Lectin‐mediated attachment assay for teratogens: Results with 32 pesticides

Alternative Tests for Teratogenicity

Summary

The major features of the tests surveyed are shown in Table I. In a tier system of tests for teratogenicity, the Chernoff test is at a different level than the other assays described here. It is not appropriate for screening large numbers of chemicals, but may be useful for studies of smaller groups of agents, for example to confirm data from a prescreen. Although the test is certainly easier, cheaper and uses less than half the animals of a Segment II test, it is still much more expensive and time-consuming than most alternative tests.

Of the remaining alternatives, whole embryos or organs in culture encompass the widest range of mammalian developmental events and are invaluable in the study of teratogenic mechanisms. They are, however, also inappropriate for screening large numbers of chemicals. The methods are technically demanding, relatively expensive and use reasonably large numbers of pregnant mammals. To screen a group of, say, 20 chemicals involves a considerable investment of time and, in fact, no study of this size has been reported. In certain specific circumstances, they may be a useful adjunt to testing; for example, if treated human serum samples are freely available, if a drug has a unique action on rodent dams which confounds evaluation of the standard in vivo tests, or if human metabolism is important and can be mimicked in vitro.

Sub-mammalian and sub-vertebrate species offer considerable advantages; reduced cost, relative rapidity and no requirement for laboratory animals. FETAX provides some indication of teratogenicity in relation to embryotoxicity, while CHEST and the planarian and Drosophila assays measure only teratogenic potential, or more strictly speaking, embryotoxic potential, although it should be possible to derive some assessment of hazard with each of the latter systems. The Hydra system is cheap, quick and easy and is commercially available. It is the only assay specifically designed to estimate teratogenic hazard and may offer considerable advantages as an alternative screen.

The metabolic cooperation assay has not generated sufficient data to enable evaluation. The neural crest cell assay is not well developed as a routine screen, and objective endpoints which are not measures of general cytotoxicity must be devised. The viral morphogenesis and Drosophila embryo cell assays have both produced encouraging validation data. With further assessment, the viral system may be shown to be useful, but it is a relatively complex assay and its relevance to teratogenesis is obscure. The Drosophila system is easier, has been used with more chemicals and is developmentally relevant. However, it has not produced dose-response data to evaluate potency or hazard, and must be improved so that it can more clearly distinguish cytotoxicity. The measurement of endpoints in the neuroblastoma cell line assay requires further refinement, and contributions of growth inhibition or stimulation to effects on differentiation must be examined. In combination, tumour cell attachment and HEPM may prove valuable. Alone, HEPM appears to be an assay for cellular toxicity, not teratogenicity, and the attachment assay suffers from a high rate of false negatives because it measures only one cell phenomenon. Although micromass cultures use mammalian tissue, are not the cheapest assays and require some skill for full evaluation of the results obtained, they show considerable promise. Validation data are encouraging, the assay includes several developmental processes and the use of multiple endpoints permits specific developmental toxicities to be evaluated.

Cytotoxicity test using blastocyst-derived euploid embryonal stem cells: a new approach to in vitro teratogenesis screening

To develop a mammalian in vitro system for teratogenicity testing, cytotoxicity of xenobiotics was evaluated in pluripotent euploid embryonal stem cells (ESC) derived from mouse blastocysts. The dimethyl-thiazol-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide (MTT) assay was the most appropriate test system for cytotoxicity determinations with ESC. Only compounds that do not require metabolic activation were selected for testing from the database for validation of in vitro teratogenesis assays by Smith et al. Results obtained with ESC were compared to corresponding data from fibroblasts from day-14 mouse embryos to detect differences in sensitivity between undifferentiated and differentiated cells. ESC showed a higher sensitivity to known teratogens than fibroblast cultures, which allows calculation of a sensitivity ratio of "adult" cells (differentiated fibroblasts) to embryonal cells (undifferentiated ESC) in a mammalian system similar to the hydra assay. Although some xenobiotics had to be classified as false negatives in our system, the ESC cytotoxicity assay holds promise as a new in vitro screening assay in teratology.

Mutagenic evaluation of the organophosphorus insecticides methyl parathion and triazophos in Drosophila melanogaster

The possible genotoxic effects of the organophosphorus insecticides methyl parathion and triazophos were evaluated by their ability to induce gene and chromosome mutations in male germ cells of Drosophila melanogaster. Sex-linked recessive lethal (SLRL), total and partial sex-chromosome losses (SCL), and non-disjunction (ND) assays were conducted. The routes of administration included adult feeding, injection, and larval feeding. Methyl parathion was unable to induce point mutations or chromosome mutations, although a small increase in the frequency of non-disjunction was detected after larval treatment. Triazophos induced point mutations when assayed in the SLRL test and induced a weak increase in the non-disjunction frequency, but gave negative results in the SCL test.

Human placental glutathione S-transferase-mediated metabolism of methyl parathion

The ability of human placental glutathione S-transferase (GSHTr) to metabolize methyl parathion (MeP) was examined. MeP was found to be a substrate for both partially purified pre-term and highly purified term placental GSHTr. The characterization of the reaction by high performance liquid chromatography revealed the presence of desmethyl parathion (DesMeP) as the sole metabolite. Term placental GSHTr activity towards MeP ranged from 2.22 to 3.53 nmoles DesMeP formed X min-1 X mg-1 while an activity of 0.60 to 1.12 nmoles DesMeP formed X min-1 X mg-1 was observed with the pre-term placental enzyme. The absence of the O-dearylation reaction by pre-term and term placental GSHTr represents a major species- and/or tissue-specific difference.

On the application of cultured neuroblastoma cells in chemical toxicity screening

The acute toxic action of a number of common chemicals was tested by their ability to cause detachment of cultured mouse neuroblastoma C1300 cells. A TD25 value was obtained by graphic estimation of the concentration needed to cause 25% of the total cell number to detach. These TD25 values were compared with LD50 values obtained from the literature, and they were found to correlate with a coefficient of 0.86. For six of the tested substances-diuron, butylated hydroxytoluene, benzidine, cyclophosphamide, Na2SeO3, and KCN-a very poor correlation was obtained. These diverging results could be ascribed to deficiencies in the neuroblastoma cell detachment test and emphasize the necessity for combined in vitro test procedures.