Protocol for multicentre comparison of interictal high-frequency oscillations as a predictor of seizure freedom

Neuronal synchrony and critical bistability: Mechanistic biomarkers for localizing the epileptogenic network

OBJECTIVE

Postsurgical seizure freedom in drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) patients varies from 30% to 80%, implying that in many cases the current approaches fail to fully map the epileptogenic zone (EZ). We aimed to advance a novel approach to better characterize epileptogenicity and investigate whether the EZ encompasses a broader epileptogenic network (EpiNet) beyond the seizure zone (SZ) that exhibits seizure activity.

METHODS

We first used computational modeling to test putative complex systems-driven and systems neuroscience-driven mechanistic biomarkers for epileptogenicity. We then used these biomarkers to extract features from resting-state stereoelectroencephalograms recorded from DRE patients and trained supervised classifiers to localize the SZ against gold standard clinical localization. To further explore the prevalence of pathological features in an extended brain network outside of the clinically identified SZ, we also used unsupervised classification.

RESULTS

Supervised SZ classification trained on individual features achieved accuracies of .6-.7 area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). Combining all criticality and synchrony features further improved the AUC to .85. Unsupervised classification discovered an EpiNet-like cluster of brain regions, in which 51% of brain regions were outside of the SZ. Brain regions in the EpiNet-like cluster engaged in interareal hypersynchrony and locally exhibited high-amplitude bistability and excessive inhibition, which was strikingly similar to the high seizure risk regime revealed by our computational modeling.

SIGNIFICANCE

The finding that combining biomarkers improves SZ localization accuracy indicates that the novel mechanistic biomarkers for epileptogenicity employed here yield synergistic information. On the other hand, the discovery of SZ-like brain dynamics outside of the clinically defined SZ provides empirical evidence of an extended pathophysiological EpiNet.

Robust compression and detection of epileptiform patterns in ECoG using a real-time spiking neural network hardware framework

Interictal Epileptiform Discharges (IED) and High Frequency Oscillations (HFO) in intraoperative electrocorticography (ECoG) may guide the surgeon by delineating the epileptogenic zone. We designed a modular spiking neural network (SNN) in a mixed-signal neuromorphic device to process the ECoG in real-time. We exploit the variability of the inhomogeneous silicon neurons to achieve efficient sparse and decorrelated temporal signal encoding. We interface the full-custom SNN device to the BCI2000 real-time framework and configure the setup to detect HFO and IED co-occurring with HFO (IED-HFO). We validate the setup on pre-recorded data and obtain HFO rates that are concordant with a previously validated offline algorithm (Spearman's ρ = 0.75, p = 1e-4), achieving the same postsurgical seizure freedom predictions for all patients. In a remote on-line analysis, intraoperative ECoG recorded in Utrecht was compressed and transferred to Zurich for SNN processing and successful IED-HFO detection in real-time. These results further demonstrate how automated remote real-time detection may enable the use of HFO in clinical practice.

Epileptic tissue localization using graph-based networks in the high frequency oscillation range of intracranial electroencephalography

PURPOSE

High frequency oscillations (HFOs) are an emerging biomarker of epilepsy. However, very few studies have investigated the functional connectivity of interictal iEEG signals in the frequency range of HFOs. Here, we study the corresponding functional networks using graph theory, and we assess their predictive value for automatic electrode classification in a cohort of 20 drug resistant patients.

METHODS

Coherence-based connectivity analysis was performed on the iEEG recordings, and six different local graph measures were computed in both sub-bands of the HFO frequency range (80-250 Hz and 250-500 Hz). Correlation analysis was implemented between the local graph measures and the ripple and fast ripple rates. Finally, the WEKA software was employed for training and testing different predictive models on the aforementioned local graph measures.

RESULTS

The ripple rate was significantly correlated with five out of six local graph measures in the functional network. For fast ripples, their rate was also significantly (but negatively) correlated with most of the local metrics. The results from WEKA showed that the Logistic Regression algorithm was able to classify highly HFO-contaminated electrodes with an accuracy of 82.5 % for ripples and 75.4 % for fast ripples.

CONCLUSION

Functional connectivity networks in the HFO band could represent an alternative to the direct use of distinct HFO events, while also providing important insights about hub epileptic areas that can represent possible surgical targets. Automatic electrode classification through FC-based classifiers can help bypass the burden of manual HFO annotation, providing at the same time similar amount of information about the epileptic tissue.

