Effects on NaeI-DNA recognition of the leucine to lysine substitution that transforms restriction endonuclease NaeI to a topoisomerase: a model for restriction endonuclease evolution

Effect of NaeI-L43K mutation on protein dynamics and DNA conformation: Insights from molecular dynamics simulations

Protein-DNA interactions are an important class of biomolecular interactions inside the cell. Delineating the mechanisms of protein-DNA interactions and more specifically, how proteins search and bind to their specific cognate sequences has been the quest of many in the scientific community. Restriction enzymes have served as useful model systems to this end. In this work, we have investigated using molecular dynamics simulations the effect of L43K mutation on NaeI, a type IIE restriction enzyme. NaeI has two domains, the Topo and the Endo domains, each binding to identical strands of DNA sequences (GCCGGC)₂. The binding of the DNA to the Topo domain is thought to enhance the binding and cleavage of DNA at the Endo domain. Interestingly, it has been found that the mutation of an amino acid that is distantly-located from the DNA cleavage site (L43K) converts the restriction endonuclease to a topoisomerase. Our investigations reveal that the L43K mutation not only induces local structural changes (as evidenced by changes in hydrogen bond propensities and differences in the percentage of secondary structure assignments of the residues in the ligase-like domain) but also alters the overall protein dynamics and DNA conformation which probably leads to the loss of specific cleavage of the recognition site. In a larger context, our study underscores the importance of considering the role of distantly-located amino acids in understanding protein-DNA interactions.

Factors influencing resistance of UV-irradiated DNA to the restriction endonuclease cleavage

DNA molecules of pUC19, pBR322 and PhiX174 were irradiated by various doses of UV light and the irradiated molecules were cleaved by about two dozen type II restrictases. The irradiation generally blocked the cleavage in a dose-dependent way. In accordance with previous studies, the (A + T)-richness and the (PyPy) dimer content of the restriction site belongs among the factors that on average, cause an increase in the resistance of UV damaged DNA to the restrictase cleavage. However, we observed strong effects of UV irradiation even with (G + C)-rich and (PyPy)-poor sites. In addition, sequences flanking the restriction site influenced the protection in some cases (e.g. HindIII), but not in others (e.g. SalI), whereas neoschizomer couples SmaI and AvaI, or SacI and Ecl136II, cleaved the UV-irradiated DNA similarly. Hence the intrastrand thymine dimers located in the recognition site are not the only photoproduct blocking the restrictases. UV irradiation of the A-form generally made the irradiated DNA less resistant to restrictase cleavage than irradiation in the B-form and in some cases, the A-form completely protected the UV-irradiated DNA against the damage recognized by the restrictases. The present results also demonstrate that the UV irradiation approach used to generate partial digests in genomic DNA studies, can be extended to the (G + C)-rich and (PyPy)-poor restriction sites. The present extensive and quantitative data can be used in genomic applications of UV damage probing by restrictases.

Amino acid substitutions at position 43 of NaeI endonuclease. Evidence for changes in NaeI structure

NaeI endonuclease contains a 10-amino acid region with sequence similarity to the active site KXDG motif of DNA ligase except for leucine (Leu-43) in NaeI ((43)LXDG(46)). Changing Leu-43 to lysine abolishes the NaeI endonuclease activity and replaces it with topoisomerase and recombinase activities. Here we report the results of substituting Leu-43 with alanine, arginine, asparagine, glutamate, and histidine. Quantitating specific activities and DNA binding values for the mutant proteins determined the range of amino acids at position 43 that alter NaeI mechanism. Substituting alanine, asparagine, glutamate, and histidine for Leu-43 maintained endonuclease activity, but at a lower level. On the other hand, substituting positively charged arginine, like lysine at position 43, converted NaeI to a topoisomerase with no observable double-strand cleavage activity. The specific activities of NaeI-43K and NaeI-43R and their relative sensitivities to salt, the topoisomerase-inhibiting drug N-[4-(9-acridinylamino)-3-methoxyphenyl]methane-sulfonamide (amsacrine) and single-stranded DNA showed that the two activities are similar. The effect of placing a positive charge at position 43 on NaeI structure was determined by measuring (for NaeI and NaeI-43K) relative susceptibilities to proteolysis, UV, circular dichroism spectra, and temperature melting transitions. The results provide evidence that a positive charge at position 43 induces dramatic changes in NaeI structure that affect both the Endo and Topo domains of NaeI. The identification of four putative DNA ligase motifs in NaeI leads us to speculate that structural changes that superimpose these motifs on the ligase structure may account for the changes in activity.

