Transmembrane helix hydrophobicity is an energetic barrier during the retrotranslocation of integral membrane ERAD substrates

Identification of polycystin 2 missense mutants targeted for endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is a common genetic disorder leading to end-stage renal disease. ADPKD arises from mutations in the PKD1 and PKD2 genes, which encode polycystin 1 (PC1) and polycystin 2 (PC2), respectively. PC2 is a nonselective cation channel, and disease-linked mutations disrupt normal cellular processes, including signaling and fluid secretion. In this study, we investigate whether disease-causing missense mutations compromise PC2 folding, an event that can lead to endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation (ERAD). To this end, we first developed a new yeast PC2 expression system. We show that the yeast system provides a tractable model to investigate PC2 biogenesis and that a disease-associated PC2 mutant, D511V, exhibits increased polyubiquitination and accelerated proteasome-dependent degradation compared with wild-type PC2. In contrast to wild-type PC2, the PC2 D511V variant also failed to improve the growth of yeast strains that lack endogenous potassium transporters, highlighting a loss of channel function at the cell surface and a new assay for loss-of-function PKD2 variants. In HEK293 cells, both D511V along with another disease-associated mutant, R322Q, were targeted for ERAD. Consistent with defects in protein folding, the surface localization of these PC2 variants was increased by incubation at low-temperature in HEK293 cells, underscoring the potential to pharmacologically rescue these and perhaps other misfolded PC2 alleles. Together, our study supports the hypothesis that select PC2 missense variants are degraded by ERAD, the potential for screening PKD2 alleles in a new genetic system, and the possibility that chemical chaperone-based therapeutic interventions might be used to treat ADPKD.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study indicates that select missense mutations in PC2, a protein that when mutated leads to ADPKD, result in protein misfolding and degradation via the ERAD pathway. Our work leveraged a new yeast model and an HEK293 cell model to discover the mechanism underlying PC2 instability and demonstrates the potential for pharmacological rescue. We also suggest that targeting the protein misfolding phenotype with chemical chaperones may offer new therapeutic strategies to manage ADPKD-related protein dysfunction.

The Dsc complex and its role in Golgi quality control

Membrane proteins play crucial roles in cellular functions. However, processes such as the insertion of membrane proteins into the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), their folding into native structures, the assembly of multi-subunit membrane protein complexes, and their targeting from the ER to specific organelles are prone to errors and have a relatively high failure rate. To prevent the accumulation of defective or orphaned membrane proteins, quality control mechanisms assess folding, quantity, and localization of these proteins. This quality control is vital for preserving organelle integrity and maintaining cellular health. In this mini-review, we will focus on how selective membrane protein quality control at the Golgi apparatus, particularly through the defective for SREBP cleavage (Dsc) ubiquitin ligase complex, detects orphaned proteins and prevents their mis-localization to other organelles.

The Dsc ubiquitin ligase complex identifies transmembrane degrons to degrade orphaned proteins at the Golgi

The Golgi apparatus is essential for protein sorting, yet its quality control mechanisms are poorly understood. Here we show that the Dsc ubiquitin ligase complex uses its rhomboid pseudo-protease subunit, Dsc2, to assess the hydrophobic length of α-helical transmembrane domains (TMDs) at the Golgi. Thereby the Dsc complex likely interacts with orphaned ER and Golgi proteins that have shorter TMDs and ubiquitinates them for targeted degradation. Some Dsc substrates will be extracted by Cdc48 for endosome and Golgi associated proteasomal degradation (EGAD), while others will undergo ESCRT dependent vacuolar degradation. Some substrates are degraded by both, EGAD- or ESCRT pathways. The accumulation of Dsc substrates entails a specific increase in glycerophospholipids with shorter and asymmetric fatty acyl chains. Hence, the Dsc complex mediates the selective degradation of orphaned proteins at the sorting center of cells, which prevents their spreading across other organelles and thereby preserves cellular membrane protein and lipid composition.

