Unexpected complex horizontal gene transfer in teleost fish

Multiple Horizontal Transfers of Immune Genes Between Distantly Related Teleost Fishes

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is less frequent in eukaryotes than in prokaryotes, yet can have strong functional implications and was proposed as a causal factor for major adaptations in several eukaryotic lineages. Most cases of eukaryote HGT reported to date are inter-domain transfers, and few studies have investigated eukaryote-to-eukaryote HGTs. Here, we performed a large-scale survey of HGT among 242 species of ray-finned fishes. We found multiple lines of evidence supporting 19 teleost-to-teleost HGT events that involve 17 different genes in 11 teleost fish orders. The genes involved in these transfers show lower synonymous divergence than expected under vertical transmission, their phylogeny is inconsistent with that of teleost fishes, and they occur at non-syntenic positions in donor and recipient lineages. The distribution of HGT events in the teleost tree is heterogenous, with 8 of the 19 transfers occurring between the same two orders (Osmeriformes and Clupeiformes). Though we favor a scenario involving multiple HGT events, future work should evaluate whether hybridization between species belonging to different teleost orders may generate HGT-like patterns. Besides the previously reported transfer of an antifreeze protein, most transferred genes play roles in immunity or are pore-forming proteins, suggesting that such genes may be more likely than others to confer a strong selective advantage to the recipient species. Overall, our work shows that teleost-to-teleost HGT has occurred on multiple occasions, and it will be worth further quantifying these transfers and evaluating their impact on teleost evolution as more genomes are sequenced.