Five Species of Xanthomonads Associated with Bacterial Leaf Spot Symptoms in Tomato from Tanzania

Influence of Co-occurring Weakly Pathogenic Bacterial Species on Bacterial Spot Disease Dynamics on Tomato

Mixed infections caused by multiple pathogenic and weakly pathogenic strains inhabiting the same host plants are common in nature and may modify pathogen dynamics. However, traditional plant pathogen studies have mostly focused on the binary interaction between a single host and a single pathogen. In this study, we have looked beyond this binary interaction and evaluated the impact of coinfection on disease dynamics on tomato using the bacterial spot pathogen Xanthomonas perforans (Xp), the co-occurring weakly pathogenic strain of X. arboricola (Xa), and the co-occurring potential weak pathogenic strain of Pseudomonas capsici (Pc). Time-series coinfection experiments monitoring disease severity and within-host population dynamics revealed higher disease severity in coinfection by three species compared with infection by Xp alone. However, coinfection by dual species, Xp and Pc, or Xa resulted in lower disease severity compared with Xp alone. Thus, coinfection outcomes depend on interacting species. Weak pathogens could exploit Xp to colonize the host plant as indicated by their higher populations in coinfection. However, Xp population dynamics were dependent on the coinfecting partner. While resource competition might be a possible explanation for lower Xp population in dual coinfection, interaction of Pc with the host was found to influence Xp population. Interestingly, Xp population was higher in the presence of three-species interaction compared with Xp and Xa coinfection, suggesting potential modulation of cooperative interactions among Xp and Xa in three-species coinfection rather than competitive interactions. Humidity played a significant role in population dynamics of the three species. Overall, this study highlighted the importance of coinfection dynamics in studying plant disease outbreaks.

Bacterial Spot of Tomato and Pepper in Africa: Diversity, Emergence of T5 Race, and Management

Bacterial spot disease was first reported from South Africa by Ethel M. Doidge in 1920. In the ensuing century after the initial discovery, the pathogen has gained global attention in plant pathology research, providing insights into host-pathogen interactions, pathogen evolution, and effector discovery, such as the first discovery of transcription activation-like effectors, among many others. Four distinct genetic groups, including Xanthomonas euvesicatoria (proposed name: X. euvesicatoria pv. euvesicatoria), Xanthomonas perforans (proposed name: X. euvesicatoria pv. perforans), Xanthomonas gardneri (proposed name: Xanthomonas hortorum pv. gardneri), and Xanthomonas vesicatoria, are known to cause bacterial spot disease. Recently, a new race of a bacterial spot pathogen, race T5, which is a product of recombination between at least two Xanthomonas species, was reported in Nigeria. In this review, our focus is on the progress made on the African continent, vis-à-vis progress made in the global bacterial spot research community to provide a body of information useful for researchers in understanding the diversity, evolutionary changes, and management of the disease in Africa.

A centenary for bacterial spot of tomato and pepper

DISEASE SYMPTOMS

Symptoms include water-soaked areas surrounded by chlorosis turning into necrotic spots on all aerial parts of plants. On tomato fruits, small, water-soaked, or slightly raised pale-green spots with greenish-white halos are formed, ultimately becoming dark brown and slightly sunken with a scabby or wart-like surface.

HOST RANGE

Main and economically important hosts include different types of tomatoes and peppers. Alternative solanaceous and nonsolanaceous hosts include Datura spp., Hyoscyamus spp., Lycium spp., Nicotiana rustica, Physalis spp., Solanum spp., Amaranthus lividus, Emilia fosbergii, Euphorbia heterophylla, Nicandra physaloides, Physalis pubescens, Sida glomerata, and Solanum americanum.

TAXONOMIC STATUS OF THE PATHOGEN

Domain, Bacteria; phylum, Proteobacteria; class, Gammaproteobacteria; order, Xanthomonadales; family, Xanthomonadaceae; genus, Xanthomonas; species, X. euvesicatoria, X. hortorum, X. vesicatoria.

