Linkage, mobility, and selfishness in the MazF family of bacterial toxins: a snapshot of bacterial evolution

Dual bacteriocin and extracellular vesicle-mediated inhibition of Campylobacter jejuni by the potential probiotic candidate Ligilactobacillus salivarius UO.C249

Campylobacter jejuni (C. jejuni) is one of the most common causes of foodborne infections worldwide and a major contributor to diarrheal diseases. This study aimed to explore the ability of commensal gut bacteria to control C. jejuni infection. Bacterial strains from the intestinal mucosa of broilers were screened in vitro against C. jejuni ATCC BAA1153. The cell-free supernatant (CFS) of Ligilactobacillus salivarius UO.C249 showed potent dose-dependent antimicrobial activity against the pathogen, likely due to the presence of bacteriocin-like moieties, as confirmed by protease treatment. Genome and exoproteome analyses revealed the presence of known bacteriocins, including Abp118. The genome of Lg. salivarius UO.C249 harbors a 1.8-Mb chromosome and a 203-kb megaplasmid. The strain was susceptible to several antibiotics and had a high survival rate in the simulated chicken gastrointestinal tract (GIT). Post-protease treatment revealed residual inhibitory activity, suggesting alternative antimicrobial mechanisms. Short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) quantification confirmed non-inhibitory levels of acetic (24.4 ± 1.2 mM), isovaleric (34 ± 1.0 µM), and butyric (32 ± 2.5 µM) acids. Interestingly, extracellular vesicles (EVs) isolated from the CFS of Lg. salivarius UO.C249 were found to inhibit C. jejuni ATCC BAA-1153. Proteome profiling of these EVs revealed the presence of unique proteins distinct from bacteriocins identified in CFS. The majority of the identified proteins in EVs are located in the membrane and play roles in transmembrane transport and peptidoglycan degradation, peptidase, proteolysis, and hydrolysis. These findings suggest that although bacteriocins are a primary antimicrobial mechanism, EV production also contributes to the inhibitory activity of Lg. salivarius UO.C249 against C. jejuni.

IMPORTANCE

Campylobacter jejuni (C. jejuni) is a major cause of gastroenteritis and a global public health concern. The increasing antibiotic resistance and lack of effective alternatives in livestock production pose serious challenges for controlling C. jejuni infections. Therefore, alternative strategies are needed to control this pathogen, especially in the poultry industry where it is prevalent and can be transmitted to humans through contaminated food products. In this study, Ligilactobacillus salivarius UO.C249 isolated from broiler intestinal mucosa inhibited C. jejuni and exhibited important probiotic features. Beyond bacteriocins, Lg. salivarius UO.C249 secretes antimicrobial extracellular vesicles (EVs) with a unique protein set distinct from bacteriocins that are involved in transmembrane transport and peptidoglycan degradation. Our findings suggest that beyond bacteriocins, EV production is also a distinct inhibitory signaling mechanism used by Lg. salivarius UO.C249 to control C. jejuni. These findings hold promise for the application of probiotic EVs for pathogen control.

MazEF Homologs in Symbiobacterium thermophilum Exhibit Cross-Neutralization with Non-Cognate MazEFs

Toxin-antitoxin systems are preserved by nearly every prokaryote. The type II toxin MazF acts as a sequence-specific endoribonuclease, cleaving ribonucleotides at specific sequences that vary from three to seven bases, as has been reported in different host organisms to date. The present study characterized the MazEF module (MazEF-sth) conserved in the Symbiobacterium thermophilum IAM14863 strain, a Gram-negative syntrophic bacterium that can be supported by co-culture with multiple bacteria, including Bacillus subtilis. Based on a method combining massive parallel sequencing and the fluorometric assay, MazF-sth was determined to cleave ribonucleotides at the UACAUA motif, which is markedly similar to the motifs recognized by MazF from B. subtilis (MazF-bs), and by several MazFs from Gram-positive bacteria. MazF-sth, with mutations at conserved amino acid residues Arg29 and Thr52, lost most ribonuclease activity, indicating that these residues that are crucial for MazF-bs also play significant roles in MazF-sth catalysis. Further, cross-neutralization between MazF-sth and the non-cognate MazE-bs was discovered, and herein, the neutralization mechanism is discussed based on a protein-structure simulation via AlphaFold2 and multiple sequence alignment. The conflict between the high homology shared by these MazF amino acid sequences and the few genetic correlations among their host organisms may provide evidence of horizontal gene transfer.

