Development of a High-Throughput Screen to Detect Inhibitors of TRPS1 Sumoylation

RREB1-mediated SUMOylation enhancement promotes chemoresistance partially by transcriptionally upregulating UBC9 in colorectal cancer

Chemoresistance is a main cause of chemotherapy failure and tumor recurrence. The effects of global protein SUMOylation on chemoresistance in colorectal cancer (CRC) remains to be investigated. Herein, we have proposed that the elevated SUMO2/3-modified proteins confer 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) chemoresistance acquisition in CRC. The SUMOylation levels of global proteins in CRC cell lines were elevated compared with normal colon cell line NCM460. 5-FU treatment obviously reduced SUMOylation of global proteins in 5-FU-sensitive CRC cells including HT29, HCT116 and HCT-8. However, in 5-FU-resistant HCT-8/5-FU cells, the expression level of SUMO2/3-modified proteins was increased under 5-FU exposure in a concentration-dependent manner. 5-FU treatment combined with SUMOylation inhibitor ML-792 significantly increased the sensitivity of 5-FU-resistant cells to 5-FU and reduced colony formation numbers in HCT-8/5-FU cells. And UBC9-mediated SUMOylation elevation contributes to 5-FU resistance in HCT116 cells. Moreover, we also identified RREB1 as a regulator of SUMOylation profiling of global cellular proteins via directly binding to the promoter of UBC9. Overexpression of RREB1 promoted 5-FU resistance in CRC, which was partially abolished by treatment of inhibitor ML-792. In conclusion, RREB1-enhanced protein SUMOylation contributes to 5-FU resistance acquisition in CRC.

The SUMOylation and ubiquitination crosstalk in cancer

BACKGROUND

The cancer occurrence and progression are largely affected by the post-translational modifications (PTMs) of proteins. Currently, it has been shown that the relationship between ubiquitination and SUMOylation is highly complex and interactive. SUMOylation affects the process of ubiquitination and degradation of substrates. Contrarily, SUMOylation-related proteins are also regulated by the ubiquitination process thus altering their protein levels or activity. Emerging evidence suggests that the abnormal regulation between this crosstalk may lead to tumorigenesis.

PURPOSE

In this review, we have discussed the study of the relationship between ubiquitination and SUMOylation, as well as the possibility of a corresponding application in tumor therapy.

METHODS

The relevant literatures from PubMed have been reviewed for this article.

CONCLUSION

The interaction between ubiquitination and SUMOylation is crucial for the occurrence and development of cancer. A greater understanding of the crosstalk of SUMOylation and ubiquitination may be more conducive to the development of more selective and effective SUMOylation inhibitors, as well as a promotion of synergy with other tumor treatment strategies.

Paradoxes of Cellular SUMOylation Regulation: A Role of Biomolecular Condensates?

Protein SUMOylation is a major post-translational modification essential for maintaining cellular homeostasis. SUMOylation has long been associated with stress responses as a diverse array of cellular stress signals are known to trigger rapid alternations in global protein SUMOylation. In addition, while there are large families of ubiquitination enzymes, all small ubiquitin-like modifiers (SUMOs) are conjugated by a set of enzymatic machinery comprising one heterodimeric SUMO-activating enzyme, a single SUMO-conjugating enzyme, and a small number of SUMO protein ligases and SUMO-specific proteases. How a few SUMOylation enzymes specifically modify thousands of functional targets in response to diverse cellular stresses remains an enigma. Here we review recent progress toward understanding the mechanisms of SUMO regulation, particularly the potential roles of liquid-liquid phase separation/biomolecular condensates in regulating cellular SUMOylation during cellular stresses. In addition, we discuss the role of protein SUMOylation in pathogenesis and the development of novel therapeutics targeting SUMOylation. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Protein SUMOylation is one of the most prevalent post-translational modifications and plays a vital role in maintaining cellular homeostasis in response to stresses. Protein SUMOylation has been implicated in human pathogenesis, such as cancer, cardiovascular diseases, neurodegeneration, and infection. After more than a quarter century of extensive research, intriguing enigmas remain regarding the mechanism of cellular SUMOylation regulation and the therapeutic potential of targeting SUMOylation.

