Palindromy and the location of deletion endpoints in Escherichia coli

Template-switching during replication fork repair in bacteria

Replication forks frequently are challenged by lesions on the DNA template, replication-impeding DNA secondary structures, tightly bound proteins or nucleotide pool imbalance. Studies in bacteria have suggested that under these circumstances the fork may leave behind single-strand DNA gaps that are subsequently filled by homologous recombination, translesion DNA synthesis or template-switching repair synthesis. This review focuses on the template-switching pathways and how the mechanisms of these processes have been deduced from biochemical and genetic studies. I discuss how template-switching can contribute significantly to genetic instability, including mutational hotspots and frequent genetic rearrangements, and how template-switching may be elicited by replication fork damage.

Duplications between direct repeats stabilized by DNA secondary structure occur preferentially in the leading strand during DNA replication

To ascertain a leading or lagging strand preference for duplication mutations, several short DNA sequences, i.e. mutation inserts, were designed that should demonstrate an asymmetric propensity for duplication mutations in the two complementary DNA strands during replication. The design of the mutation insert involved a 7-bp quasi inverted repeat that forms a remarkably stable hairpin in one DNA strand, but not the other. The inverted repeat is asymmetrically placed between flanking direct repeats. This sequence was cloned into a modified chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene containing a -1 frameshift mutation. Duplication of the mutation insert restores the reading frame of the CAT gene resulting in a chloramphenicol resistant phenotype. The mutation insert showed greater than a 200-fold preference for duplication mutations during leading strand, compared with lagging strand, replication. This result suggests that misalignment stabilized by DNA secondary structure, leading to duplication between direct repeats, occurred preferentially during leading strand synthesis.

Encoded errors: mutations and rearrangements mediated by misalignment at repetitive DNA sequences

Mutations and rearrangements that occur by misalignment during DNA replication are frequent sources of genetic variation in bacteria. Dislocations between a replicating strand and its template at repetitive DNA sequences underlie the mechanism of these genetic events. Such misalignments can be transient or stable and can involve intramolecular or intermolecular DNA mispairing, even pairing across a replication fork. Paradoxically, these replication 'slippage' events both create and destroy repetitive sequences in bacterial genomes. This review catalogues several types of slippage errors, presents the cellular processes that act to limit them and discusses the consequences of this class of genetic events on the evolution of bacterial genomes and physiology.

Characterization of a Brucella species 25-kilobase DNA fragment deleted from Brucella abortus reveals a large gene cluster related to the synthesis of a polysaccharide

In the present study we completed the nucleotide sequence of a Brucella melitensis 16M DNA fragment deleted from B. abortus that accounts for 25,064 bp and show that the other Brucella spp. contain the entire 25-kb DNA fragment. Two short direct repeats of four nucleotides, detected in the B. melitensis 16M DNA flanking both sides of the fragment deleted from B. abortus, might have been involved in the deletion formation by a strand slippage mechanism during replication. In addition to omp31, coding for an immunogenic protein located in the Brucella outer membrane, 22 hypothetical genes were identified. Most of the proteins that would be encoded by these genes show significant homology with proteins involved in the biosynthesis of polysaccharides from other bacteria, suggesting that they might be involved in the synthesis of a Brucella polysaccharide that would be a heteropolymer synthesized by a Wzy-dependent pathway. This polysaccharide would not be synthesized in B. abortus and would be a polysaccharide not identified until present in the genus Brucella, since all of the known polysaccharides are synthesized in all smooth Brucella species. Discovery of a novel polysaccharide not synthesized in B. abortus might be interesting for a better understanding of the pathogenicity and host preference differences observed between the Brucella species. However, the possibility that the genes detected in the DNA fragment deleted in B. abortus no longer lead to the synthesis of a polysaccharide must not be excluded. They might be a remnant of the common ancestor of the alpha-2 subdivision of the class Proteobacteria, with some of its members synthesizing extracellular polysaccharides and, as Brucella spp., living in association with eukaryotic cells.

Instability of repetitive DNA sequences: the role of replication in multiple mechanisms

Rearrangements between tandem sequence homologies of various lengths are a major source of genomic change and can be deleterious to the organism. These rearrangements can result in either deletion or duplication of genetic material flanked by direct sequence repeats. Molecular genetic analysis of repetitive sequence instability in Escherichia coli has provided several clues to the underlying mechanisms of these rearrangements. We present evidence for three mechanisms of RecA-independent sequence rearrangements: simple replication slippage, sister-chromosome exchange-associated slippage, and single-strand annealing. We discuss the constraints of these mechanisms and contrast their properties with RecA-dependent homologous recombination. Replication plays a critical role in the two slipped misalignment mechanisms, and difficulties in replication appear to trigger rearrangements via all these mechanisms.

