Variation in decomposition stages and carrion insect succession in a dry tropical climate and its effect on estimating postmortem interval

Vulture Exclusion Halves Large Carcass Decomposition Rates and Doubles Fly Abundance

Carcass consumption by scavengers plays a critical role in wildlife and human health by providing services that maintain ecosystem functioning and potentially mitigate disease spreading. Vultures are particularly efficient scavengers, but their populations have sharply declined in Europe, Asia and Africa, raising concerns about similar declines in the comparatively less studied species of the Americas. While the effects of vulture absence on other vertebrate scavengers have been examined, the impact on invertebrate scavengers and their role in carrion decomposition remains unexplored. To determine the effects of vulture decline, specifically neotropical cathartid vultures, we experimentally excluded this functional group from domestic pig carcasses (Sus scrofa) in Costa Rica, under different habitat conditions (grassland and forest) and across seasons with the aim to assess the impact of vulture exclusion on carrion decomposition and insect abundance. Vulture exclusion halved carcass decomposition rates relative to control carcasses without exclusion. Accordingly, vulture abundance at control carcasses was positively correlated with carcass decomposition rate. Vulture exclusion doubled fly abundance at carcasses relative to controls but did not significantly impact dung beetle abundance at carcasses. These findings suggest that neotropical vultures are instrumental in rapid carrion decomposition, a service that invertebrates alone cannot fully compensate for, underscoring the potential ecological and public health risks associated with neotropical vulture declines and increased flies at carrion sites. Further research is needed to understand the broader implications of vulture loss on ecosystem services and zoonotic disease transmission in the Neotropics.

Pig carcass decomposition dynamics: Insights into carcass disposal for emergency animal disease management

Australia is free from many economically devastating emergency animal diseases (EADs) that threaten livestock production in neighbouring countries. In Australia, an important consideration for EAD control is managing susceptible feral animal populations, especially in remote and inaccessible areas where carcass disposal poses considerable logistical challenges. One proposed solution is to utilise natural decomposition above ground through the 'destroy and let lie' (D&LL) method, relying on post-mortem changes in carcass temperature and pH to inactivate the EAD agent. We investigated temperature and pH changes in pig carcasses from death until end-stage decomposition at two locations in Queensland to gain insights into how carcasses left in situ decompose under Australian conditions. Using regression modelling, we identified days since humane killing, air temperature, rainfall, relative humidity, anatomical site and study location as significant predictors of carcass pH and temperature. Although the observed carcass pH and temperature conditions did not meet African swine fever virus (ASFV) inactivation thresholds, foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) was likely to be inactivated in the thoracic cavity, superficial and deep skeletal muscle and abdominal cavity of most carcasses. However, FMDV inactivation thresholds were not reached in bone marrow and brain. This suggests that these carcasses may potentially remain infectious with ASFV and FMDV in situ under the experimental conditions encountered, based on the inactivation thresholds selected. Despite this, culling large portions of a feral pig population, in conjunction with D&LL disposal approach, may still support disease control imperatives during an EAD response by reducing live pig numbers and disease transmission.

Retrospective review of forensic entomology casework in eastern Australia from 1994 to 2022

Forensic entomology can be a crucial source of information for medicolegal investigations, with its most well-known application being for estimating minimum post-mortem interval (mPMI) in death investigations. The analysis of entomological evidence requires robust data on insect ecology, life history, behaviour, and taxonomy. In Australia, substantial basic research on forensically relevant insects has focused predominately in the populous southeast and southwest; however, knowledge gaps remain, most importantly for the tropical north. In addition, there are scant casework data available publicly, which limits the ability of practitioners to make connections between fundamental research and real-world casework and hampers refinement of analytical methods and techniques. To address this gap, this project collated and analysed data from expert forensic entomological casework reports for five eastern Australia jurisdictions (South Australia, Victoria, New South Wales, Australian Capital Territory and Queensland) for a period spanning nearly thirty years (1994-2022). Relevant data extracted from casework reports included species and life stages collected, various decedent and case characteristics, type of opinion requested and estimated mPMI. These data were used to explore associations between species composition and geographical region, surrounding environment, season, and decedent characteristics (e.g., wounds). Additionally, the accuracy and investigative 'value' of mPMI estimates was assessed, which demonstrated that entomology-derived timeframes are largely reliable and highly informative. Finally, we report the first records in Australian casework for several species and highlight several areas that require additional research to fill critical gaps in our knowledge. Overall, this review represents highly practical real-world data that will be of enduring benefit to the forensic community.