The emerging roles of SUMOylation in the tumor microenvironment and therapeutic implications

Tumor initiation, progression, and response to therapies depend to a great extent on interactions between malignant cells and the tumor microenvironment (TME), which denotes the cancerous/non-cancerous cells, cytokines, chemokines, and various other factors around tumors. Cancer cells as well as stroma cells can not only obtain adaption to the TME but also sculpt their microenvironment through a series of signaling pathways. The post-translational modification (PTM) of eukaryotic cells by small ubiquitin-related modifier (SUMO) proteins is now recognized as a key flexible pathway. Proteins involved in tumorigenesis guiding several biological processes including chromatin organization, DNA repair, transcription, protein trafficking, and signal conduction rely on SUMOylation. The purpose of this review is to explore the role that SUMOylation plays in the TME formation and reprogramming, emphasize the importance of targeting SUMOylation to intervene in the TME and discuss the potential of SUMOylation inhibitors (SUMOi) in ameliorating tumor prognosis.

Small-molecule inhibitors targeting small ubiquitin-like modifier pathway for the treatment of cancers and other diseases

SUMOylation is a key post-translational modification that involves the covalent attachment of small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) to the lysine residues of target proteins. The well-balanced SUMOylation is essential for normal cellular behaviors, while disturbance of SUMOylation is associated with various cancers and other diseases. Herein, we summarize the structures and biological functions of proteins involved in the SUMOylation process, their dysregulation in human diseases, and the discovery of small-molecular inhibitors targeting this pathway. In addition, we highlight the emerging trends in this field.

Therapeutic Potential of Targeting the SUMO Pathway in Cancer

SUMOylation is a dynamic and reversible post-translational modification, characterized more than 20 years ago, that regulates protein function at multiple levels. Key oncoproteins and tumor suppressors are SUMO substrates. In addition to alterations in SUMO pathway activity due to conditions typically present in cancer, such as hypoxia, the SUMO machinery components are deregulated at the genomic level in cancer. The delicate balance between SUMOylation and deSUMOylation is regulated by SENP enzymes possessing SUMO-deconjugation activity. Dysregulation of SUMO machinery components can disrupt the balance of SUMOylation, contributing to the tumorigenesis and drug resistance of various cancers in a context-dependent manner. Many molecular mechanisms relevant to the pathogenesis of specific cancers involve SUMO, highlighting the potential relevance of SUMO machinery components as therapeutic targets. Recent advances in the development of inhibitors targeting SUMOylation and deSUMOylation permit evaluation of the therapeutic potential of targeting the SUMO pathway in cancer. Finally, the first drug inhibiting SUMO pathway, TAK-981, is currently also being evaluated in clinical trials in cancer patients. Intriguingly, the inhibition of SUMOylation may also have the potential to activate the anti-tumor immune response. Here, we comprehensively and systematically review the recent developments in understanding the role of SUMOylation in cancer and specifically focus on elaborating the scientific rationale of targeting the SUMO pathway in different cancers.

Novel insights into the impact of the SUMOylation pathway in hematological malignancies (Review)

The small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) system serves an important role in the regulation of protein stability and function. SUMOylation sustains the homeostatic equilibrium of protein function in normal tissues and numerous types of tumor. Accumulating evidence has revealed that SUMO enzymes participate in carcinogenesis via a series of complex cellular or extracellular processes. The present review outlines the physiological characteristics of the SUMOylation pathway and provides examples of SUMOylation participation in different cancer types, including in hematological malignancies (leukemia, lymphoma and myeloma). It has been indicated that the SUMO pathway may influence chromosomal instability, cell cycle progression, apoptosis and chemical drug resistance. The present review also discussed the possible relationship between SUMOylation and carcinogenic mechanisms, and evaluated their potential as biomarkers and therapeutic targets in the diagnosis and treatment of hematological malignancies. Developing and investigating inhibitors of SUMO conjugation in the future may offer promising potential as novel therapeutic strategies.