Evidence for two mechanisms of palindrome-stimulated deletion in Escherichia coli: single-strand annealing and replication slipped mispairing

Spontaneous deletion mutations often occur at short direct repeats that flank inverted repeat sequences. Inverted repeats may initiate genetic rearrangements by formation of hairpin secondary structures that block DNA polymerases or are processed by structure-specific endonucleases. We have investigated the ability of inverted repeat sequences to stimulate deletion of flanking direct repeats in Escherichia coli. Propensity for cruciform extrusion in duplex DNA correlated with stimulation of flanking deletion, which was partially sbcD dependent. We propose two mechanisms for palindrome-stimulated deletion, SbcCD dependent and SbcCD independent. The SbcCD-dependent mechanism is initiated by SbcCD cleavage of cruciforms in duplex DNA followed by RecA-independent single-strand annealing at the flanking direct repeats, generating a deletion. Analysis of deletion endpoints is consistent with this model. We propose that the SbcCD-independent pathway involves replication slipped mispairing, evoked from stalling at hairpin structures formed on the single-stranded lagging-strand template. The skew of SbcCD-independent deletion endpoints with respect to the direction of replication supports this hypothesis. Surprisingly, even in the absence of palindromes, SbcD affected the location of deletion endpoints, suggesting that SbcCD-mediated strand processing may also accompany deletion unassociated with secondary structures.

Characterization of the uup locus and its role in transposon excisions and tandem repeat deletions in Escherichia coli

Null mutations in the Escherichia coli uup locus (at 21.8 min) serve to increase the frequency of RecA-independent precise excision of transposable elements such as Tn10 and to reduce the plaque size of bacteriophage Mu (Uup(-) phenotype). By the combined approaches of physical mapping of the mutations, complementation analyses, and protein overexpression from cloned gene fragments, we have demonstrated in this study that the Uup(-) phenotype is the consequence of the absence of expression of the downstream gene (uup) of a two-gene operon, caused either directly by insertions in uup or indirectly by the polar effect of insertions in the upstream gene (ycbY). The promoter for uup was mapped upstream of ycbY by primer extension analysis on cellular RNA, and assays of reporter gene expression indicated that it is a moderately active, constitutive promoter. The uup mutations were also shown to increase, in a RecA-independent manner, the frequencies of nearly precise excision of Tn10 derivatives and of the deletion of one copy of a chromosomal tandem repeat, suggesting the existence of a shared step or intermediate in the pathways of these latter events and that of precise excision. Finally, we found that mutations that increase the frequency of precise excision of Tn10 are divisible into two categories, depending upon whether they did (uup, ssb, polA, and topA) or did not (mutHLS, dam, and uvrD) also increase precise excision frequency of the mini-Tn10 derivatives. It is suggested that the differential response of mini-Tn10 and Tn10 to the second category of mutations is related to the presence, respectively, of perfect and of imperfect terminal inverted repeats in them.

Palindromic sequences and A+T-rich DNA elements promote illegitimate recombination in Nicotiana tabacum

Illegitimate recombination is the prevailing molecular mechanism for the integration of recombinant DNA into the genome of most eukaryotic systems and the generation of deletions by intrachromosomal recombination. We developed a ?selectable marker system to screen for intrachromosomal illegitimate recombination events in order to assess the sequence and structure-specific requirements for illegitimate recombination in tobacco. In 12 illegitimate recombination products analysed, we found that all deletion termini localise to sites of palindromic structures or to A+T-rich DNA elements. All deletion termini showed microhomologies of two to six nucleotides. In three plants, the recombination products contained filler-DNA or an inversion of an endogenous segment. Our data strongly suggest that illegitimate recombination in plants is mediated by a DNA synthesis-dependent process, and that this mechanism is promoted by DNA regions that can form palindromic structures or facilitate DNA unwinding.

DNA-directed mutations. Leading and lagging strand specificity

The fidelity of replication has evolved to reproduce B-form DNA accurately, while allowing a low frequency of mutation. The fidelity of replication can be compromised, however, by defined order sequence DNA (dosDNA) that can adopt unusual or non B-DNA conformations. These alternative DNA conformations, including hairpins, cruciforms, triplex DNAs, and slipped-strand structures, may affect enzyme-template interactions that potentially lead to mutations. To analyze the effect of dosDNA elements on spontaneous mutagenesis, various mutational inserts containing inverted repeats or direct repeats were cloned in a plasmid containing a unidirectional origin of replication and a selectable marker for the mutation. This system allows for analysis of mutational events that are specific for the leading or lagging strands during DNA replication in Escherichia coli. Deletions between direct repeats, involving misalignment stabilized by DNA secondary structure, occurred preferentially on the lagging strand. Intermolecular strand switch events, correcting quasipalindromes to perfect inverted repeats, occurred preferentially during replication of the leading strand.

Primer-template misalignments during leading strand DNA synthesis account for the most frequent spontaneous mutations in a quasipalindromic region in Escherichia coli

Spontaneous mutant sequences which differ from the starting DNA sequence by the specific correction of quasipalindromic to perfect palindromic sequence are hallmarks of mutagenesis mediated by misalignments directed by palindromic complementarity. The mutant sequences are specifically predicted by templated, but ectopic, DNA polymerization on a misaligned DNA substrate. In a previous study, we characterized a spontaneous frameshift hotspot near a 17 bp quasipalindromic DNA sequence within the mutant chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene of plasmid pJT7. A one base-pair insertion hotspot, ectopically templated by misalignment mediated by palindromic complementarity, was shown to occur more frequently during synthesis of the leading than the lagging DNA strand. Here we analyze the misalignment mechanisms that can account for the DNA sequences of 123 additional spontaneous frameshift mutations (22 distinct genotypes) occurring in the same quasipalindromic DNA region in plasmids pJT7 and p7TJ (a pJT7 derivative with the CAT gene in the inverse orientation). Approximately 80% of the small frameshift mutants in each plasmid are predicted by palindromic misalignments of the leading strand. Smaller numbers of mutations are consistent with other DNA misalignments, including those predicted by simple slippage of the nascent DNA strand on its template. The results show that remarkable changes in the mutation spectra of a reporter gene may not be revealed by measurements of mutation frequency.

