been used in clinical diagnostics and, to a limited extent, to investigate hepatic function. From a practical perspective, tests such as the 13C-aminopyrine and 13C-methacetin breath tests are simple to administer, safe, and relatively inexpensive to perform. Surprisingly, they have not entered the mainstream of clinical practice, because they are perceived to lack the specificity and adequate precision needed to give accurate results in real time. The dynamic nature of 13C-liver-function breath tests, their possible versatility in terms of assessing a range of different liver functions, and the ease with which they can be repeated to follow relative changes in liver function with time, all imply the potential for wider clinical application. Therefore, there is a need for these tests to be critically evaluated and their potential clinical application be tested systematically against defined objectives. We describe refinements in the methodology of the tests and propose several situations in which currently reliable methods for assessment of liver function do not exist and where 13C-liver-function breath tests might be of use. We propose that use has been constrained by practical methodological considerations which could be addressed to offer tests better suited to routine application in the out-patient or community setting.