The AAA+ protein Msp1 recognizes substrates by a hydrophobic mismatch

An essential aspect of protein quality control is enzymatic removal of membrane proteins from the lipid bilayer. Failures in this essential cellular process are associated with neurodegenerative diseases and cancer. Msp1 is a AAA+ (ATPases Associated with diverse cellular Activities) protein that removes mistargeted proteins from the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM). How Msp1 selectively recognizes and extracts substrates within the complex OMM ecosystem, and the role of the lipid bilayer on these processes is unknown. Here, we describe the development of fully defined, rapid, and quantitative extraction assay that retains physiological substrate selectivity. Using this new assay, we systematically modified both substrates and the lipid environment to demonstrate that Msp1 recognizes substrates by a hydrophobic mismatch between the substrate TMD and the lipid bilayer. We further demonstrate that the rate limiting step in Msp1 activity is extraction of the TMD from the lipid bilayer. Together, these results provide foundational insights into how the lipid bilayer influences AAA+ mediated membrane protein extraction.

Energetic requirements and mechanistic plasticity in Msp1-mediated substrate extraction from lipid bilayers

AAA+ proteins are essential molecular motors involved in numerous cellular processes, yet their mechanism of action in extracting membrane proteins from lipid bilayers remains poorly understood. One roadblock for mechanistic studies is the inability to generate subunit specific mutations within these hexameric proteins. Using the mitochondrial AAA+ protein Msp1 as a model, we created covalently linked dimers with varying combinations of wild type and catalytically inactive E193Q mutations. The wide range of ATPase rates in these constructs allows us to probe how Msp1 uses the energy from ATP hydrolysis to perform the thermodynamically unfavorable task of removing a transmembrane helix (TMH) from a lipid bilayer. Our in vitro and in vivo assays reveal a non-linear relationship between ATP hydrolysis and membrane protein extraction, suggesting a minimum ATP hydrolysis rate is required for effective TMH extraction. While structural data often supports a sequential clockwise/2-residue step (SC/2R) mechanism for ATP hydrolysis, our biochemical evidence suggests mechanistic plasticity in how Msp1 coordinates ATP hydrolysis between subunits, potentially allowing for robustness in processing challenging substrates. This study enhances our understanding of how Msp1 coordinates ATP hydrolysis to drive mechanical work and provides foundational insights about the minimum energetic requirements for TMH extraction and the coordination of ATP hydrolysis in AAA+ proteins.

HERC3 facilitates ERAD of select membrane proteins by recognizing membrane-spanning domains

Aberrant proteins located in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) undergo rapid ubiquitination by multiple ubiquitin (Ub) E3 ligases and are retrotranslocated to the cytosol as part of the ER-associated degradation (ERAD). Despite several ERAD branches involving different Ub E3 ligases, the molecular machinery responsible for these ERAD branches in mammalian cells remains not fully understood. Through a series of multiplex knockdown/knockout experiments with real-time kinetic measurements, we demonstrate that HERC3 operates independently of the ER-embedded ubiquitin ligases RNF5 and RNF185 (RNF5/185) to mediate the retrotranslocation and ERAD of misfolded CFTR. While RNF5/185 participates in the ERAD process of both misfolded ABCB1 and CFTR, HERC3 uniquely promotes CFTR ERAD. In vitro assay revealed that HERC3 directly interacts with the exposed membrane-spanning domains (MSDs) of CFTR but not with the MSDs embedded in liposomes. Therefore, HERC3 could play a role in the quality control of MSDs in the cytoplasm and might be crucial for the ERAD pathway of select membrane proteins.

