Trans-NanoSim characterizes and simulates nanopore RNA-sequencing data

Systematic assessment of long-read RNA-seq methods for transcript identification and quantification

The Long-read RNA-Seq Genome Annotation Assessment Project Consortium was formed to evaluate the effectiveness of long-read approaches for transcriptome analysis. Using different protocols and sequencing platforms, the consortium generated over 427 million long-read sequences from complementary DNA and direct RNA datasets, encompassing human, mouse and manatee species. Developers utilized these data to address challenges in transcript isoform detection, quantification and de novo transcript detection. The study revealed that libraries with longer, more accurate sequences produce more accurate transcripts than those with increased read depth, whereas greater read depth improved quantification accuracy. In well-annotated genomes, tools based on reference sequences demonstrated the best performance. Incorporating additional orthogonal data and replicate samples is advised when aiming to detect rare and novel transcripts or using reference-free approaches. This collaborative study offers a benchmark for current practices and provides direction for future method development in transcriptome analysis.

The Neo-Open Reading Frame Peptides That Comprise the Tumor Framome Are a Rich Source of Neoantigens for Cancer Immunotherapy

Identification of immunogenic cancer neoantigens as targets for therapy is challenging. Here, we integrate the whole-genome and long-read transcript sequencing of cancers to identify the collection of neo-open reading frame peptides (NOP) expressed in tumors. We termed this collection of NOPs the tumor framome. NOPs represent tumor-specific peptides that are different from wild-type proteins and may be strongly immunogenic. We describe a class of hidden NOPs that derive from structural genomic variants involving an upstream protein coding gene driving expression and translation of noncoding regions of the genome downstream of a rearrangement breakpoint, i.e., where no gene annotation or evidence for transcription exists. The entire collection of NOPs represents a vast number of possible neoantigens particularly in tumors with many structural genomic variants and a low number of missense mutations. We show that NOPs are immunogenic and epitopes derived from NOPs can bind to MHC class I molecules. Finally, we provide evidence for the presence of memory T cells specific for hidden NOPs in peripheral blood from a patient with lung cancer. This work highlights NOPs as a major source of possible neoantigens for personalized cancer immunotherapy and provides a rationale for analyzing the complete cancer genome and transcriptome as a basis for the detection of NOPs.

TKSM: highly modular, user-customizable, and scalable transcriptomic sequencing long-read simulator

MOTIVATION

Transcriptomic long-read (LR) sequencing is an increasingly cost-effective technology for probing various RNA features. Numerous tools have been developed to tackle various transcriptomic sequencing tasks (e.g. isoform and gene fusion detection). However, the lack of abundant gold-standard datasets hinders the benchmarking of such tools. Therefore, the simulation of LR sequencing is an important and practical alternative. While the existing LR simulators aim to imitate the sequencing machine noise and to target specific library protocols, they lack some important library preparation steps (e.g. PCR) and are difficult to modify to new and changing library preparation techniques (e.g. single-cell LRs).

RESULTS

We present TKSM, a modular and scalable LR simulator, designed so that each RNA modification step is targeted explicitly by a specific module. This allows the user to assemble a simulation pipeline as a combination of TKSM modules to emulate a specific sequencing design. Additionally, the input/output of all the core modules of TKSM follows the same simple format (Molecule Description Format) allowing the user to easily extend TKSM with new modules targeting new library preparation steps.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

TKSM is available as an open source software at https://github.com/vpc-ccg/tksm.

Highly efficient clustering of long-read transcriptomic data with GeLuster

MOTIVATION

The advancement of long-read RNA sequencing technologies leads to a bright future for transcriptome analysis, in which clustering long reads according to their gene family of origin is of great importance. However, existing de novo clustering algorithms require plenty of computing resources.

RESULTS

We developed a new algorithm GeLuster for clustering long RNA-seq reads. Based on our tests on one simulated dataset and nine real datasets, GeLuster exhibited superior performance. On the tested Nanopore datasets it ran 2.9-17.5 times as fast as the second-fastest method with less than one-seventh of memory consumption, while achieving higher clustering accuracy. And on the PacBio data, GeLuster also had a similar performance. It sets the stage for large-scale transcriptome study in future.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

GeLuster is freely available at https://github.com/yutingsdu/GeLuster.

