International Renal Interest Society Best Practice Consensus Guidelines for Intermittent Hemodialysis in dogs and cats

Intermittent hemodialysis (IHD) is an advanced adjunctive standard of care for severe acute kidney injury (AKI) and other indications. Most animals with AKI are managed medically, however, when the disease is severe, medical management may not control the consequences of the disease, and animals with a potential for renal recovery may die from the consequences of uremia before recovery has occurred. Extracorporeal therapies aid the management of AKI by expanding the window of opportunity for recovery of sufficient kidney function to become dialysis independent. Intermittent hemodialysis (IHD) was introduced into veterinary medicine over 50 years ago, however, updated guidelines for the delivery of IHD have not been published for several decades. To that end, the International Renal Interest Society (IRIS) constituted a Working Group to establish best practice guidelines for the safe and effective delivery of IHD to animals with indications for dialytic intervention. The IRIS Working Group generated 60 consensus statements and supporting rational for a spectrum of prescription and management categories required for delivery of IHD on designated intermittent dialysis platforms (i.e., AKI, chronic hemodialysis and intoxications). A formal consensus method was used to validate the recommendations by a blinded jury of 12 veterinarians considered expert in extracorporeal therapies and actively performing IHD. Each vote provided a level of agreement for each recommendation proposed by the Working Group. To achieve a consensus, a minimum of 75% of the voting participants had to "strongly agree" or "agree" with the recommendation.

Automated adjustment of dialysate sodium by the hemodialysis monitor: Rationale, implementation, and clinical benefits

Prescribing dialysate sodium is the responsibility of the physician, but there are currently no clear guidelines for this prescription. Furthermore, there is quite frequently a significant difference between prescribed and measured dialysate sodium. Several arguments, both theoretical and experimental, suggest that dialysate sodium should be adjusted individually in such a way as to result in a decreasing sodium profile that takes into account the patient's predialytic natremia. The generalization in clinical routine of this strategy requires the integration into the hemodialysis monitor of software making the machine capable to automatically adjust the dialysate sodium at each session. The only three such softwares that have been integrated into hemodialysis machines for routine clinical use are discussed. All three work with conductivity measurements as a surrogate for sodium concentrations. Although there are only a few publications on the use of these softwares in clinical practice, they appear to result in improved intradialytic tolerance to the dialysis treatment, better control of hypertension, and reduced thirst, leading to decreased interdialytic weight gain.

Dialysate sodium management in hemodialysis and on-line hemodiafiltration: the single-pool kinetic model revisited

BACKGROUND

Determining the optimal dialysate sodium remains one of the challenges of hemodialysis prescription. Several arguments suggest that the dialysate sodium should be individually adjusted according to the patient's natremia. This strategy is greatly facilitated by using an algorithm. Only three such algorithms have been embedded in hemodialysis machines for the widespread generalization of this strategy in clinical routine: the Diacontrol (Hospal-Baxter Healthcare Corp., Deerfield, IL, USA), the HFR-Aequilibrium (Bellco-Medtronic, Dublin, Ireland) and the Na-control (Fresenius Medical Care, Bad-Homburg, Germany).

METHODS

Model the solute mass-transfer across the dialyzer membrane in online hemodiafiltration and adapt the Diacontrol algorithm based on a single-pool kinetic model of sodium balance for quantifying ionic balance and managing tonicity.

RESULTS

1) Substituting sodium measurements with conductivity measurements allows the control of tonicity which is a more physiological parameter than natremia. 2) Consideration of all ion exchanges as a whole and not just sodium exchange avoids some of the assumptions required by kinetic modeling of sodium balance. 3) Equations provided by the model are applicable to both hemodialysis and online hemodiafiltration. 4) The differences between this model used by Diacontrol and the models on which the other two software's (HFR-Aequilibrium and Na-control) are based are highlighted.

