Transition from Pediatric to Adult Care for Transgender Youth: A Qualitative Study of Patient, Parent, and Provider Perspectives

"And I don't know how I can protect him from everything that's coming" - A qualitative study on minority stress among parents of transgender adolescents

BACKGROUND

Parents play a central role for transgender adolescents' well-being and their coping with minority stress, like discrimination, rejection and violence. Yet, little is known about the experiences of parents facing minority stress as they support their transgender children who are either awaiting or undergoing medical transition. Therefore, we aimed to first examine minority stress experiences reported by the parents with respect to distal and proximal stressors. Second, we aimed to explore whether experiences relate to children's stress experiences as secondary stress experiences, or if parents report minority stress directed at themselves as primary stress experiences.

METHODS

In the context of the participatory TRANS*PARENT study in Berlin, Germany, from April 2022 to September 2022 five focus groups were conducted with a total of 24 parents who have a transgender and/or non-binary child at the age of 11-18 years. Qualitative structuring content analysis was applied.

RESULTS

Parents reported distal stressors such as structural problems (in education, medical, psychiatric and psychological institutions, leisure activities and sports) and social rejection (peer rejection like bullying and violence, gaslighting, intersectionality, blame of others). Proximal stressors covered fears of future/anticipated discrimination, internalized gender stereotypes, and self-blame. Most experiences were secondary stressors, related to the child's minority stress causing frustration and sadness for the parents, while especially fears of the future/anticipated discrimination, gaslighting and blame of others emerged as central primary stressors.

DISCUSSION

Results show a complex interaction of minority stressors affecting both parents and their transgender children on structural and social levels. The impairment of their child's education and worries about its safety and life prospects burdened parents the most. The additional direct and primary stress experiences might impede their efforts to navigate their child's transition process.

CONCLUSION

In transgender health care, the multidimensionality of the structural and social impacts of marginalization needs to be addressed not only with respect to the transgender adolescents themselves, but also with respect to their caregivers. Further research should explore how child and parental stress interact and how family-based health care can alleviate stress on both child and parent level.

CLINICAL TRIAL NUMBER

Not applicable.

An exploration of anxiety and depressive symptoms among sexual and gender minority young adults visiting a drop-in center for youth experiencing homelessness

Background

Research suggests that marginalized young adults, particularly sexual and gender minorities (SGM), face distinctive healthcare transition challenges. SGM often navigate a complex intersection of identities, experiences, and stressors that can contribute to mental health disparities. However, they often lack access to appropriate support and resources tailored to their needs, which can result in increased psychological distress. Drop-in centers are effective mental health interventions for marginalized communities. Therefore, we conducted a study to explore the healthcare access experiences and mental health outcomes of young adult SGM compared to their non-SGM counterparts.

Methods

We surveyed 151 young adults aged 18-25 who visited two drop-in centers for young adults experiencing homelessness in Houston, Texas, between October and November 2018. Depressive and anxiety symptoms were assessed using Patient Health Questionnaire- 4 (PHQ-4.ther variables included demographics, prior mental health diagnosis, and experiences of homelessness and involvement in justice.

Results

Transgender and gender-diverse individuals had higher proportions of anxiety symptoms than their cisgender counterparts, while gay and lesbian individuals were more likely to experience depressive symptoms. In general, SGM individuals were three times more likely to report a previous anxiety diagnosis and four times more likely to report a previous depression diagnosis than their non-SGM counterparts. However, we did not find a significant association between having anxiety or depressive symptoms with seeking healthcare, experiences of homelessness, and justice involvement.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that drop-in centers can provide targeted care for SGM youth with intersecting needs, thus improving their mental health outcomes. Nevertheless, more research is needed to understand further and inform more targeted and effective evidence-based interventions that support SGM young adults across the trajectory of experiences, changing needs, and care coordination over time during this critical and vulnerable transition to adulthood.

Assessing Readiness for Transition From Pediatric to Adult Gender Affirming Care

PURPOSE

Transitioning from pediatric to adult care is a critical juncture in the health of adolescents. Little is known about how best to optimize transition to adult care among transgender and nonbinary (TGNB) youth. While the Transition Readiness and Assessment Questionnaire (TRAQ) has been validated in other pediatric populations, it has not been studied in TGNB youth. Our aims were to pilot the use of the TRAQ for TGNB patients, describe transition readiness patterns, and identify factors associated with transition readiness.

