The Effects of Exercise on Coronary Collateral Circulation: A Review

The effects of exercise on the cardiovascular system are multifaceted and complex. It is well-documented that exercise can reduce mortality related to cardiovascular pathology. One anatomical structure that has been implicated in this process is the coronary collateral circulation. The goal of this review is to evaluate the current literature on the effects of exercise on human coronary collateral circulation. A search for literature was conducted on the databases Science Direct and PubMed using the terms: coronary collateral, collateral, exercise, physical activity, resistance training, endurance training, and collateral artery. Research that had the primary outcome of assessing human coronary collateralization secondary to exercise was included. Research in which the effect of exercise was not the primary outcome was excluded. As a result, a total of 13 research papers on the effects of exercise on coronary collateral circulation were included. Thirteen original research papers were reviewed. The mean age range in all studies was between 48 and 64 years old. There was a predominance of male participants, with a total of 597 male patients and 108 female patients across all studies. It was found that initial research underestimated the effect of exercise on coronary collateral circulation due to a lack of sensitive assessment methods. With the introduction of sensitive measures like the collateral flow index (CFI) and Rentrop scoring, results have shown that coronary collateral function can be increased with exercise. Exercise has been shown to enhance coronary collateral function. There is limited evidence as to which type, duration, or intensity of exercise is most favourable to enhance coronary collateral function. There is also relatively little data on the effects of exercise in the female population and those over the age of 65 years. More research is required to determine the specific effects of exercise on coronary collateral circulation in various age groups, genders, co-morbidities, specific exercise modalities, durations, intensities, and the effect of pharmacotherapy.

Leptomeningeal anastomoses: Mechanisms of pial collateral remodeling in ischemic stroke

Arterial collateralization, as determined by leptomeningeal anastomoses or pial collateral vessels, is a well‐established vital player in cerebral blood flow restoration and neurological recovery from ischemic stroke. A secondary network of cerebral collateral circulation apart from the Circle of Willis, exist as remnants of arteriole development that connect the distal arteries in the pia mater. Recent interest lies in understanding the cellular and molecular adaptations that control the growth and remodeling, or arteriogenesis, of these pre‐existing collateral vessels. New findings from both animal models and human studies of ischemic stroke suggest a multi‐factorial and complex, temporospatial interplay of endothelium, immune and vessel‐associated cell interactions may work in concert to facilitate or thwart arteriogenesis. These valuable reports may provide critical insight into potential predictors of the pial collateral response in patients with large vessel occlusion and may aid in therapeutics to enhance collateral function and improve recovery from stroke.

This article is categorized under:

Neurological Diseases > Molecular and Cellular Physiology

Extracardiac coronary steal induced by upper limb hyperemia: a feature of internal mammary artery arteriogenesis

Function of naturally existing internal mammary artery (IMA)-to-coronary artery anastomoses has been shown by augmented blood supply to the coronary collateral circulation in response to IMA occlusion. Theoretically, this beneficial functional connection is invertible and can be linked to coronary steal, the verification of whose hypothesis would provide alternate proof to the mentioned functional evidence. This was an observational study including 40 patients with chronic coronary syndrome, distal IMA occlusion, and upper limb hyperemia (verum group), and 40 propensity score matched controls (placebo group) without IMA occlusion or hyperemia. Primary study end point was the intergroup difference and temporal development in coronary collateral function (i.e., collateral flow index; CFI) as obtained at 30, 45, and 60 s following a proximal coronary artery balloon occlusion. CFI is the ratio between simultaneous mean coronary occlusive pressure divided by mean aortic pressure both subtracted by central venous pressure. To provoke a steal phenomenon, upper limb hyperemia was induced by upper arm blood pressure cuff deflation following a 5-min suprasystolic inflation ipsilateral to the sensor-wired coronary artery with release immediately after the first CFI measurement. Between the first and the second CFI measurement, CFI change (i.e., CFI@45s - CFI@30s) was absent in the verum group whereas there was CFI recruitment in the placebo group: 0.000 ± 0.023 and +0.009 ± 0.013, respectively; P = 0.032. Among patients with artificial distal IMA occlusion, induction of ipsilateral upper limb hyperemia provokes extracardiac coronary steal as expressed by temporarily absent collateral recruitment as it normally takes place without upper limb hyperemia.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Induction of ipsilateral upper limb hyperemia provokes extracardiac coronary steal among patients with artificial distal internal mammary artery occlusion. Coronary steal via the occluded internal mammary arteries serves as alternate proof of concept of the already existing evidence of their functional extracoronary collateral supply.