SYNONYMS (NONPREFERRED SCIENTIFIC NAMES)

Bacterium exitiosum, Bacterium vesicatorium, Phytomonas exitiosa, Phytomonas vesicatoria, Pseudomonas exitiosa, Pseudomonas gardneri, Pseudomonas vesicatoria, Xanthomonas axonopodis pv. vesicatoria, Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria, Xanthomonas cynarae pv. gardneri, Xanthomonas gardneri, Xanthomonas perforans.

MICROBIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES

Colonies are gram-negative, oxidase-negative, and catalase-positive and have oxidative metabolism. Pale-yellow domed circular colonies of 1-2 mm in diameter grow on general culture media.

DISTRIBUTION

The bacteria are widespread in Africa, Brazil, Canada and the USA, Australia, eastern Europe, and south-east Asia. Occurrence in western Europe is restricted.

PHYTOSANITARY CATEGORIZATION

A2 no. 157, EU Annex designation II/A2.

EPPO CODES

XANTEU, XANTGA, XANTPF, XANTVE.

Harnessing Eco-Evolutionary Dynamics of Xanthomonads on Tomato and Pepper to Tackle New Problems of an Old Disease

Bacterial spot is an endemic seedborne disease responsible for recurring outbreaks on tomato and pepper around the world. The disease is caused by four diverse species, Xanthomonas gardneri, Xanthomonas euvesicatoria, Xanthomonas perforans, and Xanthomonas vesicatoria. There are no commercially available disease-resistant tomato varieties, and the disease is managed by chemical/biological control options, although these have not reduced the incidence of outbreaks. The disease on peppers is managed by disease-resistant cultivars that are effective against X. euvesicatoria but not X. gardneri. A significant shift in composition and prevalence of different species and races of the pathogen has occurred over the past century. Here, I attempt to review ecological and evolutionary processes associated with the population dynamics leading to disease emergence and spread. The goal of this review is to integrate the knowledge on population genomics and molecular plant-microbe interactions for this pathosystem to tailor disease management strategies.

Epidemiology, diversity, and management of bacterial spot of tomato caused by Xanthomonas perforans

Tomato is an important crop grown worldwide. Various plant diseases cause massive losses in tomato plants due to diverse biotic agents. Bacterial spot of tomato (BST) is a worldwide disease that results in high losses in processed and fresh tomato. Xanthomonas perforans, an aerobic, single-flagellated, rod-shaped, Gram-negative plant pathogenic bacterium, is one of the leading causes of BST. Over the past three decades, X. perforans has increasingly been reported from tomato-growing regions and became a major bacterial disease. X. perforans thrives under high humidity and high temperature, which is commonplace in tropical and subtropical climates. Distinguishing symptoms of BST are necrotic lesions that can coalesce and cause a shot-hole appearance. X. perforans can occasionally cause fruit symptoms depending on disease pressure during fruit development. Short-distance movement in the field is mainly dependent on wind-driven rain, whereas long distance movement occurs through contaminated seed or plant material. X. perforans harbors a suite of effectors that increase pathogen virulence, fitness, and dissemination. BST management mainly relies on copper-based compounds; however, resistance is widespread. Alternative compounds, such as nanomaterials, are currently being evaluated and show high potential for BST management. Resistance breeding remains difficult to attain due to limited resistant germplasm. While the increased genetic diversity and gain and loss of effectors in X. perforans limits the success of single-gene resistance, the adoption of effector-specific transgenes and quantitative resistance may lead to durable host resistance. However, further research that aims to more effectively implement novel management tools is required to curb disease spread. KEY POINTS: • Xanthomonas perforans causes bacterial spot on tomato epidemics through infected seedlings and movement of plant material. • Genetic diversity plays a major role in shaping populations which is evident in loss and gain of effectors. • Management relies on copper sprays, but nanoparticles are a promising alternative to reduce copper toxicity.