Recent advances in clinical electroencephalography

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Clinical electroencephalography (EEG) is a conservative medical field. This explains likely the significant gap between clinical practice and new research developments. This narrative review discusses possible causes of this discrepancy and how to circumvent them. More specifically, we summarize recent advances in three applications of clinical EEG: source imaging (ESI), high-frequency oscillations (HFOs) and EEG in critically ill patients.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recently published studies on ESI provide further evidence for the accuracy and clinical utility of this method in the multimodal presurgical evaluation of patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy, and opened new possibilities for further improvement of the accuracy. HFOs have received much attention as a novel biomarker in epilepsy. However, recent studies questioned their clinical utility at the level of individual patients. We discuss the impediments, show up possible solutions and highlight the perspectives of future research in this field. EEG in the ICU has been one of the major driving forces in the development of clinical EEG. We review the achievements and the limitations in this field.

SUMMARY

This review will promote clinical implementation of recent advances in EEG, in the fields of ESI, HFOs and EEG in the intensive care.

High frequency oscillations in relation to interictal spikes in predicting postsurgical seizure freedom

We evaluate whether interictal spikes, epileptiform HFOs and their co-occurrence (Spike + HFO) were included in the resection area with respect to seizure outcome. We also characterise the relationship between high frequency oscillations (HFOs) and propagating spikes. We analysed intracranial EEG of 20 patients that underwent resective epilepsy surgery. The co-occurrence of ripples and fast ripples was considered an HFO event; the co-occurrence of an interictal spike and HFO was considered a Spike + HFO event. HFO distribution and spike onset were compared in cases of spike propagation. Accuracy in predicting seizure outcome was 85% for HFO, 60% for Spikes, and 79% for Spike + HFO. Sensitivity was 57% for HFO, 71% for Spikes and 67% for Spikes + HFO. Specificity was 100% for HFO, 54% for Spikes and 85% for Spikes + HFO. In 2/2 patients with spike propagation, the spike onset included the HFO area. Combining interictal spikes with HFO had comparable accuracy to HFO. In patients with propagating spikes, HFO rate was maximal at the onset of spike propagation.

Passive and active markers of cortical excitability in epilepsy

Electroencephalography (EEG) has been the primary diagnostic tool in clinical epilepsy for nearly a century. Its review is performed using qualitative clinical methods that have changed little over time. However, the intersection of higher resolution digital EEG and analytical tools developed in the past decade invites a re-exploration of relevant methodology. In addition to the established spatial and temporal markers of spikes and high-frequency oscillations, novel markers involving advanced postprocessing and active probing of the interictal EEG are gaining ground. This review provides an overview of the EEG-based passive and active markers of cortical excitability in epilepsy and of the techniques developed to facilitate their identification. Several different emerging tools are discussed in the context of specific EEG applications and the barriers we must overcome to translate these tools into clinical practice.

Spike propagation mapping reveals effective connectivity and predicts surgical outcome in epilepsy

Neurosurgical intervention is the best available treatment for selected patients with drug resistant epilepsy. For these patients, surgical planning requires biomarkers that delineate the epileptogenic zone, the brain area that is indispensable for the generation of seizures. Interictal spikes recorded with electrophysiological techniques are considered key biomarkers of epilepsy. Yet, they lack specificity, mostly because they propagate across brain areas forming networks. Understanding the relationship between interictal spike propagation and functional connections among the involved brain areas may help develop novel biomarkers that can delineate the epileptogenic zone with high precision. Here, we reveal the relationship between spike propagation and effective connectivity among onset and areas of spread and assess the prognostic value of resecting these areas. We analysed intracranial EEG data from 43 children with drug resistant epilepsy who underwent invasive monitoring for neurosurgical planning. Using electric source imaging, we mapped spike propagation in the source domain and identified three zones: onset, early-spread and late-spread. For each zone, we calculated the overlap and distance from surgical resection. We then estimated a virtual sensor for each zone and the direction of information flow among them via Granger causality. Finally, we compared the prognostic value of resecting these zones, the clinically-defined seizure onset zone and the spike onset on intracranial EEG channels by estimating their overlap with resection. We observed a spike propagation in source space for 37 patients with a median duration of 95 ms (interquartile range: 34-206), a spatial displacement of 14 cm (7.5-22 cm) and a velocity of 0.5 m/s (0.3-0.8 m/s). In patients with good surgical outcome (25 patients, Engel I), the onset had higher overlap with resection [96% (40-100%)] than early-spread [86% (34-100%), P = 0.01] and late-spread [59% (12-100%), P = 0.002], and it was also closer to resection than late-spread [5 mm versus 9 mm, P = 0.007]. We found an information flow from onset to early-spread in 66% of patients with good outcomes, and from early-spread to onset in 50% of patients with poor outcome. Finally, resection of spike onset, but not area of spike spread or the seizure onset zone, predicted outcome with positive predictive value of 79% and negative predictive value of 56% (P = 0.04). Spatiotemporal mapping of spike propagation reveals information flow from onset to areas of spread in epilepsy brain. Surgical resection of the spike onset disrupts the epileptogenic network and may render patients with drug resistant epilepsy seizure-free without having to wait for a seizure to occur during intracranial monitoring.