PTOX-dependent safety valve does not oxidize P700 during photosynthetic induction in the Arabidopsis pgr5 mutant

Antimycin A induces light hypersensitivity of PSII in the presence of quinone QB-site binding herbicides

Photosynthetic electron transport consists of linear electron flow and 2 cyclic electron flow (CEF) pathways around PSI (CEF-PSI). PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION 5 (PGR5)-dependent CEF-PSI is thought to be the major CEF-PSI pathway and an important regulator of photosynthetic electron transfer. Antimycin A (AA) is commonly recognized as an inhibitor of PGR5-dependent CEF-PSI in photosynthesis. Although previous findings imply that AA may also affect PSII, which does not participate in CEF-PSI, these "secondary effects" tend to be neglected, and AA is often used for inhibition of PGR5-dependent CEF-PSI as if it were a specific inhibitor. Here, we investigated the direct effects of AA on PSII using isolated spinach (Spinacia oleracea) PSII membranes and thylakoid membranes isolated from spinach, Arabidopsis thaliana (wild-type Columbia-0 and PGR5-deficient mutant pgr5hope1), and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Measurements of quinone QA- reoxidation kinetics showed that AA directly affects the acceptor side of PSII and inhibits electron transport within PSII. Furthermore, repetitive Fv/Fm measurements revealed that, in the presence of quinone QB-site binding inhibitors, AA treatment results in severe photodamage even from a single-turnover flash. The direct effects of AA on PSII are nonnegligible, and caution is required when using AA as an inhibitor of PGR5-dependent CEF-PSI. Meanwhile, we found that the commercially available compound AA3, which is a component of the AA complex, inhibits PGR5-dependent CEF-PSI without having notable effects on PSII. Thus, we propose that AA3 should be used instead of AA for physiological studies of the PGR5-dependent CEF-PSI.

Photosynthetic control at the cytochrome b6f complex

Photosynthetic control (PCON) is a protective mechanism that prevents light-induced damage to PSI by ensuring the rate of NADPH and ATP production via linear electron transfer (LET) is balanced by their consumption in the CO2 fixation reactions. Protection of PSI is a priority for plants since they lack a dedicated rapid-repair cycle for this complex, meaning that any damage leads to prolonged photoinhibition and decreased growth. The imbalance between LET and the CO2 fixation reactions is sensed at the level of the transthylakoid ΔpH, which increases when light is in excess. The canonical mechanism of PCON involves feedback control by ΔpH on the plastoquinol oxidation step of LET at cytochrome b6f. PCON thereby maintains the PSI special pair chlorophylls (P700) in an oxidized state, which allows excess electrons unused in the CO2 fixation reactions to be safely quenched via charge recombination. In this review we focus on angiosperms, consider how photo-oxidative damage to PSI comes about, explore the consequences of PSI photoinhibition on photosynthesis and growth, discuss recent progress in understanding PCON regulation, and finally consider the prospects for its future manipulation in crop plants to improve photosynthetic efficiency.

Cyclic electron flow and Photosystem II-less photosynthesis

Oxygenic photosynthesis is characterised by the cooperation of two photo-driven complexes, Photosystem II (PSII) and Photosystem I (PSI), sequentially linked through a series of redox-coupled intermediates. Divergent evolution has resulted in photosystems exhibiting complementary redox potentials, spanning the range necessary to oxidise water and reduce CO2 within a single system. Catalysing nature's most oxidising reaction to extract electrons from water is a highly specialised task that limits PSII's metabolic function. In contrast, potential electron donors in PSI span a range of redox potentials, enabling it to accept electrons from various metabolic processes. This metabolic flexibility of PSI underpins the capacity of photosynthetic organisms to balance energy supply with metabolic demands, which is key for adaptation to environmental changes. Here, we review the phenomenon of 'PSII-less photosynthesis' where PSI functions independently of PSII by operating cyclic electron flow using electrons derived from non-photochemical reactions. PSII-less photosynthesis enables supercharged ATP production and is employed, for example, by cyanobacteria's heterocysts to host nitrogen fixation and by bundle sheath cells of C4 plants to boost CO2 assimilation. We discuss the energetic benefits of this arrangement and the prospects of utilising it to improve the productivity and stress resilience of photosynthetic organisms.

