Dermal fibroblasts genetically engineered to release nerve growth factor

Standardized criterion to analyze and directly compare various materials and models for peripheral nerve regeneration

Progress in understanding conditions for optimal peripheral nerve regeneration has been stunted due to lack of standardization of experimental conditions and assays. In this paper we review the large database that has been generated using the Lundborg nerve chamber model and compare various theories for their ability to explain the experimental data. Data were normalized based on systematic use of the critical axon elongation, the gap length at which the probability of axon reconnection between the stumps is just 50%. Use of this criterion has led to a rank-ordering of devices or treatments and has led, in turn, to conclusions about the conditions that facilitate regeneration. Experimental configurations that have maximized facilitation of peripheral nerve regeneration are those in which the tube wall comprised degradable polymers, including collagen and certain synthetic biodegradable polymers, and was cell-permeable rather than protein-permeable. Tube fillings that showed very high regenerative activity were suspensions of Schwann cells, a solution either of acidic or basic fibroblast growth factor, insoluble ECM substrates rather than solutions or gels, polyamide filaments oriented along the tube axis and highly porous, insoluble analogs of the ECM with specific structure and controlled degradation rate. It is suggested that the data are best explained by postulating that the quality of regeneration depends on two critical processes. The first is compression of stumps and regenerating nerve by a thick myofibroblast layer that surrounds these tissues and blocks synthesis of a nerve of large diameter (pressure cuff theory). The second is synthesis of linear columns of Schwann cells that serve as tracks for axon elongation (basement membrane microtube theory). It is concluded that experimental configurations that show high regenerative activity suppress the first process while facilitating the second.

Evidence of innervation following extracellular matrix scaffold-mediated remodelling of muscular tissues

Naturally occurring porcine-derived extracellular matrix (ECM) has successfully been used as a biological scaffold material for site-specific reconstruction of a wide variety of tissues. The site-specific remodelling process includes rapid degradation of the scaffold, with concomitant recruitment of mononuclear, endothelial and bone marrow-derived cells, and can lead to the formation of functional skeletal and smooth muscle tissue. However, the temporal and spatial patterns of innervation of the remodelling scaffold material in muscular tissues are not well understood. A retrospective study was conducted to investigate the presence of nervous tissue in a rat model of abdominal wall reconstruction and a canine model of oesophageal reconstruction in which ECM scaffolds were used as inductive scaffolds. Evidence of mature nerve, immature nerve and Schwann cells was found within the remodelled ECM at 28 days in the rat body wall model, and at 91 days post surgery in a canine model of oesophageal repair. Additionally, a microscopic and morphological study that investigated the response of primary cultured neurons seeded upon an ECM scaffold showed that neuronal survival and outgrowth were supported by the ECM substrate. Finally, matricryptic peptides resulting from rapid degradation of the ECM scaffold induced migration of terminal Schwann cells in a concentration-dependent fashion in vitro. The findings of this study suggest that the reconstruction of tissues in which innervation is an important functional component is possible with the use of biological scaffolds composed of extracellular matrix.

Herpes simplex virus-thymidine kinase-based suicide gene therapy as a "molecular switch off" for nerve growth factor production in vitro

Tissue-engineered constructs offer a new hope to patients suffering from functional impairment after nerve injury. An effort has been made to focus on delivery, regulation, and "molecular shutoff" of nerve growth factor (NGF) in tissue-engineered constructs. We have previously demonstrated that human embryonic kidney (HEK-293) cells can be genetically modified to secrete NGF at varying time points upon up regulation with Ponasterone A (PonA) both in vitro and in vivo. In the present study, HEK-293 cells that stably and inducibly produce NGF were further stably transfected with herpes simplex virus-thymidine kinase gene as a suicide gene (hNGF-EcR-293-TK) in order to shut off the NGF secretion and kill the cells upon treatment with ganciclovir (GCV). These cells following induction with PonA secreted NGF levels of 6659.2 +/- 489.4 pg/mL at day 10 postbooster dose at day 5, which was significantly higher than the control noninduced cells. The NGF secreted by these cells was bioactive as determined by a rat adrenal pheochromocytoma (PC-12) cell bioassay. Treatment of these cells with GCV significantly reduced the NGF levels to 645.3 +/- 16.2 pg/mL at day 10 and live cell numbers dropped to 7.95 x 10(3) +/- 278 compared to 2.73 x 10(5) +/- 6.1 x 10(4). GCV-treated cell media when transferred to the PC-12 cell bioassay demonstrated less than 10% cells differentiating into neurite-like extensions. We conclude that hNGF-EcR-293-TK cells can inducibly secrete bioactive NGF when treated with the inducing agent and can also be killed upon treatment with GCV. This double-gene transfection for gene expression and molecular shutoff mechanism will be a useful tool in tissue-engineered nerve constructs.