The expression system influences stability, maturation efficiency, and oligomeric properties of the potassium-chloride co-transporter KCC2

The neuron-specific K+/Cl- co-transporter 2, KCC2, which is critical for brain development, regulates γ-aminobutyric acid-dependent inhibitory neurotransmission. Consistent with its function, mutations in KCC2 are linked to neurodevelopmental disorders, including epilepsy, schizophrenia, and autism. KCC2 possesses 12 transmembrane spans and forms an intertwined dimer. Based on its complex architecture and function, reduced cell surface expression and/or activity have been reported when select disease-associated mutations are present in the gene encoding the protein, SLC12A5. These data suggest that KCC2 might be inherently unstable, as seen for other complex polytopic ion channels, thus making it susceptible to cellular quality control pathways that degrade misfolded proteins. To test these hypotheses, we examined KCC2 stability and/or maturation in five model systems: yeast, HEK293 cells, primary rat neurons, and rat and human brain synaptosomes. Although studies in yeast revealed that KCC2 is selected for endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation (ERAD), experiments in HEK293 cells supported a more subtle role for ERAD in maintaining steady-state levels of KCC2. Nevertheless, this system allowed for an analysis of KCC2 glycosylation in the ER and Golgi, which serves as a read-out for transport through the secretory pathway. In turn, KCC2 was remarkably stable in primary rat neurons, suggesting that KCC2 folds efficiently in more native systems. Consistent with these data, the mature glycosylated form of KCC2 was abundant in primary rat neurons as well as in rat and human brain. Together, this work details the first insights into the influence that the cellular and membrane environments have on several fundamental KCC2 properties, acknowledges the advantages and disadvantages of each system, and helps set the stage for future experiments to assess KCC2 in a normal or disease setting.

The generation of detergent-insoluble clipped fragments from an ERAD substrate in mammalian cells

Proteostasis ensures the proper synthesis, folding, and trafficking of proteins and is required for cellular and organellar homeostasis. This network also oversees protein quality control within the cell and prevents accumulation of aberrant proteins, which can lead to cellular dysfunction and disease. For example, protein aggregates irreversibly disrupt proteostasis and can exert gain-of-function toxic effects. Although this process has been examined in detail for cytosolic proteins, how endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-tethered, aggregation-prone proteins are handled is ill-defined. To determine how a membrane protein with a cytoplasmic aggregation-prone domain is routed for ER-associated degradation (ERAD), we analyzed a new model substrate, TM-Ubc9ts. In yeast, we previously showed that TM-Ubc9ts ERAD requires Hsp104, which is absent in higher cells. In transient and stable HEK293 cells, we now report that TM-Ubc9ts degradation is largely proteasome-dependent, especially at elevated temperatures. In contrast to yeast, clipped TM-Ubc9ts polypeptides, which are stabilized upon proteasome inhibition, accumulate and are insoluble at elevated temperatures. TM-Ubc9ts cleavage is independent of the intramembrane protease RHBDL4, which clips other classes of ERAD substrates. These studies highlight an unappreciated mechanism underlying the degradation of aggregation-prone substrates in the ER and invite further work on other proteases that contribute to ERAD.

Lhs1 dependent ERAD is determined by transmembrane domain context

Transmembrane proteins have unique requirements to fold and integrate into the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane. Most notably, transmembrane proteins must fold in three separate environments: extracellular domains fold in the oxidizing environment of the ER lumen, transmembrane domains (TMDs) fold within the lipid bilayer, and cytosolic domains fold in the reducing environment of the cytosol. Moreover, each region is acted upon by a unique set of chaperones and monitored by components of the ER associated quality control machinery that identify misfolded domains in each compartment. One factor is the ER lumenal Hsp70-like chaperone, Lhs1. Our previous work established that Lhs1 is required for the degradation of the unassembled α-subunit of the epithelial sodium channel (αENaC), but not the homologous β- and γENaC subunits. However, assembly of the ENaC heterotrimer blocked the Lhs1-dependent ER associated degradation (ERAD) of the α-subunit, yet the characteristics that dictate the specificity of Lhs1-dependent ERAD substrates remained unclear. We now report that Lhs1-dependent substrates share a unique set of features. First, all Lhs1 substrates appear to be unglycosylated, and second they contain two TMDs. Each substrate also contains orphaned or unassembled TMDs. Additionally, interfering with inter-subunit assembly of the ENaC trimer results in Lhs1-dependent degradation of the entire complex. Finally, our work suggests that Lhs1 is required for a subset of ERAD substrates that also require the Hrd1 ubiquitin ligase. Together, these data provide hints as to the identities of as-yet unconfirmed substrates of Lhs1 and potentially of the Lhs1 homolog in mammals, GRP170.

