Is Mutation Random or Targeted?: No Evidence for Hypermutability in Snail Toxin Genes

Random with Respect to Fitness or External Selection? An Important but Often Overlooked Distinction

Mutations are often described as being "random with respect to fitness." Here we show that the experiments used to establish randomness with respect to fitness are only capable of showing that mutations are random with respect to current external selection. Current debates about whether or not mutations are directed may be at least partially resolved by making use of this distinction. Additionally, this distinction has important mathematical, experimental, and inferential implications.

Principal Component and Structural Element Analysis Provide Insights into the Evolutionary Divergence of Conotoxins

Predatory cone snails (Conus) developed a sophisticated neuropharmacological mechanism to capture prey, escape against other predators, and deter competitors. Their venom's remarkable specificity for various ion channels and receptors is an evolutionary feat attributable to the venom's variety of peptide components (conotoxins). However, what caused conotoxin divergence remains unclear and may be related to the role of prey shift. Principal component analysis revealed clustering events within diet subgroups indicating peptide sequence similarity patterns based on the prey they subdue. Molecular analyses using multiple sequence alignment and structural element analysis were conducted to observe the events at the molecular level that caused the subgrouping. Three distinct subgroups were identified. Results showed homologous regions and conserved residues within diet subgroups but divergent between other groups. We specified that these structural elements caused subgrouping in alpha conotoxins that may play a role in function specificity. In each diet subgroup, amino acid character, length of intervening amino acids between cysteine residues, and polypeptide length influenced subgrouping. This study provides molecular insights into the role of prey shift, specifically diet preference, in conotoxin divergence.

Insights into how development and life-history dynamics shape the evolution of venom

Venomous animals are a striking example of the convergent evolution of a complex trait. These animals have independently evolved an apparatus that synthesizes, stores, and secretes a mixture of toxic compounds to the target animal through the infliction of a wound. Among these distantly related animals, some can modulate and compartmentalize functionally distinct venoms related to predation and defense. A process to separate distinct venoms can occur within and across complex life cycles as well as more streamlined ontogenies, depending on their life-history requirements. Moreover, the morphological and cellular complexity of the venom apparatus likely facilitates the functional diversity of venom deployed within a given life stage. Intersexual variation of venoms has also evolved further contributing to the massive diversity of toxic compounds characterized in these animals. These changes in the biochemical phenotype of venom can directly affect the fitness of these animals, having important implications in their diet, behavior, and mating biology. In this review, we explore the current literature that is unraveling the temporal dynamics of the venom system that are required by these animals to meet their ecological functions. These recent findings have important consequences in understanding the evolution and development of a convergent complex trait and its organismal and ecological implications.

Targeted Sequencing of Venom Genes from Cone Snail Genomes Improves Understanding of Conotoxin Molecular Evolution

To expand our capacity to discover venom sequences from the genomes of venomous organisms, we applied targeted sequencing techniques to selectively recover venom gene superfamilies and nontoxin loci from the genomes of 32 cone snail species (family, Conidae), a diverse group of marine gastropods that capture their prey using a cocktail of neurotoxic peptides (conotoxins). We were able to successfully recover conotoxin gene superfamilies across all species with high confidence (> 100× coverage) and used these data to provide new insights into conotoxin evolution. First, we found that conotoxin gene superfamilies are composed of one to six exons and are typically short in length (mean = ∼85 bp). Second, we expanded our understanding of the following genetic features of conotoxin evolution: 1) positive selection, where exons coding the mature toxin region were often three times more divergent than their adjacent noncoding regions, 2) expression regulation, with comparisons to transcriptome data showing that cone snails only express a fraction of the genes available in their genome (24-63%), and 3) extensive gene turnover, where Conidae species varied from 120 to 859 conotoxin gene copies. Finally, using comparative phylogenetic methods, we found that while diet specificity did not predict patterns of conotoxin evolution, dietary breadth was positively correlated with total conotoxin gene diversity. Overall, the targeted sequencing technique demonstrated here has the potential to radically increase the pace at which venom gene families are sequenced and studied, reshaping our ability to understand the impact of genetic changes on ecologically relevant phenotypes and subsequent diversification.