Endocrine characteristics of cloned calves

Incidence of abnormal offspring from cloning and other assisted reproductive technologies

In animals produced by assisted reproductive technologies, two abnormal phenotypes have been characterized. Large offspring syndrome (LOS) occurs in offspring derived from in vitro cultured embryos, and the abnormal clone phenotype includes placental and fetal changes. LOS is readily apparent in ruminants, where a large calf or lamb derived from in vitro embryo production or cloning may weigh up to twice the expected body weight. The incidence of LOS varies widely between species. When similar embryo culture conditions are applied to nonruminant species, LOS either is not as dramatic or may even be unapparent. Coculture with serum and somatic cells was identified in the 1990s as a risk factor for abnormal development of ruminant pregnancies. Animals cloned from somatic cells may display a combination of fetal and placental abnormalities that are manifested at different stages of pregnancy and postnatally. In highly interventional technologies, such as nuclear transfer (cloning), the incidence of abnormal offspring continues to be a limiting factor to broader application of the technique. This review details the breadth of phenotypes found in nonviable pregnancies, together with the phenotypes of animals that survive the transition to extrauterine life. The focus is on animals produced using in vitro embryo culture and nuclear transfer in comparison to naturally occurring phenotypes.

Development of bovine embryos derived from reproductive techniques

Assisted reproduction techniques have improved agricultural breeding in the bovine. However, important development steps may differ from the situation in vivo and there is a high mortality rate during the first trimester of gestation. To better understand these events, we investigated the development of embryos and fetal membranes following fixed-time AI (FTAI), IVF and nuclear transfer (NT). The onset of yolk-sac development was not normal in cloned embryos. Later steps differed from conditions in vivo in all three groups; the yolk-sac was yellowish and juxtaposed with the amniotic membrane. Vascularisation of the chorioallantoic membrane was relatively late and low in NT gestations, but normal in the others. The overall development of the embryos was normal, as indicated by morphology and regression analysis of growth rate. However, NT conceptuses were significantly smaller, with the livers in some embryos occupying the abdominal cavity and others exhibiting heart abnormalities. In conclusion, the yolk-sac and the cardiovascular system seem to be vulnerable to morphogenetic alterations. Future studies will focus on gene expression and early vascularisation processes to investigate whether these changes may be responsible for the high incidence of intrauterine mortality, especially in clones.

Delivery of cloned offspring: experience in Zebu cattle (Bos indicus)

The production of a healthy cloned calf is dependent on a multitude of successful steps, including reprogramming mediated by the oocyte, the development of a functional placenta, adequate maternal–fetal interaction, the establishment of a physiological metabolic setting and the formation of a complete set of well-differentiated cells that will eventually result in well-characterised and fully competent tissues and organs. Although the efficiency of nuclear transfer has improved significantly since the first report of a somatic cell nuclear transfer-derived animal, there are many descriptions of anomalies concerning cloned calves leading to high perinatal morbidity and mortality. The present article discusses some our experience regarding perinatal and neonatal procedures for cloned Zebu cattle (B. indicus) that has led to improved survival rates in Nellore cloned calves following the application of such ‘labour-intensive technology’.

Excess estrogen sulfoconjugation as the possible cause for a poor sign of parturition in pregnant cows carrying somatic cell clone fetuses

We conducted this study to elucidate a factor causing a poor sign of parturition and prolonged gestation, which is frequently observed in cows carrying somatic clone fetuses. Pre-partum rises in concentrations of plasma estrone and estradiol-17β in the recipient cows pregnant with clones were subtle. By contrast, the plasma concentration of estrone sulfate in clone pregnancies increased gradually from pre-initiation of parturition induction whereas control cows that receivedin vivo-derived embryos showed a significant increase at parturition. Therefore, in clone pregnancies, the ratio of estrone/estrone sulfate was low during the pre-partum period compared with control. Messenger RNA expression of estrogen sulfotransferase (SULT1E1) in the placenta at parturition was significantly higher in clone pregnancies than control pregnancies and was localized in binucleate cells (BNC).SULT1E1mRNA abundance was negatively and positively correlated with concentrations of maternal estrone and estrone sulfate at parturition respectively. Messenger RNA expressions of estrogen sulfatase (STS) and aromatase (CYP19) were similar between clone and control pregnancies and were localized in BNC and caruncular epithelial cells.STSandCYP19mRNA abundances showed positive correlations with maternal estradiol-17β concentration. The population of BNC in the placenta did not differ between clone and control pregnancies. Plasma cortisol concentration of vaginally delivered newborn clone calves was comparable with those of control, although cesarean section delivered clone calves showed a low concentration. These results suggest that excess estrogen sulfoconjugation is the reason for the perturbed low ratio of active to inactive estrogens and the resulting hormonal imbalance contributes to the lack of overt signs of readiness for parturition in cows pregnant with clones.