Recycling of cell surface membrane proteins from yeast endosomes is regulated by ubiquitinated Ist1

Upon internalization, many surface membrane proteins are recycled back to the plasma membrane. Although these endosomal trafficking pathways control surface protein activity, the precise regulatory features and division of labor between interconnected pathways are poorly defined. In yeast, we show recycling back to the surface occurs through distinct pathways. In addition to retrograde recycling pathways via the late Golgi, used by synaptobrevins and driven by cargo ubiquitination, we find nutrient transporter recycling bypasses the Golgi in a pathway driven by cargo deubiquitination. Nutrient transporters rapidly internalize to, and recycle from, endosomes marked by the ESCRT-III associated factor Ist1. This compartment serves as both “early” and “recycling” endosome. We show Ist1 is ubiquitinated and that this is required for proper endosomal recruitment and cargo recycling to the surface. Additionally, the essential ATPase Cdc48 and its adaptor Npl4 are required for recycling, potentially through regulation of ubiquitinated Ist1. This collectively suggests mechanistic features of recycling from endosomes to the plasma membrane are conserved.

Elements of the ERAD ubiquitin ligase Doa10 regulating sequential poly-ubiquitylation of its targets

In ER-associated degradation (ERAD), misfolded ER proteins are degraded by the proteasome after undergoing ubiquitylation. Yeast Doa10 (human MARCHF6/TEB4) is a membrane-embedded E3 ubiquitin ligase that functions with E2s Ubc6 and Ubc7. Ubc6 attaches a single ubiquitin to substrates, which is extended by Ubc7 to form a polyubiquitin chain. We show the conserved C-terminal element (CTE) of Doa10 promotes E3-mediated Ubc6 activity. Doa10 substrates undergoing an alternative ubiquitylation mechanism are still degraded in CTE-mutant cells. Structure prediction by AlphaFold2 suggests the CTE binds near the catalytic RING-CH domain, implying a direct role in substrate ubiquitylation, and we confirm this interaction using intragenic suppression. Truncation analysis defines a minimal E2-binding region of Doa10; structural predictions suggest that Doa10 forms a retrotranslocation channel and that E2s bind within the cofactor-binding region defined here. These results provide mechanistic insight into how Doa10, and potentially other ligases, interact with their cofactors and mediate ERAD.

•

The conserved Doa10 C-terminus promotes E3-mediated activity of Ubc6

•

The minimal E2-binding region of Doa10 includes TMs 1–9

•

The N- and C-terminus of Doa10 interact, likely forming an ERAD protein channel

Towards understanding inner nuclear membrane protein degradation in plants

The inner nuclear membrane (INM) hosts a unique set of membrane proteins that play essential roles in various aspects of the nuclear function. However, overaccumulation or malfunction of INM protein has been associated with a range of rare genetic diseases; therefore, maintaining the homeostasis and integrity of INM proteins by active removal of aberrantly accumulated proteins and replacing defective molecules through proteolysis is of critical importance. Within the last decade, it has been shown that INM proteins are degraded in yeasts by a process very similar to endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation (ERAD), which is accomplished by retrotranslocation of membrane substrates followed by proteasome-dependent proteolysis, and this process was named inner nuclear membrane-associated degradation (INMAD). INMAD is distinguished from ERAD by specific INM-localized E3 ubiquitin ligases and proteolysis regulators. While much is yet to be determined about the INMAD pathway in yeasts, virtually no knowledge of it exists for higher eukaryotes, and only very recently have several critical regulators that participate in INM protein degradation been discovered in plants. Here, we review key molecular components of the INMAD pathway and draw parallels between the yeast and plant system to discuss promising directions in the future study of the plant INMAD process.