Spectra of spontaneous frameshift mutations at the hisD3052 allele of Salmonella typhimurium in four DNA repair backgrounds

To characterize the hisD3052 -1 frameshift allele of Salmonella typhimurium, we analyzed approximately 6000 spontaneous revertants (rev) for a 2-base deletion hotspot within the sequence (CG)4, and we sequenced approximately 500 nonhotspot rev. The reversion target is a minimum of 76 bases (nucleotides 843-918) that code for amino acids within a nonconserved region of the histidinol dehydrogenase protein. Only 0.4-3.9% were true rev. Of the following classes, 182 unique second-site mutations were identified: hotspot, complex frameshifts requiring DeltauvrB + pKM101 (TA98-specific) or not (concerted), 1-base insertions, duplications, and nonhotspot deletions. The percentages of hotspot mutations were 13.8% in TA1978 (wild type), 24.5% in UTH8413 (pKM101), 31.6% in TA1538 (DeltauvrB), and 41.0% in TA98 (DeltauvrB, pKM101). The DeltauvrB allele decreased by three times the mutant frequency (MF, rev/10(8) survivors) of duplications and increased by about two times the MF of deletions. Separately, the DeltauvrB allele or pKM101 plasmid increased by two to three times the MF of hotspot mutations; combined, they increased this MF by five times. The percentage of 1-base insertions was not influenced by either DeltauvrB or pKM101. Hotspot deletions and TA98-specific complex frameshifts are inducible by some mutagens; concerted complex frameshifts and 1-base insertions are not; and there is little evidence for mutagen-induced duplications and nonhotspot deletions. Except for the base substitutions in TA98-specific complex frameshifts, all spontaneous mutations of the hisD3052 allele are likely templated. The mechanisms may involve (1) the potential of direct and inverted repeats to undergo slippage and misalignment and to form quasi-palindromes and (2) the interaction of these sequences with DNA replication and repair proteins.

Factors affecting inverted repeat stimulation of recombination and deletion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Inverted DNA repeats are an at-risk motif for genetic instability that can induce both deletions and recombination in yeast. We investigated the role of the length of inverted repeats and size of the DNA separating the repeats for deletion and recombination. Stimulation of both deletion and recombination was directly related to the size of inverted repeats and inversely related to the size of intervening spacers. A perfect palindrome, formed by two 1.0-kb URA3-inverted repeats, increased intra- and interchromosomal recombination in the adjacent region 2,400-fold and 17,000-fold, respectively. The presence of a strong origin of replication in the spacer reduced both rates of deletion and recombination. These results support a model in which the stimulation of deletion and recombination by inverted repeats is initiated by a secondary structure formed between single-stranded DNA of inverted repeats during replication.

An unusual illegitimate recombination occurs in the linear-plasmid-encoded outer-surface protein A gene of Borrelia afzelii

In this study, we describe an unusual illegitimate recombination in the linear-plasmid-encoded outer-surface protein A gene of Borrelia afzelii. A 96 bp DNA segment was deleted from the ospA structural gene of B. afzelii strain R9. The nature of the rearrangement suggested that it arose by a strand slippage mechanism, which was stimulated by a 18-mer palindromic sequence and 5-mer short direct repeats at both termini of the deleted DNA. The deleted sequence could form a complex hairpin structure suggesting that it may have played important roles in pausing of replication and slippaging of the nascent strand across the replication fork. In addition, the mutant strain was isolated from a chronic Lyme disease patient, implying that the variation mechanism may have been used by the borrelial strain to avoid host immune elimination.

Stability of an inverted repeat in a human fibrosarcoma cell

Deletions and rearrangements of DNA sequences within the genome of human cells result in mutations associated with human disease. We have developed a selection system involving a neo gene containing a DNA sequence inserted into the NcoI site that can be used to quantitatively assay deletion of this sequence from the chromosome. The spontaneous deletion from the neo gene of a 122 bp inverted repeat occurred at a rate of 2.1 x 10(-8) to <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation in three different cell lines. Deletion of the 122 bp inverted repeat occurred between 6 bp flanking direct repeats. Spontaneous deletion of a 122 bp non-palindromic DNA sequence flanked by direct repeats was not observed, indicating a rate of deletion of <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation. This result demonstrates that a 122 bp inverted repeat can exhibit a low level of instability in some locations in the chromosome of a human cell line.

Copy-choice recombination mediated by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme from Escherichia coli

Formation of deletions by recombination between short direct repeats is thought to involve either a break-join or a copy-choice process. The key step of the latter is slippage of the replication machinery between the repeats. We report that the main replicase of Escherichia coli, DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, slips between two direct repeats of 27 bp that flank an inverted repeat of approximately equal 300bp. Slippage was detected in vitro, on a single-stranded DNA template, in a primer extension assay. It requires the presence of a short (8 bp) G+C-rich sequence at the base of a hairpin that can form by annealing of the inverted repeats. It is stimulated by (i) high salt concentration, which might stabilize the hairpin, and (ii) two proteins that ensure the processivity of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme: the single-stranded DNA binding protein and the beta subunit of the polymerase. Slippage is rather efficient under optimal reaction conditions because it can take place on >50% of template molecules. This observation supports the copy-choice model for recombination between short direct repeats.

