The conformational landscape of transcription intermediates involved in the regulation of the ZMP-sensing riboswitch from Thermosinus carboxydivorans

Sequential structure probing of cotranscriptional RNA folding intermediates

Cotranscriptional RNA folding pathways typically involve the sequential formation of folding intermediates. Existing methods for cotranscriptional RNA structure probing map the structure of nascent RNA in the context of a terminally arrested transcription elongation complex. Consequently, the rearrangement of RNA structures as nucleotides are added to the transcript can be inferred but is not assessed directly. Here, we describe linked-multipoint Transcription Elongation Complex RNA structure probing (TECprobe-LM), which assesses the cotranscriptional rearrangement of RNA structures by sequentially positioning E. coli RNAP at two or more points within a DNA template so that nascent RNA can be chemically probed. We validate TECprobe-LM by measuring known folding events that occur within the E. coli signal recognition particle RNA, Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, and Bacillus cereus crcB fluoride riboswitch folding pathways. Our findings establish TECprobe-LM as a strategy for observing cotranscriptional RNA folding events directly using chemical probing.

Systematic analysis of cotranscriptional RNA folding using transcription elongation complex display

RNA can fold into structures that mediate diverse cellular functions. Understanding how RNA primary sequence directs the formation of functional structures requires methods that can comprehensively assess how changes in an RNA sequence affect its structure and function. Here we have developed a platform for performing high-throughput cotranscriptional RNA biochemical assays, called Transcription Elongation Complex display (TECdisplay). TECdisplay measures RNA function by fractionating a TEC library based on the activity of cotranscriptionally displayed nascent RNA. In this way, RNA function is measured as the distribution of template DNA molecules between fractions of the transcription reaction. This approach circumvents typical RNA sequencing library preparation steps that can cause technical bias. We used TECdisplay to characterize the transcription antitermination activity of >1 million variants of the Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch designed to perturb steps within its cotranscriptional folding pathway. Our findings establish TECdisplay as an accessible platform for high-throughput RNA biochemical assays.

RNA folding kinetics control riboswitch sensitivity in vivo

Riboswitches are ligand-responsive gene-regulatory RNA elements that perform key roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. Understanding how riboswitch sensitivity to ligand (EC50) is controlled is critical to explain how highly conserved aptamer domains are deployed in a variety of contexts with different sensitivity demands. Here we uncover roles by which RNA folding dynamics control riboswitch sensitivity in cells. By investigating the Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, we identify multiple mechanistic routes of altering expression platform sequence and structure to slow RNA folding, all of which enhance riboswitch sensitivity. Applying these methods to riboswitches with diverse aptamer architectures and regulatory mechanisms demonstrates the generality of our findings, indicating that any riboswitch that operates in a kinetic regime can be sensitized by slowing expression platform folding. Our results add to the growing suite of knowledge and approaches that can be used to rationally program cotranscriptional RNA folding for biotechnology applications, and suggest general RNA folding principles for understanding dynamic RNA systems in other areas of biology.

A guide to RNA structure analysis and RNA-targeting methods

RNAs are increasingly recognized as promising therapeutic targets, susceptible to modulation by strategies that include targeting with small molecules, antisense oligonucleotides, deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes), or CRISPR/Cas13. However, while drug development for proteins follows well-established paths for rational design based on the accurate knowledge of their three-dimensional structure, RNA-targeting strategies are challenging since comprehensive RNA structures are yet scarce and challenging to acquire. Numerous methods have been developed to elucidate the secondary and three-dimensional structure of RNAs, including X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance, SHAPE, DMS, and bioinformatic methods, yet they have often revealed flexible transcripts and co-existing populations rather than single-defined structures. Thus, researchers aiming to target RNAs face a critical decision: whether to acquire the detailed structure of transcripts in advance or to adopt phenotypic screens or sequence-based approaches that are independent of the structure. Still, even in strategies that seem to rely only on the nucleotide sequence (like the design of antisense oligonucleotides), researchers may need information about the accessibility of the compounds to the folded RNA molecule. In this concise guide, we provide an overview for researchers interested in targeting RNAs: We start by revisiting current methodologies for defining secondary or three-dimensional RNA structure and then we explore RNA-targeting strategies that may or may not require an in-depth knowledge of RNA structure. We envision that complementary approaches may expedite the development of RNA-targeting molecules to combat disease.