Prevalence of Xanthomonas euvesicatoria (formally X. perforans) associated with bacterial spot severity in Capsicum annuum crops in South Central Chihuahua, Mexico

Background

Xanthomonas spp. causes bacterial spot disease, which reduces quality and yield of pepper crops in Mexico. Identification of phytopathogen species is necessary to implement more effective control strategies.

Objective

The aim of this study was to isolate and identify infecting Xanthomonas species in South Central Chihuahua pepper-producing areas.

Methods

Diseased plants were collected from 30 cultivation lots and bacteria were isolated from damaged tissues. Potential causative agents were isolated, identified, and characterized by biochemical and molecular analysis. Pathogenicity tests from each isolate were then performed on 30-d-old pepper seedlings, exposing five leaves to 10 µL of 1 × 10⁸ CFU/mL bacterial suspensions of each isolate, using sterile distilled water as a control. Disease severity was determined after 10 d by calculating leaf damage percentage. Furthermore, we evaluated the susceptibility of the highest bacterial spot severity-causing isolates (13 isolates) to copper sulphate (CuS), copper gluconate (CuG), copper oxychloride + oxytetracycline hydrochloride (Cu + Ox), gentamicin + oxytetracycline hydrochloride (Gen + Ox), and gentamicin sulphate (GenS). Copper-resistance genes (copLAB) were detected by PCR analysis among isolates.

Results

Thirty-seven foliage isolates were identified as Xanthomonas euvesicatoria (14%), which were associated with bacterial spot disease in jalapeño pepper. Tested Xanthomonas isolates were resistant to Cu-based compounds, but susceptible to Cu + Ox. All isolates were susceptible to Gen + Ox and GenS. CopLAB genes were detected in all but one strain.

Conclusions

X. euvesicatoria (formally X. perforans) may be considered as an emerging pathogen of bacterial spot pepper in Mexico. Among disease management strategies, alternatives to copper should be taken into consideration.

Genomic Inference of Recombination-Mediated Evolution in Xanthomonas euvesicatoria and X. perforans

Recombination is a major driver of evolution in bacterial populations, because it can spread and combine independently evolved beneficial mutations. Recombinant lineages of bacterial pathogens of plants are typically associated with the colonization of novel hosts and the emergence of new diseases. Here we show that recombination between evolutionarily and phenotypically distinct plant-pathogenic lineages generated recombinant lineages with unique combinations of pathogenicity and virulence factors. Xanthomonas euvesicatoria and Xanthomonas perforans are two closely related lineages causing bacterial spot disease on tomato and pepper worldwide. We sequenced the genomes of atypical strains collected from tomato in Nigeria and observed recombination in the type III secretion system and effector genes, which showed alleles from both X. euvesicatoria and X. perforans Wider horizontal gene transfer was indicated by the fact that the lipopolysaccharide cluster of one strain was most similar to that of a distantly related Xanthomonas pathogen of barley. This strain and others have experienced extensive genomewide homologous recombination, and both species exhibited dynamic open pangenomes. Variation in effector gene repertoires within and between species must be taken into consideration when one is breeding tomatoes for disease resistance. Resistance breeding strategies that target specific effectors must consider possibly dramatic variation in bacterial spot populations across global production regions, as illustrated by the recombinant strains observed here.IMPORTANCE The pathogens that cause bacterial spot of tomato and pepper are extensively studied models of plant-microbe interactions and cause problematic disease worldwide. Atypical bacterial spot strains collected from tomato in Nigeria, and other strains from Italy, India, and Florida, showed evidence of genomewide recombination that generated genetically distinct pathogenic lineages. The strains from Nigeria and Italy were found to have a mix of type III secretion system genes from X. perforans and X. euvesicatoria, as well as effectors from Xanthomonas gardneri These genes and effectors are important in the establishment of disease, and effectors are common targets of resistance breeding. Our findings point to global diversity in the genomes of bacterial spot pathogens, which is likely to affect the host-pathogen interaction and influence management decisions.

