An isolated, antegrade, perfused, peroneal nerve anterior tibialis muscle model in the rat: a novel model developed to study the factors governing the time course of action of neuromuscular blocking agents

Simulation of the kinetics of neuromuscular block: implications for speed of onset

BACKGROUND

The onset time for paralysis varies 3-fold among nondepolarizing muscle relaxants. Possible explanations include: (a) pharmacokinetic differences among drugs and (b) buffering of drug molecules by acetylcholine receptors as they diffuse into the neuromuscular junction. Although some pharmacokinetic models consider buffered diffusion, these models do not account for either the high density of receptors or synapse geometry. Here, I used computer simulations to calculate the kinetics of buffered diffusion. The goal was to determine the conditions under which buffered diffusion could account for differences in onset time among nondepolarizing muscle relaxants.

METHODS

Monte Carlo simulation was used along with a realistic 3-dimensional model of the rat neuromuscular junction. Simulations determined the time dependence of the number of drug-bound receptors. A 1000-fold range of drug potency was examined. In some simulations, the drug concentration outside the junction was changed instantaneously. In other simulations, the concentration changed according to predictions of pharmacokinetic models assuming time-dependent changes in plasma drug concentration. The rate constant for equilibration of drug between plasma and muscle, keo, was varied between 0.15 and 0.6 min(-1). Twitch amplitude was calculated from receptor occupancy assuming a high safety margin for neuromuscular transmission. Some simulations used a synaptic model with an increased nerve-muscle contact width.

RESULTS

Simulations with instantaneous changes in drug concentration at the synapse, indicated that the time to 50% twitch depression (onset time) was 0.1 to 30 seconds and was proportional to drug potency. This corresponds to iontophoretic application of drug to isolated neuromuscular junctions, but is too fast to explain onset times in humans. When pharmacokinetic models were used to calculate the drug concentration outside the synapse, buffered diffusion increased onset times of potent drugs (drugs for which the effective concentration at 50% twitch height is <600 nM). Simulations using keo = 0.6 min(-1) and a model with a 2- to 3-fold wider nerve-muscle contact width indicated that buffered diffusion could account for the differences in clinical onset times among the nondepolarizing muscle relaxants.

CONCLUSION

Monte Carlo simulation provides a biophysically appropriate way to incorporate buffered diffusion into pharmacokinetic modeling. The simulations indicated that buffered diffusion could account for differences in onset time among drugs. However, a better understanding of the geometry of the human neuromuscular junction is needed before the magnitude of the effect of buffered diffusion can be quantified.

Early and late parameters describing the offset of neuromuscular blockade are highly intercorrelated

BACKGROUND

Neuromuscular blocking agents have always shown wide inter-individual variability when it comes to their duration of action. This prevents clinicians from anticipating the evolution of the neuromuscular block for any given patient. With this study, we aimed to assess the nature of the relationships existing between different time course parameters used to describe paralysis onset and offset.

METHODS

Sixty American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) score III-IV anaesthetised patients were randomised to receive a single equipotent dose (2ED95) of either rocuronium, mivacurium or atracurium. We used acceleromyography to monitor neuromuscular transmission. We described the relationships between the time-interval measurements of: onset, the first response (T1) reappearance, T1 25% of control, train-of-four ratio 0.25 and 0.75. Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated.

RESULTS

We found no significant relationships between onset and any of the four parameters used to describe the offset. On the other hand, we showed strong and highly significant linear relationships between all the parameters describing the offset for each of the muscle relaxants studied (correlation coefficients ranging from 0.850 to 0.992).

CONCLUSIONS

We evidenced strong linear correlations between the four offset time course parameters of spontaneous recovery after a single neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs) bolus. Such relationships open up new clinical perspectives concerning quantitative neuromuscular transmission monitoring: the scope of individual valuable anticipation of the patient's recovery.

Is time to peak effect of neuromuscular blocking agents dependent on dose? Testing the concept of buffered diffusion

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

For neuromuscular blocking agents, an inverse relationship between potency and time to peak effect has been observed. To test the hypothesis that this relationship is due to buffered diffusion, we investigated the influence of dose on time to peak effect. Pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic simulations were performed to support the expected relationships between potency, dose, peak effect and time to peak effect.