METHODS

The TRAQ was introduced into routine clinical care for patients and their caregivers in a large, urban pediatric gender program in the spring of 2021. We performed a retrospective chart review comparing TRAQ responses based on demographic and clinical data.

RESULTS

We collected TRAQs from 153 adolescents (mean age: 19 years [standard deviation 2.36], range: 11-24). The TRAQ demonstrated good internal reliability with a Cronbach alpha of 0.926. Patients scored highest in the TRAQ subdomains of talking with providers and tracking health issues and lowest in the subdomains of managing medications and appointment keeping. Age and presenting to the appointment alone were associated with higher TRAQ scores.

DISCUSSION

We found that the TRAQ is internally reliable in a sample of TGNB youth. Factors associated with higher TRAQ scores and patterns identified in TRAQ score subdomains provide an insight into the needs of TGNB youth preparing to transition to adult gender-affirming care. Future research should focus on tracking transition readiness longitudinally, developing and evaluating interventions to improve transition readiness, and assessing post-transition outcomes.

Transgender Youth Readiness for Health Care Transition: A Survey of Youth, Parents, and Providers

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to identify health care transition (HCT) readiness and skills among transgender youth transitioning gender-affirming care from pediatric to adult providers.

Methods

A convenience sample of youth, 14-21 years old, their parents, and health care providers recruited from a multidisciplinary transgender youth clinic in 2019 completed a modified version of the Got Transition readiness assessment with elements specific to gender-affirming care. Youth assessed their own readiness, parents assessed their child's readiness, and providers assessed their transgender patients' readiness overall.

Results

Twenty-nine youth (mean age 17.0 years), 26 parents, and 5 health care providers participated. Ratings of the overall importance of preparing for HCT were similar across all participant groups, and there were few disagreements on the importance of individual skills included in the readiness assessment. Ratings of overall HCT readiness were similar for youth regardless of age, while parents of younger youth (<18 years old) reported lower readiness than did parents of older youth. Youth rated their own competence in several skills higher compared with parents or providers, including knowledge of hormone therapy side effects. All groups of participants reported that youth most frequently needed assistance with scheduling appointments and keeping records of health information.

Conclusions

Survey of youth, parents, and providers suggests that youth and parents require additional support to navigate the HCT process, highlighting the importance of ongoing skills assessment and planning.

Adolescent Perceptions of Adult-Mediated Healthcare Communication

Adolescence is a time of rapid growth and development and may be accompanied by increased risk-taking behaviors and independence. Youth are particularly at risk for high levels of stress, decreased physical activity, unsafe sexual activity, abuse, depression, and suicide. Considering the unique health risks adolescents face, healthcare service access and utilization can play a pivotal role in promoting positive long term health outcomes throughout adulthood. At the same time, adolescents must often rely on parents/caregivers to mediate their healthcare access. Understanding how adolescents perceive adult interactions within healthcare is important for developing interventions that increase youth access to healthcare. We found that adolescents perceived adult-mediated healthcare experiences as either supportive (Subthemes: Recognition Builds Trust and Validation) or unsupportive (Subthemes: Adult-Focused Communication and Lack of Privacy). Based on our findings, we argue that prevention-focused interventions should include communication-based strategies. We discuss social work and healthcare practice and policy implications of these findings.

"Difficult to Find, Stressful to Navigate": Parents' Experiences Accessing Affirming Care for Gender-Diverse Youth

Purpose: Gender-diverse youth (GDY) face significant health disparities, which can be mitigated by gender-affirming medical care. Understanding parents' experiences seeking care for their GDY can identify barriers to care and improve access. This study sought to understand parents' experiences accessing gender-affirming medical care with their GDY. Methods: We asked parents of GDY in the United States to describe their experiences with gender-affirming medical care through a single open-ended item on an online survey disseminated through social media in February of 2020. Open-ended survey responses were analyzed through inductive thematic analysis by two authors using an iteratively developed codebook adjudicated by consensus. This codebook was used to identify key themes. Results: We analyzed 277 responses from majority White (93.9%) parents from 41 U.S. states. Themes included (1) Experiences accessing care: finding a provider, financial and insurance-related considerations, the impact of geography on care access; (2) Experiences receiving care: factors in successful or unsuccessful patient-provider interactions, differing approaches to initiating care, sense of community with other families; and (3) Outcomes related to receiving care: how care for their child was perceived to be lifesaving or helped their child thrive. Conclusions: Parents highlighted how access to gender-affirming medical care improved their GDY's health and wellbeing, and described numerous barriers they experienced with finding and receiving this care. Given the evidence that gender-affirming medical care mitigates health disparities, providers, policymakers, insurance companies, and health systems leaders should urgently address these challenges to ensure equitable receipt of care for all GDY.

