Unexpected Short-Tandem-Repeat Patterns in Posttransplant Chimerism Testing: Investigation of 3 Cases with Help from Forensic Science

Chimeric status of biological samples after HSCT for personal identification: Y-STR based DNA analysis in sex mismatch cases

Identification of an individual is the prime object in forensic case works both in civil or criminal situations like paternity/maternity disputes, sexual assaults, murder, mass disaster victims etc. STR analysis has already proved its potential to give accurate results. In addition to autosomal chromosomes, sex determination at many times is crucial in forensic situations, especially in situations like rape cases or in cases of missing persons. The chances of wrong interpretations may arise due to false detection (or non-detection) of STR fragments overall or only at amelogenin-specific fragments, in situation like mutations, intersex conditions, trans-sexualism etc., due to natural or artificial chimersim. The forensic relevance of the possible misinterpretation of STR's or amelogenin should never be underestimated. The present study was carried out to identify an individual using Y-STR in sex mismatch patients who received hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is a method to replace patient's stem cell with the stem cell donated by the donor preferably biological related in order to cure malignant and non malignant diseases. This study enrolled ten female patients of HSCT. Samples were collected as pre and post transplant after 15 days, 30 days, 60 days, and 90 days of time interval from sex mismatch patient (female) and from donor (male) and chimeric status of the patient was analyzed using Y-STR markers (23 loci). Results demonstrated that donor genotype existed in blood and buccal swab of the recipient but no genetic profile existed for Y-STR in hair follicle of the recipient. This study suggests that only hair follicle out of three biological samples tested serves as reliable source of recipient's origin after HSCT for accurate personal identification especially in forensic situations.