VISIBILITY OF STRUCTURES OF RELEVANCE FOR PATIENTS WITH CYSTIC FIBROSIS IN CHEST TOMOSYNTHESIS: INFLUENCE OF ANATOMICAL LOCATION AND OBSERVER EXPERIENCE

EVALUATION OF TWO CHEST TOMOSYNTHESIS CYSTIC FIBROSIS SCORING SYSTEMS USING HIGH-RESOLUTION COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY BRODY SCORING AS REFERENCE

PURPOSE

To evaluate two chest tomosynthesis (CTS) scoring systems for cystic fibrosis (CF), one system developed by Vult von Steyern et al. (VvS) and one system based on the Brody scoring system for high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) (modified Brody (mB)). Brody scoring of HRCT was used as reference.

METHODS

In conjunction with routine control HRCT at clinical follow-up, 10 consecutive adult CF patients underwent CTS for research purposes. Four radiologists scored the CTS examinations using the mB and VvS scoring systems. All scores were compared to the Brody HRCT scores. The agreement between the evaluated CTS scoring systems and the reference HRCT scoring system was determined using Spearman's rank correlation coefficient and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

MAJOR FINDINGS

Spearman's rank correlation coefficient showed strong correlations between HRCT score and both the mB and the VvS CTS total scores (median rs = 0.81 and 0.85, respectively). The ICC showed strong correlation between the CTS scoring systems and the reference: 0.88 for mB and 0.85 for VvS scoring. The median time for scoring was 20 and 10 minutes for the mB and VvS scoring systems, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Both evaluated CTS scoring systems correlate well with the reference standard Brody HRCT scoring. The VvS CTS scoring system has a shorter reading time, suggesting its advantage in clinical practice.

QUANTIFICATION OF PULMONARY PATHOLOGY IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS-COMPARISON BETWEEN DIGITAL CHEST TOMOSYNTHESIS AND COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY

PURPOSE

Digital tomosynthesis (DTS) is currently undergoing validation for potential clinical implications. The aim of this study was to investigate the potential for DTS as a low-dose alternative to computed tomography (CT) in imaging of pulmonary pathology in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF).

METHODS

DTS and CT were performed as part of the routine triannual follow-up in 31 CF patients. Extent of disease was quantified according to modality-specific scoring systems. Statistical analysis included Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (r) and Krippendorff's alpha (α).

MAJOR FINDINGS

The median effective dose was 0.14 for DTS and 2.68 for CT. Intermodality correlation was very strong for total score and the subscores regarding bronchiectasis and bronchial wall-thickening (r = 0.82-0.91, P < 0.01). Interobserver reliability was high for total score, bronchiectasis and mucus plugging (α = 0.83-0.93) in DTS.

CONCLUSION

Chest tomosynthesis could be a low-dose alternative to CT in quantitative estimation of structural lung disease in CF.

The Effect of Dose Reduction on Overall Image Quality in Clinical Chest Tomosynthesis

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the effect of reduction in effective dose on the reproduction of anatomical structures in chest tomosynthesis (CTS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-four CTS examinations acquired at exposure settings resulting in an effective dose of 0.12 mSv for an average sized patient were included in the study. The examinations underwent simulated dose reduction to dose levels corresponding to 32%, 50%, and 70% of the original dose using a previously described and validated method. The image quality was evaluated by five thoracic radiologists who rated the fulfillment of specified image quality criteria in a visual grading study. The ratings for each image quality criterion in the dose-reduced images were compared to the corresponding ratings for the full-dose examinations using visual grading characteristics (VGC) analysis. The area under the resulting VGC curve (AUC_VGC) provides a measure of the difference between the ratings, where an AUC_VGC of 0.5 indicates no difference.

RESULTS

The dose reductions resulted in inferior reproduction of structures compared to the original dose level (AUC_VGC <0.5). Structures in the central region of the lung obtained the lowest AUC_VGC for each dose level whereas the reproduction of structures in the parenchyma was least affected by the dose reduction.

CONCLUSION

Although previous studies have shown that dose reduction in CTS is possible without affecting the performance of certain clinical tasks, the reproduction of normal anatomical structures is significantly degraded even at small reductions. It is therefore important to consider the clinical purpose of the CTS examinations before deciding on a permanent dose reduction.

Novel imaging techniques for cystic fibrosis lung disease

With an increasing number of patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) receiving highly effective CFTR (cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator protein) modulator therapy, particularly at a young age, there is an increasing need to identify imaging tools that can detect and regionally visualize mild CF lung disease and subtle changes in disease state. In this review, we discuss the latest developments in imaging modalities for both structural and functional imaging of the lung available to CF clinicians and researchers, from the widely available, clinically utilized imaging methods for assessing CF lung disease-chest radiography and computed tomography-to newer techniques poised to become the next phase of clinical tools-structural/functional proton and hyperpolarized gas magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Finally, we provide a brief discussion of several newer lung imaging techniques that are currently available only in selected research settings, including chest tomosynthesis, and fluorinated gas MRI. We provide an update on the clinical and/or research status of each technique, with a focus on sensitivity, early disease detection, and possibilities for monitoring treatment efficacy.