An Antisense RNA Fine-Tunes Gene Expression of the Type II MazEF Toxin-Antitoxin System

Despite their ubiquitous nature, few antisense RNAs have been functionally characterized, and this class of RNAs is considered by some to be transcriptional noise. Here, we report that an antisense RNA (asRNA), aMEF (antisense mazEF), functions as a dual regulator for the type II toxin-antitoxin (TA) system mazEF. Unlike type I TA systems and many other regulatory asRNAs, aMEF stimulates the synthesis and translation of mazEF rather than inhibition and degradation. Our data indicate that a double-stranded RNA intermediate and RNase III are not necessary for aMEF-dependent regulation of mazEF expression. The lack of conservation of asRNA promoters has been used to support the hypothesis that asRNAs are spurious transcriptional noise and nonfunctional. We demonstrate that the aMEF promoter is active and functional in Escherichia coli despite poor sequence conservation, indicating that the lack of promoter sequence conservation should not be correlated with functionality. IMPORTANCE Next-generation RNA sequencing of numerous organisms has revealed that transcription is widespread across the genome, termed pervasive transcription, and does not adhere to annotated gene boundaries. The function of pervasive transcription is enigmatic and has generated considerable controversy as to whether it is transcriptional noise or biologically relevant. Antisense transcription is one class of pervasive transcription that occurs from the DNA strand opposite an annotated gene. Relatively few pervasively transcribed asRNAs have been functionally characterized, and their regulatory roles or lack thereof remains unknown. It is important to study examples of these asRNAs and determine if they are functional regulators. In this study, we elucidate the function of an asRNA (aMEF) demonstrating that pervasive transcripts can be functional.

Modulators of protein-protein interactions as antimicrobial agents

Protein-Protein interactions (PPIs) are involved in a myriad of cellular processes in all living organisms and the modulation of PPIs is already under investigation for the development of new drugs targeting cancers, autoimmune diseases and viruses. PPIs are also involved in the regulation of vital functions in bacteria and, therefore, targeting bacterial PPIs offers an attractive strategy for the development of antibiotics with novel modes of action. The latter are urgently needed to tackle multidrug-resistant and multidrug-tolerant bacteria. In this review, we describe recent developments in the modulation of PPIs in pathogenic bacteria for antibiotic development, including advanced small molecule and peptide inhibitors acting on bacterial PPIs involved in division, replication and transcription, outer membrane protein biogenesis, with an additional focus on toxin-antitoxin systems as upcoming drug targets.

Rapid growth inhibitory activity of a YafQ-family endonuclease toxin of the Helicobacter pylori tfs4 integrative and conjugative element

Prokaryotic and archaeal chromosomes encode a diversity of toxin–antitoxin (TA) systems that contribute to a variety of stress-induced cellular processes in addition to stability and maintenance of mobile elements. Here, we find DinJ-YafQ family TA systems to be broadly distributed amongst diverse phyla, consistent with other ParE/RelE superfamily TAs, but more unusually occurring as a multiplicity of species-specific subtypes. In the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori we identify six distinct subtypes, of which three are predominantly associated with the mobilome, including the disease-associated integrative and conjugative element (ICE), tfs4. Whereas, the ICE-encoded proteins have characteristic features of DinJ-YafQ family Type II TA systems in general, the toxin component is distinguished by a broad metal-ion-dependent endonuclease activity with specificity for both RNA and DNA. We show that the remarkably rapid growth inhibitory activity of the ICE toxin is a correlate of a C-terminal lysine doublet which likely augments catalytic activity by increasing the positive electrostatic potential in the vicinity of the conserved active site. Our collective results reveal a structural feature of an ICE TA toxin that influences substrate catalysis and toxin function which may be relevant to specific TA-mediated responses in diverse genera of bacteria.

MazF Endoribonucleolytic Toxin Conserved in Nitrospira Specifically Cleaves the AACU, AACG, and AAUU Motifs

MazF is an endoribonucleolytic toxin that cleaves intracellular RNAs in sequence-specific manners. It is liberated in bacterial cells in response to environmental changes and is suggested to contribute to bacterial survival by inducing translational regulation. Thus, determining the cleavage specificity provides insights into the physiological functions of MazF orthologues. Nitrospira, detected in a wide range of environments, is thought to have evolved the ability to cope with their surroundings. To investigate the molecular mechanism of its environmental adaption, a MazF module from Nitrospira strain ND1, which was isolated from the activated sludge of a wastewater treatment plant, is examined in this study. By combining a massive parallel sequencing method and fluorometric assay, we detected that this functional RNA-cleaving toxin specifically recognizes the AACU, AACG, and AAUU motifs. Additionally, statistical analysis suggested that this enzyme regulates various specific functions in order to resist environmental stresses.