CONCLUSIONS

The single-pool kinetic model validated for the management of natremia in hemodialysis is also valid for the management of tonicity for both conventional hemodialysis and all online hemodiafiltration procedures.

Using a Human Circulation Mathematical Model to Simulate the Effects of Hemodialysis and Therapeutic Hypothermia

Background: We developed a hemodynamic mathematical model of human circulation coupled to a virtual hemodialyzer. The model was used to explore mechanisms underlying our clinical observations involving hemodialysis. Methods: The model consists of whole body human circulation, baroreflex feedback control, and a hemodialyzer. Four model populations encompassing baseline, dialysed, therapeutic hypothermia treated, and simultaneous dialysed with hypothermia were generated. In all populations atrial fibrillation and renal failure as co-morbidities, and exercise as a treatment were simulated. Clinically relevant measurables were used to quantify the effects of each in silico experiment. Sensitivity analysis was used to uncover the most relevant parameters. Results: Relative to baseline, the modelled dialysis increased the population mean diastolic blood pressure by 5%, large vessel wall shear stress by 6%, and heart rate by 20%. Therapeutic hypothermia increased systolic blood pressure by 3%, reduced large vessel shear stress by 15%, and did not affect heart rate. Therapeutic hypothermia reduced wall shear stress by 15% in the aorta and 6% in the kidneys, suggesting a potential anti-inflammatory benefit. Therapeutic hypothermia reduced cardiac output under atrial fibrillation by 12% and under renal failure by 20%. Therapeutic hypothermia and exercise did not affect dialyser function, but increased water removal by approximately 40%. Conclusions: This study illuminates some mechanisms of the action of therapeutic hypothermia. It also suggests clinical measurables that may be used as surrogates to diagnose underlying diseases such as atrial fibrillation.

Mathematical Modeling of Solute Kinetics and Body Fluid Changes during Profiled Hemodialysis

A mathematical model of solute kinetics oriented to improve hemodialysis treatment is presented. It includes a two-compartment description of the main solutes (K+, Na+, Cl–, urea, HCO–3, H+, CO2), acid-base equilibrium through two buffer systems (bicarbonate and non-carbonic buffers) and a three-compartment model of body fluids (plasma, interstitial and intracellular). The main model parameters can be individually assigned a priori, on the basis of body weight and plasma concentration values measured before beginning the session.

Model predictions are compared with clinical data obtained during 11 different hemodialysis sessions performed on six patients with profiled sodium concentration in the dialysate and profiled ultrafiltration rate. In all cases, the agreement between the time pattern of model solute concentrations in plasma and clinical data turns out fairly good as to urea, sodium, chloride and potassium kinetics. Finally, the time patterns of plasma bicarbonate concentration and pH can be reproduced fairly well with the model, provided CO2 concentration remains constant. Only in two sessions, blood volume was directly measured in the patient, and in both cases the agreement with model predictions was good.

In conclusion, the model allows a priori computation of the amount of sodium removed during hemodialysis, and may enable the prediction of plasma volume changes and plasma osmolarity changes induced by a given sodium concentration profile in the dialysate and by a given ultrafiltration profile. Hence, it can be used to improve the dialysis session taking the characteristics of individual patients into account, in order to minimize intradialytic imbalances (such as hypotension or disequilibrium syndrome).

Evidence of Profiled Hemodialysis Efficacy in the Treatment of Intradialytic Hypotension

In the last 10 years the percentage of dialysis patients suffering from clinical intradialytic intolerance has greatly increased.

Profiled hemodialysis (PHD) is a new technical approach, alternative to standard hemodialysis (SHD) for the treatment of intradialytic symptomatic hypotension. It is based on intradialytic modulation of the dialysate sodium concentration, using a dialysate sodium concentration profile elaborated by a new mathematical kinetic model.

The aim of PHD is to reduce the intradialytic blood volume decrease, thanks to a dialysate sodium profile, which allows a reduction in the plasma osmolarity decrease, thereby boosting intravascular fluid refilling.