Substrate ubiquitination retains misfolded membrane proteins in the endoplasmic reticulum for degradation

To maintain secretory pathway fidelity, misfolded proteins are commonly retained in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and selected for ER-associated degradation (ERAD). Soluble misfolded proteins use ER chaperones for retention, but the machinery that restricts aberrant membrane proteins to the ER is unclear. In fact, some misfolded membrane proteins escape the ER and traffic to the lysosome/vacuole. To this end, we describe a model substrate, SZ*, that contains an ER export signal but is also targeted for ERAD. We observe decreased ER retention when chaperone-dependent SZ* ubiquitination is compromised. In addition, appending a linear tetra-ubiquitin motif onto SZ* overrides ER export. By screening known ubiquitin-binding proteins, we then positively correlate SZ* retention with Ubx2 binding. Deletion of Ubx2 also inhibits the retention of another misfolded membrane protein. Our results indicate that polyubiquitination is sufficient to retain misfolded membrane proteins in the ER prior to ERAD.

Sun et al. characterize how misfolded membrane proteins are delivered for either ERAD or post-ER degradation in the secretory pathway. By using a model substrate that can access both pathways, they show that substrate retention requires chaperone-dependent substrate ubiquitination and interaction with a conserved ER membrane protein, Ubx2.

Distinct classes of misfolded proteins differentially affect the growth of yeast compromised for proteasome function

Maintenance of the proteome (proteostasis) is essential for cellular homeostasis and prevents cytotoxic stress responses that arise from protein misfolding. However, little is known about how different types of misfolded proteins impact homeostasis, especially when protein degradation pathways are compromised. We examined the effects of misfolded protein expression on yeast growth by characterizing a suite of substrates possessing the same aggregation-prone domain but engaging different quality control pathways. We discovered that treatment with a proteasome inhibitor was more toxic in yeast expressing misfolded membrane proteins, and this growth defect was mirrored in yeast lacking a proteasome-specific transcription factor, Rpn4p. These results highlight weaknesses in the proteostasis network's ability to handle the stress arising from an accumulation of misfolded membrane proteins.

The Capture of a Disabled Proteasome Identifies Erg25 as a Substrate for Endoplasmic Reticulum Associated Degradation

Studies in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have helped define mechanisms underlying the activity of the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS), uncover the proteasome assembly pathway, and link the UPS to the maintenance of cellular homeostasis. However, the spectrum of UPS substrates is incompletely defined, even though multiple techniques-including MS-have been used. Therefore, we developed a substrate trapping proteomics workflow to identify previously unknown UPS substrates. We first generated a yeast strain with an epitope tagged proteasome subunit to which a proteasome inhibitor could be applied. Parallel experiments utilized inhibitor insensitive strains or strains lacking the tagged subunit. After affinity isolation, enriched proteins were resolved, in-gel digested, and analyzed by high resolution liquid chromatography-tandem MS. A total of 149 proteasome partners were identified, including all 33 proteasome subunits. When we next compared data between inhibitor sensitive and resistant cells, 27 proteasome partners were significantly enriched. Among these proteins were known UPS substrates and proteins that escort ubiquitinated substrates to the proteasome. We also detected Erg25 as a high-confidence partner. Erg25 is a methyl oxidase that converts dimethylzymosterol to zymosterol, a precursor of the plasma membrane sterol, ergosterol. Because Erg25 is a resident of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and had not previously been directly characterized as a UPS substrate, we asked whether Erg25 is a target of the ER associated degradation (ERAD) pathway, which most commonly mediates proteasome-dependent destruction of aberrant proteins. As anticipated, Erg25 was ubiquitinated and associated with stalled proteasomes. Further, Erg25 degradation depended on ERAD-associated ubiquitin ligases and was regulated by sterol synthesis. These data expand the cohort of lipid biosynthetic enzymes targeted for ERAD, highlight the role of the UPS in maintaining ER function, and provide a novel tool to uncover other UPS substrates via manipulations of our engineered strain.