Differential FeS cluster photodamage plays a critical role in regulating excess electron flow through photosystem I

The photosynthetic electron flux from photosystem I (PSI) is mainly directed to NADP+ and CO2 fixation, but a fraction is always shared between alternative and cyclic electron transport. Although the electron transfer from P700 to ferredoxin, via phylloquinone and the FeSX, FeSB and FeSA clusters, is well characterized, the regulatory role of these redox intermediates in the delivery of electrons from PSI to NADP+, alternative and cyclic electron transport under environmental stress remains elusive. Here we provide evidence for sequential damage to PSI FeS clusters under high light and subsequent slow recovery under low light in Arabidopsis thaliana. Wild-type plants showed 10-35% photodamage to their FeSA/B clusters with increasing high-light duration, without much effect on P700 oxidation capacity, FeSX function or CO2 fixation rate, and without additional oxygen consumption (O2 photoreduction). Parallel FeSA/B cluster damage in the pgr5 mutant was more pronounced at 50-85%, probably due to weak photosynthetic control and low non-photochemical quenching. Such severe electron pressure on PSI was also shown to damage the FeSX clusters, with a concomitant decrease in P700 oxidation capacity and a decrease in thylakoid-bound ferredoxin in the pgr5 mutant. The results from wild-type and pgr5 plants reveal controlled damage of PSI FeS clusters under high light. In wild-type plants, this favours electron transport to linear over alternative pathways by intact PSI centres, thereby preventing reactive oxygen species production and probably promoting harmless charge recombination between P700+ and FeSX- as long as the majority of FeSA/B clusters remain functional.

Regulation of Microalgal Photosynthetic Electron Transfer

The global ecosystem relies on the metabolism of photosynthetic organisms, featuring the ability to harness light as an energy source. The most successful type of photosynthesis utilizes a virtually inexhaustible electron pool from water, but the driver of this oxidation, sunlight, varies on time and intensity scales of several orders of magnitude. Such rapid and steep changes in energy availability are potentially devastating for biological systems. To enable a safe and efficient light-harnessing process, photosynthetic organisms tune their light capturing, the redox connections between core complexes and auxiliary electron mediators, ion passages across the membrane, and functional coupling of energy transducing organelles. Here, microalgal species are the most diverse group, featuring both unique environmental adjustment strategies and ubiquitous protective mechanisms. In this review, we explore a selection of regulatory processes of the microalgal photosynthetic apparatus supporting smooth electron flow in variable environments.

Coordinated responses of rice (Oryza sativa) to the stresses of benzotriazole ultraviolet stabilizers (BZT-UVs): Antioxidative system, photosynthetic activity, and metabolic regulation

Massive use of plastic products has caused their accumulation in soils, releasing large amounts of endogenous plastic additives (e.g., benzotriazole ultraviolet stabilizers, in short BZT-UVs) into terrestrial ecosystems. However, their plant toxicity is little known. Herein, we investigated the occurrence of BZT-UVs in contaminated farmland and selected three BZT-UV congeners to explore their toxic effects on the antioxidant, photosynthetic, and metabolic perturbation on rice (Oryza sativa). Results showed that the mean concentrations of ∑BZT-UVs in soil and plant samples were 180.7 ng/g dw and 156.4 ng/g dw, respectively. UV-P, UV-327 and UV-328 were the dominant BZT-UV congeners in both of soils and plants. Three BZT-UV congeners caused oxidative damages to rice in a dose-dependent manner, especially for UV-328. Functional genes involved in chlorophyll synthetases was inhibited by over 50 % under the stress of BZT-UVs, whereas those responsible for chlorophyll degradation were obviously promoted. The chlorophyll content was thus decreased, leading to a weakened photosynthesis system and an unbalanced carbon metabolism. The transcriptome and metabolome proved that the flux of carbohydrate metabolism and amino acid metabolism were obviously promoted in plants induced by BZT-UVs, which could inhibit the growth of rice. These findings offered insights into the coordinated responses of plants and advanced our understanding of potential ecological risks of BZT-UVs to terrestrial ecosystems.

Central transcriptional regulator controls photosynthetic growth and carbon storage in response to high light

Carbon capture and biochemical storage are some of the primary drivers of photosynthetic yield and productivity. To elucidate the mechanisms governing carbon allocation, we designed a photosynthetic light response test system for genetic and metabolic carbon assimilation tracking, using microalgae as simplified plant models. The systems biology mapping of high light-responsive photophysiology and carbon utilization dynamics between two variants of the same Picochlorum celeri species, TG1 and TG2 elucidated metabolic bottlenecks and transport rates of intermediates using instationary 13C-fluxomics. Simultaneous global gene expression dynamics showed 73% of the annotated genes responding within one hour, elucidating a singular, diel-responsive transcription factor, closely related to the CCA1/LHY clock genes in plants, with significantly altered expression in TG2. Transgenic P. celeri TG1 cells expressing the TG2 CCA1/LHY gene, showed 15% increase in growth rates and 25% increase in storage carbohydrate content, supporting a coordinating regulatory function for a single transcription factor.

