Detection of transcription factor binding in vivo using lambda exonuclease

Shared nucleotide flanks confer transcriptional competency to bZip core motifs

Sequence-specific DNA binding recruits transcription factors (TFs) to the genome to regulate gene expression. Here, we perform high resolution mapping of CEBP proteins to determine how sequence dictates genomic occupancy. We demonstrate a fundamental difference between the sequence repertoire utilized by CEBPs in vivo versus the palindromic sequence preference reported by classical in vitro models, by identifying a palindromic motif at <1% of the genomic binding sites. On the native genome, CEBPs bind a diversity of related 10 bp sequences resulting from the fusion of degenerate and canonical half-sites. Altered DNA specificity of CEBPs in cells occurs through heterodimerization with other bZip TFs, and approximately 40% of CEBP-binding sites in primary human cells harbor motifs characteristic of CEBP heterodimers. In addition, we uncover an important role for sequence bias at core-motif-flanking bases for CEBPs and demonstrate that flanking bases regulate motif function across mammalian bZip TFs. Favorable flanking bases confer efficient TF occupancy and transcriptional activity, and DNA shape may explain how the flanks alter TF binding. Importantly, motif optimization within the 10-mer is strongly correlated with cell-type-independent recruitment of CEBPβ, providing key insight into how sequence sub-optimization affects genomic occupancy of widely expressed CEBPs across cell types.

ChIP-exo interrogation of Crp, DNA, and RNAP holoenzyme interactions

Numerous in vitro studies have yielded a refined picture of the structural and molecular associations between Cyclic-AMP receptor protein (Crp), the DNA motif, and RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzyme. In this study, high-resolution ChIP-exonuclease (ChIP-exo) was applied to study Crp binding in vivo and at genome-scale. Surprisingly, Crp was found to provide little to no protection of the DNA motif under activating conditions. Instead, Crp demonstrated binding patterns that closely resembled those generated by σ⁷⁰. The binding patterns of both Crp and σ⁷⁰ are indicative of RNAP holoenzyme DNA footprinting profiles associated with stages during transcription initiation that occur post-recruitment. This is marked by a pronounced advancement of the template strand footprint profile to the +20 position relative to the transcription start site and a multimodal distribution on the nontemplate strand. This trend was also observed in the familial transcription factor, Fnr, but full protection of the motif was seen in the repressor ArcA. Given the time-scale of ChIP studies and that the rate-limiting step in transcription initiation is typically post recruitment, we propose a hypothesis where Crp is absent from the DNA motif but remains associated with RNAP holoenzyme post-recruitment during transcription initiation. The release of Crp from the DNA motif may be a result of energetic changes that occur as RNAP holoenzyme traverses the various stable intermediates towards elongation complex formation.

Genomic redistribution of GR monomers and dimers mediates transcriptional response to exogenous glucocorticoid in vivo

Glucocorticoids (GCs) are commonly prescribed drugs, but their anti-inflammatory benefits are mitigated by metabolic side effects. Their transcriptional effects, including tissue-specific gene activation and repression, are mediated by the glucocorticoid receptor (GR), which is known to bind as a homodimer to a palindromic DNA sequence. Using ChIP-exo in mouse liver under endogenous corticosterone exposure, we report here that monomeric GR interaction with a half-site motif is more prevalent than homodimer binding. Monomers colocalize with lineage-determining transcription factors in both liver and primary macrophages, and the GR half-site motif drives transcription, suggesting that monomeric binding is fundamental to GR's tissue-specific functions. In response to exogenous GC in vivo, GR dimers assemble on chromatin near ligand-activated genes, concomitant with monomer evacuation of sites near repressed genes. Thus, pharmacological GCs mediate gene expression by favoring GR homodimer occupancy at classic palindromic sites at the expense of monomeric binding. The findings have important implications for improving therapies that target GR.

Coliphage HK022 Nun protein inhibits RNA polymerase translocation

The Nun protein of coliphage HK022 arrests RNA polymerase (RNAP) in vivo and in vitro at pause sites distal to phage λ N-Utilization (nut) site RNA sequences. We tested the activity of Nun on ternary elongation complexes (TECs) assembled with templates lacking the λ nut sequence. We report that Nun stabilizes both translocation states of RNAP by restricting lateral movement of TEC along the DNA register. When Nun stabilized TEC in a pretranslocated register, immediately after NMP incorporation, it prevented binding of the next NTP and stimulated pyrophosphorolysis of the nascent transcript. In contrast, stabilization of TEC by Nun in a posttranslocated register allowed NTP binding and nucleotidyl transfer but inhibited pyrophosphorolysis and the next round of forward translocation. Nun binding to and action on the TEC requires a 9-bp RNA-DNA hybrid. We observed a Nun-dependent toe print upstream to the TEC. In addition, mutations in the RNAP β' subunit near the upstream end of the transcription bubble suppress Nun binding and arrest. These results suggest that Nun interacts with RNAP near the 5' edge of the RNA-DNA hybrid. By stabilizing translocation states through restriction of TEC lateral mobility, Nun represents a novel class of transcription arrest factors.

