Changes in Distribution and Frequency of Fungi Associated With a Foliar Disease Complex of Pyrethrum in Australia

Evolution of the Genetic Structure of the Didymella tanaceti Population During Development of Succinate Dehydrogenase Inhibitor Resistance

Emergence of pathogens with decreased sensitivity to succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor fungicides is a global agronomical issue. Analysis of Didymella tanaceti isolates (n = 173), which cause tan spot of pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium), collected prior to (2004 to 2005) and after (2009, 2010, 2012, and 2014) the commercial implementation of boscalid in Tasmanian pyrethrum fields identified that insensitivity developed over time and has become widespread. To evaluate temporal change, isolates were characterized for frequency of mutations in the succinate dehydrogenase (Sdh) B, C, and D subunits associated with boscalid resistance, mating type, and SSR genotype. All isolates from 2004 and 2005 exhibited wild-type (WT) Sdh alleles. Seven known Sdh substitutions were identified in isolates collected from 2009 to 2014. In 2009, 60.7% had Sdh substitutions associated with boscalid resistance in D. tanaceti. The frequency of WT isolates decreased over time, with no WT isolates identified in 2014. The frequency of the SdhB-H277Y genotype increased from 10.7 to 77.8% between 2009 and 2014. Genotypic evidence suggested that a shift in the population structure occurred between 2005 and 2009, with decreases in gene diversity (uh; 0.51 to 0.34), genotypic evenness (E5; 0.96 to 0.67), genotypic diversity (G; 9.3 to 6.8), and allele frequencies. No evidence was obtained to support the rapid spread of Sdh genotypes by clonal expansion of the population. Thus, insensitivity to boscalid has developed and become widespread within a diverse population within 4 years of usage. These results suggest that D. tanaceti can disperse insensitivity through repeated frequent mutation, sexual recombination, or a combination of both.

Globisporangium and Pythium Species Associated with Yield Decline of Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) in Australia

Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) cultivation in Australia, which accounts for the majority of global production of natural insecticidal pyrethrins, is affected by a persistent yield decline which in part is caused by a complex of pathogens. Globisporangium and Pythium species were isolated from crown and roots of pyrethrum plants showing stunting and brown discoloration of crown tissue, and from soil adjacent to diseased plants from yield-decline-affected sites in Tasmania and Victoria, Australia. Ten known Globisporangium species (Globisporangium attrantheridium, G. erinaceum, G. intermedium, G. irregulare, G. macrosporum, G. recalcitrans, G. rostratifingens, G. sylvaticum, G. terrestris and G. ultimum var. ultimum), two new Globisporangium species (Globisporangium capense sp. nov. and Globisporangium commune sp. nov.) and three Pythium species (Pythium diclinum/lutarium, P. tracheiphilum and P. vanterpoolii) were identified through morphological studies and multigene phylogenetic analyses using ITS and Cox1 sequences. Globisporangium ultimum var. ultimum, G. sylvaticum, G. commune sp. nov. and G. irregulare were most abundant. Globisporangium attrantheridium, G. macrosporum and G. terrestris were reported for the first time in Australia. Seven Globisporangium species were pathogenic on both pyrethrum seeds (in vitro assays) and seedlings (glasshouse bioassays), while two Globisporangium species and three Pythium species only caused significant symptoms on pyrethrum seeds. Globisporangium irregulare and G. ultimum var. ultimum were the most aggressive species, causing pyrethrum seed rot, seedling damping-off and significant plant biomass reduction. This is the first report of Globisporangium and Pythium species causing disease in pyrethrum globally and suggests that oomycete species in the family Pythiaceae may have an important role in the yield decline of pyrethrum in Australia.

Confirmation of Itersonilia perplexans infecting pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) in Australia

Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium (Trevir.) Sch. Bip.) is grown to extract pyrethrins which are active ingredients for insecticides (Greenhill 2007). The Australian pyrethrum industry supplies over 50% of the world market. Surveys of Tasmanian crops in spring 2013, detected the presence of a fungus putatively identified as Itersonilia perplexans Derx. on foliage in 54 of 86 surveyed fields (Hay et al. 2015). This fungus was associated with necrotic leaf tips often spreading to encompass whole leaves. However, pathogenicity to pyrethrum was not confirmed. To isolate, tissue was excised from foliar lesions, surface sterilised using 0.4% NaClO, placed onto 2% water agar and incubated at 20°C for 5 days. Colonies were pure-cultured by hyphal-tip transfer onto potato-dextrose agar. Eleven isolates were cultured onto yeast mold agar (YMA) for 14 days at 15°C in the dark (Horita and Yasuoka 2002). Colonies were slow growing (1.9 to 2.3 mm/day) white to buff on both surfaces, with a darker center visible on lower surfaces. Mycelia were straight and hyaline with clamp connections at the septa. Squares transferred from the edge of YMA colonies onto microscope slides produced ballistoconidia that were aseptate, granular and lunate, kidney or lemon-shaped after 24 h. Ballistoconidia lengths and widths (n = 50/isolate) ranged from 14.6 to 20.4 µm and 10.0 to 13.6 µm. Chlamydospores were not observed. These observations were consistent with descriptions of I. perplexans (Koike and Tjosvold 2001; Liu et al. 2015). All 11 isolates were sequenced across the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of rDNA (ITS; primers V9G/ITS4; de Hoog and van den Ende 1998; White et al. 1990), and large (LSU; primers LROR/LR7; Rehner and Samuels 1995), and small (SSU; NS1/NS4; White et al. 1990) subunits of rDNA (Genbank accession nos. KU563626 to KU563658). The ITS (673 bp), SSU (1,047 bp) and LSU (1,318 bp) differed by 3, 1 and 0 bp, respectively, across isolates. Maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood analyses of a concatenated 3 loci alignment with Cystofilobasidiales representatives (Liu et al. 2015) placed all isolates and the I. perplexans ex-neotype strain CBS 363.85 within a single monophyletic clade with 100% bootstrap support. Two representative isolates are stored at the Plant Pathology Herbarium (accession nos. BRIP 57986 and 57987). Leaves of 46-day-old pyrethrum plants (n = 45), generated from surface sterilised seed, were inoculated with a 1.5 × 105 ballistoconidia/ml suspension (equal mix of eight isolates) and maintained between 10 and 22°C under a 12-h photoperiod for 14 days. Brown necrotic leaf tips, consistent with reported field symptoms were observed on 71% of plants and I. perplexans was recovered from 69% of symptomatic plants. For flower inoculations, pyrethrum plants were removed from fields as vegetative plants in spring and maintained in a greenhouse set at 20:14°C and 14:10 h day:night. Open flowers (10 per plant) were dipped into a 1.2 × 104 ballistoconidia/ml suspension mix of three isolates. Brown withered ray florets were observed on 10/12 plants 18 days post-inoculation, matching those described in petal blight of chrysanthemum (McRitchie et al. 1973). I. perplexans was re-isolated from 11/12 inoculated plants and 1 control plant (of 12) which exhibited the same symptoms. In both experiments, I. perplexans was identified based on its distinctive morphology. This confirms the pathogenicity of I. perplexans to both pyrethrum leaves and flowers.

Distribution of the potential pathogenic Alternaria on plant leaves determines foliar fungal communities around the disease spot

Plant leaves are colonized by a remarkably diverse fungal microbiome, which contributes to host plant growth and health. However, responses of foliar fungal community to phytopathogen invasion and measures of the fungal community taken to resist or assist pathogens remain elusive. By utilizing high-throughput sequencing of internal transcribed spacer (ITS) amplicons, we studied the relationships between the foliar fungal community around the disease spot and the pathogen of brown spot disease. The pathogenic Alternaria was found to follow a dramatically decreased trend from the disease spot to its surrounding fungal communities, whose community structure also diverged substantially away from the disease spot community. With the increase of pathogenic Alternaria, diversity indexes, including Shannon, Pielou and Simpson, showed a trend of increasing first and then decreasing. Total network links and the average path distance exhibited strong negative and positive correlations with Alternaria, respectively. Five keystone members showed direct interactions with pathogenic Alternaria. Members of Botryosphaeria, Paraphoma and Plectosphaerella might act as key 'pathogen facilitators' to increase the severity and development of brown spot disease, while Pleospora and Ochrocladosporium might be important 'pathogen antagonists' to suppress the expansion of pathogenic Alternaria. Our study provides new insights in developing new strategies for leaf disease prediction or prevention.