Critical role of cyclic electron transport around photosystem I in the maintenance of photosystem I activity

In angiosperms, cyclic electron transport around photosystem I (PSI) is mediated by two pathways that depend on the PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION 5 (PGR5) protein and the chloroplast NADH dehydrogenase-like (NDH) complex, respectively. In the Arabidopsis double mutants defective in both pathways, plant growth and photosynthesis are impaired. The pgr5-1 mutant used in the original study is a missense allele and accumulates low levels of PGR5 protein. In this study, we generated two knockout (KO) alleles, designated as pgr5-5 and pgr5-6, using the CRISPR-Cas9 technology. Although both KO alleles showed a severe reduction in P700 similar to the pgr5-1 allele, NPQ induction was less severely impaired in the KO alleles than in the pgr5-1 allele. In the pgr5-1 allele, the second mutation affecting NPQ size was mapped to ~21 cM south of the pgr5-1 locus. Overexpression of the pgr5-1 allele, encoding the glycine130-to-serine change, complemented the pgr5-5 phenotype, suggesting that the pgr5-1 mutation destabilizes PGR5 but that the mutant protein retains partial functionality. Using two KO alleles, we created the double mutants with two chlororespiratory reduction (crr) mutants defective in the NDH complex. The growth of the double mutants was notably impaired. In the double mutant seedlings that survived on the medium containing sucrose, PSI activity evaluated by the P700 oxidation was severely impaired, whereas PSII activity was only mildly impaired. Cyclic electron transport around PSI is required to maintain PSI activity.

Molecular Genetic Dissection of the Regulatory Network of Proton Motive Force in Chloroplasts

The proton motive force (pmf) generated across the thylakoid membrane rotates the Fo-ring of ATP synthase in chloroplasts. The pmf comprises two components: membrane potential (∆Ψ) and proton concentration gradient (∆pH). Acidification of the thylakoid lumen resulting from ∆pH downregulates electron transport in the cytochrome b6f complex. This process, known as photosynthetic control, is crucial for protecting photosystem I (PSI) from photodamage in response to fluctuating light. To optimize the balance between efficient photosynthesis and photoprotection, it is necessary to regulate pmf. Cyclic electron transport around PSI and pseudo-cyclic electron transport involving flavodiiron proteins contribute to the modulation of pmf magnitude. By manipulating the ratio between the two components of pmf, it is possible to modify the extent of photosynthetic control without affecting the pmf size. This adjustment can be achieved by regulating the movement of ions (such as K+ and Cl-) across the thylakoid membrane. Since ATP synthase is the primary consumer of pmf in chloroplasts, its activity must be precisely regulated to accommodate other mechanisms involved in pmf optimization. Although fragments of information about each regulatory process have been accumulated, a comprehensive understanding of their interactions is lacking. Here, I summarize current knowledge of the network for pmf regulation, mainly based on genetic studies.

Research on photosynthetic oscillations supports the classical concept of cyclic electron transport producing ATP

This article comments on:

Degen GE, Pastorelli F, Johnson MP. 2024. Proton Gradient Regulation 5 is required to avoid photosynthetic oscillations during light transitions. Journal of Experimental Botany 75, 947–961.

PGR5-LIKE PHOTOSYNTHETIC PHENOTYPE1A redox states alleviate photoinhibition during changes in light intensity