Detection of Pulmonary Nodule Growth with Chest Tomosynthesis: A Human Observer Study Using Simulated Nodules

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Chest tomosynthesis has been suggested as a suitable alternative to CT for follow-up of pulmonary nodules. The aim of the present study was to investigate the possibility of detecting pulmonary nodule growth using chest tomosynthesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Simulated nodules with volumes of approximately 100 mm³ and 300 mm³ as well as additional versions with increasing volumes were created. The nodules were inserted into images from pairs of chest tomosynthesis examinations, simulating cases where the nodule had either remained stable in size or increased in size between the two imaging occasions. Nodule volume growths ranging from 11% to 252% were included. A simulated dose reduction was applied to a subset of the cases. Cases differing in terms of nodule size, dose level, and nodule position relative to the plane of image reconstruction were included. Observers rated their confidence that the nodules were stable in size or not. The rating data for the nodules that were stable in size was compared to the rating data for the nodules simulated to have increased in size using ROC analysis.

RESULTS

Area under the curve values ranging from 0.65 to 1 were found. The lowest area under the curve values were found when there was a mismatch in nodule position relative to the reconstructed image plane between the two examinations. Nodule size and dose level affected the results.

CONCLUSION

The study indicates that chest tomosynthesis can be used to detect pulmonary nodule growth. Nodule size, dose level, and mismatch in position relative to the image reconstruction plane in the baseline and follow-up examination may affect the precision.

Dependency of image quality on acquisition protocol and image processing in chest tomosynthesis-a visual grading study based on clinical data

OBJECTIVE

To compare the quality of images obtained with two different protocols with different acquisition time and the influence from image post processing in a chest digital tomosynthesis (DTS) system.

METHODS

20 patients with suspected lung cancer were imaged with a chest X-ray equipment with tomosynthesis option. Two examination protocols with different acquisition times (6.3 and 12 s) were performed on each patient. Both protocols were presented with two different image post-processing (standard DTS processing and more advanced processing optimised for chest radiography). Thus, 4 series from each patient, altogether 80 series, were presented anonymously and in a random order. Five observers rated the quality of the reconstructed section images according to predefined quality criteria in three different classes. Visual grading characteristics (VGC) was used to analyse the data and the area under the VGC curve (AUC_VGC) was used as figure-of-merit. The 12 s protocol and the standard DTS processing were used as references in the analyses.

RESULTS

The protocol with 6.3 s acquisition time had a statistically significant advantage over the vendor-recommended protocol with 12 s acquisition time for the classes of criteria, Demarcation (AUC_VGC = 0.56, p = 0.009) and Disturbance (AUC_VGC = 0.58, p < 0.001). A similar value of AUC_VGC was found also for the class Structure (definition of bone structures in the spine) (0.56) but it could not be statistically separated from 0.5 (p = 0.21). For the image processing, the VGC analysis showed a small but statistically significant advantage for the standard DTS processing over the more advanced processing for the classes of criteria Demarcation (AUC_VGC = 0.45, p = 0.017) and Disturbance (AUC_VGC = 0.43, p = 0.005). A similar value of AUC_VGC was found also for the class Structure (0.46), but it could not be statistically separated from 0.5 (p = 0.31).

CONCLUSION

The study indicates that the protocol with 6.3 s acquisition time yields slightly better image quality than the vender-recommended protocol with acquisition time 12 s for several anatomical structures. Furthermore, the standard gradation processing  (the vendor-recommended post-processing for DTS), yields to some extent advantage over the gradation processing/multiobjective frequency processing/flexible noise control processing in terms of image quality for all classes of criteria. Advances in knowledge: The study proves that the image quality may be strongly affected by the selection of DTS protocol and that the vendor-recommended protocol may not always be the optimal choice.

Digital chest tomosynthesis: the 2017 updated review of an emerging application

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer death and second most common cancer among both men and women, but most of them are detected when patients become symptomatic and in late-stage. Chest radiography (CR) is a basic technique for the investigation of lung cancer and has the benefit of convenience and low radiation dose, but detection of malignancy is often difficult. The introduction of computed tomography (CT) for screening has increased the proportion of lung cancer detected but with higher exposure dose and higher costs. Digital chest tomosynthesis (DCT), a tomographic technique, may offer an alternative to CT. DCT uses a conventional radiograph tube, a flat-panel detector, a computer-controlled tube mover and reconstruction algorithms to produce section images. It shows promise in the detection of potentially malignant lung nodules, with higher sensibility than CR, and is emerging as a low-dose and low-cost alternative to CT to improve treatment decisions. In fact, an increasing number of researchers are showing that tomosynthesis could have a role in the detection of lung cancer, in addition to its present role in breast screening. However, DCT offers some limitations, such as limited depth resolution, which may explain the difficulty in detecting pathologies in the subpleural region and the occurrence of artefacts from medical devices. Once solved these limitations and once more studies supporting its use will be available, DCT could become the first-line lung cancer screening tool among patients at considerable risk of lung cancer.

VGC ANALYZER: A SOFTWARE FOR STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF FULLY CROSSED MULTIPLE-READER MULTIPLE-CASE VISUAL GRADING CHARACTERISTICS STUDIES

Visual grading characteristics (VGC) analysis is a non-parametric rank-invariant method for analysis of visual grading data. In VGC analysis, image quality ratings for two different conditions are compared by producing a VGC curve, similar to how the ratings for normal and abnormal cases in receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis are used to create an ROC curve. The use of established ROC software for the analysis of VGC data has therefore previously been proposed. However, the ROC analysis is based on the assumption of independence between normal and abnormal cases. In VGC analysis, this independence cannot always be assumed, e.g. if the ratings are based on the same patients imaged under both conditions. A dedicated software intended for analysis of VGC studies, which takes possible dependencies between ratings into account in the statistical analysis of a VGC study, has therefore been developed. The software-VGC Analyzer-determines the area under the VGC curve and its uncertainty using non-parametric resampling techniques. This article gives an introduction to VGC Analyzer, describes the types of analyses that can be performed and instructs the user about the input and output data.