Sequential structure probing of cotranscriptional RNA folding intermediates

Cotranscriptional RNA folding pathways typically involve the sequential formation of folding intermediates. Existing methods for cotranscriptional RNA structure probing map the structure of nascent RNA in the context of a terminally arrested transcription elongation complex. Consequently, the rearrangement of RNA structures as nucleotides are added to the transcript can be inferred but is not assessed directly. To address this limitation, we have developed linked-multipoint Transcription Elongation Complex RNA structure probing (TECprobe-LM), which assesses the cotranscriptional rearrangement of RNA structures by sequentially positioning E. coli RNAP at two or more points within a DNA template so that nascent RNA can be chemically probed. We validated TECprobe-LM by measuring known folding events that occur within the E. coli signal recognition particle RNA, Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, and Bacillus cereus crcB fluoride riboswitch folding pathways. Our findings establish TECprobe-LM as a strategy for detecting cotranscriptional RNA folding events directly using chemical probing.

Identification of RNA structures and their roles in RNA functions

The development of high-throughput RNA structure profiling methods in the past decade has greatly facilitated our ability to map and characterize different aspects of RNA structures transcriptome-wide in cell populations, single cells and single molecules. The resulting high-resolution data have provided insights into the static and dynamic nature of RNA structures, revealing their complexity as they perform their respective functions in the cell. In this Review, we discuss recent technical advances in the determination of RNA structures, and the roles of RNA structures in RNA biogenesis and functions, including in transcription, processing, translation, degradation, localization and RNA structure-dependent condensates. We also discuss the current understanding of how RNA structures could guide drug design for treating genetic diseases and battling pathogenic viruses, and highlight existing challenges and future directions in RNA structure research.

Comprehensive Profiling of Roquin Binding Preferences for RNA Stem-Loops

The cellular levels of mRNAs are controlled post-transcriptionally by cis-regulatory elements located in the 3'-untranslated region. These linear or structured elements are recognized by RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) to modulate mRNA stability. The Roquin-1 and -2 proteins specifically recognize RNA stem-loop motifs, the trinucleotide loop-containing constitutive decay elements (CDEs) and the hexanucleotide loop-containing alternative decay elements (ADEs), with their unique ROQ domain to initiate mRNA degradation. However, the RNA-binding capacity of Roquin towards different classes of stem-loops has not been rigorously characterized, leaving its exact binding preferences unclear. Here, we map the RNA-binding preference of the ROQ domain at nucleotide resolution introducing sRBNS (structured RNA Bind-n-Seq), a customized RBNS workflow with pre-structured RNA libraries. We found a clear preference of Roquin towards specific loop sizes and extended the consensus motifs for CDEs and ADEs. The newly identified motifs are recognized with nanomolar affinity through the canonical RNA-ROQ interface. Using these new stem-loop variants as blueprints, we predicted novel Roquin target mRNAs and verified the expanded target space in cells. The study demonstrates the power of high-throughput assays including RNA structure formation for the systematic investigation of (structural) RNA-binding preferences to comprehensively identify mRNA targets and elucidate the biological function of RBPs.

Opportunities for Riboswitch Inhibition by Targeting Co-Transcriptional RNA Folding Events

Antibiotic resistance is a critical global health concern, causing millions of prolonged bacterial infections every year and straining our healthcare systems. Novel antibiotic strategies are essential to combating this health crisis and bacterial non-coding RNAs are promising targets for new antibiotics. In particular, a class of bacterial non-coding RNAs called riboswitches has attracted significant interest as antibiotic targets. Riboswitches reside in the 5'-untranslated region of an mRNA transcript and tune gene expression levels in cis by binding to a small-molecule ligand. Riboswitches often control expression of essential genes for bacterial survival, making riboswitch inhibitors an exciting prospect for new antibacterials. Synthetic ligand mimics have predominated the search for new riboswitch inhibitors, which are designed based on static structures of a riboswitch's ligand-sensing aptamer domain or identified by screening a small-molecule library. However, many small-molecule inhibitors that bind an isolated riboswitch aptamer domain with high affinity in vitro lack potency in vivo. Importantly, riboswitches fold and respond to the ligand during active transcription in vivo. This co-transcriptional folding is often not considered during inhibitor design, and may explain the discrepancy between a low Kd in vitro and poor inhibition in vivo. In this review, we cover advances in riboswitch co-transcriptional folding and illustrate how intermediate structures can be targeted by antisense oligonucleotides-an exciting new strategy for riboswitch inhibitor design.

