Evidence for Sexual Reproduction: Identification, Frequency, and Spatial Distribution of Venturia effusa (Pecan Scab) Mating Type Idiomorphs

Transcriptome analysis under pecan scab infection reveals the molecular mechanisms of the defense response in pecans

Pecan scab, caused by the fungal pathogen Venturia effusa, is the most devastating disease of pecan (Carya illinoinensis) in the southeastern United States. Resistance to this pathogen is determined by a complex interaction between host genetics and disease pathotype with even field-susceptible cultivars being resistant to most scab isolates. To understand the underlying molecular mechanisms of scab resistance in pecan, we performed a transcriptome analysis of the pecan cultivar, 'Desirable', in response to inoculation with a pathogenic and a non-pathogenic scab isolate at three different time points (24, 48, and 96 hrs. post-inoculation). Differential gene expression and gene ontology enrichment analyses showed contrasting gene expression patterns and pathway enrichment in response to the contrasting isolates with varying pathogenicity. The weighted gene co-expression network analysis of differentially expressed genes detected 11 gene modules. Among them, two modules had significant enrichment of genes involved with defense responses. These genes were particularly upregulated in the resistant reaction at the early stage of fungal infection (24 h) compared to the susceptible reaction. Hub genes in these modules were predominantly related to receptor-like protein kinase activity, signal reception, signal transduction, biosynthesis and transport of plant secondary metabolites, and oxidoreductase activity. Results of this study suggest that the early response of pathogen-related signal transduction and development of cellular barriers against the invading fungus are likely defense mechanisms employed by pecan cultivars against non-virulent scab isolates. The transcriptomic data generated here provide the foundation for identifying candidate resistance genes in pecan against V. effusa and for exploring the molecular mechanisms of disease resistance.

Transcriptome profile of pecan scab resistant and susceptible trees from a pecan provenance collection

Pecan scab is a devastating disease that causes damage to pecan (Carya illinoinensis (Wangenh.) K. Koch) fruit and leaves. The disease is caused by the fungus Venturia effusa (G. Winter) and the main management practice for controlling the disease is by application of fungicides at 2-to-3-week intervals throughout the growing season. Besides disease-related yield loss, application of fungicides can result in considerable cost and increases the likelihood of fungicide resistance developing in the pathogen. Resistant cultivars are available for pecan growers; although, in several cases resistance has been overcome as the pathogen adapts to infect resistant hosts. Despite the importance of host resistance in scab management, there is little information regarding the molecular basis of genetic resistance to pecan scab.The purpose of this study was to elucidate mechanisms of natural pecan scab resistance by analyzing transcripts that are differentially expressed in pecan leaf samples from scab resistant and susceptible trees. The leaf samples were collected from trees in a provenance collection orchard that represents the natural range of pecan in the US and Mexico. Trees in the orchard have been exposed to natural scab infections since planting in 1989, and scab ratings were collected over three seasons. Based on this data, ten susceptible trees and ten resistant trees were selected for analysis. RNA-seq data was collected and analyzed for diseased and non-diseased parts of susceptible trees as well as for resistant trees. A total of 313 genes were found to be differentially expressed when comparing resistant and susceptible trees without disease. For susceptible samples showing scab symptoms, 1,454 genes were identified as differentially expressed compared to non-diseased susceptible samples. Many genes involved in pathogen recognition, defense responses, and signal transduction were up-regulated in diseased samples of susceptible trees, whereas differentially expressed genes in pecan scab resistant samples were generally down-regulated compared to non-diseased susceptible samples.Our results provide the first account of candidate genes involved in resistance/susceptibility to pecan scab under natural conditions in a pecan orchard. This information can be used to aid pecan breeding programs and development of biotechnology-based approaches for generating pecan cultivars with more durable scab resistance.

First Report of Scab Disease Caused by Venturia effusa on Pecan in Anhui Province of China