Sumoylation as an Emerging Target in Therapeutics against Cancer

Sumoylation is the Post-translational modification gaining most of the research interest recently. Sumoylation is involved in various crucial functions of the cell such as regulation of cell cycle, DNA damage repair, apoptosis, etc. Oncology is advancing in radiotherapy, targeted chemotherapy, various forms of immunotherapy and targeted gene therapy. Researches are being conducted to prove its connotation with a variety of cancers and inhibitors are being developed to obstruct the fatal effect caused by misbalance of the SUMO-catalytic cycle. It has been shown that up-regulation of certain enzymes of Sumoylation correlates with cancer incidence in most of the cases. However, in some cases, down-regulation also associates with cancer invasion such as underexpression of UBC9 in initial stage breast cancer. This can aid in future study, treatment, and diagnosis of a variety of cancers including breast cancer, prostate cancer, lung adenocarcinoma, melanoma, multiple myeloma, etc. Various mechanistic assays are being developed and used to identify potential inhibitors against the dysregulated proteins of Sumoylation. This review summarizes the normal roles of the enzymes involved in the SUMOcatalytic cycle, their misbalanced regulation leading to tumorigenesis and nearly all the potent inhibitors identified to date, while after detailed studied it was observed that ML-792 could be a promising inhibitor in treating cancers by inhibiting Sumoylation enzymes.

E2 enzymes in genome stability: pulling the strings behind the scenes

Ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like proteins (UBLs) function as critical post-translational modifiers in the maintenance of genome stability. Ubiquitin/UBL-conjugating enzymes (E2s) are responsible, as part of a wider enzymatic cascade, for transferring single moieties or polychains of ubiquitin/UBLs to one or multiple residues on substrate proteins. Recent advances in structural and mechanistic understanding of how ubiquitin/UBL substrate attachment is orchestrated indicate that E2s can exert control over chain topology, substrate-site specificity, and downstream physiological effects to help maintain genome stability. Drug discovery efforts have typically focussed on modulating other members of the ubiquitin/UBL cascades or the ubiquitin-proteasome system. Here, we review the current standing of E2s in genome stability and revisit their potential as pharmacological targets for developing novel anti-cancer therapies.

Effects of targeting sumoylation processes during latent and induced Epstein-Barr virus infections using the small molecule inhibitor ML-792

As the second leading cause of death in the United States, cancer has a considerable impact on society, and one cellular process that is commonly dysregulated in many cancers is the post-translational modification of proteins by the Small Ubiquitin-like Modifier (SUMO; sumoylation). We documented that sumoylation processes are up-regulated in lymphoma tissues in the presence of Latent Membrane Protein-1 (LMP1), the principal oncoprotein of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV). LMP1-mediated dysregulation of cellular sumoylation processes contributes to oncogenesis, modulates innate immune responses, and aids the maintenance of viral latency. Manipulation of protein sumoylation has been proposed for anti-cancer and anti-viral therapies; however, known inhibitors of sumoylation do not only target sumoylation processes. Recently, a specific and selective small-molecule inhibitor of sumoylation (ML-792) was identified; however, nothing is known about the effect of ML-792 on LMP1-mediated dysregulation of cellular sumoylation or the EBV life-cycle. We hypothesized that ML-792 modulates viral replication and the oncogenic potential of EBV LMP1 by inhibiting protein sumoylation. Results showed that ML-792 inhibited sumoylation processes in multiple EBV-positive B cell lines and EBV-positive nasopharyngeal carcinoma cell lines but not in their EBV-negative counterparts. Focusing on its effect on B cells, ML-792 inhibited B-cell growth and promoted cell death at very low doses. ML-792 also modulated LMP1-induced cell migration and cell adhesion, which suggests the abrogation of the oncogenic potential of LMP1. Finally, while higher concentrations of ML-792 were sufficient to induce low levels EBV spontaneous reactivation, they decreased the production of new infectious virus following an induced reactivation and the infection of new cells, suggesting that ML-792 has anti-viral potential. Together, these findings suggest that ML-792 may be a potential therapeutic drug to treat EBV-associated lymphoid malignancies by targeting oncogenesis and the EBV life-cycle.