Plants have evolved photosynthetic regulatory mechanisms to maintain homeostasis in response to light changes during diurnal transitions and those caused by passing clouds or by wind. One such adaptation directs photosynthetic electron flow to a cyclic pathway to alleviate excess energy surges. Here, we assign a function to regulatory cysteines of PGR5-like protein 1A (PGRL1A), a constituent of the PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION5 (PGR5)-dependent cyclic electron flow (CEF) pathway. During step increases from darkness to low light intensity in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), the intermolecular disulfide of the PGRL1A 59-kDa complex was reduced transiently within seconds to the 28-kDa form. In contrast, step increases from darkness to high light stimulated a stable, partially reduced redox state in PGRL1A. Mutations of 2 cysteines in PGRL1A, Cys82 and Cys183, resulted in a constitutively pseudo-reduced state. The mutant displayed higher proton motive force (PMF) and nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) than the wild type (WT) and showed altered donor and acceptor dynamic flow around PSI. These changes were found to correspond with the redox state of PGRL1A. Continuous light regimes did not affect mutant growth compared to the WT. However, under fluctuating regimes of high light, the mutant showed better growth than the WT. In contrast, in fluctuating regimes of low light, the mutant displayed a growth penalty that can be attributed to constant stimulation of CEF under low light. Treatment with photosynthetic inhibitors indicated that PGRL1A redox state control depends on the penultimate Fd redox state. Our results showed that redox state changes in PGRL1A are crucial to optimize photosynthesis.

Restricting electron flow at cytochrome b6f when downstream electron acceptors are severely limited

Photosynthetic organisms frequently experience abiotic stress that restricts their growth and development. Under such circumstances, most absorbed solar energy cannot be used for CO2 fixation and can cause the photoproduction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) that can damage the photosynthetic reaction centers of PSI and PSII, resulting in a decline in primary productivity. This work describes a biological "switch" in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii that reversibly restricts photosynthetic electron transport (PET) at the cytochrome b6f (Cyt b6f) complex when the capacity for accepting electrons downstream of PSI is severely limited. We specifically show this restriction in STARCHLESS6 (sta6) mutant cells, which cannot synthesize starch when they are limited for nitrogen (growth inhibition) and subjected to a dark-to-light transition. This restriction represents a form of photosynthetic control that causes diminished electron flow to PSI and thereby prevents PSI photodamage but does not appear to rely on a ΔpH. Furthermore, when electron flow is restricted, the plastid alternative oxidase (PTOX) becomes active, functioning as an electron valve that dissipates some excitation energy absorbed by PSII and allows the formation of a proton motive force (PMF) that would drive some ATP production (potentially sustaining PSII repair and nonphotochemical quenching [NPQ]). The restriction at the Cyt b6f complex can be gradually relieved with continued illumination. This study provides insights into how PET responds to a marked reduction in availability of downstream electron acceptors and the protective mechanisms involved.

High cyclic electron transfer via the PGR5 pathway in the absence of photosynthetic control

The light reactions of photosynthesis couple electron and proton transfers across the thylakoid membrane, generating NADPH, and proton motive force (pmf) that powers the endergonic synthesis of ATP by ATP synthase. ATP and NADPH are required for CO2 fixation into carbohydrates by the Calvin-Benson-Bassham cycle. The dominant ΔpH component of the pmf also plays a photoprotective role in regulating photosystem II light harvesting efficiency through nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) and photosynthetic control via electron transfer from cytochrome b6f (cytb6f) to photosystem I. ΔpH can be adjusted by increasing the proton influx into the thylakoid lumen via upregulation of cyclic electron transfer (CET) or decreasing proton efflux via downregulation of ATP synthase conductivity (gH+). The interplay and relative contributions of these two elements of ΔpH control to photoprotection are not well understood. Here, we showed that an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) ATP synthase mutant hunger for oxygen in photosynthetic transfer reaction 2 (hope2) with 40% higher proton efflux has supercharged CET. Double crosses of hope2 with the CET-deficient proton gradient regulation 5 and ndh-like photosynthetic complex I lines revealed that PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION 5 (PGR5)-dependent CET is the major pathway contributing to higher proton influx. PGR5-dependent CET allowed hope2 to maintain wild-type levels of ΔpH, CO2 fixation and NPQ, however photosynthetic control remained absent and PSI was prone to photoinhibition. Therefore, high CET in the absence of ATP synthase regulation is insufficient for PSI photoprotection.