Pecan (Carya illinoinensis) is a world-famous nut tree which widely cultivated in China. Quanjiao County, located in Anhui province, is reputed to be the capital of pecan production in China. Since 2019, typical scab symptoms were observed on most pecan cultivars in orchards located in the regions of Quanjiao (32°5'7.08″ N, 118°16'2.91″ E). In April, dark brown to black lesions of scab could be observed on both the abaxial and adaxial surface of the lamina, and were often associated with the veins or midrib. In July, small, brownish, and circular lesions ranging from 1 to 2 mm in diameter were observed at the end of stems and shoulder of the fruit. In the surveyed orchards, disease incidence on the leaves reached more than 35%. While, according to the number of infected nut clusters, disease incidence ranged from 40 to 60% on the infected fruits. Using a sterilized scalpel, conidia were scraped from the surface of a single lesion from the infected leaves or fruits, and a dilute spore suspension was prepared in sterile distilled water, of which 100 microliters was spread on 1% water-agar plate (Bock et al. 2014). The conidia were incubated at 25°C for 48 h under fluorescent lights with a 12-hphotoperiod. Single germinated conidia were selected and transferred into potato dextrose agar (PDA) plate to obtain monospore isolates. From 2019 to 2020, more than 20 isolates were obtained from the infected leaves and fruits. Incubated at 24°C for 6 weeks in darkness on PDA, the colonies were gray-black with circular morphology and floccose texture, which were consistent with the characteristics of Venturia effusa described previously (Gottwald 1982). The conidia were pyriform to ellipsoid, zero to one septate, smooth, attenuated towards apex and base, base truncate, pale brown and 10.08 to 18.14 × 4.86 to 9.56 μm (n = 50) in size. To further identify the isolates, the regions of internal transcribed spacer (ITS), beta-tubulin 2 (TUB2) and translation elongation factor 1 alpha (EF1-a) were amplified and sequenced from genomic DNA for the three representative isolates (AH-81 and AH-82 from the infected leaves, and AH-41 from the infected fruits), respectively (White et al. 1990; Young et al. 2018; Bensch et al. 2006). Sequences of them were deposited in GenBank under nos. OP199056 to OP199058 (ITS), OP566581 to OP566583 (TUB2) and OP566578 to OP566580 (EF1-a). Multilocus phylogenetic analysis revealed that three isolates and V. effusa were clustered in the same clade, indicating high genetic similarity between these organisms. Their morphological and molecular characteristics were consistent with those for V. effusa. The pathogenicity of three isolates were tested on two-year-old container-grown pecan seedlings, which were grown in the nursery. The conidial suspension with a concentration of 5 × 105 conidia/ml was sprayed evenly on the surface of leaves of a healthy pecan seedling, and each isolate inoculated four pecan seedlings. The pathogenicity experiment was repeated three times. The plants inoculated with sterile water were used a negative control. The inoculated plants were enclosed in plastic bags for 2 days, and kept in the nursery greenhouse. Four weeks after inoculation, a similar symptom of scab was observed on leaves of cultivar Mahan, and V. effusa was isolated again from inoculated leaves with the frequency of 100% by the single-spore isolation, whereas no symptoms were observed on the control plants. To our knowledge, this is the first report of V. effusa as a scab pathogen on pecan in Anhui Province of China and underscores the need for monitoring this disease and developing disease control strategies to prevent severe reduction in the value of fruit. References: Bensch, K., et al. 2006. Studies in Mycology, 55(1): 299-305. Bock, C. H., et al. 2014. Forest Pathology, 44(4): 266-275. Gottwald, T. R. 1982. Taxonomy of the pecan scab fungus Cladosporium caryigenum. Mycologia. 74 (3), 382-390. White, T. T., et al. 1990. Page 315 in: PCR Protocols: A Guide to Methods and Application. Academic Press, San Diego, CA. Young, C. A., et al. 2018. Phytopathology, 108(7): 837-846. The author(s) declare no conflict of interest. Keywords: Venturia effusa, Scab, Pecan, Identification †Indicates the corresponding author.Y. Q. Zhao; zhaoyuqiang123@126.com.

Population Genetic Characteristics and Mating Type Frequency of Venturia effusa from Pecan in South America

Scab, caused by the plant-pathogenic fungus Venturia effusa, is a major disease of pecan in South America, resulting in loss of quantity and quality of nut yield. Characteristics of the populations of V. effusa in South America are unknown. We used microsatellites to describe the genetic diversity and population structure of V. effusa in South America, and determined the mating type status of the pathogen. The four hierarchically sampled orchard populations from Argentina (AR), Brazil (BRC and BRS), and Uruguay (UR) had moderate to high genotypic and gene diversity. There was evidence of population differentiation (F_st = 0.196) but the correlation between geographic distance and genetic distance was not statistically significant. Genetic differentiation was minimal between the UR, BRC, and BRS populations, and these populations were more clearly differentiated from the AR population. The MAT1-1 and MAT1-2 mating types occurred in all four orchards and their frequencies did not deviate from the 1:1 ratio expected under random mating; however, multilocus linkage equilibrium was rejected in three of the four populations. The population genetics of South American populations of V. effusa has many similarities to the population genetics of V. effusa previously described in the United States. Characterizing the populations genetics and reproductive systems of V. effusa are important to establish the evolutionary potential of the pathogen and, thus, its adaptability-and can provide a basis for informed approaches to utilizing available host resistance and determining phytosanitary needs.