A Mixed Methods Study on Healthcare Transition From Pediatric to Adult Care in Transgender and Gender-Diverse Adolescents and Young Adults

PURPOSE

This study assessed healthcare transition (HCT) readiness and barriers to HCT among transgender and gender diverse (TGD) adolescent and young adults (AYA) using mixed-method techniques.

METHODS

Fifty TGD AYA participants were surveyed using a validated transition readiness assessment questionnaire and open-ended questions examining challenges, influential factors, and health implications of HCT. Open-ended responses underwent qualitative analysis to identify consistent themes and response frequency.

RESULTS

Participants felt most prepared for communicating with providers and completing medical forms and least prepared for navigating insurance/financial systems. Half of the participants anticipated worsening mental health during HCT, with additional concerns related to transfer logistics and transphobia/discrimination. Participants identified intrinsic skills and external factors (such as social relationships) that would contribute to a more successful HCT.

DISCUSSION

TGD AYA face unique challenges in navigating the transition to adult health care, particularly related to concerns of discrimination and negative impacts on mental health, but these challenges may be mitigated by certain intrinsic resilience factors as well as targeted support from personal networks and pediatric providers.

Rural Perspectives on Health Services for Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth

As the world grows more diverse, physicians and public health practitioners must become adept at providing care to everyone, including people who identify as transgender or gender diverse (TGD). Although this population is growing in all age demographics, there is a large increase in young TGD individuals who require pediatric health care providers to improve their practices. While a few comprehensive care clinics have been established to serve the TGD community, they are mostly located in urban areas. In addition to the unique barriers faced by rural TGD youth, providers must care for their patients with limited resources. In this commentary, we offer a set of recommendations to improve provider education, build connections between the health system and community, address the fragmentation of health services in rural areas and improve the transition from pediatric to adult health care.

Understanding Transgender and Gender-Diverse Youth's Experiences Receiving Care via Telemedicine: Qualitative Interview Study

BACKGROUND

Access to virtual care has increased since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, yet little is known about transgender and gender-diverse (TGD) youth's experiences and perspectives on receiving care via telemedicine.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to explore these experiences to (1) inform necessary changes to the provision of pediatric gender-affirming care and (2) help providers and health systems determine if and how telemedicine should be made available post pandemic.

METHODS

Youth (aged 14-17 years) who completed a telemedicine visit in the Seattle Children's Gender Clinic were invited to participate in a semistructured interview exploring perceived advantages or disadvantages of telemedicine and preferred visit modalities. Interview transcriptions were analyzed by 2 research team members using an inductive thematic analysis framework.

RESULTS

A total of 15 TGD youth completed an interview. Commonly cited advantages of telemedicine were convenience and comfort with having visits in their own environments. Reported disadvantages included technical issues, discomfort with the impersonal nature, lack of familiarity with the platform, and privacy concerns. Overall, slightly more youth preferred in-person visits over telemedicine, referencing both specific characteristics of the clinical visit (ie, initial vs return and complexity) and proximity to the clinic as reasons for this preference. Although a plurality of TGD youth preferred in-person visits, they also recognized the value of telemedicine and the impact it may have in facilitating access to care.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the variations in needs and visit complexity, our study supports the provision of both in-person and telemedicine modalities as options for pediatric gender-affirming care.

The genogram as a recruitment tool for identifying primary caregivers of youth living with sickle cell disease preparing for transition

AIMS

The purpose of this secondary analysis was to describe the impact of using genograms to identify family caregivers from an original research study which used family caregiver-adolescents/young adults (AYA) dyads.

BACKGROUND

Research to improve transition preparation for AYA with chronic disease is essential as 90% will survive into adulthood. Family-based transition research is specifically needed as a majority of transition preparation will occur in the home setting. Dyadic research on transition has not previously described strategies for recruiting appropriate family caregivers.

