Episcleral plaque thermoradiotherapy of posterior uveal melanomas

Episcleral plaque 125I radiotherapy with episcleral LCF hyperthermia: a prospective randomized trial

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to search for an optimal radiation dose in the treatment of patients with uveal melanoma using 125I episcleral plaque radiotherapy (EPRT) and episcleral hyperthermia (HT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From 1991-1998, 35 patients with uveal melanoma were enrolled in a phase II prospective randomized trial of 125I EPRT combined with episcleral HT. Two groups were closely matched for pre-treatment patient and tumor characteristics. Group 1: N = 16, and Group 2: N = 19. The median dose to the tumor apex for Group 1 was 80.0 Gy and 60.8 Gy for Group 2. Episcleral HT was given once for 45 min immediately prior to EPRT with a median temperature of 44 degrees C for both groups. The median follow-up was 5.5 years for Group 1 and 5.3 years for Group 2.

RESULTS

The median tumor height decreased 1.7 mm for patients of both groups. The 5- and 8-year probability of local recurrence was 33% for Group 1, and 25% for Group 2, p = 0.73. The 5-year probability of DFS was 54% for Group 1 and 67% for Group 2, p = 0.51. The 5- and 8-year overall survival was 68% and 34%, respectively, for Group 1, and 83% and 50%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.60. The rate of distant metastasis at 5- and 8-years for Group 1 was 29% and 62%, respectively, and 17% and 17%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.18. The incidence of enucleation was 4 (25%) in Group 1 vs. 4 (22%) in Group 2. The incidence of late complications was similar in either treatment group. The ambulatory visual acuity (> 5/200) at last follow-up was slightly better in Group 2 (80%) than Group 1 (64%).

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment outcomes were similar despite a 25% difference in radiation dose. In view of these findings and in an attempt to reduce the incidence of late treatment toxicity a still lower radiation dose in combination with HT needs to be studied. The reported outcomes need to be evaluated with caution due to the small number of patients in this study.

Thermotherapy in the management of choroidal melanoma

During the past 20 years of enucleation, which was the standard treatment for choroidal melanoma over more than a century, has largely been replaced by eye salvaging therapies such as radiotherapy or local resection. In 1995 transpupillary thermotherapy (TTT) using an infrared diode laser was introduced as a new conservative therapy for patients with choroidal melanoma. TTT can be defined as a heat treatment modality, which is delivered through a dilated pupil to the tumour surface. The technique uses a wide diode laser beam diameter with a low irradiance and a long exposure time. TTT induces tumour necrosis at sub-photocoagulation levels by a direct cell destructive effect with only a few ocular complications. TTT can be performed as sole therapy or combined with plaque radiotherapy, thus permitting a lower radiation dose. For amelanotic tumours dye-enhanced TTT with indocyanine green can be used. In this paper we review the role of sole or combined TTT, related to the current other treatment modalities for choroidal melanoma.

Tumour location affects the incidence of cataract and retinopathy after ophthalmic plaque radiation therapy

AIM

To examine how tumour location affects ocular morbidity after ophthalmic plaque radiotherapy for uveal melanoma.

METHODS

69 eyes were irradiated and followed for a mean 42 months. There were 23 anterior uveal melanomas and 46 were posterior to the equator. Anterior and posterior tumours had similar basal dimensions. Their mean apical heights were 4.8 mm (anterior) and 3.5 mm (posterior) which received a mean 88 Gy and 83.4 Gy respectively.

RESULTS

Only one patient (4%) plaqued for an anterior uveal melanoma developed secondary retinopathy (cystoid macular oedema). In contrast, 24 (52%) of the posterior choroidal melanoma patients developed retinopathy (p value <0.0001). Cataract developed in 18 (86%) eyes with phakic anterior tumour compared with seven (17%) eyes with posterior tumours (p value <0.0000). No posterior nasal tumours lost more than two lines of vision though 45% developed retinopathy.

CONCLUSION

While plaque radiation of anterior melanomas is more likely to cause reversible vision loss secondary to cataract, treatment of posterior tumours is more likely to be associated with irreversible loss because of retinopathy. Nasal location is also protective against severe loss of vision.