Perinatal physiology in cloned and normal calves: physical and clinical characteristics

The period immediately after birth is a vital time for all newborn calves as the cardiovascular, respiratory, and other organ systems adapt to life ex utero. Reported neonatal mortality rates suggest this period to be especially critical in cloned calves; yet prospective, controlled studies on the physiological status of these calves are lacking. The objectives of this study were to compare neonatal (birth to 48 h of age) physical and clinical characteristics and placental morphology of cloned and embryo transfer control calves delivered by cesarean section after induced labor. All calves were raised under specialized neonatal-care protocols at a large-animal veterinary research and teaching hospital. Cloned calves were similar to controls for many parameters studied. Notable exceptions included developmental delays of important physical adjustment parameters and enlargement of the umbilical region. Placentas associated with cloned calves contained fewer total placentomes, a twofold increase in surface area and mass per placentome, and a shift in placentome morphology toward larger, flatter placentomes. The most striking clinical variations detected in clones were hypoglycemia and hyperfructosemia, both measures of carbohydrate metabolism. Because the placenta is known to be the source of plasma fructose in newborn calves, increased fructose production by the cloned placenta may be an important factor in the etiology of umbilical and cardiac anomalies in clones observed in this and other studies.

Perinatal Physiology in Cloned And Normal Calves: Hematologic And Biochemical Profiles

Although a majority of clones are born normal and apparently healthy, mortality rates of nearly 30% are described in many reports. Such losses are a major limitation of cloning technology and represent substantial economic investment as well as justifiable animal health and welfare concerns. Prospective, controlled studies are needed to understand fully the causes of neonatal mortality in clones and to develop preventive and therapeutic strategies to minimize losses. We report here the findings of studies on the hematologic and biochemical profiles of cloned and control calves in the immediate 48-h postpartum period. Cloned calves were similar to control calves for a majority of parameters studied including blood gases, concentrations of plasma proteins, minerals and electrolytes, and white blood cell, neutrophil, lymphocyte, and platelet counts. The most notable differences between clones and controls in this study were reduced red- and white-blood cell counts in clones at birth and 1 h of age. As a group, plasma electrolyte concentrations were more variable in clones, and the variability tended to be shifted either higher (sodium, chloride) or lower (potassium, bicarbonate) than in controls. Previously, we noted differences in carbohydrate parameters, the length of time required for clones to make the neonatal adaptation to life ex utero, and morphology of the cloned placenta. Taken together, our findings suggest that cloned calves experience greater difficulty adjusting to life ex utero and that further research is warranted to determine the nature of the relationship between the physiological differences noted here in clones at birth and concomitant abnormal placental morphology.

The US FDA and animal cloning: Risk and regulatory approach

The Food and Drug Administration's (FDA's) Center for Veterinary Medicine issued a voluntary request to producers of livestock clones not to introduce food from clones or their progeny into commerce until the agency had assessed whether production of cattle, swine, sheep, or goats by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) posed any unique risks to the animal(s) involved in the process, humans, or other animals by consuming food from those animals, compared with any other assisted reproductive technology (ART) currently in use. Following a comprehensive review, no anomalies were observed in animals produced by cloning that have not also been observed in animals produced by other ARTs and natural mating. Further systematic review on the health of, and composition of meat and milk from, cattle, swine, and goat clones and the progeny of cattle and sheep did not result in the identification of any food-consumption hazards. The agency therefore concluded that food from cattle, swine, and goat clones was as safe to eat as food from animals of those species derived by conventional means. The agency also concluded that food from the progeny of the clone of any species normally consumed for food is as safe to eat as those animals. The article also describes the methodology used by the agency to analyze data and draw these conclusions, the plans the agency has proposed to manage any identified risks, and the risk communication approaches the agency has used.