Nitrosomonas europaea MazF Specifically Recognises the UGG Motif and Promotes Selective RNA Degradation

Toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems are implicated in prokaryotic stress adaptation. Previously, bioinformatics analysis predicted that such systems are abundant in some slowly growing chemolithotrophs; e.g., Nitrosomonas europaea. Nevertheless, the molecular functions of these stress-response modules remain largely unclear, limiting insight regarding their physiological roles. Herein, we show that one of the putative MazF family members, encoded at the ALW85_RS04820 locus, constitutes a functional toxin that engenders a TA pair with its cognate MazE antitoxin. The coordinate application of a specialised RNA-Seq and a fluorescence quenching technique clarified that a unique triplet, UGG, serves as the determinant for MazF cleavage. Notably, statistical analysis predicted that two transcripts, which are unique in the autotroph, comprise the prime targets of the MazF endoribonuclease: hydroxylamine dehydrogenase (hao), which is essential for ammonia oxidation, and a large subunit of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rbcL), which plays an important role in carbon assimilation. Given that N. europaea obtains energy and reductants via ammonia oxidation and the carbon for its growth from carbon dioxide, the chemolithotroph might use the MazF endoribonuclease to modulate its translation profile and subsequent biochemical reactions.

Endoribonuclease type II toxin-antitoxin systems: functional or selfish?

Most bacterial genomes have multiple type II toxin-antitoxin systems (TAs) that encode two proteins which are referred to as a toxin and an antitoxin. Toxins inhibit a cellular process, while the interaction of the antitoxin with the toxin attenuates the toxin's activity. Endoribonuclease-encoding TAs cleave RNA in a sequence-dependent fashion, resulting in translational inhibition. To account for their prevalence and retention by bacterial genomes, TAs are credited with clinically significant phenomena, such as bacterial programmed cell death, persistence, biofilms and anti-addiction to plasmids. However, the programmed cell death and persistence hypotheses have been challenged because of conceptual, methodological and/or strain issues. In an alternative view, chromosomal TAs seem to be retained by virtue of addiction at two levels: via a poison-antidote combination (TA proteins) and via transcriptional reprogramming of the downstream core gene (due to integration). Any perturbation in the chromosomal TA operons could cause fitness loss due to polar effects on the downstream genes and hence be detrimental under natural conditions. The endoribonucleases encoding chromosomal TAs are most likely selfish DNA as they are retained by bacterial genomes, even though TAs do not confer a direct advantage via the TA proteins. TAs are likely used by various replicons as 'genetic arms' that allow the maintenance of themselves and associated genetic elements. TAs seem to be the 'selfish arms' that make the best use of the 'arms race' between bacterial genomes and plasmids.

Characterization of a Deinococcus radiodurans MazF: A UACA-specific RNA endoribonuclease

Microbes are known to withstand environmental stresses by using chromosomal toxin–antitoxin systems. MazEF is one of the most extensively studied toxin–antitoxin systems. In stressful environments, MazF toxins modulate translation by cleaving single‐stranded RNAs in a sequence‐specific fashion. Previously, a chromosomal gene located at DR0417 in Deinococcus radiodurans was predicted to code for a MazF endoribonuclease (MazF_DR0417); however, its function remains unclear. In the present study, we characterized the molecular function of MazF_DR0417. Analysis of MazF_DR0417‐cleaved RNA sites using modified massively parallel sequencing revealed a unique 4‐nt motif, UACA, as a potential cleavage pattern. The activity of MazF_DR0417 was also assessed in a real‐time fluorometric assay, which revealed that MazF_DR0417 strictly recognizes the unique tetrad UACA. This sequence specificity may allow D. radiodurans to alter its translation profile and survive under stressful conditions.

Carriage of type II toxin-antitoxin systems by the growing group of IncX plasmids

The stable maintenance of certain plasmids in bacterial populations has contributed significantly to the current worldwide antibiotic resistance (AbR) emergency. IncX plasmids, long underestimated in this regard, have achieved recent notoriety for their roles in transmission of resistance to carbapenem and colistin, the last-line antibiotics for Gram-negative infections. Toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems contribute to stable maintenance of many AbR plasmids, and a few TA systems have been previously described in the IncX plasmids. Here we present an updated overview of the IncX plasmid family and an in silico analysis of the type II TA systems carried in 153 completely sequenced IncX plasmids that are readily available in public databases at time of writing. The greatest number is in the IncX1 subgroup, followed by IncX3 and IncX4, with only a few representatives of IncX2, IncX5 and IncX6. Toxins from the RelE/ParE superfamily are abundant within IncX1 and IncX4 subgroups, and are associated with a variety of antitoxins. By contrast, the HicBA system is almost exclusively encoded by IncX4 plasmids. Toxins from the superfamily CcdB/MazF were also identified, as were less common systems such as PIN-like and GNAT toxins, and plasmids encoding more than one TA system are probably not unusual. Our results highlight the importance of the IncX plasmid group and update previous much smaller studies, and we present for the first time a detailed analysis of type II TA systems in these plasmids.