Multiplexed measurement of variant abundance and activity reveals VKOR topology, active site and human variant impact

Vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR) drives the vitamin K cycle, activating vitamin K-dependent blood clotting factors. VKOR is also the target of the widely used anticoagulant drug, warfarin. Despite VKOR's pivotal role in coagulation, its structure and active site remain poorly understood. In addition, VKOR variants can cause vitamin K-dependent clotting factor deficiency or alter warfarin response. Here, we used multiplexed, sequencing-based assays to measure the effects of 2,695 VKOR missense variants on abundance and 697 variants on activity in cultured human cells. The large-scale functional data, along with an evolutionary coupling analysis, supports a four transmembrane domain topology, with variants in transmembrane domains exhibiting strongly deleterious effects on abundance and activity. Functionally constrained regions of the protein define the active site, and we find that, of four conserved cysteines putatively critical for function, only three are absolutely required. Finally, 25% of human VKOR missense variants show reduced abundance or activity, possibly conferring warfarin sensitivity or causing disease.

Doa10 is a membrane protein retrotranslocase in ER-associated protein degradation

In endoplasmic reticulum-associated protein degradation (ERAD), membrane proteins are ubiquitinated, extracted from the membrane, and degraded by the proteasome. The cytosolic ATPase Cdc48 drives extraction by pulling on polyubiquitinated substrates. How hydrophobic transmembrane (TM) segments are moved from the phospholipid bilayer into cytosol, often together with hydrophilic and folded ER luminal protein parts, is not known. Using a reconstituted system with purified proteins from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we show that the ubiquitin ligase Doa10 (Teb-4/MARCH6 in animals) is a retrotranslocase that facilitates membrane protein extraction. A substrate’s TM segment interacts with the membrane-embedded domain of Doa10 and then passively moves into the aqueous phase. Luminal substrate segments cross the membrane in an unfolded state. Their unfolding occurs on the luminal side of the membrane by cytoplasmic Cdc48 action. Our results reveal how a membrane-bound retrotranslocase cooperates with the Cdc48 ATPase in membrane protein extraction.

The inside of a cell contains many different compartments called organelles, which are separated by membranes. Each organelle is composed of a unique set of proteins and performs specific roles in the cell. The endoplasmic reticulum, or ER for short, is an organelle where many proteins are produced. Most of these proteins are then released from the cell or sorted to other organelles. The ER has a strict quality control system that ensures any faulty proteins are quickly marked for the cell to destroy. However, the destruction process itself does not happen in the ER, so faulty proteins first need to leave this organelle. This is achieved by a group of proteins known as endoplasmic reticulum-associated protein degradation machinery (or ERAD for short).

To extract a faulty protein from the ER, proteins of the ER and outside the ER cooperate. First, an ERAD protein called Doa10 attaches a small protein tag called ubiquitin to the faulty proteins to mark them for destruction. Then, outside of the ER, a protein called Cdc48 ‘grabs’ the ubiquitin tag and pulls. But that is only part of the story. Many of the proteins made by the ER have tethers that anchor them firmly to the membrane, making them much harder to remove.

To get a better idea of how the extraction works, Schmidt et al. rebuilt the ERAD machinery in a test tube. This involved purifying proteins from yeast and inserting them into artificial membranes, allowing closer study of each part of the process. This revealed that attaching ubiquitin tags to faulty proteins is only one part of Doa10's role; it also participates in the extraction itself. Part of Doa10 resides within the membrane, and this ‘membrane-spanning domain’ can interact with faulty proteins, loosening their membrane anchors. At the same time, Cdc48 pulls from the outside. This pulling force causes the faulty proteins to unfold, allowing them to pass through the membrane.