Differential DNA secondary structure-mediated deletion mutation in the leading and lagging strands

The frequencies of deletion of short sequences (mutation inserts) inserted into the chloramphenicol acetyl-transferase (CAT) gene were measured for pBR325 and pBR523, in which the orientation of the CAT gene was reversed, in Escherichia coli. Reversal of the CAT gene changes the relationship between the transcribed strand and the leading and lagging strands of the DNA replication fork in pBR325-based plasmids. Deletion of these mutation inserts may be mediated by slipped misalignment during DNA replication. Symmetrical sequences, in which the same potential DNA structural misalignment can form in both the leading and lagging strands, exhibited an approximately twofold difference in the deletion frequencies upon reversal of the CAT gene. Sequences that contained an inverted repeat that was asymmetric with respect to flanking direct repeats were designed. With asymmetric mutation inserts, different misaligned structural intermediates could form in the leading and lagging strands, depending on the orientation of the insert and/or of the CAT gene. When slippage could be stabilized by a hairpin in the lagging strand, thereby forming a three-way junction, deletion occurred by up to 50-fold more frequently than when this structure formed in the leading strand. These results support the model that slipped misalignment involving DNA secondary structure occurs preferentially in the lagging strand during DNA replication.

Genetic instability within monotonous runs of CpG sequences in Escherichia coli

Genetic information can be altered by base substitutions, frameshift mutations, and addition or deletion of nucleotides. Deletions represent an important class of genetic aberration occurring at DNA sequences where it is often possible to predict the existence of intermediates of mutation. Instability within tracts of repetitive sequence have recently been associated with several genetic disorders, including the so-called triplet repeat diseases and certain forms of colorectal cancers. In Escherichia coli, (GpC)n repetitive sequences have been shown to be deletion prone, but the precise mechanism of this mutagenic pathway is still unknown. We show here that interrupting the monotony of the (GpC)n run with an ApT or a GpT dinucleotide decreases the rate of deletions within these sequences. On the other hand, introducing purine-pyrimidine alternating sequences beside the GpC insert results in an increased rate of deletion. Two pathways can be envisioned: (1) (GpC)n tracts can be seen as potential Z-forming DNA sequences, and this unusual DNA structure can be processed by an unknown cellular mechanism to give rise to the observed deletions and (2) (GpC)n monotonous runs can be considered as a succession of direct or palindromic repeats, allowing formation of DNA structures that are known to participate to frameshift mutagenesis. The results presented in this article are discussed in the light of these two alternative pathways.

A mutation hotspot in the chloroplast genome of a conifer (Douglas-fir: Pseudotsuga) is caused by variability in the number of direct repeats derived from a partially duplicated tRNA gene

We determined the DNA sequence of a 2.7-kb cpDNA XbaI fragment from douglas-fir [Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco]. RFLPs revealed by the 2.7-kb XbaI clone were observed to vary up to 1 kb among species within the genus Pseudotsuga and up to 200 bp among trees of P. menziesii. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allowed the locus of polymorphism to be identified, and the variable region was then sequenced in a second Douglas-fir tree, a single tree of a related species, Japanese Douglas-fir (P. japonica), and in a species lacking a mutation hotspot in the region, Pinus radiata (Monterey pine). The locus of polymorphism is characterized by hundreds of base pairs of imperfect, tandem direct repeats flanked by a partially duplicated and an intact trn Y-GUA gene. The duplication is direct in orientation and consists of 43 bp of the 3' end of trnY and 25 bp of its 3' flanking sequence. Tandem repeats show high sequence similarity to a 27-bp region of the trnY gene that overlaps one end of the duplication. The two trees of Douglas-fir sequenced differed by a single tandem repeat unit, whereas these trees differed from the Japanese Douglas-fir sequenced by approximately 34 repeat units. Repetitive DNA in the Pseudotsuga cpDNA hotspot was most likely generated at the time of the partial trnY gene duplication and these sequences expanded by slipped-strand mispairing and unequal crossing-over.

Spontaneous mutations in pcaH and -G, structural genes for protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase in Acinetobacter calcoaceticus

Bacteria containing spontaneous null mutations in pcaH and -G, structural genes for protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase, were selected by exposure of an Acinetobacter calcoaceticus strain to physiological conditions in which expression of the genes prevents growth. The parental bacterial strain exhibits high competence for natural transformation, and this procedure was used to characterize 94 independently isolated spontaneous mutations. Four of the mutations were caused by integration of a newly identified insertion sequence, IS1236. Many (22 of 94) of the mutations were lengthy deletions, the largest of which appeared to eliminate at least 17 kb of DNA containing most of the pca-qui-pob supraoperonic gene cluster. DNA sequence determination revealed that the endpoints of four smaller deletions (74 to 440 bp in length) contained DNA sequence repetitions aligned imprecisely with the sites of mutation. Analysis of direct and inverted DNA sequence repetitions associated with the sites of mutation suggested the existence of DNA slippage structures that make unhybridized nucleotides particularly susceptible to mutation.