AAU-Specific RNA Cleavage Mediated by MazF Toxin Endoribonuclease Conserved in Nitrosomonas europaea

Nitrosomonas europaea carries numerous toxin-antitoxin systems. However, despite the abundant representation in its chromosome, studies have not surveyed the underlying molecular functions in detail, and their biological roles remain enigmatic. In the present study, we found that a chromosomally-encoded MazF family member, predicted at the locus NE1181, is a functional toxin endoribonuclease, and constitutes a toxin-antitoxin system, together with its cognate antitoxin, MazE. Massive parallel sequencing provided strong evidence that this toxin endoribonuclease exhibits RNA cleavage activity, primarily against the AAU triplet. This sequence-specificity was supported by the results of fluorometric assays. Our results indicate that N. europaea alters the translation profile and regulates its growth using the MazF family of endoribonuclease under certain stressful conditions.

Characterization of MazF-Mediated Sequence-Specific RNA Cleavage in Pseudomonas putida Using Massive Parallel Sequencing

Under environmental stress, microbes are known to alter their translation patterns using sequence-specific endoribonucleases that we call RNA interferases. However, there has been limited insight regarding which RNAs are specifically cleaved by these RNA interferases, hence their physiological functions remain unknown. In the current study, we developed a novel method to effectively identify cleavage specificities with massive parallel sequencing. This approach uses artificially designed RNAs composed of diverse sequences, which do not form extensive secondary structures, and it correctly identified the cleavage sequence of a well-characterized Escherichia coli RNA interferase, MazF, as ACA. In addition, we also determined that an uncharacterized MazF homologue isolated from Pseudomonas putida specifically recognizes the unique triplet, UAC. Using a real-time fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay, the UAC triplet was further proved to be essential for cleavage in P. putida MazF. These results highlight an effective method to determine cleavage specificity of RNA interferases.

Horizontal gene transfer of chromosomal Type II toxin-antitoxin systems of Escherichia coli

Type II toxin-antitoxin systems (TAs) are small autoregulated bicistronic operons that encode a toxin protein with the potential to inhibit metabolic processes and an antitoxin protein to neutralize the toxin. Most of the bacterial genomes encode multiple TAs. However, the diversity and accumulation of TAs on bacterial genomes and its physiological implications are highly debated. Here we provide evidence that Escherichia coli chromosomal TAs (encoding RNase toxins) are 'acquired' DNA likely originated from heterologous DNA and are the smallest known autoregulated operons with the potential for horizontal propagation. Sequence analyses revealed that integration of TAs into the bacterial genome is unique and contributes to variations in the coding and/or regulatory regions of flanking host genome sequences. Plasmids and genomes encoding identical TAs of natural isolates are mutually exclusive. Chromosomal TAs might play significant roles in the evolution and ecology of bacteria by contributing to host genome variation and by moderation of plasmid maintenance.

Structural basis of Bacillus anthracis MoxXT disruption and the modulation of MoxT ribonuclease activity by rationally designed peptides

Bacillus anthracis MoxXT is a Type II proteic Toxin-Antitoxin (TA) module wherein MoxT is a ribonuclease that cleaves RNA specifically while MoxX interacts with MoxT and inhibits its activity. Disruption of the TA interaction has been proposed as a novel antibacterial strategy. Peptides, either based on antitoxin sequence or rationally designed, have previously been reported to disrupt the MoxXT interaction but cause a decrease in MoxT ribonuclease activity. In the present study, we report the crystal structure of MoxT, and the effect of several peptides in disrupting the MoxXT interaction as well as augmentation of MoxT ribonuclease activity by binding to MoxT in vitro. Docking studies on the peptides were carried out in order to explain the observed structure activity relationships. The peptides with ribonuclease augmentation activity possess a distinct structure and are proposed to bind to a distinct site on MoxT. The docking of the active peptides with MoxT showed that they possess an aromatic group that occupies a conserved hydrophobic pocket. Additionally, the peptides inducing high ribonuclease activity were anchored by a negatively charged group near a cluster of positively charged residues present near the pocket. Our study provides a structural basis and rationale for the observed properties of the peptides and may aid the development of small molecules to disrupt the TA interaction.