A Global Survey of Ergonomics Practice Patterns and Rates of Musculoskeletal Pain Among Urologists Performing Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery

Incorporating intra-operative education into ergonomics training for endourology cases: a pilot study

OBJECTIVE

To pilot an intra-operative ergonomics educational intervention for urologic surgeons performing endourologic procedures and compare this to didactic education alone.

METHODS

All participants completed a didactic session on endourologic ergonomics. One group completed the didactic session alone, while the other also received in intra-operative education, in which a physical therapist observed urologists performing endoscopic procedures and provided feedback. Participants were surveyed about physical pain symptoms, prior ergonomics training and ergonomics knowledge and comfort with application of principles before and after the interventions, with a follow-up survey 1 month post intervention.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight individuals completed the pre-intervention survey. 55% experienced physical pain often in the OR, and 42% experienced pain during an endoscopic case in the last month. 15 completed the survey immediately following the educational sessions. There was a consistent increase in understanding of ergonomics principles amongst participants participating in the didactic session and intra-operative education. Amongst those who participated in the didactic session alone, all but two had improved understanding of ergonomics principles.

CONCLUSIONS

There was a high prevalence of musculoskeletal pain in this cohort of urologists who lacked consistent prior experience with ergonomics training. Our pilot surgical ergonomics educational model involving a partnership with physical therapy, comprised of an intra-operative education and a didactic session, increased knowledge of ergonomics principles.

Urologist's Fatigue and Discomfort in Different Body Regions After Performing Flexible Ureteroscopy

OBJECTIVE

To assess self-reported surgeon fatigue and discomfort in different body regions after performing flexible ureteroscopy.

METHODS

An anonymous survey was designed and distributed among urologists and trainees in four hospitals. Participants rated their discomfort in different body and hand regions as well as overall fatigue before and immediately after each flexible ureteroscopy procedure they performed.

RESULTS

The final working sample size was 45 unique surgeons (26 female and 19 male) completing 58 procedures. Respondents were 38.2 ± 14.7 years of age. Forty-two percent of respondents were male, 75% were right-hand dominant, and 25% reported existing musculoskeletal disorder. Urologists' overall fatigue score significantly increased after ureteroscopy, but females had a significantly larger increase (female β: 1.74, P <.001; male β: 0.78, P = .017). Women experienced higher discomfort in neck, upper back, right shoulder, and right elbow than men. Across different hand regions, increased post-procedural discomfort was reported mostly in the thenar area (41.8%), followed by the hypothenar area (28.5%) and thumb area (27.9%).

DISCUSSION

Urologists experience significant increase in overall fatigue and discomfort across most body and hand regions. Women seem to be disproportionally affected. Additional studies are needed to determine the causality of these findings and explore potential interventions aimed at reducing procedure-related discomfort among all urologists, especially women.

Does tilt-retrograde intrarenal surgery enhance stone clearance and offer better surgical ergonomics in patients with renal calculi? A prospective randomized control study

INTRODUCTION

Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) is the standard treatment for renal calculi. Direct visualization and fragmentation are its major advantages. The variable stone clearance rates and the ergonomic challenges faced by urologists are a few limitations. Table tilt enhances stone clearance and improves surgical ergonomics by facilitating better access to stones and reducing procedural strain.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

In this prospective study, patients with intrarenal calculi were randomized into standard lithotomy RIRS (S-RIRS) and table-tilted RIRS (T-RIRS) groups. Specified table tilts were suggested for each of the stone locations. The outcomes with regard to stone clearance, operative and lasing time, and ergonomics were studied.

RESULTS

About 100 patients were studied, with 50 in each group. The overall operating time and lasing time in the T-RIRS group were less than that in the S-RIRS group (P < 0.001). The complication rates were the same in both groups. Most surgeons felt that the surgical ergonomics was better in the T-RIRS group (P < 0.001). When stone-free status was analyzed, seven patients in the S-RIRS group and one in the T-RIRS group had residual stones. The mean Borg category-ratio 10 (CR-10) scores in the S-RIRS and T-RIRS groups were 4.18 and 2.20, respectively (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to document the distinct advantages of T-RIRS and its benefits on surgical ergonomics. T-RIRS resulted in significantly shorter operative and lasing times, particularly for stones in lower calyces. Surgical ergonomics, assessed by the Borg CR-10 scale, were significantly better in the T-RIRS group. T-RIRS should become a standard of care for patients undergoing RIRS.

