Sensing complex regulatory networks by conformationally controlled hairpin ribozymes

Engineering of Small Ribozymes Acting on RNA: What is Needed to Make a New Function Work with an Existing Catalyst?

The engineering of nucleic acids has been a longstanding objective in research, with the field gaining significant attention following the discovery of ribozymes in the early 1980s. Numerous nucleic acid catalysts have been developed to catalyze a wide range of reactions, and the structures of ribozymes have been modified to allow allosteric regulation by an external cofactor. All these constructs hold considerable promise for applications in biosensors for medical and environmental diagnostics, as well as in molecular tools for regulating cellular processes. In addition to the development of nucleic acid enzymes through in vitro selection, rational design offers a robust strategy for engineering ribozymes with customized properties. The structures and mechanisms of numerous nucleic acid catalysts have been thoroughly elucidated, making structural modulation a viable approach for designing their functional properties. Rational design necessitates the consideration of several parameters, and a range of tools is available to guide sequence design. This review discusses sequence, structural, and functional design, primarily using the example of the hairpin ribozyme, to highlight the challenges and opportunities of rational nucleic acid enzyme engineering.

Ligand-dependent ribozymes

The discovery of catalytic RNA (ribozymes) more than 30 years ago significantly widened the horizon of RNA-based functions in natural systems. Similarly to the activity of protein enzymes that are often modulated by the presence of an interaction partner, some examples of naturally occurring ribozymes are influenced by ligands that can either act as cofactors or allosteric modulators. Recent discoveries of new and widespread ribozyme motifs in many different genetic contexts point toward the existence of further ligand-dependent RNA catalysts. In addition to the presence of ligand-dependent ribozymes in nature, researchers have engineered ligand dependency into natural and artificial ribozymes. Because RNA functions can often be assembled in a truly modular way, many different systems have been obtained utilizing different ligand-sensing domains and ribozyme activities in diverse applications. We summarize the occurrence of ligand-dependent ribozymes in nature and the many examples realized by researchers that engineered ligand-dependent catalytic RNA motifs. We will also highlight methods for obtaining ligand dependency as well as discuss the many interesting applications of ligand-controlled catalytic RNAs. WIREs RNA 2017, 8:e1395. doi: 10.1002/wrna.1395 For further resources related to this article, please visit the WIREs website.

MIPs and Aptamers for Recognition of Proteins in Biomimetic Sensing

Biomimetic binders and catalysts have been generated in order to substitute the biological pendants in separation techniques and bioanalysis. The two major approaches use either "evolution in the test tube" of nucleotides for the preparation of aptamers or total chemical synthesis for molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs). The reproducible production of aptamers is a clear advantage, whilst the preparation of MIPs typically leads to a population of polymers with different binding sites. The realization of binding sites in the total bulk of the MIPs results in a higher binding capacity, however, on the expense of the accessibility and exchange rate. Furthermore, the readout of the bound analyte is easier for aptamers since the integration of signal generating labels is well established. On the other hand, the overall negative charge of the nucleotides makes aptamers prone to non-specific adsorption of positively charged constituents of the sample and the "biological" degradation of non-modified aptamers and ionic strength-dependent changes of conformation may be challenging in some application.

Ribozymes that can be regulated by external stimuli

Ribozymes have been known for about 30 years, and nowadays are understood well enough to be turned into useful tools for a number of applications in vitro and in vivo. Allosteric ribozymes switch on and off their activity in response to a specific chemical (ligand) or physical (temperature, light) signal. The possibility of controlling ribozyme activity by external stimuli is of particular relevance for applications in different fields, such as environmental and medicinal diagnostics, molecular computing, control of gene expression and others. Herein, we review recent advances and describe selected examples of addressable ribozymes.

Allosteric control of a DNA-hydrolyzing deoxyribozyme with short oligonucleotides and its application in DNA logic gates

Allosteric control of deoxyribozymes is useful for a broad range of practical applications, such as nucleic acid sensing and DNA-computing. We found that the catalytic activity of a DNA-hydrolyzing deoxyribozyme could be allosterically regulated by adding short oligonucleotides. We used this technique to construct deoxyribozyme-based logic gates.

Aptamers for allosteric regulation

Aptamers are useful for allosteric regulation because they are nucleic acid-based structures in which ligand binding induces conformational changes that may alter the function of a connected oligonucleotide at a distant site. Through this approach, a specific input is efficiently converted into an altered output. This property makes these biomolecules ideally suited to function as sensors or switches in biochemical assays or inside living cells. The ability to select oligonucleotide-based recognition elements in vitro in combination with the availability of nucleic acids with enzymatic activity has led to the development of a wide range of engineered allosteric aptasensors and aptazymes. Here, we discuss recent progress in the screening, design and diversity of these conformational switching oligonucleotides. We cover their application in vitro and for regulating gene expression in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Modular reporter hairpin ribozymes for analyzing molecular interactions

Methods for the detection of biologically relevant interactions by highly precise catalytic control elements based on hairpin ribozymes, and their subsequent analysis are described. These include ribozyme design, catalytic performance in real time as a function of fluorescence signal amplification, and applications for sensing protein and nucleic acid interactions in high-throughput formats. Detailed instructions for two of our main reporter ribozyme formats that either follow repressible or inducible regulatory mechanisms are provided. We have shown that these techniques can be applied for detecting diverse target molecules including microRNAs, or protein-protein interactions. These reporter systems thus represent a general way to obtain signal-amplifying sensors for diverse applications in molecular profiling.