Dark Septate Endophytes Isolated From Wild Licorice Roots Grown in the Desert Regions of Northwest China Enhance the Growth of Host Plants Under Water Deficit Stress

This study aimed to explore dark septate endophytes (DSE) that may improve the cultivation of medicinal plants in arid ecosystems. We isolated and identified eight DSE species (Acremonium nepalense, Acrocalymma vagum, Alternaria chartarum, Alternaria chlamydospora, Alternaria longissima, Darksidea alpha, Paraphoma chrysanthemicola, and Preussia terricola) colonizing the roots of wild licorice (Glycyrrhiza uralensis) in the desert areas of northwest China. Moreover, we investigated the osmotic stress tolerance of the DSE using pure culture, along with the performance of licorice plants inoculated with the DSE under drought stress in a growth chamber, respectively. Here, five species were first reported in desert habitats. The osmotic-stress tolerance of DSE species was highly variable, A. chlamydospora and P. terricola increased the total biomass and root biomass of the host plant. All DSE except A. vagum and P. chrysanthemicola increased the glycyrrhizic acid content; all DSE except A. chartarum increased the glycyrrhizin content under drought stress. DSE × watering regimen improved the glycyrrhizic acid content, soil organic matter, and available nitrogen. Structural equation model analysis showed that DSE × watering regimen positively affected soil organic matter, and total biomass, root length, glycyrrhizic acid, and glycyrrhizin (Shapotou site); and positively affected soil organic matter, available phosphorus, and glycyrrhizin (Minqin site); and positively affected the root length (Anxi site). DSE from the Shapotou site accounted for 8.0, 13.0, and 11.3% of the variations in total biomass, root biomass, and active ingredient content; DSE from the Minqin site accounted for 6.6 and 8.3% of the variations in total biomass and root biomass; DSE from the Anxi site accounted for 4.2 and 10.7% of the variations in total biomass and root biomass. DSE × watering regimen displayed a general synergistic effect on plant growth and active ingredient contents. These findings suggested that the DSE-plant interactions were affected by both DSE species and DSE originating habitats. As A. chlamydospora and P. terricola positively affected the total biomass, root biomass, and active ingredient content of host plants under drought stress, they may have important uses as promoters for the cultivation of licorice in dryland agriculture.

Population Structure of Colletotrichum tanaceti in Australian Pyrethrum Reveals High Evolutionary Potential

Colletotrichum tanaceti, the causal agent of anthracnose, is an emerging pathogen of commercially grown pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) in Australia. A microsatellite marker library was developed to understand the spatio-genetic structure over three sampled years and across two regions where pyrethrum is cultivated in Australia. Results indicated that C. tanaceti was highly diverse with a mixed reproductive mode; comprising both sexual and clonal reproduction. Sexual reproduction of C. tanaceti was more prevalent in Tasmania than in Victoria. Little differentiation was observed among field populations likely due to isolation by colonization but most of the genetic variation was occurring within populations. C. tanaceti was likely to have had a long-distance gene and genotype flow among distant populations within a state and between states. Anthropogenic transmission of propagules and wind dispersal of ascospores are the most probable mechanisms of long-distance dispersal of C. tanaceti. Evaluation of putative population histories suggested that C. tanaceti most likely originated in Tasmania and expanded from an unidentified host onto pyrethrum. Victoria was later invaded by the Tasmanian population. With the mixed mode of reproduction and possible long-distance gene flow, C. tanaceti is likely to have a high evolutionary potential and thereby has ability to adapt to management practices in the future.

Multiple mutations across the succinate dehydrogenase gene complex are associated with boscalid resistance in Didymella tanaceti in pyrethrum

Failures in control of tan spot of pyrethrum, caused by Didymella tanaceti, has been associated with decreased sensitivity within the pathogen population to the succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SDHI) fungicide boscalid. Sequencing the SdhB, SdhC, and SdhD subunits of isolates with resistant and sensitive phenotypes identified 15 mutations, resulting in three amino acid substitutions in the SdhB (H277Y/R, I279V), six in the SdhC (S73P, G79R, H134R, H134Q, S135R and combined H134Q/S135R), and two in the SdhD (D112E, H122R). In vitro testing of their boscalid response and estimation of resistance factors (RF) identified isolates with wild-type (WT) Sdh genotypes were sensitive to boscalid. Isolates with SdhB-I279V, SdhC-H134Q and SdhD-D112E exhibited moderate resistance phenotypes (10 ≥ RF < 100) and isolates with SdhC-H134R exhibited very high resistance phenotypes (RF ≥ 1000). All other substitutions were associated with high resistance phenotypes (100 ≥ RF < 1000). High-resolution melt assays were designed and used to estimate the frequencies of substitutions in four field populations (n = 774) collected in August (pre-boscalid application) and November (post-boscalid application) 2012. The SdhB-H277Y, SdhC-H134R and SdhB-H277R genotypes were most frequently observed across populations at 56.7, 19.0, and 10.3%, respectively. In August 92.9% of D. tanaceti contained a substitution associated with decreased sensitivity. Following boscalid application, this increased to 98.9%, with no WT isolates detected in three fields. Overlaying previously obtained microsatellite and mating-type data revealed that all ten recurrent substitutions were associated with multiple genotypes. Thus, boscalid insensitivity in D. tanaceti appears widespread and not associated with clonal spread of a limited pool of individuals.