Multiple Mutations and Overexpression in the CYP51A and B Genes Lead to Decreased Sensitivity of Venturia effusa to Tebuconazole

Multiple demethylation-inhibiting (DMI) fungicides are used to control pecan scab, caused by Venturia effusa. To compare the efficacy of various DMI fungicides on V. effusa, field trials were conducted at multiple locations applying fungicides to individual pecan terminals. In vitro assays were conducted to test the sensitivity of V. effusa isolates from multiple locations to various concentrations of tebuconazole. Both studies confirmed high levels of resistance to tebuconazole. To investigate the mechanism of resistance, two copies of the CYP51 gene, CYP51A and CYP51B, of resistant and sensitive isolates were sequenced and scanned for mutations. In the CYP51A gene, mutation at codon 444 (G444D), and in the CYP51B gene, mutations at codon 357 (G357H) and 177 (I77T/I77L) were found in resistant isolates. Expression analysis of CYP51A and CYP51B revealed enhanced expression in the resistant isolates compared to the sensitive isolates. There were 3.0- and 1.9-fold increases in gene expression in the resistant isolates compared to the sensitive isolates for the CYP51A and CYP51B genes, respectively. Therefore, two potential mechanisms—multiple point mutations and gene over expression in the CYP51 gene of V. effusa isolates—were revealed as likely reasons for the observed resistance in isolates of V. effusa to tebuconazole.

Genetic Diversity and Population Structure of Phyllosticta citriasiana in China

Phyllosticta citriasiana is the causal agent of citrus tan spot, an important pomelo disease in Asia. At present, there is little or no information on the epidemiology or population structure of P. citriasiana. By using simple sequence repeat markers, we analyzed 94 isolates from three pomelo production regions in southern and southeastern China. The analyses showed high genetic diversity in each of the three geographic populations. A STRUCTURE analysis revealed two genetic clusters among the 94 isolates; one geographic population was dominated by genotypes in one cluster, and the other two geographic populations were dominated by genotypes of the second cluster. P. citriasiana has a heterothallic mating system with two idiomorphs, MAT1-1 and MAT1-2. Analyses using mating type-specific primers revealed that both mating types were present in all three geographic populations, and in all three populations the mating type ratios were in equilibrium. Although the sexual stage of the fungus has not been discovered yet, analyses of allelic associations indicated evidence for sexual and asexual reproduction within and between populations. Despite the observed genetic differentiation between the three geographic populations, evidence for long-distance gene flow was found.

Mating Type Idiomorphs, Heterothallism, and High Genetic Diversity in Venturia carpophila, Cause of Peach Scab

Scab (caused by Venturia carpophila) is a major disease affecting peach in the eastern United States. The aims of the study were to characterize the mating-type loci in V. carpophila, determine whether they are in equilibrium, and assess the population genetic diversity and structure of the pathogen. The mating-type gene MAT1-1-1 was identified in isolate JP3-5 in an available genome sequence, and the MAT1-2-1 gene was PCR amplified from isolate PS1-1, thus indicating a heterothallic structure. Mating-type loci structures were consistent with those of other Venturia spp. (V. effusa and V. inaequalis): the mating-type gene is positioned between APN2 encoding a DNA lyase and a gene encoding a Pleckstrin homology domain. Primers designed to each of the mating-type genes and a reference gene TUB2 were used as a multiplex PCR to screen a population (n = 81) of V. carpophila from various locations in the eastern United States. Mating types in five of the nine populations studied were in equilibrium. Among the 81 isolates, there were 69 multilocus genotypes. A population genetic analysis of the populations with >10 individuals (four populations) showed them to be genetically diverse. Linkage disequilibrium was found in five of nine populations with ≥4 isolates. A discriminant analysis of principal components indicated three genetic clusters, although extensive admixture was observed. Mating-type identification in V. carpophila provides a basis for understanding reproductive methods of the pathogen and can be a basis for further studies of the genetics of the peach scab pathogen.

