The Degree of Adeno-Associated Virus-Induced Retinal Inflammation Varies Based on Serotype and Route of Delivery: Intravitreal, Subretinal, or Suprachoroidal

Retina-directed gene therapy: Achievements and remaining challenges

Gene therapy is an innovative medical approach that offers new treatment options for congenital and acquired diseases by transferring, correcting, inactivating or regulating genes to supplement, replace or modify a gene function. The approval of voretigene neparvovec (Luxturna), a gene therapy for RPE65-associated retinopathy, has marked a milestone for the field of retinal gene therapy, but has also helped to accelerate the development of gene therapies for genetic diseases affecting other organs. Voretigene neparvovec is a vector based on adeno-associated virus (AAV) that delivers a functional copy of RPE65 to supplement the missing function of this gene. The AAV-based gene delivery has proven to be versatile and safe for the transfer of genetic material to retinal cells. However, challenges remain in treating additional inherited as well as acquired retinopathies with this technology. Despite the high level of activity in this field, no other AAV gene therapy for retinal diseases has been approved since voretigene neparvovec. Ongoing research focuses on overcoming the current restraints through innovative strategies like AAV capsid engineering, dual-AAV vector systems, or CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome editing. Additionally, AAV gene therapy is being explored for the treatment of complex acquired diseases like age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and diabetic retinopathy (DR) by targeting molecules involved in the pathobiology of the degenerative processes. This review outlines the current state of retinal gene therapy, highlighting ongoing challenges and future directions.

Gene Therapy-Associated Uveitis (GTAU): Understanding and mitigating the adverse immune response in retinal gene therapy

Retinal gene therapy using adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors has been a groundbreaking step-change in the treatment of inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) and could also be used to treat more common retinal diseases such as age-related macular degeneration and diabetic retinopathy. The delivery and expression of therapeutic transgenes in the eye is limited by innate and adaptive immune responses against components of the vector product, which has been termed gene therapy-associated uveitis (GTAU). This is clinically important as intraocular inflammation could lead to irreversible loss of retinal cells, deterioration of visual function and reduced durability of treatment effect associated with a costly one-off treatment. For retinal gene therapy to achieve an improved efficacy and safety profile for treating additional IRDs and more common diseases, the risk of GTAU must be minimised. We have collated insights from pre-clinical research, clinical trials, and the real-world implementation of AAV-mediated retinal gene therapy to help understand the risk factors for GTAU. We draw attention to an emerging framework, which includes patient demographics, vector construct, vector dose, route of administration, and choice of immunosuppression regime. Importantly, we consider efforts to date and potential future strategies to mitigate the adverse immune response across each of these domains. We advocate for more targeted immunomodulatory approaches to the prevention and treatment of GTAU based on better understanding of the underlying immune response.

Adeno-associated viruses for efficient gene expression in the axolotl nervous system

Axolotls are amphibian models for studying nervous system evolution, development, and regeneration. Tools to visualize and manipulate cells of the axolotl nervous system with high-efficiency, spatial and temporal precision are therefore greatly required. Recombinant adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) are frequently used for in vivo gene transfer of the nervous system but virus-mediated gene delivery to the axolotl nervous system has not yet been described. Here, we demonstrate the use of AAVs for efficient gene transfer within the axolotl brain, the spinal cord, and the retina. We show that serotypes AAV8, AAV9, and AAVPHP.eB are suitable viral vectors to infect both excitatory and inhibitory neuronal populations of the axolotl brain. We further use AAV9 to trace retrograde and anterograde projections between the retina and the brain and identify a cell population projecting from the brain to the retina. Together, our work establishes AAVs as a powerful tool to interrogate neuronal organization in the axolotl.