Toprim--a conserved catalytic domain in type IA and II topoisomerases, DnaG-type primases, OLD family nucleases and RecR proteins

Iterative profile searches and structural modeling show that bacterial DnaG-type primases, small primase-like proteins from bacteria and archaea, type IA and type II topoisomerases, bacterial and archaeal nucleases of the OLD family and bacterial DNA repair proteins of the RecR/M family contain a common domain, designated Toprim (topoisomerase-primase) domain. The domain consists of approximately 100 amino acids and has two conserved motifs, one of which centers at a conserved glutamate and the other one at two conserved aspartates (DxD). Examination of the structure of Topo IA and Topo II and modeling of the Toprim domains of the primases reveal a compact beta/alpha fold, with the conserved negatively charged residues juxtaposed, and inserts seen in Topo IA and Topo II. The conserved glutamate may act as a general base in nucleotide polymerization by primases and in strand rejoining by topoisomerases and as a general acid in strand cleavage by topoisomerases and nucleases. The role of this glutamate in catalysis is supported by site-directed mutagenesis data on primases and Topo IA. The DxD motif may coordinate Mg2+that is required for the activity of all Toprim-containing enzymes. The common ancestor of all life forms could encode a prototype Toprim enzyme that might have had both nucleotidyl transferase and polynucleotide cleaving activity.

Step-wise DNA relaxation and decatenation by NaeI-43K

Nae I protein was originally isolated for its restriction endonuclease properties. Nae I was later discovered to either relax or cleave supercoiled DNA, depending upon whether Nae I position 43 contains a lysine (43K) or leucine (43L) respectively. Nae I-43K DNA relaxation activity appears to be the product of coupling separate endonuclease and ligase domains within the same polypeptide. Whereas Nae I relaxes supercoiled DNA like a topoisomerase, even forming a transient covalent intermediate with the substrate DNA, Nae I shows no obvious sequence similarity to the topoisomerases. To further characterize the topoisomerase activity of Nae I, we report here that Nae I-43K changes the linking number of a single negatively supercoiled topoisomer of pBR322 by units of one and therefore is a type I topoisomerase. Positively supercoiled pBR322 was resistant to Nae I-43K. At low salt concentration Nae I-43K was processive; non-saturating amounts of enzyme relaxed a fraction of the DNA. At high salt concentration the same non-saturating amounts of Nae I-43K partially relaxed all the DNA in a step-wise fashion to give a Gaussian distribution of topoisomers, demonstrating a switch from a processive to a distributive mode of action. Nae I-43K decatenated kinetoplast DNA containing nicked circles, implying that Nae I-43K can cleave opposite a nick. The products of the reaction are decatenated nicked circles under both processive and distributive conditions. The behavior of Nae I-43K is consistent with that of a prokaryotic type I topoisomerase.