Understanding current ergonomics setup for urologists conducting anatomical endoscopic enucleation of the prostate surgeries: Survey analysis from the endourological society

BACKGROUND

Ensuring ergonomic posture and safety for surgeons is key to preventing work-related injuries and promoting sustained practice. We evaluated ergonomic aspects of Anatomic Endoscopic Enucleation of the Prostate (AEEP) and its relation to musculoskeletal injuries.

METHOD

A two-month online survey involving 119 Endourological Society members provided an in-depth analysis of AEEP practices and their musculoskeletal impacts.

RESULTS

The sample experienced general (65.5%), back (32.8%), neck (35.3%) and shoulder (37%) pain. Female AEEP surgeons reported greater back pain. Experience and age were inversely related to MSK injuries, and operative times over 2 ​h increased back pain. AEEP procedures predominantly involved sitting (86%) on backless stools (58%), with most surgeons wearing protective eyewear (75.6%) and using large resectoscopes (76.5%). Monitors were usually above eye-level (57%) and beyond 1 ​m (68.9%).

CONCLUSION

Musculoskeletal complaints are prevalent among AEEP endourologists. More awareness and further studies on risk factors are necessary to limit work-related injuries in urology.

Optimizing outcome reporting after robotic flexible ureteroscopy for management of renal calculi: Introducing the concept of tetrafecta

Robotic flexible ureteroscopy (RFURS) has shown encouraging results in terms of stone free rate (SFR) and better ergonomics compared to conventional FURS. However, few studies have reported its outcomes. The goal of this study was to report our initial results of RFURS, furthermore we proposed a novel metrics for composite outcome reporting named tetrafecta. A retrospective analysis of electronic records of 100 patients treated with RFURS for renal stones between 2019 till 2023 was performed. Tetrafecta criteria included, complete stone removal after a single treatment session, without auxiliary procedures, absence of high-grade complications (GIII-V) and same-day hospital discharge. Mean patient age and stone size were 40.7 ± 9.2 and 11.7 ± 5.8 mm, respectively. Median stone volume was 916 (421-12,235) mm3. Twenty-eight patients had multiple renal stones. Staghorn stones were seen in 12 patients. Preoperative DJ stent was fixed in 58 patients. Median operative time and stone treatment time were 116 min (97-148) and 37 (22-69) min. The median stone treatment efficiency (STE) was 21.6 (8.9-41.6). A strong positive correlation between stone volume and STE (R = 0.8, p < 0.0001). Overall, 73 patients were stone free after the initial treatment session while tetrafecta was achieved in 70 patients. Univariate analysis showed that the stone size (p = 0.008), acute infundibulopelvic angle (p = 0.023) and preoperative stenting (p = 0.017) had significant influence on achieving tetrafecta. Multivariate analysis identified preoperative stenting (OR 0.3, 95% CI 0.1-0.8, p = 0.019) as the only independent predictor of tetrafecta achievement. A comprehensive reporting methodology for reporting outcomes of RFURS is indicated for patient counseling and comparing different techniques. Tetrafecta was achieved in 70% of cases. Presence of significant residual stones ≥ 3mm was the leading cause of missing tetrafecta. Absence of preoperative stent was the only predictor of missing tetrafecta.

First prospective clinical assessment of the ILY® robotic flexible ureteroscopy platform

PURPOSE

To present the initial prospective clinical assessment of the ILY® robotic ureteroscopy manipulator platform, focusing on its safety and effectiveness.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Data gathered from 31 kidney units which underwent elective robotic flexible ureteroscopy (FURS) for renal stone management utilizing the ILY® robotic system. Patient demographics, stone characteristics, surgical durations, perioperative and post-operative complications, and follow-up parameters were collected. Our primary outcome was evaluating the efficacy and safety of the ILY® robotic ureteroscopy for treating kidney stones. Therefore, we analyzed complication rates, surgical durations, and the stone-free rate during follow-up.

RESULTS

Our cohort consisted of 29 patients, presenting with 45 stones with a median volume of 736.22 mm3. The median operation time was 85 min, accompanied by 3 min for robot draping, 3.5 min for robot docking, 48 min of console operation, and lasing time of 36.75 min. Post operative stay for all patients was 1 day, while complications were observed in 9.68% of cases. Notably, all complications were classified as CVD (Clavien-Dindo) class 1 due to pain requiring emergency department visit. The stone-free rate achieved was 93.55%, and none of the patient required reoperation for the treated stone.

CONCLUSION

In the first prospective clinical experience of the ILY® robotic FURS, we demonstrated its efficacy and safety. To further investigate its clinical practical value, additional investigations are warranted, including direct comparative analyses with manual flexible ureteroscopy techniques.