Synthetic RNA circuits

Natural and engineered RNA 'parts' can perform a variety of functions, including hybridizing to targets, binding ligands and undergoing programmed conformational changes, and catalyzing reactions. These RNA parts can in turn be assembled into synthetic genetic circuits that regulate gene expression by acting either in cis or in trans on mRNAs. As more parts are discovered and engineered, it should be increasingly possible to create synthetic RNA circuits that are able to carry out complex logical operations in cells, either superimposed on or autonomous to extant gene regulation.

DNA aptamer-mediated regulation of the hairpin ribozyme by human alpha-thrombin

The combination of specific ligand-binding aptamers with hairpin ribozyme catalysis generates molecules that can be controlled by external factors. Here we have generated hairpin ribozymes that can be regulated by a short DNA aptamer specific for human alpha-thrombin. This was achieved by constructing a ribozyme variant harboring an RNA sequence complementary to the aptamer, to which the aptamer can hybridize forming a heteroduplex. In this way, the DNA aptamer completely abolishes the catalytic activity of the ribozyme, due to the formation of an inactive ribozyme conformation. However, in the presence of the aptamer's target protein human alpha-thrombin, the inhibitory effect of the DNA aptamer is competitively neutralized and the ribozyme is activated in a highly specific fashion. Protein-responsive allosteric ribozymes are proposed to act as tools with potential applications in medicine where fast detection of clinically relevant targets is required.

Deoxyribozymes that recode sequence information

Allosteric nucleic acid ligases have been used previously to transform analyte-binding into the formation of oligonucleotide templates that can be amplified and detected. We have engineered binary deoxyribozyme ligases whose two components are brought together by bridging oligonucleotide effectors. The engineered ligases can 'read' one sequence and then 'write' (by ligation) a separate, distinct sequence, which can in turn be uniquely amplified. The binary deoxyribozymes show great specificity, can discriminate against a small number of mutations in the effector, and can read and recode DNA information with high fidelity even in the presence of excess obscuring genomic DNA. In addition, the binary deoxyribozymes can read non-natural nucleotides and write natural sequence information. The binary deoxyribozyme ligases could potentially be used in a variety of applications, including the detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms in genomic DNA or the identification of short nucleic acids such as microRNAs.

Competitive regulation of modular allosteric aptazymes by a small molecule and oligonucleotide effector

The hairpin ribozyme can catalyze the cleavage of RNA substrates by employing its conformational flexibility. To form a catalytic complex, the two domains A and B of the hairpin-ribozyme complex must interact with one another in a folding step called docking. We have constructed hairpin ribozyme variants harboring an aptamer sequence that can be allosterically induced by flavin mononucleotide (FMN). Domains A and B are separated by distinct bridge sequences that communicate the formation of the FMN-aptamer complex to domains A and B, facilitating their docking. In the presence of a short oligonucleotide that is complementary to the aptamer, catalytic activity of the ribozyme is completely abolished, due to the formation of an extended conformer that cannot perform catalysis. However, in the presence of the small molecule effector FMN, the inhibitory effect of the oligonucleotide is competitively neutralized and the ribozyme is activated 150-fold. We thus have established a new principle for the regulation of ribozyme catalysis in which two regulatory factors (an oligonucleotide and a small molecule) that switch the ribozyme's activity in opposite directions compete for the same binding site in the aptamer domain.

Allosterically activated Diels-Alder catalysis by a ribozyme

We describe the allosteric control of Diels-Alder reactions by a small organic effector, theophylline. This is achieved by converting a Diels-Alder ribozyme into an allosterically regulated system. In contrast to other published systems, we have a bond-forming reaction with two small-molecule substrates and multiple turnover. This system could be very attractive for the development of assays for a variety of analytes and can be regarded as a prototype of fully synthetic signaling cascades.

Natural and engineered nucleic acids as tools to explore biology

RNA and DNA molecules can form complex, three-dimensional folded structures that have surprisingly sophisticated functions, including catalysing chemical reactions and controlling gene expression. Although natural nucleic acids make occasional use of these advanced functions, the true potential for sophisticated function by these biological polymers is far greater. An important challenge for biochemists is to take RNA and DNA beyond their proven use as polymers that form double-helical structures. Molecular engineers are beginning to harness the power of nucleic acids that form more complex three-dimensional structures, and apply them as tools for exploring biological systems and as therapeutics.