Fungicide Resistance in Venturia effusa, Cause of Pecan Scab: Current Status and Practical Implications

Pecan scab, caused by Venturia effusa, is the most economically damaging disease of pecan in the southeastern United States, and annual epidemics are most effectively managed through multiple fungicide applications. The fungicide applications can be the single greatest operating cost for commercial growers and the return on that investment is impacted by fungicide resistance. V. effusa produces multiple generations of conidia per season, exhibits substantial genetic diversity, overwinters as stromata in the tree, and is under immense selection from the applied fungicides, all of which lead to a high risk for developing fungicide resistance. Since the mid-1970s, resistance or reduced sensitivity has been observed in isolates of V. effusa to the methyl benzimidazole carbamates, demethylation inhibitors, quinone outside inhibitors, organotin compounds, and the guanidines. Over the last 10 years, several studies have been conducted that have improved both scab management and fungicide resistance management in V. effusa. The aim of this review is to summarize recent developments in our understanding of fungicide resistance in V. effusa in the context of scab management in southeastern pecan orchards. The history, modes of action, general use of the labeled fungicides, and mechanisms and stability of fungicide resistance in V. effusa are discussed; conclusions and future research priorities are also presented.

First description of the sexual stage of Venturia effusa, causal agent of pecan scab

Pecan scab, caused by Venturia effusa, is the most prevalent disease of pecan in the southeastern United States. Recent characterization of the mating type (MAT) distribution of V. effusa revealed that the MAT idiomorphs are in equilibrium at various spatial scales, indicative of regular sexual recombination. However, the occurrence of the sexual stage of V. effusa has never been observed, and the pathogen was previously considered to rely entirely on asexual reproduction. We were able to generate the sexual stage by pairing isolates of opposite mating types on oatmeal culture media. Cultures were incubated at 24 C for 2 mo to allow hyphae from isolates of each mating type to interact. Culture plates were then incubated at 4 C for 4 mo, after which immature pseudothecia were observed. Following exposure to a 12-h photoperiod for 2 wk at 24 C, asci and ascospores readily developed. Pseudothecium and ascospore production was optimal when incubated for 4 mo at 4 C. We utilized progeny from a cross of an albino isolate and wild-type (melanized) isolates to determine that recombination had occurred. Multilocus genotyping using 32 microsatellite markers confirmed that progeny were the result of recombination, which was further supported by segregation of mating types and culture pigmentation. Albino progeny were all confirmed to contain the same mutation in the polyketide synthase (PKS1) melanin biosynthesis gene as the albino parent. The results of this study demonstrate the heterothallic nature of V. effusa. The impact of determining the source of the overwintering ascostroma will aid in management decisions to reduce the primary inoculum in the disease cycle.

Chromosome-Level Reference Genome of Venturia effusa, Causative Agent of Pecan Scab

Pecan scab, caused by Venturia effusa, is a devastating disease of pecan (Carya illinoinensis), which results in economic losses on susceptible cultivars throughout the southeastern United States. To enhance our understanding of pathogenicity in V. effusa, we have generated a complete telomere-to-telomere reference genome of V. effusa isolate FRT5LL7-Albino. By combining Illumina MiSeq and Oxford Nanopore MinION data, we assembled a 45.2-Mb genome represented by 20 chromosomes and containing 10,820 putative genes, of which 7,619 have at least one functional annotation. The likely causative mutation of the albino phenotype was identified as a single base insertion and a resulting frameshift in the gene encoding the polyketide synthase ALM1. This genome represents the first full chromosome-level assembly of any Venturia sp.

Assessing Fitness Costs and Phenotypic Instability of Fentin Hydroxide and Tebuconazole Resistance in Venturia effusa

Sensitivity monitoring of Venturia effusa, cause of pecan scab, has revealed insensitivity to fentin hydroxide and tebuconazole, but recent research indicates that the insensitivity to fentin hydroxide is not stable. A study was undertaken to determine if a fitness cost may be responsible for this instability. In this study, experiments were conducted to evaluate fitness components and phenotypic stability of insensitivity of V. effusa to fentin hydroxide and tebuconazole. Conidial production, conidial germination, microcolony growth, sensitivity to osmotic stress, and sensitivity to oxidative stress in the absence of fungicide were compared for isolates with differing sensitivities to both fungicides. Percent conidial germination decreased linearly with increasing fentin hydroxide insensitivity, and microcolony growth on 1.0 mM H₂O₂ decreased linearly with increasing tebuconazole insensitivity. Stability of resistance was assessed on concentrations of 1.0, 3.0, and 10 µg/ml of both fungicides prior to and after five transfers on non-fungicide-amended medium. Tebuconazole insensitivity was stable after transfers, but fentin hydroxide insensitivity on 1.0 and 3.0 µg/ml decreased significantly after transfers, indicating instability. Here we provide evidence that in V. effusa tebuconazole insensitivity is stable and fentin hydroxide insensitivity is not. These results suggest that fentin-hydroxide-resistant V. effusa isolates have reduced conidial viability compared with sensitive isolates, which may allow the population to regain sensitivity in the absence of this frequently used fungicide.