Ergonomics in Urology: Current Landscape and Future Directions

Optimal ergonomics are essential to improving clinical performance and longevity among urologists, as poor ergonomics can contribute to work-related injury and physician burnout. While a majority of urologists experience muscular injury throughout their career, women and trainees are disproportionately affected. These disparities are exacerbated by the lack of formal ergonomics education within urologic training programs. This review provides an overview of practical approaches to optimize ergonomics across working environments for urologists and trainees. We highlight intraoperative techniques and novel devices which have been shown to reduce work-related injury, and we identify knowledge gaps to guide future areas of ergonomic research.

Miniaturization of flexible ureteroscopes: a comparative trend analysis of 59 flexible ureteroscopes

The purpose of this review is to analyze the trend in miniaturization of flexible ureteroscopes over the past decades, identify the advantages and disadvantages, and determine the correlation of individual parameters with release period. Flexible ureteroscopes mentioned in the literature or those commercially available were searched. To minimize the search bias, the instruments were grouped by release date time periods of < 2000 year, 2000-2009, 2010-2019, and 2020 onwards. The final review included only those instrument models for which data on tip size, overall shaft, working length and channel size had been determined. The correlation among features investigated as well as with release period was also determined. 59 models of flexible ureteroscopes (26 fiber optic and 33 digital scopes) were included. Among the different features investigated among fiber optic endoscopes, only the sizes of the distal tip and overall shaft positively correlated with each other. In contrast to their fiber optic counterparts, a strong positive correlation was observed between tip and channel sizes, whereas negative correlation was found between channel size and overall shaft size and working length of digital scopes. Only distal tip of fiber optic flexible ureteroscopes and overall shaft of digital endoscopes were significantly reduced over their evolution. With the development of technology, there has been an improvement of flexible ureteroscopes and one of the indicators of this trend is a decrease in their size. With a definite trend towards miniaturization over the past decades, a significant correlation was observed in tip size and overall shaft for fiber optic and digital endoscopes, respectively.

Technique, Feasibility, Utility, Limitations, and Future Perspectives of a New Technique of Applying Direct In-Scope Suction to Improve Outcomes of Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery for Stones

Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) is accepted as a primary modality for the management of renal stones up to 2 cm. The limitations of RIRS in larger volume stones include limited visualization due to the snow-globe effect and persistence of fragments that cannot be removed. We describe a new, simple, cost-effective modification that can be attached to any flexible ureteroscope which allows simultaneous/alternating suction and aspiration during/after laser lithotripsy using the scope as a conduit to remove the fragments or dust from the pelvicalyceal system called direct in-scope suction (DISS) technique. Between September 2020 and September 2021, 30 patients with kidney stones underwent RIRS with the DISS technique. They were compared with 28 patients who underwent RIRS with a 11Fr/13Fr suction ureteral access sheaths (SUASs) in the same period. RIRS and laser lithotripsy were carried out traditionally with a Holmium laser for the SUAS group or a thulium fiber laser for the DISS group. There was no difference in age, gender, and history of renal lithiasis between the two groups. Ten (40%) patients had multiple stones in the DISS groups, whilst there were no patients with multiple stones in the SUAS group. Median stone size was significantly higher in the DISS group [22.0 (18.0−28.8) vs. 13.0 (11.8−15.0) millimeters, p < 0.001]. Median surgical time was significantly longer in the DISS group [80.0 (60.0−100) minutes] as compared to the SUAS group [47.5 (41.5−60.3) minutes, p < 0.001]. Hospital stay was significantly shorter in the DISS group [1.00 (0.667−1.00) vs. 1.00 (1.00−2.00) days, p = 0.02]. Postoperative complications were minor, and there was no significant difference between the two groups. The incidence of residual fragments did not significantly differ between the two groups [10 (33.3%) in the DISS group vs. 10 (35.7%) in the SUAS group, p = 0.99] but 10 (33.3%) patients required a further RIRS for residual fragments in the DISS group, whilst only one (3.6%) patient in the SUAS group required a subsequent shock wave lithotripsy treatment. Our audit study highlighted that RIRS with DISS technique was feasible with an acceptable rate of retreatment as compared to RIRS with SUAS.

Robotic Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery: A Journey from "Back to the Future"

The introduction of robotics has revolutionized surgery. Robotic platforms have also recently been introduced in clinical practice specifically for flexible ureteroscopy. In this paper, we look at the robotic platforms currently available for flexible ureteroscopy, describing their advantages and limitations. The following robotic platforms are discussed: Roboflex Avicenna^®, EasyUretero^®, and ILY^® robot. Finally, potential future advancements in this field are presented.