Effective Biological Control Depends on Life History Strategies of Both Parasitoid and Its Host: Evidence from Aphidius colemani-Myzus persicae System

Sub-Lethal Effects of λ-Cyhalothrin on Behavior and Development of the Parasitoid Aphidius colemani (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) on kdr-Resistant and Susceptible Green Peach Aphid, Myzus persicae (Hemiptera: Aphididae)

The green peach aphid, Myzus persicae (Sulzer), is a pest mainly controlled with insecticides, and it can acquire resistance through different mechanisms. Pyrethroids can select the knock down resistance (kdr) mutation in M. persicae and can also produce lethal and sub-lethal effects on its main parasitoid, Aphidius colemani Viereck. However, kdr-resistant M. persicae exhibits a reduced response to alarm pheromone and increased vulnerability to natural enemies. To study the effects of sub-lethal concentrations of a pyrethroid on the aphid-parasitoid interaction, kdr-resistant and susceptible M. persicae were confronted with A. colemani with residual sub-lethal concentrations of λ-cyhalothrin. The behavior, survival, and development of parasitoids were evaluated after exposure to λ-cyhalothrin LC20 for adult parasitoids (0.52 mg/liter) for susceptible (Mp-SS, 0.56 mg/liter) and kdr-resistant M. persicae (Mp-RR, 12.15 mg/liter). The foraging and oviposition behaviors of the parasitoids were not affected by the lower parasitoid or Mp-SS LC20. Conversely, the higher Mp-RR LC20 significantly reduced parasitoid walking, the frequency of sting attempts, and successful stings, as well as aphid defensive behaviors, such as walking, kicking, and jerking. Therefore, the higher vulnerability of kdr-resistant M. persicae could not be capitalized by A. colemani parasitoids under a high concentration of λ-cyhalothrin. Similarly, the parasitism rate, survival of progeny, productivity, sex ratio (proportion of females), longevity, and adult body mass were reduced, and the development time increased with a higher Mp-RR LC20. Our results suggest that A. colemani could efficiently control kdr-resistant and susceptible M. persicae only at lower λ-cyhalothrin concentrations.

Potential Aphid Population Regulation by Aphidius colemani (Hymenoptera: Aphidiidae) in Response to Host Density, Parasitoid Density, and Age

Aphidius colemani Viereck is an important parasitoid of green peach aphid [Myzus persicae (Sulzer)], a serious pest of greenhouse crops. Augmentation of natural enemies is the most used approach to biological control of greenhouse pests. Yet, the optimal release time, rate, and age of natural enemies are often unclear. Here we tested the influence of population density of both A. colemani and M. persicae, as well as parasitoid age, on parasitism and sex allocation. We aim is to provide information for cost-effective aphid biological control programs. We show that 1) parasitoid females increased parasitism and produced more female-biased offspring with an increase of aphid density, 2) a moderate increase of parasitoid release rate elevated parasitism and daughter production when aphid density was high, 3) parasitism rate declined with an increase of aphid density but the moderate increase of parasitoid release rate eased the decline rate, and 4) 3-d-old parasitoids parasitized more aphids than younger ones but parasitoid age had no effect on daughter production. These findings suggest that A. colemani females can adjust their ability to regulate the aphid population in response to aphid population dynamics. In augmentative programs, a moderate increase of parasitoid release when aphid density is high could achieve effective control and a release of 3-d-old parasitoids could lead to a better control outcome.

Impact of differences in nutritional quality of wingless and winged aphids on parasitoid fitness

Winged aphids are described as hosts of lesser quality for parasitoids because a part of their resources is used to produce wings and associated muscles during their development. Host lipid content is particularly important for parasitoid larvae as they lack lipogenesis and therefore rely entirely on the host for this resource. The goal of this study was to determine to what extent winged and wingless aphids differ from a nutritional point of view and whether these differences impact parasitoid fitness, notably the lipid content. We analysed the energetic budget (proteins, lipids and carbohydrates) of aphids of different ages (third instars, fourth instars and adults) according to the morph (winged or wingless). We also compared fitness indicators for parasitoids emerging from winged and wingless aphids (third and fourth instars). We found that in third instars, parasitoids are able to inhibit wing development whereas this is not the case in fourth instars. Both winged instars allow the production of heavier and fattier parasitoids. The presence of wings in aphids seems to have little effect on the fitness of emerging parasitoids and did not modify female choice for oviposition. Finally, we demonstrate that Aphidius colemani, used as a biological control agent, is able to parasitize wingless as well as winged Myzus persicae, at least in the juvenile stages. If the parasitism occurs in third instars, the parasitoid will prevent the aphid from flying, which could in turn reduce virus transmission.