Switching from bromocriptine to ropinirole in patients with advanced Parkinson's disease: open label pilot responses to three different dose-ratios

Summary of the recommendations of the EFNS/MDS-ES review on therapeutic management of Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVE

To summarize the 2010 EFNS/MDS-ES evidence-based treatment recommendations for the management of Parkinson's disease (PD). This summary includes the treatment recommendations for early and late PD.

METHODS

For the 2010 publication, a literature search was undertaken for articles published up to September 2009. For this summary, an additional literature search was undertaken up to December 2010. Classification of scientific evidence and the rating of recommendations were made according to the EFNS guidance. In cases where there was insufficient scientific evidence, a consensus statement ('good practice point') is made.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

For each clinical indication, a list of therapeutic interventions is provided, including classification of evidence.

Overnight Switch From Oral Dopaminergic Agonists to Transdermal Rotigotine Patch in Subjects With Parkinson Disease

OBJECTIVE

To assess safety, tolerability, and efficacy outcomes of an overnight switch from oral ropinirole, pramipexole, or cabergoline to rotigotine, a dopaminergic agonist with transdermal delivery over 24 hours in subjects with established Parkinson disease (PD).

METHODS

In this open-label multicenter study, we hypothesized that the selected doses of transdermal rotigotine would provide at least equivalent antiparkinsonian actions in subjects with idiopathic PD not adequately controlled with oral ropinirole (up to 9 mg/d), pramipexole (up to 2 mg/d), or cabergoline (up to 3 mg/d). The tolerability of the rotigotine switch was evaluated by the number of subjects completing the scheduled 28-day treatment period, need for rotigotine dose reductions, and dropouts due to adverse events. Efficacy assessment relied on changes in Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale from the baseline to the end of treatment in PD symptoms and subject preference of dopaminergic agonist.

RESULTS

Of 116 PD subjects enrolled, 104 completed the 28-day rotigotine treatment. Fifteen subjects required rotigotine dose adjustment; of these, 11 completed the trial. The most common adverse events (generally mild or moderate in intensity) were application site reactions, nausea, and somnolence. The change to rotigotine was well tolerated. Rotigotine was preferred by 77% of subjects who were not adequately controlled by their previous oral dopaminergic agonist. The predetermined rotigotine substitutions provided improvements over baseline in Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale II and III subscales.

CONCLUSIONS

Subjects and clinicians found the overnight switch to rotigotine convenient, well tolerated, and effective for control of PD signs and symptoms for subjects previously receiving low-to-moderate doses of oral dopaminergic agonists.

Clinical studies with ropinirole in Parkinson's disease and RLS

Ropinirole is a modern dopamine agonist with a half-life of medium extent that is highly selective for D(2)-receptors. Ropinirole is an indole derivative and thus does not belong to the group of ergoline dopamine receptor agonists. Its effect has been proved in a number of controlled studies in both monotherapy and combination treatments of Parkinson's disease. We can meanwhile refer to the long-term data of studies that have been run for more than 10 years. The substance has also been approved for the management of restless legs syndrome. A long-acting formula of the substance will be available soon.

Review of the therapeutic management of Parkinson's disease. Report of a joint task force of the European Federation of Neurological Societies and the Movement Disorder Society-European Section. Part I: early (uncomplicated) Parkinson's disease

The aim of the study was to provide evidence-based recommendations for the management of early (uncomplicated) Parkinson's disease (PD), based on a review of the literature. Uncomplicated PD refers to patients suffering from the classical motor syndrome of PD only, without treatment-induced motor complications and without neuropsychiatric or autonomic problems. MEDLINE, Cochrane Library and International Network of Agencies for Health Technology Assessment (INAHTA) database literature searches were conducted. National guidelines were requested from all European Federation of Neurological Societies (EFNS) societies. Non-European guidelines were searched for using MEDLINE. Part I of the guidelines deals with prevention of disease progression, symptomatic treatment of motor features (parkinsonism), and prevention of motor and neuropsychiatric complications of therapy. For each topic, a list of therapeutic interventions is provided, including classification of evidence. Following this, recommendations for management are given, alongside ratings of efficacy. Classifications of evidence and ratings of efficacy are made according to EFNS guidance. In cases where there is insufficient scientific evidence, a consensus statement (good practice point) is made.