Changes in attitude, changes in latitude: nuclear receptors remodeling chromatin to regulate transcription

Nuclear receptors (NRs) are a large family of ligand-dependent transcription factors that regulate important physiological processes. To activate or repress genes assembled naturally as chromatin, NRs recruit two distinct enzymatic activities, namely histone-modifying enzymes and ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling complexes, to alter local chromatin structure at target gene promoters. In this review, we examine the functional relationship between ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling complexes and NRs in the context of transcriptional regulation. Using the steroid-responsive mouse mammary tumor virus promoter as a model system, we discuss in detail the molecular mechanisms underlying the recruitment of these complexes and subsequent chromatin structure changes catalyzed by this group of enzymes. In addition, we extend the discussion to other NR-regulated promoters including the pS2 promoter. Finally, we summarize specific principles governing this critical relationship, identify unanswered questions and discuss the potential application of these principles in rational drug design.

Nuclear factor 1 is required for both hormone-dependent chromatin remodeling and transcriptional activation of the mouse mammary tumor virus promoter

The mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter has been used as a model to study how the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) remodels chromatin to allow other transcription factors to bind and activate transcription. To dissect the precise role of nuclear factor 1 (NF1) in chromatin remodeling and transcriptional activation, we used linker-scanning mutants of transcription factor binding sites on the MMTV promoter. We compared the NF1 mutant MMTV promoter in the context of transiently transfected templates (transient transfection) and templates organized as chromatin (stable transfection) to understand the effect of chromatin on factor binding and transcription. We show that on a transiently transfected template, mutation in the NF1 binding site reduces both basal and hormone-dependent transcription. This suggests that NF1 is required for transcription in the absence of organized chromatin. We also found that binding of NF1 on a transiently transfected template is independent of mutation in hormone response elements or the octamer transcription factor (OTF) binding site. In contrast, the binding of OTF proteins to a transiently transfected template was found to be dependent on the binding of NF1, which may imply that NF1 has a stabilizing effect on OTF binding. On a chromatin template, mutation in the NF1 binding site does not affect the positioning of nucleosomes on the promoter. We also show that in the absence of NF1 binding, GR-mediated chromatin remodeling of nucleosome B is reduced and hormone-dependent activation of transcription is abolished. Further, we demonstrate that NF1 is required for both the association of BRG1 chromatin remodeling complex and the GR on the promoter in vivo. These results suggest the novel possibility that NF1 may participate in chromatin remodeling activities in addition to directly enhancing transcription and that in the absence of its binding site the GR is unable to effectively bind the promoter and recruit the remodeling complex.

The histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A blocks progesterone receptor-mediated transactivation of the mouse mammary tumor virus promoter in vivo

Post-translational modifications of histones play an important role in modulating gene transcription within chromatin. We used the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter, which adopts an ordered nucleosomal structure, to investigate the impact of a specific inhibitor of histone deacetylase, trichostatin A (TSA), on progesterone receptor-activated transcription. TSA induced global histone hyperacetylation, and this effect occurred independently of the presence of hormone. Interestingly, chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis revealed no significant change in the level of acetylated histones associated with the MMTV promoter following high TSA treatment. In human breast cancer cells, in which the MMTV promoter adopts a constitutively "open" chromatin structure, treatment with TSA converted the MMTV promoter into a closed structure. Addition of hormone did not overcome this TSA-induced closure of the promoter chromatin. Furthermore, TSA treatment resulted in the eviction of the transcription factor nuclear factor-1 from the promoter and reduced progesterone receptor-induced transcription. Kinetic experiments revealed that a loss of chromatin-remodeling proteins was coincident with the decrease in MMTV transcriptional activity and the imposition of repressed chromatin architecture at the promoter. These results demonstrate that deacetylase inhibitor treatment at levels that induce global histone acetylation may leave specific regulatory regions relatively unaffected and that this treatment may lead to transcriptional inhibition by mechanisms that modify chromatin-remodeling proteins rather than by influencing histone acetylation of the local promoter chromatin structure.

Selective binding of steroid hormone receptors to octamer transcription factors determines transcriptional synergism at the mouse mammary tumor virus promoter

Transcriptional synergism between glucocorticoid receptor (GR) and octamer transcription factors 1 and 2 (Oct-1 and Oct-2) in the induction of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) transcription has been proposed to be mediated through directed recruitment of the octamer factors to their binding sites in the viral long terminal repeat. This recruitment correlates with direct binding between the GR DNA binding domain and the POU domain of the octamer factors. In present study, in vitro experiments identified several nuclear hormone receptors to have the potential to bind to the POU domains of Oct-1 and Oct-2 through their DNA binding domains, suggesting that POU domain binding may be a property shared by many nuclear hormone receptors. However, physiologically relevant binding to the POU domain appeared to be a property restricted to only a few nuclear receptors as only GR, progesterone receptor (PR), and androgen receptor (AR), were found to interact physically and functionally with Oct-1 and Oct-2 in transfected cells. Thus GR, PR, and AR efficiently promoted the recruitment of Oct-2 to adjacent octamer motifs in the cell, whereas mineralocorticoid receptor (MR), estrogen receptor alpha, and retinoid X receptor failed to facilitate octamer factor DNA binding. For MMTV, although GR and MR both induced transcription efficiently, mutation of the promoter proximal octamer motifs strongly decreased GR-induced transcription without affecting the total level of reporter gene activity in response to MR. These results suggest that the configuration of the hormone response element within the MMTV long terminal repeat may promote a dependence for the glucocorticoid response upon the recruitment of octamer transcription factors to their response elements within the viral promoter.