Population Genome Sequencing of the Scab Fungal Species Venturia inaequalis, Venturia pirina, Venturia aucupariae and Venturia asperata

The Venturia genus comprises fungal species that are pathogens on Rosaceae host plants, including V. inaequalis and V. asperata on apple, V. aucupariae on sorbus and V. pirina on pear. Although the genetic structure of V. inaequalis populations has been investigated in detail, genomic features underlying these subdivisions remain poorly understood. Here, we report whole genome sequencing of 87 Venturia strains that represent each species and each population within V. inaequalis. We present a PacBio genome assembly for the V. inaequalis EU-B04 reference isolate. The size of selected genomes was determined by flow cytometry, and varied from 45 to 93 Mb. Genome assemblies of V. inaequalis and V. aucupariae contain a high content of transposable elements (TEs), most of which belong to the Gypsy or Copia LTR superfamilies and have been inactivated by Repeat-Induced Point mutations. The reference assembly of V. inaequalis presents a mosaic structure of GC-equilibrated regions that mainly contain predicted genes and AT-rich regions, mainly composed of TEs. Six pairs of strains were identified as clones. Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) analysis between these clones revealed a high number of SNPs that are mostly located in AT-rich regions due to misalignments and allowed determining a false discovery rate. The availability of these genome sequences is expected to stimulate genetics and population genomics research of Venturia pathogens. Especially, it will help understanding the evolutionary history of Venturia species that are pathogenic on different hosts, a history that has probably been substantially influenced by TEs.

Fine-Scale Population Genetic Structure and Within-Tree Distribution of Mating Types of Venturia effusa, Cause of Pecan Scab in the United States

Scab (caused by Venturia effusa) is the major disease of pecan in the southeastern United States. There is no information available on the fine-scale population genetic diversity or the occurrence of clonal types at small spatial scales that provides insight into inoculum sources and dispersal mechanisms, and potential opportunity for sexual reproduction. To investigate fine-scale genetic diversity, four trees of cultivar Wichita (populations) were sampled hierarchically: within each tree canopy, four approximately evenly spaced terminals (subpopulations) were selected and up to six leaflets (sub-subpopulations) were sampled from different compound leaves on each terminal. All lesions (n = 1 to 8) on each leaflet were sampled. The isolates were screened against a panel of 29 informative microsatellite markers and the resulting multilocus genotypes (MLG) subject to analysis. Mating type was also determined for each isolate. Of 335 isolates, there were 165 MLG (clonal fraction 49.3%). Nei's unbiased measure of genetic diversity for the clone-corrected data were moderate to high (0.507). An analysis of molecular variance demonstrated differentiation (P = 0.001) between populations on leaflets within individual terminals and between terminals within trees in the tree canopies, with 93.8% of variance explained among isolates within leaflet populations. Other analyses (minimum-spanning network, Bayesian, and discriminant analysis of principal components) all indicated little affinity of isolate for source population. Of the 335 isolates, most unique MLG were found at the stratum of the individual leaflets (n = 242), with similar total numbers of unique MLG observed at the strata of the terminal (n = 170), tree (n = 166), and orchard (n = 165). Thus, the vast majority of shared clones existed on individual leaflets on a terminal at the scale of 10s of centimeters or less, indicating a notable component of short-distance dispersal. There was significant linkage disequilibrium (P < 0.001), and an analysis of P_sex showed that where there were multiple encounters of an MLG, they were most probably the result of asexual reproduction (P < 0.05) but there was no evidence that asexual reproduction was involved in single or first encounters of an MLG (P > 0.05). Overall, the MAT1-1-1 and MAT1-2-1 idiomorphs were at equilibrium (73:92) and in most populations, subpopulations, and sub-subpopulations. Both mating types were frequently observed on the same leaflet. The results provide novel information on the characteristics of populations of V. effusa at fine spatial scales, and provide insights into the dispersal of the organism within and between trees. The proximity of both mating idiomorphs on single leaflets is further evidence of opportunity for development of the sexual stage in the field.