Challenges and considerations in forensic entomology: A comprehensive review

Forensic entomology is the study of insect biology as it relates to societal problems that come to the attention of the legal profession and that often must be resolved by legal proceedings. These problems come under the purview of medico-criminal entomology. Forensic entomology is the study of arthropods, especially insects, their identification, post-mortem intervals (PMI), crime scene details associated with crimes and other aspects of the courts and judicial system. Understanding the predictable succession patterns of Diptera and Coleoptera on decomposing remains is crucial for accurately determining the post-mortem interval in forensic investigations. Beetles and blowflies play a critical role in the decomposition process, with beetles often appearing later and blowflies swiftly colonizing remains, making both essential for accurately estimating the post-mortem interval and understanding decomposition dynamics. Insects, particularly flies, serve as crucial forensic tools, allowing for detecting drugs, poisons, and other substances long after traditional tissue samples degrade. Their ability to retain and reveal evidence, even in severely decomposed or altered remains, significantly enhances the accuracy of criminal investigations. Recent advancements in forensic entomology, such as integrating infrared spectroscopy, omics technologies, and molecular taxonomy, have significantly improved the precision and scope of forensic investigations. These tools, combined with thorough validation processes, enable forensic scientists to identify species, estimate post-mortem intervals, and interpret complex cases with greater accuracy and reliability. However, challenges such as environmental influences, insect behavior, body concealment, faunal succession limitations, and gaps in knowledge and resources present obstacles to accuracy and standardization. This review summarises key insect species involved in crime Investigation, PMI Intervals and their significance, Recent advances, Challenges and limitations so that entomotoxicologists can analyze challenging cases recovered after a long period this review also analyses the scope of entomotoxicology in the area of death investigations.

Changes in blowfly (Diptera: Calliphoridae) wing morphology during succession in rat carcasses across forest and grassland habitats in South Brazil

Succession is one of the most extensively studied ecological phenomena, yet debates persist about the importance of dispersal and external factors in driving this process. We aimed to quantify the influence of these factors by investigating how wing-related traits evolve across succession of blowfly (Diptera: Calliphoridae) communities in South Brazil. Rat carrion was placed in both forest and grassland habitats, and the associated blowfly communities were documented throughout the decomposition process. Using morphometric analysis, we measured wing and thorax traits and assessed trait changes over succession through mixed models. Our findings revealed that carrion succession follows distinct trajectories in forest and grassland environments. Specifically, we observed that Calliphora lopesi predominantly visited carcasses during the final phase of decomposition, resulting in significant differences in species composition and wing size between habitats. In forests, wing size increased toward the later stages of succession, whereas an opposite trend was observed in grasslands. Notably, these trait patterns were only evident at the species level, indicating that intraspecific trait variation is irrelevant. Stronger dispersers tend to arrive during the later stages of succession, suggesting that dispersal has a negligible role in shaping successional dynamics. Instead, environmental differences between habitats drive trait patterns throughout succession. Our results suggest that community composition in ephemeral resources is governed by deterministic processes and that successional stages can be predicted based on blowfly wing traits. Specifically, the presence of the large-winged C. lopesi indicates late decay, while the small-winged Chrysomia albiceps and Lucilia eximia are indicative of early decay.

Changes in blowfly (Diptera: Calliphoridae) wing morphology during succession in rat carcasses across forest and grassland habitats in South Brazil

Succession is one of the most extensively studied ecological phenomena, yet debates persist about the importance of dispersal and external factors in driving this process. We aimed to quantify the influence of these factors by investigating how wing-related traits evolve across succession of blowfly (Diptera: Calliphoridae) communities in South Brazil. Rat carrion was placed in both forest and grassland habitats, and the associated blowfly communities were documented throughout the decomposition process. Using morphometric analysis, we measured wing and thorax traits and assessed trait changes over succession through mixed models. Our findings revealed that carrion succession follows distinct trajectories in forest and grassland environments. Specifically, we observed that Calliphora lopesi predominantly visited carcasses during the final phase of decomposition, resulting in significant differences in species composition and wing size between habitats. In forests, wing size increased toward the later stages of succession, whereas an opposite trend was observed in grasslands. Notably, these trait patterns were only evident at the species level, indicating that intraspecific trait variation is irrelevant. Stronger dispersers tend to arrive during the later stages of succession, suggesting that dispersal has a negligible role in shaping successional dynamics. Instead, environmental differences between habitats drive trait patterns throughout succession. Our results suggest that community composition in ephemeral resources is governed by deterministic processes and that successional stages can be predicted based on blowfly wing traits. Specifically, the presence of the large-winged C. lopesi indicates late decay, while the small-winged Chrysomia albiceps and Lucilia eximia are indicative of early decay.