SQANTI-SIM: a simulator of controlled transcript novelty for lrRNA-seq benchmark

Long-read RNA sequencing has emerged as a powerful tool for transcript discovery, even in well-annotated organisms. However, assessing the accuracy of different methods in identifying annotated and novel transcripts remains a challenge. Here, we present SQANTI-SIM, a versatile tool that wraps around popular long-read simulators to allow precise management of transcript novelty based on the structural categories defined by SQANTI3. By selectively excluding specific transcripts from the reference dataset, SQANTI-SIM effectively emulates scenarios involving unannotated transcripts. Furthermore, the tool provides customizable features and supports the simulation of additional types of data, representing the first multi-omics simulation tool for the lrRNA-seq field.

SQANTI-SIM: a simulator of controlled transcript novelty for lrRNA-seq benchmark

Long-read RNA-seq has emerged as a powerful tool for transcript discovery, even in well-annotated organisms. However, assessing the accuracy of different methods in identifying annotated and novel transcripts remains a challenge. Here, we present SQANTI-SIM, a versatile utility that wraps around popular long-read simulators to allow precise management of transcript novelty based on the structural categories defined by SQANTI3. By selectively excluding specific transcripts from the reference dataset, SQANTI-SIM effectively emulates scenarios involving unannotated transcripts. Furthermore, the tool provides customizable features and supports the simulation of additional types of data, representing the first multi-omics simulation tool for the lrRNA-seq field. We demonstrate the effectiveness of SQANTI-SIM by benchmarking five transcriptome reconstruction pipelines using the simulated data.

Reference-free assembly of long-read transcriptome sequencing data with RNA-Bloom2

Long-read sequencing technologies have improved significantly since their emergence. Their read lengths, potentially spanning entire transcripts, is advantageous for reconstructing transcriptomes. Existing long-read transcriptome assembly methods are primarily reference-based and to date, there is little focus on reference-free transcriptome assembly. We introduce "RNA-Bloom2 [ https://github.com/bcgsc/RNA-Bloom ]", a reference-free assembly method for long-read transcriptome sequencing data. Using simulated datasets and spike-in control data, we show that the transcriptome assembly quality of RNA-Bloom2 is competitive to those of reference-based methods. Furthermore, we find that RNA-Bloom2 requires 27.0 to 80.6% of the peak memory and 3.6 to 10.8% of the total wall-clock runtime of a competing reference-free method. Finally, we showcase RNA-Bloom2 in assembling a transcriptome sample of Picea sitchensis (Sitka spruce). Since our method does not rely on a reference, it further sets the groundwork for large-scale comparative transcriptomics where high-quality draft genome assemblies are not readily available.

Characterization and simulation of metagenomic nanopore sequencing data with Meta-NanoSim

BACKGROUND

Nanopore sequencing is crucial to metagenomic studies as its kilobase-long reads can contribute to resolving genomic structural differences among microbes. However, sequencing platform-specific challenges, including high base-call error rate, nonuniform read lengths, and the presence of chimeric artifacts, necessitate specifically designed analytical algorithms. The use of simulated datasets with characteristics that are true to the sequencing platform under evaluation is a cost-effective way to assess the performance of bioinformatics tools with the ground truth in a controlled environment.

RESULTS

Here, we present Meta-NanoSim, a fast and versatile utility that characterizes and simulates the unique properties of nanopore metagenomic reads. It improves upon state-of-the-art methods on microbial abundance estimation through a base-level quantification algorithm. Meta-NanoSim can simulate complex microbial communities composed of both linear and circular genomes and can stream reference genomes from online servers directly. Simulated datasets showed high congruence with experimental data in terms of read length, error profiles, and abundance levels. We demonstrate that Meta-NanoSim simulated data can facilitate the development of metagenomic algorithms and guide experimental design through a metagenome assembly benchmarking task.

CONCLUSIONS

The Meta-NanoSim characterization module investigates read features, including chimeric information and abundance levels, while the simulation module simulates large and complex multisample microbial communities with different abundance profiles. All trained models and the software are freely accessible at GitHub: https://github.com/bcgsc/NanoSim.