Cooperative binding properties of restriction endonuclease EcoRII with DNA recognition sites

EcoRII is a member of the expanding group of type IIe restriction endonucleases that share the distinguishing feature of requiring cooperativity between two recognition sites in their substrate DNA. To determine the stoichiometry of the active DNA-enzyme complex and the mode of cooperative interaction, we have investigated the dependence of EcoRII cleavage on the concentration of EcoRII dimers. Maximal restriction was observed at dimer/site ratios of 0.25 and 0. 5. The molecular weight of the DNA-enzyme complex eluted from a gel filtration column also corresponds to a dimeric enzyme structure bound to two substrate sites. We conclude that one EcoRII dimer is sufficient to interact cooperatively with two DNA recognition sites. A Lac repressor "barrier" bound between two normally reactive EcoRII sites did not inhibit restriction endonuclease activity, indicating that cooperativity between EcoRII sites is achieved by bending or looping of the intervening DNA stretch. Comparative cleavage of linear substrates with differently spaced interacting sites revealed an inverse correlation between cleavage rate and site distance. At the optimal distance of one helical turn, EcoRII cleavage is independent of the orientation of the recognition sequence in the DNA double strand.

Polynucleotide ligase activity of eukaryotic topoisomerase I

Introduction of a single ribonucleoside immediately 5' of the scissile phosphate of a duplex DNA substrate converts eukaryotic topoisomerase I into an endoribonuclease. Here, I demonstrate that the RNase reaction is reversible. Vaccinia topoisomerase can ligate 2', 3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini annealed to a bridging template strand. Remarkably, the ligase activity of topoisomerase does not require the active site tyrosine, implying that strand joining can occur via direct attack of the 5' hydroxyl on the cyclic phosphate without a covalent intermediate. Ligation does require other catalytic side chains on the enzyme. These findings underscore how a common ancestral mechanism of phosphoryl and nucleotidyl transfer can be harnessed to perform seemingly diverse tasks through subtle changes at the active site.

The domain organization of NaeI endonuclease: separation of binding and catalysis

NaeI is a remarkable type II restriction endonuclease. It must bind two recognition sequences to cleave DNA, forms a covalent protein-DNA intermediate, and is only 1 aa change away from topoisomerase and recombinase activity. The latter activities apparently derive from reactivation of a cryptic DNA ligase active site. Here, we demonstrate that NaeI has two protease-resistant domains, involving approximately the N-terminal and C-terminal halves of the protein, linked by a protease-accessible region of 30 aa. The domains were purified by cloning. The C-terminal domain was shown by gel mobility-shift assay to have approximately 8-fold lower DNA-binding ability than intact NaeI. Analytical ultracentrifugation showed this domain to be a monomer in solution. The N-terminal domain, which contains the catalytic region defined by random mutagenesis, did not bind DNA and was a mixture of different-sized complexes in solution implying that it mediates self-association. DNA greatly inhibited proteolysis of the linker region. The results identify the DNA-binding domain, imply that DNA cleavage and recognition are independent and separable, and lead us to speculate about a cleft-like structure for NaeI.

Nick sensing by vaccinia virus DNA ligase requires a 5' phosphate at the nick and occupancy of the adenylate binding site on the enzyme

Vaccinia virus DNA ligase has an intrinsic nick-sensing function. The enzyme discriminates at the substrate binding step between a DNA containing a 5' phosphate and a DNA containing a 5' hydroxyl at the nick. Further insights into nick recognition and catalysis emerge from studies of the active-site mutant K231A, which is unable to form the covalent ligase-adenylate intermediate and hence cannot activate a nicked DNA substrate via formation of the DNA-adenylate intermediate. Nonetheless, K231A does catalyze phosphodiester bond formation at a preadenylated nick. Hence, the active-site lysine of DNA ligase is not required for the strand closure step of the ligation reaction. The K231A mutant binds tightly to nicked DNA-adenylate but has low affinity for a standard DNA nick. The wild-type vaccinia virus ligase, which is predominantly ligase-adenylate, binds tightly to a DNA nick. This result suggests that occupancy of the AMP binding pocket of DNA ligase is essential for stable binding to DNA. Sequestration of an extrahelical nucleotide by DNA-bound ligase is reminiscent of the base-flipping mechanism of target-site recognition and catalysis used by other DNA modification and repair enzymes.