Reevaluating safety pharmacology respiratory studies within the ICH S7A core battery: A multi-company evaluation of preclinical utility and clinical translation

Optimization of ICH safety guideline studies for inclusion into regulatory submissions is critical for resource conservation, animal use reduction, and efficient drug development. The ICH S7A guidance for Safety Pharmacology (SP) studies adopted in 2001 identified the core battery of studies to evaluate the acute safety of putative pharmaceutical molecules prior to First in Human (FIH) trials. To assess the utility of respiratory studies in predicting clinical AE's, seven pharmaceutical companies pooled preclinical and clinical respiratory findings. A large database of novel molecules included all relevant data from standard S7A respiratory (n = 459) and FIH studies (n = 309). The data were analyzed with respect to the progression of these molecules, clinical adverse event reporting of these same molecules, and achieved exposures. These S7A respiratory assay findings had no impact on compound progression, and only 12 of 309 drug candidates were 'positive' preclinically and reported a respiratory-related AE in clinical trials (i.e. cough, dyspnea, etc.), an overall incidence rate of 3.9%. Contingency tables/statistics support a lack of concordance of these preclinical assays. Overall, our extensive analysis clearly indicated that the preclinical respiratory assay fails to provide any prognostic value for detecting clinically relevant respiratory adverse events.

Modelling hemodynamics regulation in rats and dogs to facilitate drugs safety risk assessment

Pharmaceutical companies routinely screen compounds for hemodynamics related safety risk. In vitro secondary pharmacology is initially used to prioritize compounds while in vivo studies are later used to quantify and translate risk to humans. This strategy has shown limitations but could be improved via the incorporation of molecular findings in the animal-based toxicological risk assessment. The aim of this study is to develop a mathematical model for rat and dog species that can integrate secondary pharmacology modulation and therefore facilitate the overall pre-clinical safety translation assessment. Following an extensive literature review, we built two separate models recapitulating known regulation processes in dogs and rats. We describe the resulting models and show that they can reproduce a variety of interventions in both species. We also show that the models can incorporate the mechanisms of action of a pre-defined list of 50 pharmacological mechanisms whose modulation predict results consistent with known pharmacology. In conclusion, a mechanistic model of hemodynamics regulations in rat and dog species has been developed to support mechanism-based safety translation in drug discovery and development.

The rat telemetry assay and venous catheter access buttons for use in cardiovascular safety pharmacology assessments - Surgical methods, refinements and colony maintenance

INTRODUCTION

Rat telemetry is the assay of choice to assess the potential effects of novel drug candidates on cardiovascular parameters during early drug discovery. Telemetry device implantation can be combined with venous catheter and access button implantation when intravenous administration of the drug substance is required.

METHODS

Rats (Sprague Dawley or Han Wistar) were implanted with telemetry devices for arterial blood pressure measurement using either direct aortic catheterisation (n = 131) or aortic catheterisation via the femoral artery (n = 17). Bipolar leads for ECG recording were also implanted in some of the animals (n = 102). Femoral vein catheters and access buttons were implanted as a separate surgery after the initial telemetry implantation (n = 43).

RESULTS

128 animals (86%) were implanted successfully with telemetry devices without any notable surgical or post-surgical problems. When considering the 2 different catheterisation methods separately, the success rate of the direct aortic approach was 88% compared to 76% with the aortic placement via the femoral artery. Lameness was the most common post-surgical problem. Blood loss during surgery and ischaemic patches on the tail were also observed at a low incidence with the direct aortic approach. Catheter pull-out occurred in some rats before the first signal check reducing the overall success rate for blood pressure measurement using the direct aortic approach to 85%. A 95% success rate was observed for catheter and access button implantation.

DISCUSSION

A high success rate is possible when implanting telemetry devices in rats with and without venous catheters and access buttons. We have attempted to provide solutions to problems and describe refinements to the procedure which may further improve surgical outcomes.

A Retrospective Comparison of Electrocardiographic Parameters in Ketamine and Tiletamine-Zolazepam Anesthetized Indian Rhesus Monkeys (Macaca mulatta)

Electrocardiographic evaluation is performed in rhesus monkeys to establish the cardiovascular safety of candidate molecules before progressing to clinical trials. These animals are usually immobilized chemically by ketamine (KTM) and tiletamine-zolazepam (TZ) to obtain a steady-state heart rate and to ensure adequate human safety. The present study aimed to evaluate the effect of these anesthetic regimens on different electrocardiographic parameters. Statistically significant lower HR and higher P-wave duration, RR, QRS, and QT intervals were observed in the KTM-anesthetized group in comparison to TZ-anesthetized animals. No significant changes were noticed in the PR interval and p-wave amplitude. Sex-based significance amongst these parameters was observed in male and female animals of TZ- and KTM-anesthetized groups. Regression analysis of four QTc formulas in TZ-anesthetized rhesus monkeys revealed that QTcNAK (Nakayama) better corrected the QT interval than QTcHAS (Hassimoto), QTcBZT (Bazett), and QTcFRD (Fridericia) formulas. QTcNAK exhibited the least correlation with the RR interval (slope closest to zero and r = .01) and displayed no statistical significance between male and female animals. These data will prove useful in the selection of anesthetic regimens for chemical restraint of rhesus monkeys in nonclinical safety evaluation studies.