Gene transfer strategies in tissue engineering

Aiming for regeneration of severed or lost parts of the body, the combined application of gene therapy and tissue engineering has received much attention by regenerative medicine. Techniques of molecular biology can enhance the regenerative potential of a biomaterial by co-delivery of therapeutic genes, and several different strategies have been used to achieve that goal. Possibilities for application are many-fold and have been investigated to regenerate tissues such as skin, cartilage, bone, nerve, liver, pancreas and blood vessels. This review discusses advantages and problems encountered with the different gene delivery strategies as far as they relate to tissue engineering, analyses the positive aspects of polymeric gene delivery from matrices and discusses advances and future challenges of gene transfer strategies in selected tissues.

Tissue engineered nerve constructs: where do we stand?

Driven by enormous clinical need, interest in peripheral nerve regeneration has become a prime focus of research and area of growth within the field of tissue engineering. While using autologous donor nerves for bridging peripheral defects remains today's gold standard, it remains associated with high donor site morbidity and lack of full recovery. This dictates research towards the development of biomimetic constructs as alternatives. Based on current concepts, this review summarizes various approaches including different extracellular matrices, scaffolds, and growth factors that have been shown to promote migration and proliferation of Schwann cells. Since neither of these concepts in isolation is enough, although each is gaining increased interest to promote nerve regeneration, various combinations will need to be identified to strike a harmonious balance. Additional factors that must be incorporated into tissue engineered nerve constructs are also unknown and warrant further research efforts. It seems that future directions may allow us to determine the "missing link".

La réparation nerveuse périphérique : 30 siècles de recherche

INTRODUCTION

Nerve injury compromises sensory and motor functions. Techniques of peripheral nerve repair are based on our knowledge regarding regeneration. Microsurgical techniques introduced in the late 1950s and widely developed for the past 20 years have improved repairs. However, functional recovery following a peripheral mixed nerve injury is still incomplete.

STATE OF ART

Good motor and sensory function after nerve injury depends on the reinnervation of the motor end plates and sensory receptors. Nerve regeneration does not begin if the cell body has not survived the initial injury or if it is unable to initiate regeneration. The regenerated axons must reach and reinnervate the appropriate target end-organs in a timely fashion. Recovery of motor function requires a critical number of motor axons reinnervating the muscle fibers. Sensory recovery is possible if the delay in reinnervation is short. Many additional factors influence the success of nerve repair or reconstruction. The timing of the repair, the level of injury, the extent of the zone of injury, the technical skill of the surgeon, and the method of repair and reconstruction contribute to the functional outcome after nerve injury.

CONCLUSION

This review presents the recent advances in understanding of neural regeneration and their application to the management of primary repairs and nerve gaps.

In vivo induction and delivery of nerve growth factor, using HEK-293 cells

Tissue-engineering strategies offer hope to patients facing functional impairment after nerve injury. We have previously demonstrated that HEK-293 cells can release nerve growth factor (NGF) in vitro, using an inducible system of expression. In this study, our objective was to assess the efficacy of the NGF delivery system in vivo, using nude rats. HEK-293 cells were transfected with human NGF cDNA. Ponasterone A (PonA) was used as the inducing agent. NGF collection chambers were implanted subcutaneously in nude rats. Sealed chambers were filled with one of the following: (1) DMEM, (2) untransfected 293 cells (EcR-293) plus PonA, (3) untransfected EcR-293 without PonA, (4) transfected 293 cells (hNGF-EcR-293) plus PonA, or (5) transfected hNGF-EcR-293 without PonA. Chambers were aspirated 24, 48, and 120 h postimplantation. NGF secretion was analyzed in the following ways: (1) NGF protein expression bioactivity was assessed in a PC-12 cell bioassay, and (2) the concentration of secreted NGF was quantified by NGF ELISA. NGF quantification by ELISA reached a maximal release of 12.9 +/- 3.57 ng/mL at 120 h. PC-12 cells exposed to media from induced transfected HEK-293 cell chambers demonstrated higher levels of differentiation compared with controls. We conclude that hNGF-EcR-293 cells can inducibly secrete bioactive NGF when exposed to the induction agent PonA. This regulated delivery system can secrete bioactive NGF for up to 5 days in vivo. We believe this regulated delivery system will be useful for tissue-engineered nerve constructs.

Nerve Growth Factor Expression Response to Induction Agent Booster Dosing in Transfected Human Embryonic Kidney Cells

To assess whether nerve growth factor (NGF) expression would respond to booster dosing with the inducing agent ponasterone A, human embryonic kidney cells (HEK-293) were transfected with human NGF cDNA. Cells were cultured for 5 days in media with or without ponasterone A. On day 5, controls received a ponasterone A media replacement, whereas experimental groups received ponasterone A booster media replacement. NGF protein expression bioactivity was assessed using a PC-12 cell bioassay and the concentration of secreted NGF was quantified using NGF enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Cells with and without ponasterone A were left for 5 days without changing the medium. On day 5, the supernatants were collected and flash-frozen for enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The ponasterone A-positive and -negative booster medium was replaced in the appropriate wells. Supernatants were collected from the wells at 2, 4, and 6 days after the booster dose and removal of original supernatant. The medium was flash-frozen for enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (1.5 ml), and the remaining 500 mul was transferred to PC-12 cells seeded onto 12-well plates to determine NGF bioactivity. All experiments were performed in quadruplicate. NGF production was measured daily by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay over a 6-day period after the ponasterone A booster to a maximal release of 1233 +/- 130 pg/ml at day 6 (11 days after original induction). Maximal NGF production per 10(3) cells was 2.5 +/- 0.61 pg at day 6. Bioactivity was determined by percentage differentiation (per 100 cells counted) at 26, 52, and 98 percent for ponasterone A-treated wells on 2, 4, and 6 days after booster dosing (7, 9, and 11 days after induction), respectively. PC-12 cell differentiation was not visualized in the ponasterone A-negative control wells. Human NGF-EcR-293 cells can inducibly secrete bioactive NGF when exposed to the induction agent ponasterone A. Furthermore, repeated bioactive NGF expression peaks beyond that previously demonstrated can be achieved using induction agent booster dosing, indicating the ability to regulate the system over an extended period.