Characterization of the ocular inflammatory response to AAV reveals divergence by sex and age

Progress for ocular adeno-associated virus (AAV) gene therapy has been hindered by AAV-induced inflammation, limiting dose escalation and long-term efficacy. Broadly, the extent of inflammatory responses alters with age and sex, yet these factors are poorly represented in pre-clinical development of ocular AAV gene therapies. Here, we combined clinical imaging, flow cytometry, and bulk sequencing of sorted microglia to interrogate the longitudinal inflammatory response following intravitreal delivery of AAV2 in young (3-month-old), middle aged (9-month-old), and old (18-month-old) Cx3cr1-creER:R26tdTomato+/- mice of both sexes. Young males and females exhibited a similar dynamic response, with peak inflammation evident at days 10-12 and signs of clinical resolution by day 28. However, the magnitude of the transcriptional response by microglia and adaptive T cell infiltrate differed between sexes. With age, increased and persistent inflammation were observed in both sexes, although old males maintained their microglia transcriptional AAV response signature. Contrarily, females demonstrated greater divergence in their inflammatory response across age, with enriched cellular stress and inflammatory gene expression in older mice and corresponding signs of retinal degeneration. These findings inform crucial sex and age differences for the therapeutic application of ocular gene therapy, highlighting the need to further understand these factors to overcome AAV immunogenicity.

Intravitreal AAV2 gene delivery to feline retinal ganglion cells

Effective strategies for the neuroprotection and preservation of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) remain elusive in the management of glaucoma. A spontaneous genetic model of glaucoma has been identified in cats and extensively characterized as a viable translational model, with eye size and anatomy similar to humans. In this study we sought to establish initial proof of concept for gene delivery to feline RGCs via intravitreal injection of AAV2 in normal cats. Pre-retinal, posterior vitreal injection of AAV2/2-CMV-GFP, was performed overlying the area centralis in 5 adult cats. Immunosuppressive oral prednisolone was administered perioperatively and gradually tapered over 6-10wks post-injection. Ophthalmic examination was performed pre- and post-injection. The GFP reporter expression and morphological effects of viral transduction on the retina were monitored in vivo using confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (cSLO) and optical coherence tomography (OCT), respectively (Spectralis OCT-HRA, Heidelberg), at 1-2wk intervals over 6-10wks. Full-field electroretinograms (ERG) and visual evoked potentials (VEP) were recorded at baseline and post-injection. Retinas were examined by histology and immunolabeling for the RGC marker RBPMS and Müller cell and astrocyte marker SOX9, and GFP expression was examined in the retina, optic nerve (ON), optic tract and lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN). GFP+ retinal cells and RGC axons were visualized by cSLO at 1-2 weeks post-injection. No retinal morphological changes were observed by OCT in vivo but 3/5 eyes exhibited mild retinal inflammation on histology. Retinal and ON function were preserved in injected eyes compared to baseline and untreated eyes. GFP expression was predominantly identified in RBPMS+ RGC cells as well as SOX9+ Müller cells. GFP fluorescence was observed throughout RGC nerve fiber tract in the central visual pathway. Peak transduction in RGCs (up to ∼ 20 %) was observed in the regions with high GFP expression, but < 1 % of RGCs expressed GFP across the whole retina. Our data provide proof of concept that pre-retinal injection of AAV2/2 may represent a feasible platform for gene delivery to feline RGCs in vivo but highlight a need for further refinement to improve RGC transduction efficiency and control low-grade retinal inflammation.

Characterization of anti-AAV2 neutralizing antibody levels in sheep prior to and following intravitreal AAV2.7m8 injection

Gene augmentation therapy is a promising treatment for incurable, blinding inherited retinal diseases, and intravitreal delivery is being studied as a safe alternative to subretinal injections. Adeno-Associated Viruses (AAV) are commonly-used vectors for ocular gene augmentation therapy. Naturally occurring pre-operative exposure and infection with AAV could result in presence of neutralizing antibodies (NAB's) in patients' serum, and may affect the safety and efficacy of treatment. Our aim was to characterize the humoral response against AAV pre- and post-intravitreal delivery of AAV2.7m8 vectors in a naturally-occurring sheep model of CNGA3 achromatopsia. Serial serum neutralization assays were performed to screen sheep for pre-exiting anti-AAV2 NAB's, and to assess the effect of intravitreal AAV2.7m8 injection on post-operative NAB titers and intraocular inflammation in sheep. The effect of viral dose and transgene type were also assessed. Serological screening revealed pre-operative seropositivity in 21.4% of animals, with age being a risk factor for the presence of anti-AAV2 NAB's. NAB titers increased following intravitreal AAV administration in the majority of sheep. There was no significant difference in the degree of post-operative serum neutralization between pre-operatively seronegative sheep and those with pre-existing antibodies. However, only sheep with pre-existing antibodies presented with signs of post-operative inflammation. We conclude that pre-existing anti-AAV2 NAB's do not affect the level of post-operative NAB titers; however, they increase the risk of post-operative ocular inflammation. Our results could have implications for the management of AAV-mediated ocular gene therapies, a technology being increasingly studied and used in patients.