Recruitment of octamer transcription factors to DNA by glucocorticoid receptor

Glucocorticoid receptor (GR) and octamer transcription factors 1 and 2 (Oct-1/2) interact synergistically to activate the transcription of mouse mammary tumor virus and many cellular genes. Synergism correlates with cooperative DNA binding of the two factors in vitro. To examine the molecular basis for these cooperative interactions, we have studied the consequences of protein-protein binding between GR and Oct-1/2. We have determined that GR binds in solution to the octamer factor POU domain. Binding is mediated through an interface in the GR DNA binding domain that includes amino acids C500 and L501. In transfected mammalian cells, a transcriptionally inert wild-type but not an L501P GR peptide potentiated transcriptional activation by Oct-2 100-fold above the level that could be attained in the cell by expressing Oct-2 alone. Transcriptional activation correlated closely with a striking increase in the occupancy of octamer motifs adjacent to glucocorticoid response elements (GREs) on transiently transfected DNAs. Intriguingly, GR-Oct-1/2 binding was interrupted by the binding of GR to a GRE. We propose a model for transcriptional cooperativity in which GR-Oct-1/2 binding promotes an increase in the local concentration of octamer factors over glucocorticoid-responsive regulatory regions. These results reveal transcriptional cooperativity through a direct protein interaction between two sequence-specific transcription factors that is mediated in a way that is expected to restrict transcriptional effects to regulatory regions with DNA binding sites for both factors.

Steroid hormone receptor status defines the MMTV promoter chromatin structure in vivo

The ability to respond to small signalling molecules such as steroid hormones is important for many physiological processes. Steroid hormones act through a group of high affinity receptors that regulate transcription by binding to hormone response elements (HREs) located within the promoters of target genes, which themselves are organized with nuclear proteins to form chromatin. To dissect the mechanisms(s) of steroid hormone action we have used the steroid inducible mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter as a model system. The MMTV promoter is assembled into a phased array of nucleosomes that are specifically positioned in rodent cells. Induction of transcription by glucocorticoids is accompanied by the appearance of a hypersensitive region in the proximal promoter which allows the hormone dependent assembly of a preinitiation complex including transcription factors such as nuclear factor 1 (NF1) and the octamer transcription factor (OTF). Surprisingly, when introduced by transient transfection, the progesterone receptor (PR) is unable to activate this promoter in vivo, a finding that may result from its inability to alter MMTV promoter chromatin. In an attempt to investigate the failure of the PR to activate the promoter, we have stably introduced the MMTV promoter into human T47D breast cancer cells that express high levels of the PR. In contrast to what has been observed previously in rodent cells, the MMTV templates resident in human breast cancer cells adopt a novel and constitutively open chromatin structure. The constitutively open chromatin structure is accompanied by the hormone independent loading of transcription factors including the PR and NF1. In T47D cells that stably express the glucocorticoid receptor, the MMTV promoter responds to glucocorticoids, but not progestins, and displays glucocorticoid induced restriction enzyme hypersensitivity and transcription factor loading. These findings suggest that the organization of the MMTV chromatin structure is dependent upon the cell type and receptor status of the recipient cell into which the MMTV promoter is stably introduced.

Dissection of progesterone receptor-mediated chromatin remodeling and transcriptional activation in vivo

We have investigated whether constitutive binding by the progesterone receptor (PR) to a promoter is required for the maintenance of an open chromatin structure in vivo. For these experiments, we used human T47D breast cancer cells in which the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter, stably assembled as chromatin, is constitutively hypersensitive to endonucleolytic cleavage. In vivo footprinting revealed that transcription factors nuclear factor 1 and the PR were constitutively bound to the MMTV promoter in these cells. Treatment of these cells for 1 hr with the steroid antagonist ZK98299 prevented PR binding to chromatin in vivo and reversed hypersensitivity, leading to the loss of transcription factor binding. The reduction in hypersensitivity induced by ZK98299 was readily reversed by treatment with the progestin R5020. The chromatin organization of the promoter could be cycled between the open and closed states by consecutive treatments with agonist or antagonist. The antagonist RU486 also blocked activation of transcription and the assembly of a transcription preinitiation complex, but in contrast to ZK98299, maintained the hypersensitive chromatin state. Taken together, these results suggest that PR binding to chromatin is sufficient to induce hypersensitivity to endonucleolytic cleavage. Furthermore, they indicate that the PR binding to DNA and the resulting chromatin hypersensitivity is functionally separate from transcriptional activation in vivo.