A tutorial for model-based evaluation and translation of cardiovascular safety in preclinical trials

Assessment of drug-induced effects on the cardiovascular (CV) system remains a critical component of the drug discovery process enabling refinement of the therapeutic index. Predicting potential drug-related unintended CV effects in the preclinical stage is necessary for first-in-human dose selection and preclusion of adverse CV effects in the clinical stage. According to the current guidelines for small molecules, nonclinical CV safety assessment conducted via telemetry analyses should be included in the safety pharmacology core battery studies. However, the manual for quantitative evaluation of the CV safety signals in animals is available only for electrocardiogram parameters (i.e., QT interval assessment), not for hemodynamic parameters (i.e., heart rate, blood pressure, etc.). Various model-based approaches, including empirical pharmacokinetic-toxicodynamic analyses and systems pharmacology modeling could be used in the framework of telemetry data evaluation. In this tutorial, we provide a comprehensive workflow for the analysis of nonclinical CV safety on hemodynamic parameters with a sequential approach, highlight the challenges associated with the data, and propose respective solutions, complemented with a reproducible example. The work is aimed at helping researchers conduct model-based analyses of the CV safety in animals with subsequent translation of the effect to humans seamlessly and efficiently.

A generalized canine transfer function accurately reconstructs central aortic pressure waveforms to enable enhanced pulse wave analysis

Routine preclinical blood pressure evaluation is an important risk assessment tool. Although proximal aortic pressure is most relevant for key target organs, abdominal aortic pressures are more commonly recorded. Pulse pressure amplification and waveform distortion in abdominal waveforms make it inappropriate for central hemodynamic analytical methods without the use of a mathematical transfer function. Clinical transfer functions have been developed to estimate ascending aortic waveforms from brachial or radial artery waveforms in humans, but no preclinical analogues exist. The aim of this study was to develop a canine-specific transfer function to reconstruct thoracic aortic pressure waveforms from abdominal aortic data to enable the application of central hemodynamic analytical methods. Simultaneous abdominal and thoracic blood pressures were recorded from seven conscious, male beagle dogs administered 3 well-characterized pharmacologic standards and animals were appointed to a training (n = 3) or validation (n = 4) group at baseline and during dosing. A generalized transfer function was developed from the training group data and evaluated for its ability to synthesize thoracic pressure waves in the training and validation groups. Select hemodynamic parameters were evaluated in measured and synthesized thoracic data. There was a high degree of correlation between measured and synthesized thoracic parameters (r2 = 0.74-0.99). There was no difference between indices computed from synthesized or actual thoracic waveforms at baseline or after administration of pharmacologic standards. This work demonstrates that a generalized preclinical transfer function can reproduce thoracic pressure waves across a range of hemodynamic responses thus enabling the application of central hemodynamic analytical methods.

Targeting RNA with small molecules-A safety perspective

RNA is a major player in cellular function, and consequently can drive a number of disease pathologies. Over the past several years, small molecule-RNA targeting (smRNA targeting) has developed into a promising drug discovery approach. Numerous techniques, tools, and assays have been developed to support this field, and significant investments have been made by pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies. To date, the focus has been on identifying disease validated primary targets for smRNA drug development, yet RNA as a secondary (off) target for all small molecule drug programs largely has been unexplored. In this perspective, we discuss structure, target, and mechanism-driven safety aspects of smRNAs and highlight how these parameters can be evaluated in drug discovery programs to produce potentially safer drugs.

Quantitative Investigation of Irinotecan Metabolism, Transport, and Gut Microbiome Activation