The return of copy-choice in DNA recombination

In a recent publication, d'Alençon et al.(1) presented evidence that a form of non-homologous DNA recombination involving direct repeats is dependent upon the replication of the DNA. In addition, density-labeling experiments showed that after recombination was stimulated, progenies were present only in molecules that had undergone complete replication. These observations are consistent with a replicative and not a breakage-and-rejoining model for the DNA recombination events. These two models had of course been contrasted many years ago in mechanistic studies of homologous DNA recombination. It is therefore interesting to place the latest findings of d'Alençon et al. in this historical context.

Recombination between repeats in Escherichia coli by a recA-independent, proximity-sensitive mechanism

We have examined the influence of proximity on the efficiency of recombination between repeated DNA sequences in Escherichia coli. Our experiments have employed a plasmid-based assay to detect deletions between direct repeats of 100 bp. The rate of deletion of the juxtaposed direct repeats was reasonably high at 6 x 10(-5) per cell. A comparison of recA+ and recA mutant strains showed that these deletion events are primarily the result of recA-independent recombination at these homologous sequences. Random restriction fragments of yeast or E. coli genomic DNA were used to separate the two repeats. Deletion rates decreased over two orders of magnitude with increasing separation of up to 7 kb. There was a surprisingly strong effect of even short sequence separations, with insertions of a few hundred base pairs exhibiting 10-fold reductions of deletion rates. No effect of recA on the efficiency of deletion was observed at any distance between repeats.

Strand displacement amplification as an in vitro model for rolling-circle replication: deletion formation and evolution during serial transfer

Strand displacement amplification is an isothermal DNA amplification reaction based on a restriction endonuclease nicking its recognition site and a polymerase extending the nick at its 3' end, displacing the downstream strand. The reaction resembles rolling-circle replication of single-stranded phages and small plasmids. The displaced sense strand serves as target for an antisense reaction and vice versa, resulting in exponential growth and the autocatalytic nature of this in vitro reaction as long as the template is the limiting agent. We describe the optimization of strand displacement amplification for in vitro evolution experiments under serial transfer conditions. The reaction was followed and controlled by use of the fluorescent dye thiazole orange binding to the amplified DNA. We were able to maintain exponential growth conditions with a doubling time of 3.0 min throughout 100 transfers or approximately 350 molecular generations by using an automatic handling device. Homology of in vitro amplification with rolling-circle replication was mirrored by the occurring evolutionary processes. Deletion events most likely caused by a slipped mispairing mechanism as postulated for in vivo replication took place. Under our conditions, the mutation rate was high and a molecular quasi-species formed with a mutant lacking internal hairpin formation ability and thus outgrowing all other species under dGTP/dCTP deficiency.

Frequency of deletion formation decreases exponentially with distance between short direct repeats

The effect of distance between 18 bp direct repeats on deletion formation has been examined in Bacillus subtilis. The deletion frequency decreased exponentially by more than 1000-fold as the distance increased from 33 to 2313 bp. This decrease occurred in two distinct phases, which may be determined by DNA-duplex flexibility. A similar relationship between deletion formation and distance was observed in a theta-replicating plasmid and in the chromosome, indicating that this relationship might have a general validity.

Mechanisms of illegitimate recombination

Illegitimate recombination, which is one of the major causes of genome rearrangements, can occur in a number of ways. These might involve enzymes which cut and join DNA or enzymes which replicate DNA, as illustrated by two examples: (i) formation of deletions at the replication origin (ori) of an Escherichia coli bacteriophage, M13; and (ii) excision of E. coli transposon Tn10. It is proposed that a common theme to various ways by which illegitimate recombination can occur might be the capacity to create ends in the DNA molecule and to make the ends meet.

Deletion between direct repeats in bacteriophage T7 gene 1.2

Deletion mutagenesis in bacteriophage T7 was studied with an insertion-reversion assay involving phage containing inserts of foreign DNA that form 10-bp direct repeats. The precise deletion of the insert restores the function of the non-essential gene and is easily assayed by growth on selection strains of E. coli. Similar inserts with unique direct repeats were placed in either gene 1.2 (dGTPase Inhibitor) or gene 1.3 (DNA ligase). The deletion rates of the inserts were quantified with Luria and Delbrück fluctuation tests. Deletion rates were similar for inserts in both genes indicating that the rates of deletion were not unique to either specific site, or the sequence of the direct repeats. Deletion was independent of functional T7 ligase at 37 degrees C, while an increase in the rate of deletion was noted in some ligase-deficient phage at 43 degrees C. The effect of E. coli DNA Polymerase I on deletion rate was tested and found to decrease deletion rate 60% with the polA1 mutation and 90% with the polA546ex mutation.