Targeting SUMO Signaling to Wrestle Cancer

The small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) signaling cascade is critical for gene expression, genome integrity, and cell cycle progression. In this review, we discuss the important role SUMO may play in cancer and how to target SUMO signaling. Recently developed small molecule inhibitors enable therapeutic targeting of the SUMOylation pathway. Blocking SUMOylation not only leads to reduced cancer cell proliferation but also to an increased antitumor immune response by stimulating interferon (IFN) signaling, indicating that SUMOylation inhibitors have a dual mode of action that can be employed in the fight against cancer. The search for tumor types that can be treated with SUMOylation inhibitors is ongoing. Employing SUMO conjugation inhibitory drugs in the years to come has potential as a new therapeutic strategy.

An in vitro Förster resonance energy transfer-based high-throughput screening assay identifies inhibitors of SUMOylation E2 Ubc9

SUMOylation is one of the posttranslational modifications that mediate cellular activities such as transcription, DNA repair, and signal transduction and is involved in the cell cycle. However, only a limited number of small molecule inhibitors have been identified to study its role in cellular processes. Here, we report a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) high-throughput screening assay based on the interaction between E2 Ubc9 and E3 PIAS1. Of the 3200 compounds screened, 34 (1.1%) showed higher than 50% inhibition and 4 displayed dose-response inhibitory effects. By combining this method with a label-free surface plasmon resonance (SPR) assay, false positives were excluded leading to discovering WNN0605-F008 and WNN1062-D002 that bound to Ubc9 with K_D values of 1.93 ± 0.62 and 5.24 ± 3.73 μM, respectively. We examined the effect of the two compounds on SUMO2-mediated SUMOylation of RanGAP1, only WNN0605-F008 significantly inhibited RanGAP1 SUMOylation, whereas WNN1062-D002 did not show any inhibition. These compounds, with novel chemical scaffolds, may serve as the initial material for developing new SUMOylation inhibitors.

Small-Molecule Inhibitors Targeting Protein SUMOylation as Novel Anticancer Compounds

SUMOylation, one of post-translational modifications, is covalently modified on lysine residues of a target protein through an enzymatic cascade reaction similar to protein ubiquitination. Along with identification of many SUMOylated proteins, protein SUMOylation has been proven to regulate multiple biologic activities including transcription, cell cycle, DNA repair, and innate immunity. The dysregulation of protein SUMOylation and deSUMOylation modification is linked with carcinogenesis and tumor progression. The SUMOylation-associated enzymes are usually elevated in various cancers, which function as cancer biomarkers to relate to poor outcomes for patients. Considering the significance of protein SUMOylation in regulating diverse biologic functions in cancer progression, numerous small-molecule inhibitors targeting protein SUMOylation pathway are developed as potentially clinical anticancer therapeutics. Here, we systematically summarize the latest progresses of associations of small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) enzymes with cancers and small-molecular inhibitors against human cancers by targeting SUMOylation enzymes. We also compared the pros and cons of several special anticancer inhibitors targeting SUMO pathway. As more efforts are invested in this field, small-molecule inhibitors targeting the SUMOylation modification pathway are promising for development into novel anticancer drugs.

A Small-Molecule Microarray Approach for the Identification of E2 Enzyme Inhibitors in Ubiquitin-Like Conjugation Pathways

E2 enzymes in ubiquitin-like conjugation pathways are important, highly challenging pharmacological targets, and despite significant efforts, few noncovalent modulators have been discovered. Small-molecule microarray (SMM)-based screening was employed to identify an inhibitor of the "undruggable" small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) E2 enzyme Ubc9. The inhibitor, a degradation product from a commercial screening collection, was chemically synthesized and evaluated in biochemical, mechanistic, and structure-activity relationship studies. Binding to Ubc9 was confirmed through the use of ligand-detected nuclear magnetic resonance, and inhibition of sumoylation in a reconstituted enzymatic cascade was found to occur with an IC₅₀ of 75 µM. This work establishes the utility of the SMM approach for identifying inhibitors of E2 enzymes, targets with few known small-molecule modulators.