Gene therapy for age-related macular degeneration: potential, feasibility, and pitfalls

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The landscape for age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is rapidly changing with addition of biosimilars and now United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved nonneovascular AMD (nnAMD) treatment options. These developments have inspired a burgeoning pipeline of gene therapy approaches focused on similar antivascular endothelial growth factors (VEGF) and complement related pathways. Historic and more recent setbacks in the gene therapy pipeline, including intraocular inflammatory reactions, have raised important concerns for adverse events related to AMD therapeutics both for gene and nongene approaches. The specific clinical profile of these therapeutics approaching later stage clinical trials are complex and under active investigation; however, these options hold promise to disrupt the current landscape and change management paradigms for one of the leading causes of vision loss worldwide.

RECENT FINDINGS

This review covers current gene therapy approaches for neovascular AMD (nAMD) and nnAMD. Intravitreal, suprachoroidal, and subretinal delivery routes are discussed with attention to technical procedure, capabilities for transgene delivery to target tissue, immunogenicity, and collateral effects. Suprachoroidal delivery is an emerging approach which may bridge some of the practical drawbacks for intravitreal and subretinal methods, though with less elaborated immunologic profile. In parallel to delivery modification, viral vectors have been cultivated to target specific cells, with promising enhancements in adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors and persistent interest in alternate viral and nonviral delivery vectors. Ongoing questions such as steroid or immunosuppressive regimen and economic considerations from a payer and societal perspective are discussed.

SUMMARY

The present review discusses emerging gene therapy options which could foster new, more durable nAMD and nnAMD therapeutics. These options will need refinement with regards to route, vector, and dosage, and specialists must decipher the specific clinical risk benefit profile for individual patients. Ongoing concerns for immunogenicity or dosage related adverse events could stifle progress, while further vector development and refined delivery techniques have the potential to change the safety and efficacy of currently options in the pipeline.

Seeing the Future: A Review of Ocular Therapy

Ocular diseases present a unique challenge and opportunity for therapeutic development. The eye has distinct advantages as a therapy target given its accessibility, compartmentalization, immune privilege, and size. Various methodologies for therapeutic delivery in ocular diseases are under investigation that impact long-term efficacy, toxicity, invasiveness, and delivery range. While gene, cell, and antibody therapy and nanoparticle delivery directly treat regions that have been damaged by disease, they can be limited in the duration of the therapeutic delivery and have a focal effect. In contrast, contact lenses and ocular implants can more effectively achieve sustained and widespread delivery of therapies; however, they can increase dilution of therapeutics, which may result in reduced effectiveness. Current therapies either offer a sustained release or a broad therapeutic effect, and future directions should aim toward achieving both. This review discusses current ocular therapy delivery systems and their applications, mechanisms for delivering therapeutic products to ocular tissues, advantages and challenges associated with each delivery system, current approved therapies, and clinical trials. Future directions for the improvement in existing ocular therapies include combination therapies, such as combined cell and gene therapies, as well as AI-driven devices, such as cortical implants that directly transmit visual information to the cortex.