The anticancer drug irinotecan shows serious dose-limiting gastrointestinal toxicity regardless of intravenous dosing. Although enzymes and transporters involved in irinotecan disposition are known, quantitative contributions of these mechanisms in complex in vivo disposition of irinotecan are poorly understood. We explained intestinal disposition and toxicity of irinotecan by integrating 1) in vitro metabolism and transport data of irinotecan and its metabolites, 2) ex vivo gut microbial activation of the toxic metabolite SN-38, and 3) the tissue protein abundance data of enzymes and transporters relevant to irinotecan and its metabolites. Integration of in vitro kinetics data with the tissue enzyme and transporter abundance predicted that carboxylesterase (CES)-mediated hydrolysis of irinotecan is the rate-limiting process in the liver, where the toxic metabolite formed is rapidly deactivated by glucuronidation. In contrast, the poor SN-38 glucuronidation rate as compared with its efficient formation by CES2 in the enterocytes is the key mechanism of the intestinal accumulation of the toxic metabolite. The biliary efflux and organic anion transporting polypeptide-2B1-mediated enterocyte uptake can also synergize buildup of SN-38 in the enterocytes, whereas intestinal P-glycoprotein likely facilitates SN-38 detoxification in the enterocytes. The higher SN-38 concentration in the intestine can be further nourished by β-d-glucuronidases. Understanding the quantitative significance of the key metabolism and transport processes of irinotecan and its metabolites can be leveraged to alleviate its intestinal side effects. Further, the proteomics-informed quantitative approach to determine intracellular disposition can be extended to determine susceptibility of cancer cells over normal cells for precision irinotecan therapy. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: This work provides a deeper insight into the quantitative relevance of irinotecan hydrolysis (activation), conjugation (deactivation), and deconjugation (reactivation) by human or gut microbial enzymes or transporters. The results of this study explain the characteristic intestinal exposure and toxicity of irinotecan. The quantitative tissue-specific in vitro to in vivo extrapolation approach presented in this study can be extended to cancer cells.

INSPIRE: A European training network to foster research and training in cardiovascular safety pharmacology

Safety pharmacology is an essential part of drug development aiming to identify, evaluate and investigate undesirable pharmacodynamic properties of a drug primarily prior to clinical trials. In particular, cardiovascular adverse drug reactions (ADR) have halted many drug development programs. Safety pharmacology has successfully implemented a screening strategy to detect cardiovascular liabilities, but there is room for further refinement. In this setting, we present the INSPIRE project, a European Training Network in safety pharmacology for Early Stage Researchers (ESRs), funded by the European Commission's H2020-MSCA-ITN programme. INSPIRE has recruited 15 ESR fellows that will conduct an individual PhD-research project for a period of 36 months. INSPIRE aims to be complementary to ongoing research initiatives. With this as a goal, an inventory of collaborative research initiatives in safety pharmacology was created and the ESR projects have been designed to be complementary to this roadmap. Overall, INSPIRE aims to improve cardiovascular safety evaluation, either by investigating technological innovations or by adding mechanistic insight in emerging safety concerns, as observed in the field of cardio-oncology. Finally, in addition to its hands-on research pillar, INSPIRE will organize a number of summer schools and workshops that will be open to the wider community as well. In summary, INSPIRE aims to foster both research and training in safety pharmacology and hopes to inspire the future generation of safety scientists.

A pharmacological characterization of electrocardiogram PR and QRS intervals in conscious telemetered rats

INTRODUCTION

The conscious telemetered rat is widely used as an early in vivo screening model for assessing the cardiovascular safety of novel pharmacological agents. The current study aimed to identify its utility in assessing electrocardiogram (ECG) PR and QRS interval changes.

METHOD

Male Han-Wistar rats (~250 g) were implanted with radio-telemetry devices for the recording of ECG and haemodynamic parameters. Animals (n = 4-8) were treated with single doses of calcium (nifedipine, diltiazem or verapamil; CCBs) or sodium channel blockers (quinidine or flecainide; SCBs) or their corresponding vehicles in an ascending dose design. Data was recorded continuously up to 24 h post-dose. Pharmacokinetic analysis of blood samples was performed to allow comparison of effects to published data in other species.

RESULTS

Of the CCBs, only diltiazem (300 mg/kg) prolonged the PR interval (49 ± 2 versus vehicle: 43 ± 1 ms), although this was not statistically significant (p = .11). QA interval decreased with nifedipine (30 ± 1 versus 24 ± 0 ms) and diltiazem (34 ± 1 versus 27 ± 1 ms) but increased with verapamil (30 ± 0 versus 37 ± 1 ms) demonstrating pharmacological activity of each agent. Both SCBs, caused statistically significant (p < .05) increases in both intervals - quinidine (100 mg/kg; PR: 50 ± 2 versus 43 ± 1 ms; QRS: 22 ± 2 versus 18 ± 1 ms) and flecainide (9 mg/kg; PR: 56 ± 1 versus 46 ± 1 ms; QRS: 27 ± 1 versus 21 ± 1 ms). Drug plasma exposure was confirmed in all animals.

DISCUSSION

At similar plasma concentrations to other species, the conscious telemetered rat demonstrates limited utility in assessing PR interval prolongation by CCBs, despite significant contractility effects being observed. However, results with SCBs demonstrate a potential application for evaluating drug-induced QRS prolongation.