Exercise Training as a Mediator for Enhancing Coronary Collateral Circulation: A Review of the Evidence

Coronary collateral vessels supply blood to areas of myocardium at risk after arterial occlusion. Flow through these channels is driven by a pressure gradient between the donor and the occluded artery. Concomitant with increased collateral flow is an increase in shear force, a potent stimulus for collateral development (arteriogenesis). Arteriogenesis is self-limiting, often ceasing prematurely when the pressure gradient is reduced by the expanding lumen of the collateral vessel. After the collateral has reached its self-limited maximal conductance, the only way to drive further increases is to re-establish the pressure gradient.

During exercise, the myocardial oxygen demand is increased, subsequently increasing coronary flow. Therefore, exercise may represent a means of driving augmented arteriogenesis in patients with stable coronary artery disease. Studies investigating the ability of exercise to drive collateral development in humans are inconsistent. However, these inconsistencies may be due to the heterogeneity of assessment methods used to quantify change. This article summarises current evidence pertaining to the role of exercise in the development of coronary collaterals, highlighting areas of future research.

The Human Coronary Collateral Circulation, Its Extracardiac Anastomoses and Their Therapeutic Promotion

Cardiovascular disease remains the leading global cause of death, and the number of patients with coronary artery disease (CAD) and exhausted therapeutic options (i.e., percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) and medical treatment) is on the rise. Therefore, the evaluation of new therapeutic approaches to offer an alternative treatment strategy for these patients is necessary. A promising research field is the promotion of the coronary collateral circulation, an arterio-arterial network able to prevent or reduce myocardial ischemia in CAD. This review summarizes the basic principles of the human coronary collateral circulation, its extracardiac anastomoses as well as the different therapeutic approaches, especially that of stimulating the extracardiac collateral circulation via permanent occlusion of the internal mammary arteries.

Pathophysiology of coronary collaterals

While the existence of structural adaptation of coronary anastomoses is undisputed, the potential of coronary collaterals to be capable of functional adaptation has been questioned. For many years, collateral vessels were thought to be rigid tubes allowing only limited blood flow governed by the pressure gradient across them. This concept was consistent with the notion that although collaterals could provide adequate blood flow to maintain resting levels, they would be unable to increase blood flow sufficiently in situations of increased myocardial oxygen demand.

However, more recent studies have demonstrated the capability of the collateral circulation to deliver sufficient blood flow even during exertion or pharmacologic stress. Moreover, it has been shown that increases in collateral flow could be attributed directly to collateral vasomotion.

This review summarizes the pathophysiology of the coronary collateral circulation, ie the functional adapation of coronary collaterals to acute alterations in the coronary circulation.

Synergistic Adaptations to Exercise in the Systemic and Coronary Circulations That Underlie the Warm-Up Angina Phenomenon

Background—

The mechanisms of reduced angina on second exertion in patients with coronary arterial disease, also known as the warm-up angina phenomenon, are poorly understood. Adaptations within the coronary and systemic circulations have been suggested but never demonstrated in vivo. In this study we measured central and coronary hemodynamics during serial exercise.