METHODS

Pigs (20-28 kg body weight) were anaesthetized with ketamine and midazolam, followed by pentobarbital and fentanyl intravenously. Neuromuscular block was measured by stimulating the peroneal nerve supramaximally at 0.1 Hz and measuring the response of the tibialis anterior muscle mechanomyographically. After an initial dose to establish the individual ED90 of a neuromuscular blocking agent (rocuronium, vecuronium, pipecuronium or d-tubocurarine), five different doses of the same compound were administered to each animal, aiming at 20%, 40%, 60%, 75% or 90% block, in a random order. Doses were given 45 min after complete recovery of the twitch response.

RESULTS

For rocuronium and pipecuronium, time to peak effect increased with dose, whereas dose did not affect time to peak effect of vecuronium and d-tubocurarine. Simulations predict that time to peak effect decreases with dose if buffered diffusion is taken into account.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that buffered diffusion does not play a dominant role in the time to peak effect of neuromuscular blocking agents. Therefore it is unlikely that the observed inverse relationship between potency and time to peak effect of neuromuscular blocking agents in the clinical range is due to buffered diffusion.

Onset-potency relationship of nondepolarizing muscle relaxants: a reexamination using simulations

Nondepolarizing muscle relaxants (MRs) display an inverse onset-potency relationship, that is, less potent MRs display a more rapid onset. We have conducted the current investigation to estimate the impact of variable pharmacokinetic or pharmacodynamic properties of the MRs on potency and onset time, and on the onset-potency relationship. Using a model of neuromuscular transmission, we changed either the affinity of MRs for the postsynaptic receptors or the pharmacokinetic properties of the MRs. The elimination rate constant, k(10), which defines the systemic clearance, was assigned one of 9 values and the transport rate constant, k(12), one of 5 values. The transport rate constant into the effect compartment was constant (k(e1) = 0.2 min(-1)). Only one parameter was altered at a time. With constant pharmacokinetics, a 100-fold decrease in affinity caused a proportional decrease in potency, but little change (0.02 min) in onset time. With constant affinity, increasing the clearance from 1 to 250 mL x kg(-1) x min(-1) shortened the onset time from 7.2 to 0.7 min and decreased the potency 12-fold. In a double logarithmic plot, the onset-potency relationship was linear. Lesser affinities produce a nearly parallel rightward shift of the regression lines. The inverse onset-potency relationship may be explained by the pharmacokinetic factors producing changes in both the potency and onset times.

Keuskamp and the Amsterdam Infant Ventilator

At the First International Symposium on the History of Modern Anaesthesia (1982), Professor Keuskamp mentioned that the introduction of breathing machines for lung ventilation during operations had taken over 'the tiresome handwork of ventilation'. This paper traces some aspects of Keuskamp's professional career and his role in the development of the Amsterdam Infant Ventilator. In 1974, Urban and Weitzner from the State University of New York reported that the ventilator was a reliable and effective constant-volume paediatric ventilator. Other clinicians from the United States and Europe echoed this satisfactory clinical evaluation. At present, this paediatric ventilator is still in use for the initial ventilation of small infants and for the mechanical ventilation of different animal species in a variety of experimental settings.

Decreased number of acetylcholine receptors is the mechanism that alters the time course of muscle relaxants in myasthenia gravis

BACKGROUND

In myasthenic patients, the time course of action of non-depolarizing neuromuscular blocking agents is prolonged and the sensitivity is increased. We used our antegrade perfused rat peroneal nerve anterior tibialis muscle model to investigate if this altered time course of effect and sensitivity can be explained by the decreased acetylcholine receptor concentration that is caused by the disease.

METHODS

Functional acetylcholine receptors were reduced by administration of alpha-bungarotoxin or by injecting monoclonal antibodies against rat acetylcholine receptors (experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis). After induction of anaesthesia, the model was set up and perfusion of the tibialis anterior muscle with blood was started. After stabilization of the twitch, rocuronium or pancuronium were infused until 90% block was obtained. Twitch data and infusion data were recorded and used to calculate the time course of effect and potency.

RESULTS

The potency of neuromuscular blocking agents was increased and the offset of the neuromuscular block was prolonged in both the alpha-bungarotoxin groups and the experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis groups compared to controls.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that the increased sensitivity to neuromuscular-blocking agents in myasthenia gravis can be accounted for by a decreased number of acetylcholine receptors. It also shows that the antegrade perfused rat peroneal nerve anterior tibialis muscle model is a suitable model to study the effects of myasthenia gravis on the time course of effect of neuromuscular blocking agents.