Bacterial spot of tomato and pepper: diverse Xanthomonas species with a wide variety of virulence factors posing a worldwide challenge

TAXONOMIC STATUS

Bacteria; Phylum Proteobacteria; Class Gammaproteobacteria; Order Xanthomonadales; Family Xanthomonadaceae; Genus Xanthomonas; Species Xanthomonas euvesicatoria, Xanthomonas vesicatoria, Xanthomonas perforans and Xanthomonas gardneri.

MICROBIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES

Gram-negative, rod-shaped bacterium, aerobic, motile, single polar flagellum.

HOST RANGE

Causes bacterial spot disease on plants belonging to the Solanaceae family, primarily tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), pepper (Capsicum annuum) and chilli peppers (Capsicum frutescens).

DISEASE SYMPTOMS

Necrotic lesions on all above-ground plant parts.

DISTRIBUTION

Worldwide distribution of X. euvesicatoria and X. vesicatoria on tomato and pepper; X. perforans and X. gardneri increasingly being isolated from the USA, Canada, South America, Africa and Europe. A wide diversity within the bacterial spot disease complex, with an ability to cause disease at different temperatures, makes this pathogen group a worldwide threat to tomato and pepper production. Recent advances in genome analyses have revealed the evolution of the pathogen with a plethora of novel virulence factors. Current management strategies rely on the use of various chemical control strategies and sanitary measures to minimize pathogen spread through contaminated seed. Chemical control strategies have been a challenge because of resistance by the pathogen. Breeding programmes have been successful in developing commercial lines with hypersensitive and quantitative resistance. However, durability of resistance has been elusive. Recently, a transgenic approach has resulted in the development of tomato genotypes with significant levels of resistance and improved yield that hold promise. In this article, we discuss the current taxonomic status, distribution of the four species, knowledge of virulence factors, detection methods and strategies for disease control with possible directions for future research.

Classification and Taxonomy of Vegetable Macergens

Macergens are bacteria capable of releasing pectic enzymes (pectolytic bacteria). These enzymatic actions result in the separation of plant tissues leading to total plant destruction. This can be attributed to soft rot diseases in vegetables. These macergens primarily belong to the genus Erwinia and to a range of opportunistic pathogens namely: the Xanthomonas spp., Pseudomonas spp., Clostridium spp., Cytophaga spp., and Bacillus spp. They consist of taxa that displayed considerable heterogeneity and intermingled with members of other genera belonging to the Enterobacteriaceae. They have been classified based on phenotypic, chemotaxonomic and genotypic which obviously not necessary in the taxonomy of all bacterial genera for defining bacterial species and describing new ones These taxonomic markers have been used traditionally as a simple technique for identification of bacterial isolates. The most important fields of taxonomy are supposed to be based on clear, reliable and worldwide applicable criteria. Hence, this review clarifies the taxonomy of the macergens to the species level and revealed that their taxonomy is beyond complete. For discovery of additional species, further research with the use modern molecular methods like phylogenomics need to be done. This can precisely define classification of macergens resulting in occasional, but significant changes in previous taxonomic schemes of these macergens.

Synergisms between microbial pathogens in plant disease complexes: a growing trend

Plant diseases are often thought to be caused by one species or even by a specific strain. Microbes in nature, however, mostly occur as part of complex communities and this has been noted since the time of van Leeuwenhoek. Interestingly, most laboratory studies focus on single microbial strains grown in pure culture; we were therefore unaware of possible interspecies and/or inter-kingdom interactions of pathogenic microbes in the wild. In human and animal infections, it is now being recognized that many diseases are the result of multispecies synergistic interactions. This increases the complexity of the disease and has to be taken into consideration in the development of more effective control measures. On the other hand, there are only a few reports of synergistic pathogen-pathogen interactions in plant diseases and the mechanisms of interactions are currently unknown. Here we review some of these reports of synergism between different plant pathogens and their possible implications in crop health. Finally, we briefly highlight the recent technological advances in diagnostics as these are beginning to provide important insights into the microbial communities associated with complex plant diseases. These examples of synergistic interactions of plant pathogens that lead to disease complexes might prove to be more common than expected and understanding the underlying mechanisms might have important implications in plant disease epidemiology and management.