The influence of primary and secondary DNA structure in deletion and duplication between direct repeats in Escherichia coli

We describe a system to measure the frequency of both deletions and duplications between direct repeats. Short 17- and 18-bp palindromic and nonpalindromic DNA sequences were cloned into the EcoRI site within the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene of plasmids pBR325 and pJT7. This creates an insert between direct repeated EcoRI sites and results in a chloramphenicol-sensitive phenotype. Selection for chloramphenicol resistance was utilized to select chloramphenicol resistant revertants that included those with precise deletion of the insert from plasmid pBR325 and duplication of the insert in plasmid pJT7. The frequency of deletion or duplication varied more than 500-fold depending on the sequence of the short sequence inserted into the EcoRI site. For the nonpalindromic inserts, multiple internal direct repeats and the length of the direct repeats appear to influence the frequency of deletion. Certain palindromic DNA sequences with the potential to form DNA hairpin structures that might stabilize the misalignment of direct repeats had a high frequency of deletion. Other DNA sequences with the potential to form structures that might destabilize misalignment of direct repeats had a very low frequency of deletion. Duplication mutations occurred at the highest frequency when the DNA between the direct repeats contained no direct or inverted repeats. The presence of inverted repeats dramatically reduced the frequency of duplications. The results support the slippage-misalignment model, suggesting that misalignment occurring during DNA replication leads to deletion and duplication mutations. The results also support the idea that the formation of DNA secondary structures during DNA replication can facilitate and direct specific mutagenic events.

Multiple pathways of deletion formation in Escherichia coli

We are investigating the mechanisms for deletion formation through the use of mutants which alter deletion frequency together with well characterized systems for deletion detection. We report here on three mutations which were isolated for their ability to stimulate deletions in plasmid pMC874 (dli mutations). The mutation rec-2251 (formerly known as dli1) is a new allele of recBCD, a group of genes coding for the polypeptide components of the major recombination enzyme complex in E. coli; the second one, dli2 may be a new allele of uvrD, which codes for DNA helicase II; and the third one, dli3, has the phenotype of a mismatch repair mutation. Here we compare the effects of mutations in SOS-repair genes to those of the dli mutations on three different deletion events: (a) the deletion of short (60-100-bp) palindromic and non-palindromic inserts in derivatives of plasmid pBR325; (b) larger (600-800-bp) deletions in plasmid pMC874; and (c) the excision of the Tn10 transposon from chromosomal sites. Our results indicate that some form of SOS processing stimulates the loss of palindromes but not non-palindromes in plasmid pBR325 derivatives, and that RecA is necessary for UV-induced excision of Tn10 but this event is inhibited by UmuCD or its homolog MucAB. Each of the dli mutations showed unique effects on different classes of deletions. Mutation rec-2251 stimulated specifically deletions in pMC874 but had no effect on the deletion of non-palindromes in pBR325, and reduced the incidence of the other deletion events tested including loss of palindromic inserts in pBR325 as well as Tn10 excision. Mutation dli2, on the other hand, stimulated all deletions tested to varying extents, while dli3 did not affect markedly deletion formation in pBR325 plasmids but had a large stimulatory effect on both deletions in plasmid pMC874 and Tn10 excision. These results reveal that (a) some SOS-repair functions participate in deletion formation, (b) mutations selected for altering the incidence of one class of deletions may have totally different effects on other deletion events, and (c) the differences in mutant behavior may result in part from the ability of some pathways to discriminate among different deletion intermediates such as hairpins or cruciforms formed by palindromic sequences vs. transient secondary structures stabilized by direct repeats flanking non-palindromic sequences.

Participation of the SOS system in producing deletions in E. coli plasmids

The participation of the SOS response in the deletion of palindromic and non-palindromic inserts of about 66 and 100 bp cloned within the EcoR1 site of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (cat) gene of plasmid pBR325 was tested after introducing the derived plasmids into strains containing different combinations of lexA, recA and umuC alleles and the auxotrophic mutation trpE65. This allowed for a comparison of deletion frequency in the plasmids, measured as the reversion of chloramphenicol sensitivity to resistance (Cms-->Cmr), to point-mutation frequency measured from the reversion of trpE65 to tryptophan independence (Trp(-)-->Trp+). We found that the spontaneous deletion frequency of palindromic inserts was increased by the overproduction of activated RecA* and UmuC+ in lexA (Def) backgrounds but the deletion of the non-palindromic inserts was unaltered. Overproduction of RecA+ had no significant effect on deletion incidence but it did increase Trp(-)-->Trp+ reversions. The SOS stimulation of palindrome deletions paralleled the SOS mutator effect of certain recA and umuC alleles on Trp(-)-->Trp+ reversions, suggesting that some form of SOS processing was responsible for the observed increases. The results further suggest that the SOS effect on deletions depends on the distinction between palindromy vs. non-palindromy, rather than on the sizes or sequences of the inserts or those of the terminal homologies bracketing them.

Structural analysis of length mutations in a hot-spot region of wheat chloroplast DNAs

The hot-spot region related to length mutations in the chloroplast genome of the wheat group was precisely analyzed at the DNA sequence level. This region, located downstream from the rbcL gene, was highly enriched in A + T, and contained a number of direct and inverted repeats. Many deletions/insertions were observed in the region. In most deletions/insertions of multiple nucleotides, short repeated sequences were found at the mutation points. Furthermore, a pair of short repeated sequences was also observed at the border of the translocated gene. A sequence homologous with ORF512 of tobacco cpDNA was truncated in cpDNAs of the wheat group and found only in the mitochondrial DNA of Ae. crassa, suggesting the inter-organellar translocation of this sequence. Mechanisms that could generate structural alterations of the chloroplast genome in the wheat group are discussed.