Comparative genome analysis indicates high evolutionary potential of pathogenicity genes in Colletotrichum tanaceti

Colletotrichum tanaceti is an emerging foliar fungal pathogen of commercially grown pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium). Despite being reported consistently from field surveys in Australia, the molecular basis of pathogenicity of C. tanaceti on pyrethrum is unknown. Herein, the genome of C. tanaceti (isolate BRIP57314) was assembled de novo and annotated using transcriptomic evidence. The inferred putative pathogenicity gene suite of C. tanaceti comprised a large array of genes encoding secreted effectors, proteases, CAZymes and secondary metabolites. Comparative analysis of its putative pathogenicity gene profiles with those of closely related species suggested that C. tanaceti likely has additional hosts to pyrethrum. The genome of C. tanaceti had a high repeat content and repetitive elements were located significantly closer to genes inferred to influence pathogenicity than other genes. These repeats are likely to have accelerated mutational and transposition rates in the genome, resulting in a rapid evolution of certain CAZyme families in this species. The C. tanaceti genome showed strong signals of Repeat Induced Point (RIP) mutation which likely caused its bipartite nature consisting of distinct gene-sparse, repeat and A-T rich regions. Pathogenicity genes within these RIP affected regions were likely to have a higher evolutionary rate than the rest of the genome. This "two-speed" genome phenomenon in certain Colletotrichum spp. was hypothesized to have caused the clustering of species based on the pathogenicity genes, to deviate from taxonomic relationships. The large repertoire of pathogenicity factors that potentially evolve rapidly due to the plasticity of the genome, indicated that C. tanaceti has a high evolutionary potential. Therefore, C. tanaceti poses a high-risk to the pyrethrum industry. Knowledge of the evolution and diversity of the putative pathogenicity genes will facilitate future research in disease management of C. tanaceti and other Colletotrichum spp.

Genera of phytopathogenic fungi: GOPHY 2

This paper represents the second contribution in the Genera of Phytopathogenic Fungi (GOPHY) series. The series provides morphological descriptions and information regarding the pathology, distribution, hosts and disease symptoms for the treated genera. In addition, primary and secondary DNA barcodes for the currently accepted species are included. This second paper in the GOPHY series treats 20 genera of phytopathogenic fungi and their relatives including: Allantophomopsiella, Apoharknessia, Cylindrocladiella, Diaporthe, Dichotomophthora, Gaeumannomyces, Harknessia, Huntiella, Macgarvieomyces, Metulocladosporiella, Microdochium, Oculimacula, Paraphoma, Phaeoacremonium, Phyllosticta, Proxypiricularia, Pyricularia, Stenocarpella, Utrechtiana and Wojnowiciella. This study includes the new genus Pyriculariomyces, 20 new species, five new combinations, and six typifications for older names.

Evidence for Sexual Recombination in Didymella tanaceti Populations, and Their Evolution Over Spring Production in Australian Pyrethrum Fields

Tan spot, caused by Didymella tanaceti, is one of the most important foliar diseases affecting pyrethrum in Tasmania, Australia. Population dynamics, including mating-type ratios and genetic diversity of D. tanaceti, was characterized within four geographically separated fields in both late winter and spring 2012. A set of 10 microsatellite markers was developed and used to genotype 774 D. tanaceti isolates. Isolates were genotypically diverse, with 123 multilocus genotypes (MLG) identified across the four fields. Fifty-eight MLG contained single isolates and P_sex analysis estimated that, within many of the recurrent MLG, there were multiple clonal lineages derived from recombination. Isolates of both mating types were at a 1:1 ratio following clone correction in each field at each sampling period, which was suggestive of sexual recombination. No evidence of genetic divergence of isolates of each mating type was identified, indicating admixture within the population. Linkage equilibrium in two of the four field populations sampled in late winter could not be discounted following clone correction. Evaluation of temporal changes in gene and genotypic diversity identified that they were both similar for the two sampling periods despite an increased D. tanaceti isolation frequency in spring. Genetic differentiation was similar in populations sampled between the two sampling periods within fields or between fields. These results indicated that sexual reproduction may have contributed to tan spot epidemics within Australian pyrethrum fields and has contributed to a genetically diverse D. tanaceti population.