Human Embryonic Kidney Cells (HEK-293 Cells): Characterization and Dose-Response Relationship for Modulated Release of Nerve Growth Factor for Nerve Regeneration

The development of engineered constructs to bridge nerve gaps may hold the key to improved functional outcomes in the repair of injured peripheral nerves. These constructs must be rendered bioactive by providing the growth factors required for successful peripheral nerve regeneration. Previous studies demonstrated that harvested human and rat dermal fibroblasts could be genetically engineered to release nerve growth factor (NGF) both in vitro and in vivo. The use of fibroblasts, however, has the potential to cause scarring, and the expression of NGF from those cells was transient. To overcome these potential difficulties, human embryonic kidney cells were modified for use with the ecdysone-inducible mammalian expression system. These cells (hNGF-EcR-293) have been engineered and regulated to secrete human NGF in response to the ecdysone analogue ponasterone A. HEK-293 cells were transfected with human NGF cDNA with the ecdysone-inducible mammalian expression system (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif.). Stable clones were then selected. Ponasterone A, an analogue of ecdysone, was used as the inducing agent. The secretion of NGF into the medium was analyzed with two different methods. After 24 hours of exposure to the inducing agent, cell medium was transferred to PC-12 cells seeded in 12-well plates, for determination of whether the secreted NGF was bioactive. Medium from untreated or ponasterone A-treated hNGF-EcR-293 cells was deemed bioactive on the basis of its ability to induce PC-12 cell differentiation. The concentrations of secreted NGF were also quantified with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, in triplicate. NGF production was measured in successive samples of the same medium during a 9-day period, with maximal release of 9.05 +/- 2.6 ng/ml at day 9. Maximal NGF production was 8.46 +/- 2.1 pg/10(3) cells at day 9. These levels were statistically significantly different from levels in noninduced samples (p <or= 0.05). Differences in NGF secretion with the three different concentrations of ponasterone A (1, 2, and 3 microM) were not statistically significant. PC-12 cells exposed to medium from induced transfected HEK-293 cells demonstrated markedly higher levels of differentiation, compared with control levels, indicating bioactive protein secretion. It was demonstrated that this regulated delivery system could secrete bioactive NGF for up to 9 days and might be useful for in vivo applications. This regulated delivery system should be useful for tissue-engineered nerve constructs.

Neural tissue engineering: strategies for repair and regeneration

Nerve regeneration is a complex biological phenomenon. In the peripheral nervous system, nerves can regenerate on their own if injuries are small. Larger injuries must be surgically treated, typically with nerve grafts harvested from elsewhere in the body. Spinal cord injury is more complicated, as there are factors in the body that inhibit repair. Unfortunately, a solution to completely repair spinal cord injury has not been found. Thus, bioengineering strategies for the peripheral nervous system are focused on alternatives to the nerve graft, whereas efforts for spinal cord injury are focused on creating a permissive environment for regeneration. Fortunately, recent advances in neuroscience, cell culture, genetic techniques, and biomaterials provide optimism for new treatments for nerve injuries. This article reviews the nervous system physiology, the factors that are critical for nerve repair, and the current approaches that are being explored to aid peripheral nerve regeneration and spinal cord repair.

Approaches to tissue engineered peripheral nerve

The late 1980s and early 1990s brought excitement to the idea that we would be able to replace body tissues and organs through the field of tissue engineering. This enthusiasm was soon replaced by the realization of the limitations in our knowledge for specific tissue types and replication efforts. Such is the case with nerve tissue. We have progressed in this field of knowledge; however, full elucidation to the complex interactions of nerve repair falls short.

Tissue engineering

Tissue engineering will potentially change the practice of plastic surgery more than any other clinical specialty. It is an interdisciplinary field that promises new methods of tissue repair. There has been more than $3.5 billion invested in this field since 1990. Relevant areas of progress include advanced computing, biomaterials, cell technology, growth factor fabrication and delivery, and gene manipulation. Beneficial clinical techniques will emerge from continued investigation in each of these areas. Techniques that are developed must be scaled up to industry with products cleared by regulatory agencies and acceptable to clinicians and patients. A goal of tissue engineering is to change clinical practice, yielding improved patient outcomes and lower costs of care.