Transposon Tn5 excision in yeast: influence of DNA polymerases alpha, delta, and epsilon and repair genes

Interaction between short repeats may be a source of genomic rearrangements and deletions. We investigated possible interactions between short (9 base pairs) direct repeats in yeast by using our previously described system for analyzing bacterial transposon Tn5 excision in yeast. Mutations of either POL3 or POL1, the proposed structural genes for polymerases delta and alpha, respectively, yield high levels of excision at semipermissive temperatures. pol2 (corresponding to polymerase epsilon) and pol2 pol3 double mutants do not exhibit enhanced excision. A majority of excision events involve direct repeats and are precise; the remaining imprecise excisions occur within or in the vicinity of the repeats. The three DNA repair pathways identified by rad1, rad6 and rad18, rad50 and rad52 mutations were examined for their possible role in Tn5 excision; no enhancement was observed in mutants. However, the pol3-stimulated Tn5 excision was reduced in rad52 and rad50 mutants. This suggests the potential for interaction between the systems for DNA double-strand break/recombinational repair and DNA synthesis. Based on the suggestion of Morrison et al. [Morrison, A., Araki, H., Clark, A. B., Hamatake, R. H. & Sugino, A. (1990) Cell 62, 1143-1151] that polymerases delta and alpha are responsible for lagging-strand synthesis and that polymerase epsilon is responsible for leading-strand synthesis, we suggest that Tn5 excision is stimulated under conditions of altered lagging-strand synthesis, possibly due to extended opportunities for single-strand interactions between the inverted insertion sequence I550 repeats of Tn5.

On the deletion of inverted repeated DNA in Escherichia coli: effects of length, thermal stability, and cruciform formation in vivo

We have studied the deletion of inverted repeats cloned into the EcoRI site within the CAT gene of plasmid pBR325. A cloned inverted repeat constitutes a palindrome that includes both EcoRI sites flanking the insert. In addition, the two EcoRI sites represent direct repeats flanking a region of palindromic symmetry. A current model for deletion between direct repeats involves the formation of DNA secondary structure which may stabilize the misalignment between the direct repeats during DNA replication. Our results are consistent with this model. We have analyzed deletion frequencies for several series of inverted repeats, ranging from 42 to 106 bp, that were designed to form cruciforms at low temperatures and at low superhelical densities. We demonstrate that length, thermal stability of base pairing in the hairpin stem, and ease of cruciform formation affect the frequency of deletion. In general, longer palindromes are less stable than shorter ones. The deletion frequency may be dependent on the thermal stability of base pairing involving approximately 16-20 bp from the base of the hairpin stem. The formation of cruciforms in vivo leads to a significant increase in the deletion frequency. A kinetic model is presented to describe the relationship between the physical-chemical properties of DNA structure and the deletion of inverted repeats in living cells.

Mechanisms of deletion formation in Escherichia coli plasmids. II. Deletions mediated by short direct repeats

A set of plasmids containing 42, 21 and 31 bp direct repeats was used to analyze the effect of repeat length on the frequencies of deletion formation and the structure of the deleted derivatives of different recombination-deficient Escherichia coli strains. Agarose gel electrophoresis of plasmid DNA demonstrated that the formation of deletions in these plasmids was associated with dimerization of plasmid DNA. Restriction analysis of the dimers showed that deletions at short direct repeats arose non-conservatively, that is, the formation of a deletion in one monomeric plasmid unit was not associated with a duplication in the other. Mutations in the recA, recF, recJ and recO genes had no marked effect on either the frequencies of deletion formation or the structure of dimers. In contrast, recB recC mutations greatly increased the frequencies of deletion formation, 6-fold for 42 bp, and 115-fold for 21 bp direct repeats. Conversion of DNA replication to the rolling circle mode in a recB recC strain, resulting in the formation of double-stranded ends, is suggested as the stimulatory effector.

The effect of the length of direct repeats and the presence of palindromes on deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7

The frequency of genetic deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7 was measured as a function of the length of the direct repeat. The non-essential ligase gene (gene 1.3) of bacteriophage T7 was interrupted with pieces of synthetic DNA bracketed by direct repeats of various lengths. Deletion of these 76 bp long inserts was too low to be measured when the direct repeats were less than 6 bp long. However, the frequency of deletion of inserts with longer direct repeats increased exponentially as the length of the repeats increased from 8 to 20 bp. When inverted repeats (palindromes) were designed in the midst of the insert there was essentially no increase in deletion frequency between 10 bp direct repeats. But, the same palindromic sequences increased the deletion frequency between 5 bp direct repeats by at least two orders of magnitude. Thus, in this system homology at the endpoints is a more important determinant of deletion frequency than is the presence of palindromes between the direct repeats.

Plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis is stimulated by single-stranded rolling-circle replication intermediates

The effects of the rolling-circle mode of replication and the generation of single-stranded DNA (ss DNA) on plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis were studied. Deletion units consisting of direct repeats (9, 18, or 27 bp) that do or do not flank inverted repeats (300 bp) were introduced into various plasmid replicons that generate different amounts of ss DNA (from 0% to 40% of the total plasmid DNA). With ss DNA-generating rolling-circle-type plasmids, deletion frequencies between the direct repeats were 3- to 13-fold higher than in plasmids not generating ss DNA. When the direct repeats flanked inverted repeats the deletion frequencies in ss DNA-generating plasmids were increased by as much as 20- to 140-fold. These results support models for deletion formation based on template-switching errors during complementary strand synthesis of rolling-circle-type plasmids. The structural instability (deletion formation between short direct repeats) of the ss DNA-generating plasmid pTA1060 in B. subtilis was very low in the presence of a functional initiation site for complementary strand synthesis (minus origin). This observation suggests that it will be possible to develop stable host-vector cloning systems for B. subtilis.

Limits to the role of palindromy in deletion formation

We tested the effect of palindromy on deletion formation. This involved a study of reversion of insertion mutations in the pBR322 amp gene at a site where deletions end either in 9-bp direct repeats or in adjoining 4-bp direct repeats. Inserts of palindromic DNAs ranging from 10 to more than 26 bp and related nonpalindromic DNAs were compared. The frequency of deletions (selected as Ampr revertants) was stimulated by palindromy only at lengths greater than 26 bp. The 4-bp direct repeats, one component of which is located in the palindromic insert, were used preferentially as deletion endpoints with palindromes of at least 18 bp but not of 16 or 10 bp. We interpret these results with a model of slippage during DNA replication. Because deletion frequency and deletion endpoint location depend differently on palindrome length, we propose that different factors commit a molecule to undergo deletion and determine exactly where deletion endpoints will be.

Spontaneous deletion formation within the beta-galactosidase gene of Lactobacillus bulgaricus

To investigate the genetic stability of the dairy organism Lactobacillus bulgaricus, we have analyzed 107 spontaneous mutations of the beta-galactosidase gene of this organism. Ten of these mutations were DNA rearrangements giving rise to different deletions, located predominantly within a small hot spot area. The DNA sequences of the different deletion junctions have been determined. The analysis showed that the deletions can be divided into two classes, depending on the presence of short direct-repeat sequences at the deletion endpoints and on the length of the deleted sequences. Possible mechanisms of these deletion formations and the involvement of inverted-repeat sequences that may enhance slipped DNA mispairing are discussed.

Context effects in the formation of deletions in Escherichia coli

We have examined the frequency with which identical deletions are formed in different chromosomal contexts. A panel of six mutant bla genes containing palindrome/direct repeat structures were moved from pBR322 to three locations: at lambda att, at chromosomal lac, and at F'lac. Deletion of the palindromes and one of the direct repeats results in reversion to Ampr. The frequency of deletion for all alleles declines beyond the reduction in copy number when they are moved from the multicopy plasmid environment to a single-copy chromosome. The magnitude of the declines varies in an allele-specific and location-specific manner. Our data support the hypothesis that context can influence the frequency of mutation independent of the immediate DNA sequence.

The role of direct oligonucleotide repeats in gonococcal pilin gene variation

Previous studies indicate that gonococcal pilin phase and antigenic variation occur by intragenomic pilin gene recombination, the outcome of which resembles that of gene conversion. During such transitions, the expressed complete pilin gene (pilE) acquires a novel sequence corresponding to that of a silent pilin gene (pilS). In the present study, we find that internal deletions of pilE can produce pilus-/pilus+ phase transitions: direct oligonucleotide repeats in the pilin-encoding portion of pilE bracket the deleted segments. A novel, orthodox pilE is formed upon repair of the internal deletions, with pilS sequence probably acting as a template for repair. Such deletion/repair of pilE is suggested as a principal mechanism underlying gonococcal pilus variation.

Analysis of relative reversion frequencies for IS2 insertion mutations in the regulatory region of the galOPETK operon of Escherichia coli

Two previously characterized mutations in the galOPETK operon of Escherichia coli, galOP-3 and galOPE-490, contain IS2 insertions only 1 bp apart in the gal regulatory region; yet only the former yields Gal+ phenotypic revertants at a detectable frequency. We have shown that the galOPE-490 allele comprises two mutations--an IS2(I) insertion at bp+(2-6) (relative to the gal mRNA start site) plus a C/G to A/T transversion at bp + 59. The latter creates an ochre stop codon and lies within the internal site of the bipartite gal operator; it acts as an operator mutation in an in vivo repressor titration assay. Analysis of a newly isolated allele (galOP-490*) which retains the IS2 of galOPE-490 but is galE+ reveals a reversion frequency approximately 30-fold higher than that of galOP-3. Reversion of galOPE-490 is at least 10,000-fold lower and has not been detectable even under conditions conducive to enhanced double mutations in other systems.

Specificity of deletion events in pBR322

The reversion of mutations due to inserts of identical palindromic DNAs just 1-bp apart in the amp gene of plasmid pBR322 varied up to 3000-fold (U. DasGupta, K. Weston-Hafer, and D.E. Berg (1987) Genetics 115, 41-49). The experiments reported here show that the intrinsic frequencies of deletion from these sites are truly very different. Deletions were selected by the joint loss of sacB (sucrose sensitivity) and lacZ alpa genes cloned together at these sites, without requiring restoration of the ampr allele. We found that greater than 90% of deletions at each of these sites do restore the ampr allele. This result reinforces the view that the probability of forming a particular deletion depends strongly on the DNA sequence at its prospective endpoints.