SUMO wrestling with Ras

This review discusses our current understanding of the small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) pathway and how it functionally intersects with Ras signaling in cancer. The Ras family of small GTPases are frequently mutated in cancer. The role of the SUMO pathway in cancer and in Ras signaling is currently not well understood. Recent studies have shown that the SUMO pathway can both regulate Ras/MAPK pathway activity directly and support Ras-driven oncogenesis through the regulation of proteins that are not direct Ras effectors. We recently discovered that in Ras mutant cancer cells, the SUMOylation status of a subset of proteins is altered and one such protein, KAP1, is required for Ras-driven transformation. A better understanding of the functional interaction between the SUMO and Ras pathways could lead to new insights into the mechanism of Ras-driven oncogenesis.

A gene-expression screen identifies a non-toxic sumoylation inhibitor that mimics SUMO-less human LRH-1 in liver

SUMO-modification of nuclear proteins has profound effects on gene expression. However, non-toxic chemical tools that modulate sumoylation in cells are lacking. Here, to identify small molecule sumoylation inhibitors we developed a cell-based screen that focused on the well-sumoylated substrate, human Liver Receptor Homolog-1 (hLRH-1, NR5A2). Our primary gene-expression screen assayed two SUMO-sensitive transcripts, APOC3 and MUC1, that are upregulated by SUMO-less hLRH-1 or by siUBC9 knockdown, respectively. A polyphenol, tannic acid (TA) emerged as a potent sumoylation inhibitor in vitro (IC₅₀ = 12.8 µM) and in cells. TA also increased hLRH-1 occupancy on SUMO-sensitive transcripts. Most significantly, when tested in humanized mouse primary hepatocytes, TA inhibits hLRH-1 sumoylation and induces SUMO-sensitive genes, thereby recapitulating the effects of expressing SUMO-less hLRH-1 in mouse liver. Our findings underscore the benefits of phenotypic screening for targeting post-translational modifications, and illustrate the potential utility of TA for probing the cellular consequences of sumoylation.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.09003.001

Proteins in cells carry out diverse tasks. One way in which this diversity is achieved by proteins is through the attachment of molecular tags. SUMO is one such tag that can reversibly attach to proteins and alter their activity. The modification of proteins by SUMO is known as sumoylation, and it regulates many processes that are essential for living cells. In particular, transcription factors—the proteins that bind to DNA to switch genes on or off—are highly modified by SUMO. However, the consequences of sumoylation are not fully understood, and current research into this area has been hindered by a lack of effective and non-toxic chemicals that stop or slow down sumoylation.

Suzawa, Miranda, Ramos et al. have now screened a large collection of compounds, which had already been approved for medical use, to find one that could inhibit sumoylation without toxic effects. The compounds were tested for their ability to alter the activity of a transcription factor called human Liver Receptor Homolog-1. This protein, which is referred to as LRH-1 for short, is an ideal candidate to test SUMO inhibitors because it is highly modified by multiple SUMO tags.

This screen identified a compound from plants called tannic acid as a non-toxic and potent inhibitor of sumoylation. Further experiments confirmed that tannic acid prevented the modification of LHR-1 as well a number of different proteins that also commonly modified by SUMO. Inhibiting the sumoylation of LRH-1 led to an increase in the expression of genes that are normally silenced by SUMO-modified LRH-1. Similar results were obtained when tannic acid was tested using human cells and “humanized” liver cells from mice that had been engineered to express human LRH-1. The next big challenge is to find new chemical probes that can be used to specifically promote or inhibit SUMO modification of just one particular protein.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.09003.002

Synthetic derivatives of the SUMO consensus sequence provide a basis for improved substrate recognition

Protein sumoylation is a dynamic posttranslational modification that regulates a diverse subset of the proteome. The mechanism by which sumoylation enzymes recognize their cognate substrates is unclear, and the consequences of sumoylation remain difficult to predict. While small molecule probes of the sumoylation process could be valuable for understanding SUMO biology, few small molecules that modulate this process exist. Here, we report the synthesis and evaluation of over 600 oxime-containing peptide sumoylation substrates. Our work demonstrates that higher modification efficiency can be achieved with non-natural side chains that deviate substantially from the consensus site requirement of a hydrophobic substituent. Furthermore, docking studies suggest that these improved substrates mimic binding interactions that are used by other endogenous protein sequences through tertiary interactions. The development of these high efficiency substrates provides key mechanistic insights toward specific recognition of low molecular weight species in the sumoylation pathway.