RNA folding kinetics control riboswitch sensitivity in vivo

Riboswitches are ligand-responsive gene-regulatory RNA elements that perform key roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. Understanding how riboswitch sensitivity is controlled is critical to understanding how highly conserved aptamer domains are deployed in a variety of contexts with different sensitivity demands. Here we uncover new roles by which RNA folding dynamics control riboswitch sensitivity in cells. By investigating the Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, we identify multiple mechanistic routes of altering expression platform sequence and structure to slow RNA folding, all of which enhance riboswitch sensitivity. Applying these methods to riboswitches with diverse aptamer architectures that regulate transcription and translation with ON and OFF logic demonstrates the generality of our findings, indicating that any riboswitch that operates in a kinetic regime can be sensitized by slowing expression platform folding. Comparison of the most sensitized versions of these switches to equilibrium aptamer:ligand dissociation constants suggests a limit to the sensitivities achievable by kinetic RNA switches. Our results add to the growing suite of knowledge and approaches that can be used to rationally program cotranscriptional RNA folding for biotechnology applications, and suggest general RNA folding principles for understanding dynamic RNA systems in other areas of biology.

Flipping the script: Understanding riboswitches from an alternative perspective

Riboswitches are broadly distributed regulatory elements most frequently found in the 5'-leader sequence of bacterial mRNAs that regulate gene expression in response to the binding of a small molecule effector. The occupancy status of the ligand-binding aptamer domain manipulates downstream information in the message that instructs the expression machinery. Currently, there are over 55 validated riboswitch classes, where each class is defined based on the identity of the ligand it binds and/or sequence and structure conservation patterns within the aptamer domain. This classification reflects an "aptamer-centric" perspective that dominates our understanding of riboswitches. In this review, we propose a conceptual framework that groups riboswitches based on the mechanism by which RNA manipulates information directly instructing the expression machinery. This scheme does not replace the established aptamer domain-based classification of riboswitches but rather serves to facilitate hypothesis-driven investigation of riboswitch regulatory mechanisms. Based on current bioinformatic, structural, and biochemical studies of a broad spectrum of riboswitches, we propose three major mechanistic groups: (1) "direct occlusion", (2) "interdomain docking", and (3) "strand exchange". We discuss the defining features of each group, present representative examples of riboswitches from each group, and illustrate how these RNAs couple small molecule binding to gene regulation. While mechanistic studies of the occlusion and docking groups have yielded compelling models for how these riboswitches function, much less is known about strand exchange processes. To conclude, we outline the limitations of our mechanism-based conceptual framework and discuss how critical information within riboswitch expression platforms can inform gene regulation.

Advances, Applications, and Perspectives in Small-Angle X-ray Scattering of RNA

RNAs exhibit a plethora of functions far beyond transmitting genetic information. Often, RNA functions are entailed in their structure, be it as a regulatory switch, protein binding site, or providing catalytic activity. Structural information is a prerequisite for a full understanding of RNA-regulatory mechanisms. Owing to the inherent dynamics, size, and instability of RNA, its structure determination remains challenging. Methods such as NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and cryo-electron microscopy can provide high-resolution structures; however, their limitations make structure determination, even for small RNAs, cumbersome, if at all possible. Although at a low resolution, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) has proven valuable in advancing structure determination of RNAs as a complementary method, which is also applicable to large-sized RNAs. Here, we review the technological and methodological advancements of RNA SAXS. We provide examples of the powerful inclusion of SAXS in structural biology and discuss possible future applications to large RNAs.

NMR of RNA - Structure and interactions

RNA was shown to have a more substantial role in the regulation of diverse cellular processes than anticipated until recently. Answers to questions what is the structure of specific RNAs, how structure changes to accommodate different functional roles, and how RNA senses other biomolecules and changes its fold upon interaction create a complete representation of RNA involved in cellular processes. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy encompasses a collection of methods and approaches that offer insight into several structural aspects of RNAs. We review the most recent advances in the field of viral, long non-coding, regulatory, and four-stranded RNAs, with an emphasis on the detection of dynamic sub-states and in view of chemical modifications that expand RNA's function.

Quantitative Analysis of Transcription Termination via Position-Selective Labeling of RNA (PLOR) Method

T7 RNA polymerase is the most widely used enzyme in RNA synthesis, and it is also used for RNA labeling in position-selective labeling of RNA (PLOR). PLOR is a liquid-solid hybrid phase method that has been developed to introduce labels to specific positions of RNA. Here, we applied PLOR as a single-round transcription method to quantify the terminated and read-through products in transcription for the first time. Various factors, including pausing strategies, Mg²⁺, ligand and the NTP concentration at the transcriptional termination of adenine riboswitch RNA have been characterized. This helps to understand transcription termination, which is one of the least understood processes in transcription. Additionally, our strategy can potentially be used to study the co-transcription behavior of general RNA, especially when continuous transcription is not desired.