ESPRESSO: Robust discovery and quantification of transcript isoforms from error-prone long-read RNA-seq data

Long-read RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) holds great potential for characterizing transcriptome variation and full-length transcript isoforms, but the relatively high error rate of current long-read sequencing platforms poses a major challenge. We present ESPRESSO, a computational tool for robust discovery and quantification of transcript isoforms from error-prone long reads. ESPRESSO jointly considers alignments of all long reads aligned to a gene and uses error profiles of individual reads to improve the identification of splice junctions and the discovery of their corresponding transcript isoforms. On both a synthetic spike-in RNA sample and human RNA samples, ESPRESSO outperforms multiple contemporary tools in not only transcript isoform discovery but also transcript isoform quantification. In total, we generated and analyzed ~1.1 billion nanopore RNA-seq reads covering 30 human tissue samples and three human cell lines. ESPRESSO and its companion dataset provide a useful resource for studying the RNA repertoire of eukaryotic transcriptomes.

Accurate isoform discovery with IsoQuant using long reads

Annotating newly sequenced genomes and determining alternative isoforms from long-read RNA data are complex and incompletely solved problems. Here we present IsoQuant-a computational tool using intron graphs that accurately reconstructs transcripts both with and without reference genome annotation. For novel transcript discovery, IsoQuant reduces the false-positive rate fivefold and 2.5-fold for Oxford Nanopore reference-based or reference-free mode, respectively. IsoQuant also improves performance for Pacific Biosciences data.

PBSIM3: a simulator for all types of PacBio and ONT long reads

Long-read sequencers, such as Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) and Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) sequencers, have improved their read length and accuracy, thereby opening up unprecedented research. Many tools and algorithms have been developed to analyze long reads, and rapid progress in PacBio and ONT has further accelerated their development. Together with the development of high-throughput sequencing technologies and their analysis tools, many read simulators have been developed and effectively utilized. PBSIM is one of the popular long-read simulators. In this study, we developed PBSIM3 with three new functions: error models for long reads, multi-pass sequencing for high-fidelity read simulation and transcriptome sequencing simulation. Therefore, PBSIM3 is now able to meet a wide range of long-read simulation requirements.

Sequencing of individual barcoded cDNAs using Pacific Biosciences and Oxford Nanopore technologies reveals platform-specific error patterns

Long-read transcriptomics require understanding error sources inherent to technologies. Current approaches cannot compare methods for an individual RNA molecule. Here, we present a novel platform-comparison method that combines barcoding strategies and long-read sequencing to sequence cDNA copies representing an individual RNA molecule on both Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) and Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT). We compare these long-read pairs in terms of sequence content and isoform patterns. Although individual read pairs show high similarity, we find differences in (1) aligned length, (2) transcription start site (TSS), (3) polyadenylation site (poly(A)-site) assignment, and (4) exon–intron structures. Overall, 25% of read pairs disagree on either TSS, poly(A)-site, or splice site. Intron-chain disagreement typically arises from alignment errors of microexons and complicated splice sites. Our single-molecule technology comparison reveals that inconsistencies are often caused by sequencing error–induced inaccurate ONT alignments, especially to downstream GUNNGU donor motifs. However, annotation-disagreeing upstream shifts in NAGNAG acceptors in ONT are often confirmed by PacBio and are thus likely real. In both barcoded and nonbarcoded ONT reads, we find that intron number and proximity of GU/AGs better predict inconsistencies with the annotation than read quality alone. We summarize these findings in an annotation-based algorithm for spliced alignment correction that improves subsequent transcript construction with ONT reads.

Theory of local k-mer selection with applications to long-read alignment

Motivation

Selecting a subset of k-mers in a string in a local manner is a common task in bioinformatics tools for speeding up computation. Arguably the most well-known and common method is the minimizer technique, which selects the ‘lowest-ordered’ k-mer in a sliding window. Recently, it has been shown that minimizers may be a sub-optimal method for selecting subsets of k-mers when mutations are present. There is, however, a lack of understanding behind the theory of why certain methods perform well.