Methods and Results—

Sixteen patients (15 male, 61±4.3 years) with a positive exercise ECG and exertional angina completed the protocol. During cardiac catheterization via radial access, they performed 2 consecutive exertions (Ex1, Ex2) using a supine cycle ergometer. Throughout exertions, distal coronary pressure and flow velocity were recorded in the culprit vessel using a dual sensor wire while central aortic pressure was recorded using a second wire. Patients achieved a similar workload in Ex2 but with less ischemia than in Ex1 ( P <0.01). A 33% decline in aortic pressure augmentation in Ex2 ( P <0.0001) coincided with a reduction in tension time index, a major determinant of left ventricular afterload ( P <0.001). Coronary stenosis resistance was unchanged. A sustained reduction in coronary microvascular resistance resulted in augmented coronary flow velocity on second exertion (both P <0.001). These changes were accompanied by a 21% increase in the energy of the early diastolic coronary backward-traveling expansion, or suction, wave on second exercise ( P <0.05), indicating improved microvascular conductance and enhanced left ventricular relaxation.

Conclusions—

On repeat exercise in patients with effort angina, synergistic changes in the systemic and coronary circulations combine to improve vascular–ventricular coupling and enhance myocardial perfusion, thereby potentially contributing to the warm-up angina phenomenon.

Microvascular response to metabolic and pressure challenge in the human coronary circulation

In vivo observations of microcirculatory behavior during autoregulation and adaptation to varying myocardial oxygen demand are scarce in the human coronary system. This study assessed microvascular reactions to controlled metabolic and pressure provocation [bicycle exercise and external counterpulsation (ECP)]. In 20 healthy subjects, quantitative myocardial contrast echocardiography and arterial applanation tonometry were performed during increasing ECP levels, as well as before and during bicycle exercise. Myocardial blood flow (MBF; ml·min−1·g−1), the relative blood volume (rBV; ml/ml), the coronary vascular resistance index (CVRI; dyn·s·cm−5/g), the pressure-work index (PWI), and the pressure-rate product (mmHg/min) were assessed. MBF remained unchanged during ECP (1.08 ± 0.44 at baseline to 0.92 ± 0.38 at high-level ECP). Bicycle exercise led to an increase in MBF from 1.03 ± 0.39 to 3.42 ± 1.11 ( P < 0.001). The rBV remained unchanged during ECP, whereas it increased under exercise from 0.13 ± 0.033 to 0.22 ± 0.07 ( P < 0.001). The CVRI showed a marked increase under ECP from 7.40 ± 3.38 to 11.05 ± 5.43 and significantly dropped under exercise from 7.40 ± 2.78 to 2.21 ± 0.87 (both P < 0.001). There was a significant correlation between PWI and MBF in the pooled exercise data (slope: +0.162). During ECP, the relationship remained similar (slope: +0.153). Whereas physical exercise decreases coronary vascular resistance and induces considerable functional capillary recruitment, diastolic pressure transients up to 140 mmHg trigger arteriolar vasoconstriction, keeping MBF and functional capillary density constant. Demand-supply matching was maintained over the entire ECP pressure range.

Effects of exercise training on coronary collateralization and control of collateral resistance

Coronary collateral vessels serve as a natural protective mechanism to provide coronary flow to ischemic myocardium secondary to critical coronary artery stenosis. The innate collateral circulation of the normal human heart is typically minimal and considerable variability occurs in extent of collateralization in coronary artery disease patients. A well-developed collateral circulation has been documented to exert protective effects upon myocardial perfusion, contractile function, infarct size, and electrocardiographic abnormalities. Thus therapeutic augmentation of collateral vessel development and/or functional adaptations in collateral and collateral-dependent arteries to reduce resistance into the ischemic myocardium represent a desirable goal in the management of coronary artery disease. Tremendous evidence has provided documentation for the therapeutic benefits of exercise training programs in patients with coronary artery disease (and collateralization); mechanisms that underlie these benefits are numerous and multifaceted, and currently under investigation in multiple laboratories worldwide. The role of enhanced collateralization as a major beneficial contributor has not been fully resolved. This topical review highlights literature that examines the effects of exercise training on collateralization in the diseased heart, as well as effects of exercise training on vascular endothelial and smooth muscle control of regional coronary tone in the collateralized heart. Future directions for research in this area involve further delineation of cellular/molecular mechanisms involved in effects of exercise training on collateralized myocardium, as well as development of novel therapies based on emerging concepts regarding exercise training and coronary artery disease.