The cotranscriptional folding landscape for two cyclic di-nucleotide-sensing riboswitches with highly homologous aptamer domains acting either as ON- or OFF-switches

Riboswitches are gene regulatory elements located in untranslated mRNA regions. They bind inducer molecules with high affinity and specificity. Cyclic-di-nucleotide-sensing riboswitches are major regulators of genes for the environment, membranes and motility (GEMM) of bacteria. Up to now, structural probing assays or crystal structures have provided insight into the interaction between cyclic-di-nucleotides and their corresponding riboswitches. ITC analysis, NMR analysis and computational modeling allowed us to gain a detailed understanding of the gene regulation mechanisms for the Cd1 (Clostridium difficile) and for the pilM (Geobacter metallireducens) riboswitches and their respective di-nucleotides c-di-GMP and c-GAMP. Binding capability showed a 25 nucleotide (nt) long window for pilM and a 61 nt window for Cd1. Within this window, binding affinities ranged from 35 μM to 0.25 μM spanning two orders of magnitude for Cd1 and pilM showing a strong dependence on competing riboswitch folds. Experimental results were incorporated into a Markov simulation to further our understanding of the transcriptional folding pathways of riboswitches. Our model showed the ability to predict riboswitch gene regulation and its dependence on transcription speed, pausing and ligand concentration.

Characterization of Structure and Dynamics of the Guanidine-II Riboswitch from Escherichia coli by NMR Spectroscopy and Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS)

Riboswitches are regulatory RNA elements that undergo functionally important allosteric conformational switching upon binding of specific ligands. The here investigated guanidine-II riboswitch binds the small cation, guanidinium, and forms a kissing loop-loop interaction between its P1 and P2 hairpins. We investigated the structural changes to support previous studies regarding the binding mechanism. Using NMR spectroscopy, we confirmed the structure as observed in crystal structures and we characterized the kissing loop interaction upon addition of Mg2+ and ligand for the riboswitch aptamer from Escherichia coli. We further investigated closely related mutant constructs providing further insight into functional differences between the two (different) hairpins P1 and P2. Formation of intermolecular interactions were probed by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and NMR DOSY data. All data are consistent and show the formation of oligomeric states of the riboswitch induced by Mg2+ and ligand binding.

Cotranscriptional RNA Chemical Probing

Cotranscriptional folding is a fundamental step in RNA biogenesis and the basis for many RNA-mediated gene regulation systems. Understanding how RNA folds as it is synthesized requires experimental methods that can systematically identify intermediate RNA structures that form during transcription. Cotranscriptional RNA chemical probing experiments achieve this by applying high-throughput RNA structure probing to an in vitro transcribed array of cotranscriptionally folded intermediate transcripts. In this chapter, we present guidelines and procedures for integrating single-round in vitro transcription using E. coli RNA polymerase with high-throughput RNA chemical probing workflows. We provide an overview of key concepts including DNA template design, transcription roadblocking strategies, single-round in vitro transcription with E. coli RNA polymerase, and RNA chemical probing and describe procedures for DNA template preparation, cotranscriptional RNA chemical probing, RNA purification, and 3' adapter ligation. The end result of these procedures is a purified RNA library that can be prepared for Illumina sequencing using established high-throughput RNA structure probing library construction strategies.

Developments in solution-state NMR yield broader and deeper views of the dynamic ensembles of nucleic acids

Nucleic acids do not fold into a single conformation, and dynamic ensembles are needed to describe their propensities to cycle between different conformations when performing cellular functions. We review recent advances in solution-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods and their integration with computational techniques that are improving the ability to probe the dynamic ensembles of DNA and RNA. These include computational approaches for predicting chemical shifts from structure and generating conformational libraries from sequence, measurements of exact nuclear Overhauser effects, development of new probes to study chemical exchange using relaxation dispersion, faster and more sensitive real-time NMR techniques, and new NMR approaches to tackle large nucleic acid assemblies. We discuss how these advances are leading to new mechanistic insights into gene expression and regulation.