Distinct contribution of two cyclic electron transport pathways to P700 oxidation

Cyclic electron transport (CET) around Photosystem I (PSI) acidifies the thylakoid lumen and downregulates electron transport at the cytochrome b6f complex. This photosynthetic control is essential for oxidizing special pair chlorophylls (P700) of PSI for PSI photoprotection. In addition, CET depending on the PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION 5 (PGR5) protein oxidizes P700 by moving a pool of electrons from the acceptor side of PSI to the plastoquinone pool. This model of the acceptor-side regulation was proposed on the basis of the phenotype of the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) pgr5-1 mutant expressing Chlamydomonas (Chlamydomonas reinhardtii) plastid terminal oxidase (CrPTOX2). In this study, we extended the research including the Arabidopsis chlororespiratory reduction 2-2 (crr2-2) mutant defective in another CET pathway depending on the chloroplast NADH dehydrogenase-like (NDH) complex. Although the introduction of CrPTOX2 did not complement the defect in the acceptor-side regulation by PGR5, the function of the NDH complex was complemented except for its reverse reaction during the induction of photosynthesis. We evaluated the impact of CrPTOX2 under fluctuating light intensity in the wild-type, pgr5-1 and crr2-2 backgrounds. In the high-light period, both PGR5- and NDH-dependent CET were involved in the induction of photosynthetic control, whereas PGR5-dependent CET preferentially contributed to the acceptor-side regulation. On the contrary, the NDH complex probably contributed to the acceptor-side regulation in the low-light period but not in the high-light period. We evaluated the sensitivity of PSI to fluctuating light and clarified that acceptor-side regulation was necessary for PSI photoprotection by oxidizing P700 under high light.

The ability of P700 oxidation in photosystem I reflects chilling stress tolerance in cucumber

Low temperature inhibits photosynthesis and negatively affects plant growth. Cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) is a chilling-sensitive plant, and its greenhouse production requires considerable energy during the winter. Therefore, a useful stress marker for selecting chilling-tolerant cucumber cultivars is desirable. In this study, we evaluated chilling-stress damage in different cucumber cultivars by measuring photosynthetic parameters. The majority of cultivars showed decreases in the quantum yield of photosystem (PS) II [Fv/Fm and Y(II)] and the quantity of active PS I (Pm) after chilling stress. In contrast, Y(ND)-the ratio of the oxidized state of PSI reaction center chlorophyll P700 (P700⁺)-differed among cultivars and was perfectly inversely correlated with Y(NA)-the ratio of the non-photooxidizable P700. It has been known that P700⁺ accumulates under stress conditions and protects plants to suppress the generation of reactive oxygen species. In fact, cultivars unable to induce Y(ND) after chilling stress showed growth retardation with reductions in chlorophyll content and leaf area. Therefore, Y(ND) can be a useful marker to evaluate chilling-stress tolerance in cucumber.

NaCl Pretreatment Enhances the Low Temperature Tolerance of Tomato Through Photosynthetic Acclimation

Plants often need to withstand multiple types of environmental stresses (e.g., salt and low temperature stress) because of their sessile nature. Although the physiological responses of plants to single stressor have been well-characterized, few studies have evaluated the extent to which pretreatment with non-lethal stressors can maintain the photosynthetic performance of plants in adverse environments (i.e., acclimation-induced cross-tolerance). Here, we studied the effects of sodium chloride (NaCl) pretreatment on the photosynthetic performance of tomato plants exposed to low temperature stress by measuring photosynthetic and chlorophyll fluorescence parameters, stomatal aperture, chloroplast quality, and the expression of stress signaling pathway-related genes. NaCl pretreatment significantly reduced the carbon dioxide assimilation rate, transpiration rate, and stomatal aperture of tomato leaves, but these physiological acclimations could mitigate the adverse effects of subsequent low temperatures compared with non-pretreated tomato plants. The content of photosynthetic pigments decreased and the ultra-microstructure of chloroplasts was damaged under low temperature stress, and the magnitude of these adverse effects was alleviated by NaCl pretreatment. The quantum yield of photosystem I (PSI) and photosystem II (PSII), the quantum yield of regulatory energy dissipation, and non-photochemical energy dissipation owing to donor-side limitation decreased following NaCl treatment; however, the opposite patterns were observed when NaCl-pretreated plants were exposed to low temperature stress. Similar results were obtained for the electron transfer rate of PSI, the electron transfer rate of PSII, and the estimated cyclic electron flow value (CEF). The production of reactive oxygen species induced by low temperature stress was also significantly alleviated by NaCl pretreatment. The expression of ion channel and tubulin-related genes affecting stomatal aperture, chlorophyll synthesis genes, antioxidant enzyme-related genes, and abscisic acid (ABA) and low temperature signaling-related genes was up-regulated in NaCl-pretreated plants under low temperature stress. Our findings indicated that CEF-mediated photoprotection, stomatal movement, the maintenance of chloroplast quality, and ABA and low temperature signaling pathways all play key roles in maintaining the photosynthetic capacity of NaCl-treated tomato plants under low temperature stress.