Results

We first theoretically investigate the conservation metric for k-mer selection methods. We derive an exact expression for calculating the conservation of a k-mer selection method. This turns out to be tractable enough for us to prove closed-form expressions for a variety of methods, including (open and closed) syncmers, (a, b, n)-words, and an upper bound for minimizers. As a demonstration of our results, we modified the minimap2 read aligner to use a more conserved k-mer selection method and demonstrate that there is up to an 8.2% relative increase in number of mapped reads. However, we found that the k-mers selected by more conserved methods are also more repetitive, leading to a runtime increase during alignment. We give new insight into how one might use new k-mer selection methods as a reparameterization to optimize for speed and alignment quality.

Availability and implementation

Simulations and supplementary methods are available at https://github.com/bluenote-1577/local-kmer-selection-results. os-minimap2 is a modified version of minimap2 and available at https://github.com/bluenote-1577/os-minimap2.

Supplementary information

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Improved nanopore direct RNA sequencing of cardiac myocyte samples by selective mt-RNA depletion

RNA sequencing is a powerful tool to analyze gene expression transcriptome wide. However, RNA sequencing in general and especially the recently developed methods of long read RNA sequencing are still low-throughput and cost-intensive. Here, one important design choice is to concentrate the sequencing capacity on specific parts of the transcriptome. Especially, abundant transcripts as ribosomal RNAs may dominate the available sequencing space, if not removed prior to sequencing. Several methods exist to reduce ribosomal RNA read numbers: either based on enrichment of the relevant fraction (polyA⁺ RNA) or depletion, respectively degradation of ribosomal RNAs. Furthermore, commercial kits are available to deplete globin transcripts from blood samples. However, so far, no solution exists to deal with other tissue-specific highly abundant transcripts. This is especially of interest in the heart and other muscle derived samples, where reads originating from mitochondrial RNAs make up to 30% of reads in polyA⁺ selected libraries and around 70% in single cell sequencing experiments. We present a simple method to diminish sequencing of mitochondrial RNAs in Oxford Nanopore direct RNA sequencing libraries by RNase H based clipping of the polyA tail. We show that mt-clipping enables enhanced detection of cytoplasmic mRNAs, among them genes involved in heart development and pathogenesis. Mt-clipping may be applied as well to other sequencing protocols that are based on oligo(dT) priming and can be easily adapted to other tissue-specific high-abundant transcripts.

LIQA: long-read isoform quantification and analysis

Long-read RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) technologies can sequence full-length transcripts, facilitating the exploration of isoform-specific gene expression over short-read RNA-seq. We present LIQA to quantify isoform expression and detect differential alternative splicing (DAS) events using long-read direct mRNA sequencing or cDNA sequencing data. LIQA incorporates base pair quality score and isoform-specific read length information in a survival model to assign different weights across reads, and uses an expectation-maximization algorithm for parameter estimation. We apply LIQA to long-read RNA-seq data from the Universal Human Reference, acute myeloid leukemia, and esophageal squamous epithelial cells and demonstrate its high accuracy in profiling alternative splicing events.

Trans-NanoSim characterizes and simulates nanopore RNA-sequencing data

Background

Compared with second-generation sequencing technologies, third-generation single-molecule RNA sequencing has unprecedented advantages; the long reads it generates facilitate isoform-level transcript characterization. In particular, the Oxford Nanopore Technology sequencing platforms have become more popular in recent years owing to their relatively high affordability and portability compared with other third-generation sequencing technologies. To aid the development of analytical tools that leverage the power of this technology, simulated data provide a cost-effective solution with ground truth. However, a nanopore sequence simulator targeting transcriptomic data is not available yet.

Findings

We introduce Trans-NanoSim, a tool that simulates reads with technical and transcriptome-specific features learnt from nanopore RNA-sequncing data. We comprehensively benchmarked Trans-NanoSim on direct RNA and complementary DNA datasets describing human and mouse transcriptomes. Through comparison against other nanopore read simulators, we show the unique advantage and robustness of Trans-NanoSim in capturing the characteristics of nanopore complementary DNA and direct RNA reads.

Conclusions

As a cost-effective alternative to sequencing real transcriptomes, Trans-NanoSim will facilitate the rapid development of analytical tools for nanopore RNA-sequencing data. Trans-NanoSim and its pre-trained models are freely accessible at https://github.com/bcgsc/NanoSim.