Conformational Ensemble of TteAdoCbl Riboswitch Provides Stable Structural Elements for Conformation Selection and Population Shift in Cobalamin Recognition

Cobalamin riboswitch is a cis-regulatory element widely found in the 5'-UTRs of the vitamin B12-associated genes in bacteria, resulting in modulation and production of a particular protein. Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis (Tte) AdoCbl riboswitches are the largest of the known riboswitches with 210 nucleotides, partially due to its long peripheral P6-extension, which enable high affinity of AdoCbl. Two structural elements, T-loop/T-looplike motif and kissing loop are key to the global folding of the RNA. While the structure of the TteAdoCbl riboswitch complex is known, we still do not understand the structure and conformation before AdoCbl ligand recognition. In order to delineate the conformational changes and the stabilities of long-range interactions, we have performed extensive all-atom replica-exchange molecular dynamics simulations of the TteAdoCbl riboswitch with a total simulation time of 2296 ns. We found that both the T-loop/T-looplike motif and kissing loop are very stable with ligand binding. The gating conformation changes of P6-extension allow the ligand to bind to the preorganized kissing loop binding pocket. The T-loop/T-looplike motif has much more hydrogen bonds than observed in TteAdoCbl riboswitch complex crystal structure, indicating an allosteric response of the T-loop/T-looplike motif. Our study demonstrated that the conformational ensemble of TteAdoCbl riboswitch provides stable structural elements for conformation selection and population shift in cobalamin recognition.

The Perturbed Free-Energy Landscape: Linking Ligand Binding to Biomolecular Folding

The effects of ligand binding on biomolecular conformation are crucial in drug design, enzyme mechanisms, the regulation of gene expression, and other biological processes. Descriptive models such as "lock and key", "induced fit", and "conformation selection" are common ways to interpret such interactions. Another historical model, linked equilibria, proposes that the free-energy landscape (FEL) is perturbed by the addition of ligand binding energy for the bound population of biomolecules. This principle leads to a unified, quantitative theory of ligand-induced conformation change, building upon the FEL concept. We call the map of binding free energy over biomolecular conformational space the "binding affinity landscape" (BAL). The perturbed FEL predicts/explains ligand-induced conformational changes conforming to all common descriptive models. We review recent experimental and computational studies that exemplify the perturbed FEL, with emphasis on RNA. This way of understanding ligand-induced conformation dynamics motivates new experimental and theoretical approaches to ligand design, structural biology and systems biology.

Real-time monitoring of single ZTP riboswitches reveals a complex and kinetically controlled decision landscape

RNAs begin to fold and function during transcription. Riboswitches undergo cotranscriptional switching in the context of transcription elongation, RNA folding, and ligand binding. To investigate how these processes jointly modulate the function of the folate stress-sensing Fusobacterium ulcerans ZTP riboswitch, we apply a single-molecule vectorial folding (VF) assay in which an engineered superhelicase Rep-X sequentially releases fluorescently labeled riboswitch RNA from a heteroduplex in a 5′-to-3′ direction, at ~60 nt s⁻¹ [comparable to the speed of bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP)]. We demonstrate that the ZTP riboswitch is kinetically controlled and that its activation is favored by slower unwinding, strategic pausing between but not before key folding elements, or a weakened transcription terminator. Real-time single-molecule monitoring captures folding riboswitches in multiple states, including an intermediate responsible for delayed terminator formation. These results show how individual nascent RNAs occupy distinct channels within the folding landscape that controls the fate of the riboswitch.

Many RNAs become functional before their synthesis completes. Here the authors employ a single-molecule vectorial folding assay mimicking RNA transcription and show that the ZTP riboswitch is kinetically controlled and activated by slower unwinding and strategic pausing.

Parallel Discovery Strategies Provide a Basis for Riboswitch Ligand Design

Riboswitches are mRNA domains that make gene-regulatory decisions upon binding their cognate ligands. Bacterial riboswitches that specifically recognize 5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide riboside 5'-monophosphate (ZMP) and 5'-triphosphate (ZTP) regulate genes involved in folate and purine metabolism. Now, we have developed synthetic ligands targeting ZTP riboswitches by replacing the sugar-phosphate moiety of ZMP with various functional groups, including simple heterocycles. Despite losing hydrogen bonds from ZMP, these analogs bind ZTP riboswitches with similar affinities as the natural ligand, and activate transcription more strongly than ZMP in vitro. The most active ligand stimulates gene expression ∼3 times more than ZMP in a live Escherichia coli reporter. Co-crystal structures of the Fusobacterium ulcerans ZTP riboswitch bound to synthetic ligands suggest stacking of their pyridine moieties on a conserved RNA nucleobase primarily determines their higher activity. Altogether, these findings guide future design of improved riboswitch activators and yield insights into how RNA-targeted ligand discovery may proceed.