Mouse model findings and the future of human tissue in disease research

Issues in the Use of Human Tissues to Support Precision Medicine

Precision medicine is an approach in which the characteristics of patients as well as their diseases are used to identify optimal therapy; it links researchers, patients, health care providers, and clinical laboratories. In precision medicine, specific molecular characteristics of an untreatable cancer can be targeted by specific molecular-based therapy. Access to high-quality human tissues is necessary to determine many characteristics of patients and their diseases (such as targetable molecules). There are ethical issues in using human tissues in precision medicine, including informed consent and confidentiality, optimal utilization, quality of tissues, and minimization of bias. When human tissues are obtained for patient therapy, the bioresource should be a component certified by Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments. For precision medicine to benefit medically underserved populations requires extensive focused research, planning, and resources, some of which are currently unavailable at rural and other sites where care is provided to underserved populations.

The Importance of Human Tissue Bioresources in Advancing Biomedical Research

Medical research advances enabling the realization of precision medicine have relied heavily on the biospecimens provided by bioresources to identify the targets and biomarkers that are the focus of the new generation of more effective molecular-based therapies for specific subtypes of diseases. Through the biospecimens they have distributed, bioresources have permitted subtypes of cancers to be identified and molecular features of these subtypes to be effectively targeted. A prototype example is the human epidermal growth factor receptor type 2 (HER2), which currently is targeted in breast and gastric cancers. In the future, the use of biospecimens from bioresources will continue to increase the understanding of the molecular actions of drugs and how drugs may be more or less active in subpopulations of patients. Although the biospecimen inventories of the initial forms of bioresources may not have always been optimally planned and, therefore, utilized in supporting biomedical research, bioresources are evolving and overall, bioresource inventories and increasingly their prospective collection capabilities will continue to be a critical component of the research infrastructure.

Use of human specimens in research: the evolving United States regulatory, policy, and scientific landscape

The use of human specimens in research has contributed to significant scientific and medical advancements. However, the development of sophisticated whole genome and informatics technologies and the increase in specimen and data sharing have raised new questions about the identifiability of specimens and the protection of participants in human specimen research. In the US, new regulations and policies are being considered to address these changes. This review discusses the current and proposed regulations as they apply to specimen research, as well as relevant policy discussions. It summarizes the ways that researchers and other stakeholders can provide their input to these discussions and policy development efforts. Input from all the stakeholders in specimen research will be essential for the development of policies that facilitate such research while at the same time protecting the rights and welfare of research participants.