This work aims at clinically validating the PHD technique, by testing its ability, against SHD, to maintain a more stable intradialytic blood volume; this evaluation was supported by monitoring some hemodynamic parameters.

Twelve dialysis patients on SHD treatment were selected because of their intradialytic symptomatic hypotension. Twelve SHD (one per patient) and 12 PHD sessions (one per patient) were performed to achieve the same sodium mass removal and body weight decrease on both PHD and SHD. During these sessions we monitored the blood volume variation % by the critline (a non invasive blood volume monitoring device), the mean blood pressure and heart rate directly and, finally, the stroke volume and cardiac output indirectly by bidimensional doppler-echocardiography.

Comparison of the results obtained with the two techniques shows PHD to achieve a significantly more stable blood volume, blood pressure and cardiovascular function than SHD, in particular during the second and the third hour of the dialysis session.

Clinical Application of Sodium Profiling in the Treatment of Intradialytic Hypotension

Background

Intradialytic hypotension is mainly induced by the removal of extracellular sodium during dialysis, which impairs intravascular fluid refilling and reduces blood volume. To counter this complication we tested a new kind of profiled hemodialysis (PHD) consisting of the intradialytic modulation of dialysate sodium concentration according to individual profiles set up using a new mathematical model for intradialytic solutes and water kinetics. The clinical aim of this PHD is to stabilize blood pressure maintaining higher blood volume values than standard dialysis treatments. We clinically validated PHD in comparison with constant dialysate sodium dialysis (CHD).

Methods

Twenty hypotensive dialysis patients underwent one PHD and one CHD session maintaining the same dialysis length, sodium mass removal and body weight decrease. A new mathematical model was used to define both the dialysate sodium profiles for PHD and the constant dialysate sodium for CHD. Percent blood volume variation (Crit-line), mean blood pressure, heart rate, cardiac output (Doppler-echocardiography) were monitored intradialitically.

Results

Cardiovascular stability improved on PHD as compared with CHD sessions; blood volume and cardiac output during PHD showed a lower decrease than on CHD, the differences statistically significant (from 30' and 60' respectively). Mean blood pressure was, at all time intervals, more stable on PHD than on CHD and was accompanied, on PHD, by a lower heart rate increase (differences statistically significant).

Conclusions

This study shows that PHD performed using dialysate sodium profiles elaborated by our mathematical model obtains, in hypotensive patients, a higher hemodynamic intradialytic stability than CHD, probably due to a higher stabilization of blood volume.

Blood pressure and heart rate variability in patients on conventional or sodium-profiling hemodialysis

BACKGROUND

Autonomic nervous system dysfunction and dialysate sodium (Na) concentration are believed to play a role in the pathogenesis of hemodialysis-related hypertension. The present study was undertaken to determine whether increases in blood pressure in hemodialysis patients are associated with changes in heart rate variability (HRV), a measure of the autonomic nervous system function, and long-term exposure to increased dialysate Na concentration.

METHODS

Baseline clinical, biochemical data and HRV of patients undergoing increased Na profiling dialysis (High-Na, n = 9) and on conventional treatment (Control, n = 11) were compared with those obtained after one year of study.

RESULTS

After one year, the mean predialysis systolic blood pressure (SBP) increased in seven patients of the High-Na and in five of the Control group, and decreased or remained unchanged in the remaining subjects. Initial HRV was significantly higher in patients with increased SBP, and it increased further in these patients after one year. At the end of the study, post-dialysis plasma Na, osmolality, and weight gains were significantly higher in the High-Na group. No significant correlation, however, was found between individual changes in intradialytic sodium elimination and the alterations in blood pressure.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that the dialysate sodium concentration, a most important determinant of interdialytic weight gain and fluid balance, is only partly correlated with long-term changes in blood pressure. An increased blood pressure over time may develop in a subset of hemodialysis patients with higher HRV, suggestive of increased sympathetic activity.