Given these findings, the next step is to find out exactly how Doa10 works by looking at its three-dimensional structure. This could have implications not only for the study of ERAD, but of similar quality control processes in other organelles too. A build-up of faulty proteins can cause diseases like neurodegeneration, so understanding how cells remove faulty proteins could help future medical research.

Protein quality control in the secretory pathway

Protein folding is inherently error prone, especially in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Even with an elaborate network of molecular chaperones and protein folding facilitators, misfolding can occur quite frequently. To maintain protein homeostasis, eukaryotes have evolved a series of protein quality-control checkpoints. When secretory pathway quality-control pathways fail, stress response pathways, such as the unfolded protein response (UPR), are induced. In addition, the ER, which is the initial hub of protein biogenesis in the secretory pathway, triages misfolded proteins by delivering substrates to the proteasome or to the lysosome/vacuole through ER-associated degradation (ERAD) or ER-phagy. Some misfolded proteins escape the ER and are instead selected for Golgi quality control. These substrates are targeted for degradation after retrieval to the ER or delivery to the lysosome/vacuole. Here, we discuss how these guardian pathways function, how their activities intersect upon induction of the UPR, and how decisions are made to dispose of misfolded proteins in the secretory pathway.

Exploring the Functional Consequences of Protein Backbone Alteration in Ubiquitin through Native Chemical Ligation

Ubiquitin (Ub) plays critical roles in myriad protein degradation and signaling networks in the cell. We report herein Ub mimetics based on backbones that blend natural and artificial amino acid units. The variants were prepared by a modular route based on native chemical ligation. Biological assays show that some are enzymatically polymerized onto protein substrates, and that the resulting Ub tags are recognized for downstream pathways. These results advance the size and complexity of folded proteins mimicked by artificial backbones and expand the functional scope of such agents.

Chaperoning Endoplasmic Reticulum-Associated Degradation (ERAD) and Protein Conformational Diseases

Misfolded proteins compromise cellular homeostasis. This is especially problematic in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), which is a high-capacity protein-folding compartment and whose function requires stringent protein quality-control systems. Multiprotein complexes in the ER are able to identify, remove, ubiquitinate, and deliver misfolded proteins to the 26S proteasome for degradation in the cytosol, and these events are collectively termed ER-associated degradation, or ERAD. Several steps in the ERAD pathway are facilitated by molecular chaperone networks, and the importance of ERAD is highlighted by the fact that this pathway is linked to numerous protein conformational diseases. In this review, we discuss the factors that constitute the ERAD machinery and detail how each step in the pathway occurs. We then highlight the underlying pathophysiology of protein conformational diseases associated with ERAD.

Harmonizing Experimental Data with Modeling to Predict Membrane Protein Insertion in Yeast

Membrane proteins must adopt their proper topologies within biological membranes, but achieving the correct topology is compromised by the presence of marginally hydrophobic transmembrane helices (TMHs). In this study, we report on a new model membrane protein in yeast that harbors two TMHs fused to an unstable nucleotide-binding domain. Because the second helix (TMH2) in this reporter has an unfavorable predicted free energy of insertion, we employed established methods to generate variants that alter TMH2 insertion free energy. We first found that altering TMH2 did not significantly affect the extent of protein degradation by the cellular quality control machinery. Next, we correlated predicted insertion free energies from a knowledge-based energy scale with the measured apparent free energies of TMH2 insertion. Although the predicted and apparent insertion energies showed a similar trend, the predicted free-energy changes spanned an unanticipated narrow range. By instead using a physics-based model, we obtained a broader range of free energies that agreed considerably better with the magnitude of the experimentally derived values. Nevertheless, some variants still inserted better in yeast than predicted from energy-based scales. Therefore, molecular dynamics simulations were performed and indicated that the corresponding mutations induced conformational changes within TMH2, which altered the number of stabilizing hydrogen bonds. Together, our results offer insight into the ability of the cellular quality control machinery to recognize conformationally distinct misfolded topomers, provide a model to assess TMH insertion in vivo, and indicate that TMH insertion energy scales may be limited depending on the specific protein and the mutation present.