DESIGN

A descriptive, secondary analysis was conducted using genograms developed during the original study conducted between October 2019 and February 2020.

METHODS

For this secondary analysis conducted between July 2020 and August 2021, 50 genograms were analysed using descriptive statistics to describe family structures, relationships and responsibilities in families of AYAs living with sickle cell disease.

RESULTS

In 43 genograms, there was only one primary caregiver in the family. In seven genograms, there were multiple primary caregivers who met the inclusion criteria for primary caregiver in a single family. In five genograms, there were two appropriate primary caregivers in a single family, and in two genograms, there were three appropriate individuals in a single family who met study criteria as a primary caregiver.

CONCLUSIONS

Findings from the analysis of the genograms used in the original study demonstrated potential ability to improve on dyad recruitment by more specifically identifying the family member most involved in supporting the AYA's disease management.

IMPACT

Genograms are an established tool for gathering information on families and application with recruitment could improve research in the realm of transition and other family-based research.

NO PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

This was a secondary analysis that assessed already existing data.

Feasibility of communication platforms to empower transgender cultural competence among human immunodeficiency virus screeners: A qualitative analysis

Background

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) screeners have limited experience of interacting with trans people. The application of communication platforms between them to empower HIV screeners' trans-related cultural competence remains unknown.

Objective

This study aims to qualitatively explore the follow-up interviews of HIV screeners regarding their opinions on the feasibility of an online platform group discussion and web page to enhance communication between them and trans people and to explore their perspectives on how these components enhanced their promotion of cultural competence.

Methods

This study was conducted between October 2020 and June 2021. Purposive and snowball sampling were applied to recruit 6 trans persons and 11 HIV screeners. Six online platform group discussions were held on weekday evenings, each group meeting for 60 min, 360 min in total within 3 months, via a video chat room of Google Meet; this was supplemented by a closed web page. The major results were presented through content analysis of the HIV screeners' follow-up interviews.

Results

The HIV screeners identified the facilitators of participating in the communication platforms, which included a reminder message, easy-to-use interface, visible-audible and readable interaction, recalled and reviewable content and group belonging; the barriers included time and space limitation, device restrictions and operation problem. Two categories of trans-related cultural competence - trans awareness and action taken - were revealed, from which five major themes emerged: provoked to ask questions, improved cognition, reflection, trans-sensitive communication and self-enhancement.

Conclusion

The results revealed that the communication platforms could facilitate the mutual and vivid discussion between HIV screeners and trans people and empower the trans-related cultural competence of HIV screeners. The highly feasible intervention design of this research can be applied to digital training courses related to gender diversity issues.

Setting a research agenda in trans health: An expert assessment of priorities and issues by trans and nonbinary researchers

Background

This article is by a group of trans and nonbinary researchers and experts in the field of trans health who have conducted an analysis of trans health research needs.

Aims

To highlight topics that need further research and to outline key considerations for those conducting research in our field.

Methods

The first author conducted semi-structured interviews with all coauthors, and these were used to create a first draft of this manuscript. This draft was circulated to all authors, with edits made until consensus was reached among the authors.

Results

More comprehensive long-term research that centers trans people's experiences is needed on the risks and benefits of gender affirming hormones and surgeries. The trans health research field also needs to have a broader focus beyond medical transition or gender affirmation, including general health and routine healthcare; trans people's lives without, before, and after medical gender affirmation; and sexuality, fertility, and reproductive healthcare needs. More research is also needed on social determinants of health, including ways to make healthcare settings and other environments safer and more supportive; social and legal gender recognition; the needs of trans people who are most marginalized; and the ways in which healing happens within trans communities. The second part of this article highlights key considerations for researchers, the foremost being acknowledging trans community expertise and centering trans community members' input into research design and interpretation of findings, in advisory and/or researcher roles. Ethical considerations include maximizing benefits and minimizing harms (beneficence) and transparency and accountability to trans communities. Finally, we note the importance of conferences, grant funding, working with students, and multidisciplinary teams.

Discussion

This article outlines topics and issues needing further consideration to make the field of trans health research more responsive to the needs of trans people. This work is limited by our authorship group being mostly White, all being Anglophone, and residing in the Global North.