Proposed dose equivalence for rapid switch between dopamine receptor agonists in Parkinson's disease: a review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Progressive reduction of the dose of one dopamine receptor agonist and simultaneous, progressive dose escalation of another is a frequently used strategy for controlling motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease (PD) or avoiding specific adverse events. Rapid switch has been proposed as an alternative that might reduce the need for such major limitations as the possible exacerbation of symptoms and the need to monitor patients for several weeks. However, the equivalence of doses of dopamine receptor agonists before and after switching drugs remains empirical because few clinical trials have addressed this issue.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this review was to use the available data from the literature to calculate conversion factors for rapidly switching between dopamine receptor agonists in patients with PD.

METHODS

Using the MEDLINE and Cochrane Library Central databases, we selected clinical trials that allowed paired comparisons of bromocriptine with the most frequently prescribed dopamine receptor agonists in PD (ie, pergolide, piribedil, pramipexole, and ropinirole). From these data, we calculated dose equivalents of optimal daily doses for each pair of dopamine receptor agonists.

RESULTS

Six studies comparing 2 dopamine agonists and 4 studies analyzing the switch between dopamine agonists were selected. The proposed conversion factors were 1:6 for bromocriptine to piribedil, 1:6 for pergolide to ropinirole, 10:6 for bromocriptine to ropinirole, 10:1 for bromocriptine to pergolide, and 10:1 to 10:1.5 for bromocriptine to pramipexole.

CONCLUSIONS

The conversion factors proposed in this article, based on a literature analysis, could facilitate rapid switches between dopamine receptor agonists in patients with PD, but they must first be confirmed in prospective, double-blind, randomized clinical trials.

Ropinirole, a non-ergoline dopamine agonist

Dopamine agonists have become indispensable in the treatment of Parkinson's disease. In every-day practice, however, the decision to select the best compound for an individual patient is rendered difficult because of the large number of substances available on the market. This review article provides a closer look at the experimental and clinical studies with ropinirole published so far. Ropinirole is a non-ergoline dopamine agonist which has been proven to be effective in both, monotherapy and combination therapy of idiopathic Parkinson's disease. In addition to ameliorating bradykinesia, rigor, and tremor, ropinirole facilitates the daily life and improves depressive moods of patients with Parkinson's disease. The long-term complications of levodopa are avoided, and problems commonly associated with levodopa treatment are reduced. Ropinirole appears to have a neuroprotective effect. In addition to Parkinson's disease, ropinirole has also been used successfully in the treatment of restless legs syndrome.

Changing dopamine agonist treatment in Parkinson's disease: experiences with switching to pramipexole

1202 patients suffering from Parkinson's disease switched from other dopamine agonists to pramipexole under open conditions either abruptly or in an overlapping, gradual manner. Mostly insufficient effectiveness motivated the switch. The investigators gave equal preference to either an abrupt or an overlapping switch to pramipexole in this observational study. There was a tendency in favour of the overlapping switch procedure in those patients who were on a relatively higher dose of a dopamine agonist before the switch. The switch was performed because the investigators expected the effect of pramipexole on tremor, motor functions and depression/anhedonia to be better compared with previous dopamine agonists. The main reasons for switching to pramipexole (anti-tremor effect, anti-depressive/anti-anhedonic effect) as given by the physicians at baseline came up to expectations. The switch to pramipexole mostly yielded further improvements irrespective of the mode of switching.

High doses of pergolide improve clinical global impression in advanced Parkinson's disease—A preliminary open label study

We evaluated the efficacy and safety of high-dose pergolide treatment in patients with moderate to severe Parkinson's disease (PD) in an open-label multicenter clinical trial. The primary objective was to assess the amount of reduction in levodopa, the improvement in Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) and adverse reactions. We treated 32 patients with PD presenting with motor fluctuations. Pergolide treatment started with a dose escalation period of 12 weeks followed by a 12-week continuation period. Pergolide doses were increased up to a maximum of 12 mg/day in combination with a simultaneous decrease of levodopa doses in 100mg steps. Levodopa was reduced from 500 mg/day (median) to 250 mg/day. Mean UPDRS part III improved significantly (p=0.01). Clinical global impression improved significantly after 24 weeks (p<0.01). Most frequent adverse events were hallucinations, asthenia, anxiety, abdominal pain, and peripheral edema. Twenty-two patients finished the complete study according to protocol. A possible relationship to the study medication was assumed for two serious adverse events reporting psychosis. We conclude that high doses of pergolide are efficacious in advanced stages of PD if given in appropriate regimens.