Gene and cell-based therapies for retinal and optic nerve disease

Leading causes of blindness worldwide include neurodegenerative diseases of the retina, which cause irreversible loss of retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and photoreceptors, and optic neuropathies, which result in retinal ganglion cell (RGC) death. Because photoreceptor and RGCs do not spontaneously regenerate in mammals, including humans, vision loss from these conditions is, at present, permanent. Recent advances in gene and cell-based therapies have provided new hope to patients affected by these conditions. This chapter reviews the current state and future of these approaches to treating ocular neurodegenerative disease. Gene therapies for retinal degeneration and optic neuropathies primarily focus on correcting known pathogenic mutations that cause inherited conditions to halt progression. There are multiple retinal and optic neuropathy gene therapies in clinical trials, and one retinal gene therapy is approved in the United States, Canada, Europe, and Australia. Cell-based therapies are mutation agnostic and have the potential to repopulate neurons regardless of the underlying etiology of degeneration. While photoreceptor cell replacement is nearing a human clinical trial, RPE transplantation is currently in phase I/II clinical trials. RGC replacement faces numerous logistical challenges, but preclinical research has laid the foundation for functional repair of optic neuropathies to be feasible.

The RLR intrinsic antiviral system is expressed in neural retina and restricts lentiviral transduction of human Mueller cells

The retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG)-I-like receptor (RLR) family of RNA sensor proteins plays a key role in the innate immune response to viral nucleic acids, including viral gene delivery vectors, but little is known about the expression of RLR proteins in the retina. The purpose of this study was to characterize cell-specific expression patterns of RLR proteins in non-human primate (NHP) neural retina tissue and to examine if RLR pathway signaling restricts viral gene delivery transduction. Since RLR protein signaling converges at the mitochondrial antiviral signaling protein (MAVS), experiments were performed to determine if knockdown of MAVS affected FIVGFP transduction efficiency in the human Mueller cell line MIO-M1. Immunoblotting confirmed expression of RIG-I, melanoma differentiation-associated protein 5 (MDA5), laboratory of genetics and physiology 2 (LGP2), and MAVS proteins in MIO-M1 cells and NHP retina tissue. Double label immunofluorescence (IF) studies revealed RIG-I, LGP2, and MAVS were expressed in Mueller microglial cells in the NHP retina. In addition, LGP2 and MDA5 proteins were detected in cone and retinal ganglion cells (RGC). MDA5 was also present in a subset of calretinin positive amacrine cells, and in nuclei within the inner nuclear layer (INL). Knockdown of MAVS significantly increased the transduction efficiency of the lentiviral vector FIVGFP in MIO-M1 cells, compared to control cells. FIVGFP or AAVGFP challenge did not alter expression of the LGP2, MAVS, MDA5 or RIG-I genes in MIO-M1 cells or NHP retina tissue compared to media treated controls. Our data demonstrate that innate immune response proteins involved in viral RNA sensing, including MDA5, RIG-I, LGP2, and MAVS, are expressed in several cell types within the NHP neural retina. In addition, the MAVS protein restricts non-human lentiviral transduction efficiency in MIO-M1 cells.

Suprachoroidal Injection: A Novel Approach for Targeted Drug Delivery

Treating posterior segment and retinal diseases poses challenges due to the complex structures in the eye that act as robust barriers, limiting medication delivery and bioavailability. This necessitates frequent dosing, typically via eye drops or intravitreal injections, to manage diseases, often leading to side effects with long-term use. Suprachoroidal injection is a novel approach for targeted drug delivery to the posterior segment. The suprachoroidal space is the region between the sclera and the choroid and provides a potential route for minimally invasive medication delivery. Through a more targeted delivery to the posterior segment, this method offers advantages over other routes of administration, such as higher drug concentrations, increased bioavailability, and prolonged duration of action. Additionally, this approach minimizes the risk of corticosteroid-related adverse events such as cataracts and intraocular pressure elevation via compartmentalization. This review focuses on preclinical and clinical studies published between 2019 and 2023, highlighting the potential of suprachoroidal injection in treating a variety of posterior segment diseases. However, to fully harness its potential, more research is needed to address current challenges and limitations, such as the need for technological advancements, refinement of injection techniques, and consideration of cost and accessibility factors. Future studies exploring its use in conjunction with biotech products, gene therapies, and cell-based therapies can lead to personalized treatments that can revolutionize the field of ophthalmology.