Retrospective analysis of factors affecting rate of skeletonization within a tropical climate

Estimating the post mortem interval (PMI) in skeletonized cases is an extremely challenging exercise. Sri Lanka lacks adequate taphonomic research which is a serious limitation when assessing PMI in forensic death investigations. Methods that have been proposed to estimate PMI using the total body score (TBS) and accumulated degree days (ADD) are mainly based on data from continental and temperate climates and have shown less reliability in tropical climates. With the intention of developing a region-specific, evidence-based guide which would be applicable to tropical climates like Sri Lanka, we selected thirteen skeletonized remains with known PMIs from forensic case records and analysed their taphonomy in relation to selected weather data. We also compared the ADD values within our dataset with reference ranges calculated using published formula. All except one were found from outdoor locations. The TBS ranged from 24 to 32 and had a weak positive correlation with the PMI. The earliest appearance of skeletonization was 15 days in a body found indoors. The highest rate of skeletonization was seen in a body with a TBS of 32 and a PMI of 23 days. The average daily temperature and relative humidity were similar across all the cases however, the amount of rainfall varied. Bodies exposed to monsoon rains (n = 6) had a lower mean rate of skeletonization compared to those that were not exposed (n = 4) suggesting lower rates of decomposition during periods of heavy rainfall. No correlation was found between ADD and TBS. In 9 (69.2%) cases, the actual ADD was much lower than reference ADD ranges for TBS values, indicating poor applicability of TBS and ADD based formulae in estimating PMI within the Sri Lankan climate. Our study shows a strong need for taphonomic and entomological research in tropical climates to further explore the impact of monsoons on biotic and abiotic factors affecting skeletonization.

Decomposition and insect succession of pig cadavers in tents versus outdoors - A preliminary study

The pattern of insect succession and the species composition on cadavers can be influenced by several parameters, one of which is concealment. It has been previously shown for cadavers inside containers (e.g. suitcases or vehicles) or various indoor situations, that concealment can lead to a delayed arrival, altered species composition and decreased number of taxa present at the cadaver. As no data is yet available for the specific environment of tents on these processes, we placed five pig cadavers inside closed two-person tents during the summer of 2021 in a mixed forest in Germany. Five control cadavers were freely accessible for insects. To minimize disturbances, tents were only opened every fifth day over a period of 25 days for estimating the temperature profiles, insect diversity and quantification of the cadavers' decomposition using the total body score (TBS). The temperature inside the tents was only slightly elevated compared to the ambient temperature during the study. Although the tents prevented direct access of adult flies and beetles, the cadavers were colonized because the flies oviposited on the zippers and fly screens of the inner tents. However, the resulting infestation of the cadavers by fly larvae was reduced and delayed, compared to the exposed cadavers. The dominant fly species on both the tent and exposed cadavers was the blow fly Lucilia caesar. Open cadavers showed the expected decomposition patterns with large larval masses. 25 days after placement, only bones and hair remained from the exposed pigs (TBS = 32), while most of the tissue of the cadavers inside the tents was still present (TBS = 22.5) and post feeding larvae were not able to leave the tents. Regarding the attraction of beetles to both treatments, open cadavers were predominately colonized by the silphid Oiceoptoma thoracicum, while the silphid Necrodes littoralis was the most dominant species in the pitfall traps surrounding the tents. Considering the prolonged pre-appearance interval of fly larvae colonizing the cadavers inside tents, the entomological evidence of forensic cases dealing with concealed bodies should be handled with caution, since the post mortem interval might be significantly underestimated.

Insect Decline-A Forensic Issue?

Simple Summary

Numerous studies report a decline in insect biodiversity and biomass on a global scale. Since forensic entomology relies on the presence of insects, the question of whether this discipline will be or already is affected by such a decrease is not only posed to investigative authorities and the public, but also to the scientific community. While the data does indeed provide overwhelming evidence of insect decline, even if the methods of evaluation and data pooling are occasionally questioned, only a few studies deal with forensically relevant insects. These few data do hardly prove a decrease in forensically relevant insect species so far. However, one factor driving insect decline is likely to have also a strong influence on necrophagous insects in the future: climate change.

Abstract

Recent reports have shown a dramatic loss in insect species and biomass. Since forensic entomology relies on the presence of insects, the question is whether this decline effects the discipline. The present review confirms that numerous studies document insect population declines or even extinction, despite the fact that the rates of decline and the methods used to demonstrate it are still much debated. However, with regard to a decline in necrophagous insects, there is little or only anecdotal data available. A hypothetical decrease in species diversity and population density in necrophagous insects could lead to a delayed colonization of dead bodies and a modified succession pattern due to the disappearance or new occurrence of species or their altered seasonality. Climate change as one of the drivers of insect decline will probably also have an impact on necrophagous insects and forensic entomology, leading to reduced flight and oviposition activity, modified growth rates and, therefore, an over- or underestimation of a minimum postmortem interval. Global warming with increased temperature and extreme weather requires a better understanding about necrophagous insect responses to environmental variations. Here, transgeneration effects in particular should be analysed in greater depth as this will help to understand rapid adaptation and plasticity in insects of forensic importance.