Mycoflora Associated With Pyrethrum Seed and the Integration of Seed Steam Treatment Into Foliar Disease Management Strategies

A complex of foliar diseases can affect pyrethrum in Australia, but those of greatest importance are ray blight, caused by Stagonosporopsis tanaceti, and tan spot, caused primarily by Didymella tanaceti. Isolation of fungi from pyrethrum seed lots produced over 15 years resulted in recovery of six known pathogens: S. tanaceti, D. tanaceti, Alternaria tenuissima, Colletotrichum tanaceti, Stemphylium botryosum, and Botrytis cinerea. The incidence of S. tanaceti and D. tanaceti isolated from seed varied between 0.9 and 19.5% (mean = 7.7%) and 0 and 24.1% (mean = 5.3%) among years, respectively. Commercial heat treatment of pyrethrum seed via steaming reduced the incidence of D. tanaceti from 10.9 to 0.06% and the incidence of S. tanaceti from 24.6% to nondetectable levels (<0.18%). In a second experiment, both species were reduced to nondetectable levels (<0.20%) from their initial incidences of 22.4 and 2.4%, respectively. In a field study in 2013, colonization of pyrethrum foliage by S. tanaceti was reduced from 21.1 to 14.3% in early winter when heat-treated seed was planted. However, isolation frequency of D. tanaceti was not affected significantly by seed treatment in this year. In a related experiment in 2015, the isolation frequency of D. tanaceti in plots planted from heat-treated seed depended on both prior application of an industry-standard fungicide program and proximity to another pyrethrum field in autumn. The fungus was recovered at a similar frequency in fungicide-treated and nontreated plots located near other pyrethrum fields (13.8 versus 16.3%, respectively), whereas recovery of the pathogen was reduced by fungicide applications in geographically remote pyrethrum fields (6.7 versus 1.4%, respectively). However, these differences in isolation frequency of D. tanaceti in autumn did not obviate the need for later fungicide applications to suppress foliar disease intensity in spring or flower yield in summer, independent of the proximity to other pyrethrum fields. This study suggests that steam treatment of seed can delay development of the foliar disease complex on pyrethrum, although an extremely low level of remaining infected seed or exogenous sources of inoculum necessitates the use of foliar fungicide applications in spring.

Paraphoma Crown Rot of Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium)

Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) is commercially cultivated for the extraction of natural pyrethrin insecticides from the oil glands inside seed. Yield decline has caused significant yield losses in Tasmania during the last decade. A new pathogen of pyrethrum causing crown rot and reduced growth of the plants in yield decline affected fields of northern Tasmania was isolated from necrotic crown tissue and described as Paraphoma vinacea. Multigene phylogenetic identification of the pathogen also revealed that P. vinacea was a new species different from other Paraphoma type strains. Glasshouse pathogenicity experiments showed that P. vinacea significantly reduced belowground and total biomass of pyrethrum plants 2 months after inoculation. Dull-tan to reddish-brown discoloration of the cortical and subcortical crown tissue was observed in 100% of the infected plants. P. vinacea infected 75% of the plants inoculated with root dip and soil drench inoculation techniques in an inoculation optimization experiment. P. vinacea, the causal agent of Paraphoma crown rot disease, represents an important pathogen that will negatively impact the commercial cultivation of pyrethrum in Tasmania.

Mating-Type Gene Structure and Spatial Distribution of Didymella tanaceti in Pyrethrum Fields

Tan spot of pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) is caused by the ascomycete Didymella tanaceti. To assess the evolutionary role of ascospores in the assumed asexual species, the structure and arrangement of mating-type (MAT) genes were examined. A single MAT1-1 or MAT1-2 idiomorph was identified in all isolates examined, indicating that the species is heterothallic. The idiomorphs were flanked upstream and downstream by regions encoding pyridoxamine phosphate oxidase-like and DNA lyase-like proteins, respectively. A multiplex MAT-specific polymerase chain reaction assay was developed and used to genotype 325 isolates collected within two transects in each of four fields in Tasmania, Australia. The ratio of isolates of each mating-type in each transect was consistent with a 1:1 ratio. The spatial distribution of the isolates of the two mating-types within each transect was random for all except one transect for MAT1-1 isolates, indicating that clonal patterns of each mating-type were absent. However, evidence of a reduced selection pressure on MAT1-1 isolates was observed, with a second haplotype of the MAT1-1-1 gene identified in 4.4% of MAT1-1 isolates. In vitro crosses between isolates with opposite mating-types failed to produce ascospores. Although the sexual morph could not be induced, the occurrence of both mating-types in equal frequencies suggested that a cryptic sexual mode of reproduction may occur within field populations.