Endocrine Profiles and Growth Patterns of Cloned Goats

Two groups of goats produced by fetal somatic cell nuclear transfer (NT) were monitored to evaluate the similarities in growth patterns among cloned animals. Clone group I consisted of five Toggenburg females cloned from the same transgenic cell line and born to different recipient does. Clone group II consisted of two Saanen does born as twins to a single recipient female from a second transgenic cell line. Each cell line was constructed with a transgene (different for each clone group) that would express, producing a protein product in the milk during lactation of the does. Weight, hip height, and circulating levels of growth-related hormones were monitored at weekly and monthly intervals for comparison within the clone groups. A contemporary group (group III) consisting of seven crossbred does of similar ages and weights was also monitored for baseline endocrine values during the study. Serum samples from all groups were analyzed for growth hormone (GH), insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I), triiodothyronine (T3), thyroxine (T4), and insulin via standard laboratory radioimmunoassay procedures. The averaged standard deviation from the mean was used to evaluate similarities within the groups of cloned does and the does in the contemporary group. The does in clone group II were less variable than the goats in clone group I for weight and hip height. This was perhaps due to a recipient effect. The two groups of cloned females were less variable than the contemporary group for circulating IGF-I and T4 concentrations. In contrast, the two groups of cloned does had at least one cloned group that was more variable than the contemporary group for GH, T3, and insulin. The animal variation, measured by the average standard deviation from the mean, of the cloned does is possibly due to environmental effects encountered in utero and/or in the postnatal period, as well as possible mitochondrial DNA differences between the cell line and donor oocytes used for NT. The variation among cloned does in this study indicates that the use of somatic cell NT to reproduce identical phenotypes may not succeed in all situations.

Cloning and assisted reproductive techniques: Influence on early development and adult phenotype

Over the past 40 years, our increased understanding and development of cell and molecular biology has allowed even greater advances in reproductive biology. This is most evident by the development of various aspects of assisted reproductive techniques (ART), generation of transgenic animals, and most recently generation of mammals through somatic cell cloning. To date, cloning from adult somatic cells has been successful in at least 10 mammalian species. Although generating viable cloned mammals from adult cells is technically feasible and the list of successes will only continue to grow with time, prenatal and perinatal mortality is high and live cloned offspring have not been without health problems. The success of many of the proposed applications of the cloning technique obviously depends upon the health and survival of founder animals generated by nuclear transfer. This article summarizes the health consequences of cloning in mice, and discusses possible mechanisms through which these conditions may arise. In addition, we discuss the effects of ART in animal models and in humans. ART also involves some of the same procedures used in cloning, and there are reports that offspring generated by ART sometimes display aberrant phenotypes as well. It is important to point out that although these techniques do sometimes produce abnormalities, the majority of offspring are born apparently normal and survive to adulthood. Additionally, we must emphasize that the effects of ART and cloning observed in animal models do not necessarily indicate that they will occur in humans. In this article, we review studies examining the phenotype of animals generated by cloning and various ART, and discuss clinical implications of these findings.

Review: Health Status of Cloned Cattle at Different Ages

The procedure of somatic cloning is associated with important losses during pregnancy and in the perinatal period, reducing the overall efficacy to less than 5% in most cases. A mean of 30% of the cloned calves die before reaching 6 months of age with a wide range of pathologies, including, for the most common, respiratory failure, abnormal kidney development, liver steatosis. Heart and liver weight in relation to body weight are also increased. Surviving animals, although mostly clinically normal, differ from controls obtained by artificial insemination (AI) within the first 1-2 months, to become undistinguishable from them thereafter. Hemoglobin concentrations, for instance, are lower, and leptin concentrations are elevated. In response to the lack of prospective studies addressing the health of adult clones, a long-term, 3-4-year study is currently being conducted to assess the health of mature bovine clones at INRA. Preliminary results over 1 year of study do not show any statistical difference between groups for hematological parameters.