Hsp104 facilitates the endoplasmic-reticulum-associated degradation of disease-associated and aggregation-prone substrates

Misfolded proteins in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) are selected for ER-associated degradation (ERAD). More than 60 disease-associated proteins are substrates for the ERAD pathway due to the presence of missense or nonsense mutations. In yeast, the Hsp104 molecular chaperone disaggregates detergent-insoluble ERAD substrates, but the spectrum of disease-associated ERAD substrates that may be aggregation prone is unknown. To determine if Hsp104 recognizes aggregation-prone ERAD substrates associated with human diseases, we developed yeast expression systems for a hydrophobic lipid-binding protein, apolipoprotein B (ApoB), along with a chimeric protein harboring a nucleotide-binding domain from the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) into which disease-causing mutations were introduced. We discovered that Hsp104 facilitates the degradation of ER-associated ApoB as well as a truncated CFTR chimera in which a premature stop codon corresponds to a disease-causing mutation. Chimeras containing a wild-type version of the CFTR domain or a different mutation were stable and thus Hsp104 independent. We also discovered that the detergent solubility of the unstable chimera was lower than the stable chimeras, and Hsp104 helped retrotranslocate the unstable chimera from the ER, consistent with disaggregase activity. To determine why the truncated chimera was unstable, we next performed molecular dynamics simulations and noted significant unraveling of the CFTR nucleotide-binding domain. Because human cells lack Hsp104, these data indicate that an alternate disaggregase or mechanism facilitates the removal of aggregation-prone, disease-causing ERAD substrates in their native environments.

The degradation pathway of a model misfolded protein is determined by aggregation propensity

Protein homeostasis in the secretory pathway is maintained by a hierarchy of quality control checkpoints, including endoplasmic reticulum–associated degradation (ERAD), which leads to the destruction of misfolded proteins in the ER, as well as post-ER proteolysis. Although most aberrant proteins are degraded by ERAD, some misfolded proteins escape the ER and are degraded instead by lysosomal/vacuolar proteases. To date, it remains unclear how misfolded membrane proteins are selected for these different fates. Here we designed a novel model substrate, SZ*, to investigate how substrate selection is mediated in yeast. We discovered that SZ* is degraded by both the proteasome and vacuolar proteases, the latter of which occurs after ER exit and requires the multivesicular body pathway. By interrogating how various conditions affect the fate of SZ*, we also discovered that heat-shock and substrate overexpression increase ERAD targeting. These conditions also increase substrate aggregation. We next found that aggregation of the membrane-free misfolded domain in SZ* is concentration dependent, and fusion of this misfolded domain to a post-ER quality control substrate instead targets the substrate for ERAD. Our data indicate that a misfolded membrane protein with a higher aggregation propensity is preferentially retained in the ER and targeted for ERAD.

Substrate Insolubility Dictates Hsp104-Dependent Endoplasmic-Reticulum-Associated Degradation

Misfolded proteins in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) are destroyed by ER-associated degradation (ERAD). Although the retrotranslocation of misfolded proteins from the ER has been reconstituted, how a polypeptide is initially selected for ERAD remains poorly defined. To address this question while controlling for the diverse nature of ERAD substrates, we constructed a series of truncations in a single ER-tethered domain. We observed that the truncated proteins exhibited variable degradation rates and discovered a positive correlation between ERAD substrate instability and detergent insolubility, which demonstrates that aggregation-prone species can be selected for ERAD. Further, Hsp104 facilitated degradation of an insoluble species, consistent with the chaperone's disaggregase activity. We also show that retrotranslocation of the ubiquitinated substrate from the ER was inhibited in the absence of Hsp104. Therefore, chaperone-mediated selection frees the ER membrane of potentially toxic, aggregation-prone species.