Does bilateral stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus aggravate apathy in Parkinson's disease?

OBJECTIVE

High frequency stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) dramatically decreases motor disability in patients with Parkinson"s disease (PD), but has been reported to aggravate apathy. The aim of this study was to analyse the effect of STN stimulation on motivation and reward sensitivity in a consecutive series of PD patients.

METHODS

Apathy and reward sensitivity (Apathy Scale, Stimulus-Reward Learning, Reversal, Extinction, and Gambling tasks) were assessed in 18 PD patients treated by bilateral STN stimulation ("on" and "off" conditions) compared with 23 matched patients undergoing long term treatment with levodopa ("on" and "off" conditions).

RESULTS

Apathy decreased under both STN stimulation and levodopa treatment, whereas explicit and implicit stimulus reward learning was unchanged.

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral STN stimulation in PD patients does not necessarily have a negative effect on motivation and reward sensitivity and can even improve apathy provided patients have been appropriately selected for neurosurgery.

Treatment of motor dysfunction in Parkinson's disease: an overview

Levodopa remains the most effective treatment for Parkinson's disease (PD). However, the use of this drug is complicated by several adverse effects, in particular motor fluctuations and dyskinesias. Drugs providing more continuous dopaminergic stimulation and surgical approaches, such as deep-brain stimulation, have an important ameliorative effect on these problems. Despite these advances, the progression of the disease remains unaffected and strategies that slow or stop the neurodegenerative process are currently not available. Nevertheless, several compounds or surgical procedures are candidates for being neuroprotective and some of them are under evaluation.

Dopamine agonist switching in Parkinson's disease

There are a number of situations for patients with Parkinson's disease in which a safe and efficacious switch from treatment with one dopamine agonist to another may be required. This article explores reasons for making such a switch, and provides practical guidance on performing it.

Switching from ergot to nonergot dopamine agonists in Parkinson's disease: A clinical series and five-drug dose conversion table

Of 99 patients on ergot-derived dopamine agonists informed about possible long-term side effects, switching to a nonergot was undertaken in 88 (89%). There were adverse events in 26%. After 11 months, 82% were on their switch agonist and 93% were on any agonist. Switching dopamine agonists is feasible in this population.

Dopaminergic substitution in Parkinson's disease

Motor complications associated with long-term levodopa application, which follow the so-called honeymoon period of well-tolerated levodopa administration and are looked upon as one clinical marker for progression of Parkinson's disease (PD), initiated a long and controversial debate on the putative neurotoxicity of levodopa. Since dopamine agonists (DA) delay onset of motor complications, they support the neuroprotective treatment strategy in PD. Efficacy and tolerability of DA differs in particular due to their affinity to various dopamine receptor subtypes. The accumulating evidence for levodopa-associated homocysteinaemia, which represents a risk factor for increased incidence of vascular disease in PD, supports the strategy of initial DA application and the use of levodopa as an add-on compound in as low a dose as possible in young PD patients.

Parkinson's disease: medical treatment of moderate to advanced disease

Parkinson's disease, a common neurodegenerative disorder, results in significant morbidity 10 to 15 years after disease onset and increased mortality. Levodopa is the mainstay of therapy and provides benefit for the duration of the illness. However, within 5 years, up to 50% of individuals develop fluctuations, including dyskinesias, wearing off, and "on/off" effects. Optimal management of Parkinson's disease patients requires careful titration of medications, with use of polypharmacy, including levodopa, dopamine agonists, catechol-O-methyltransferase inhibitors, amantadine, and anticholinergics in order to maintain good motor function and quality of life. With advancing disease, problems such as dysphagia, dysarthria, and gait and balance abnormalities occur, which are not responsive to dopaminergic medication. Due to extradopaminergic neuronal system degeneration, autonomic dysfunction can also be prominent. Recognition and management of these problems is helpful in improving quality of life in late-stage disease. In very late stages, dementia may complicate treatment, requiring discontinuation of combination therapy and use of low-dose levodopa with atypical neuroleptics.