Stages of change theory and the nicotine-dependent client: direction for decision making in nursing practice

Applying the Transtheoretical Model to Tobacco Cessation and Prevention: A Review of Literature

Objective.

To comprehensively review all published, peer-reviewed research on the Transtheoretical Model (TTM) and tobacco cessation and prevention by exploring the validity of its constructs, the evidence for use of interventions based on the TTM, the description of populations using TTM constructs, and the identification of areas for further research. The three research questions answered were: “How is the validity of the TTM as applied to tobacco supported by research?” “How does the TTM describe special populations regarding tobacco use?” “What is the nature of evidence supporting the use of stage-matched tobacco interventions?”

Data Source.

Computer Database search (PsychInfo, Medline, Current Contents, ERIC, CINAHL-Allied Health, and Pro-Quest Nursing) and manual journal search.

Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria.

All English, original, research articles on the TTM as it relates to tobacco use published in peer-reviewed journals prior to March 1, 2001, were included. Commentaries, editorials, and books were not included.

Data Extraction and Synthesis.

Articles were categorized as TTM construct validation, population descriptions using TTM constructs, or intervention evaluation using TTM constructs. Summary tables including study design, research rating, purpose, methods, findings, and implications were created. Articles were further divided into groups according to their purpose. Considering both the findings and research quality of each, the three research questions were addressed.

Results.

The 148 articles reviewed included 54 validation studies, 73 population studies, and 37 interventions (some articles fit two categories). Overall, the evidence in support of the TTM as applied to tobacco use was strong, with supportive studies being more numerous and of a better design than nonsupportive studies. Using established criteria, we rated the construct validity of the entire body of literature as good; however, notable concerns exist about the staging construct. A majority of stage-matched intervention studies provided positive results and were of a better quality than those not supportive of stage-matched interventions; thus, we rated the body of literature using stage-matched tobacco interventions as acceptable and the body of literature using non–stage-matched interventions as suggestive. Population studies indicated that TTM constructs are applicable to a wide variety of general and special populations both in and outside of the United States, although a few exceptions exist.

Conclusions.

Evidence for the validity of the TTM as it applies to tobacco use is strong and growing; however, it is not conclusive. Eight different staging mechanisms were identified, raising the question of which are most valid and reliable. Interventions tailored to a smoker's stage were successful more often than nontailored interventions in promoting forward stage movement. Stage distribution is well-documented for U.S. populations; however, more research is needed for non-U.S. populations, for special populations, and on other TTM constructs.

Ethnicity predicts perceptions of smoking and smoking cessation among veterans

The objective of this study was to determine if race/ethnicity predicts motivation to quit smoking and preferences for cessation services among smokers serviced by a primarily psychiatric Veterans Affairs hospital. A self-administered survey was given to a convenience sample of smokers (n=146) at the Battle Creek Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Univariate, bivariate and multivariate regression analyses were calculated to determine the association between race/ethnicity and motivation to quit smoking. Forty-two per cent of the sample was non-white. Non-white patients smoked significantly less cigarettes per day as compared with white patients (P=0.002). In the multivariate analyses, compared with whites, non-whites had 3.5 times greater odds of thinking that quitting smoking was extremely/very important to health (P= 0.01), 4.0 times greater odds of thinking of quitting using tobacco products in the next 30 days (P=0.004) and 3.4 times greater odds of being interested in receiving smoking cessation services (P=0.007). Yet, non-white patients were less likely to be interested in intensive nurse counselling and cessation medications. As the number of non-whites continues to increase in the military, novel strategies may be needed to capitalize on the high motivation to quit smoking and preference for non-traditional interventions among non-white smokers treated in Veterans Affairs hospitals.

Medical comorbidities increase motivation to quit smoking among veterans being treated by a psychiatric facility

PURPOSE

This study determined if comorbidities predicted motivation to quit smoking among smokers treated in a primarily psychiatric Veterans Affairs facility.

DESIGN AND METHODS

A cross-sectional study was conducted with a convenience sample of smokers (N = 117).

FINDINGS

Multivariate analyses showed a history of arthritis, diabetes, lung disease, or stroke predicted motivation to quit smoking (p < .05). Having a history of high blood pressure, heart disease, or cancer was not associated with motivation to quit smoking.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

Relating smoking behavior to the patient's medical comorbidities may increase motivation to quit smoking among veterans.

Using Roy's adaptation model when caring for a group of young women contemplating quitting smoking

This article provides an overview of the use of Roy's adaptation model when caring for a group of young women who were in the precontemplation phase of smoking cessation. The model served as a guide to assess each member's level of adaptation in each of the four modes to identify actual or potential adaptation problems and then examining the stimuli that influence those problems. Nursing interventions focused on approaches to the management of stimuli to promote adaptation for the group by helping the members move to the phase of thinking of quitting smoking.