Is surgical fusion still desirable in spinal tuberculosis?

Role of transarticular screw fixation in tuberculous atlanto-axial instability

Prospective study of 27 consecutive cases of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability operated between 1998 and 2003. Early surgical stabilization of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability has gained popularity. This is largely due to success of chemotherapy in rapid control of infection. Although selective atlanto-axial fusion techniques are advocated in other indications, their role in tuberculosis remains confined to atlanto-axial wiring techniques that are mechanically unsound. The role of three-point rigid fixation using trans-articular screws (TAS) remains unclear. The objectives of this study are: (1) To define the role of trans-articular screws in tuberculous atlanto-axial instability based on radiological criteria. (2) To attempt to separate patients that can be treated by selective atlanto-axial fixation as against the standard occipito-cervical fusion (OCF). (3) Compare the clinical and radiological outcome parameters between the two groups. Twenty-seven consecutive patients of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability were operated between 1998 and 2003. The pattern of articular surface destruction and the reducibility of the atlanto-axial complex were assessed on plain radiographs and MRI. The reducibility of the C1-C2 joint was graded as reducible, partially reducible and irreducible. Pattern of the C1-C2 articular mass destruction was grouped as minimal, moderate and severe. The patients were divided into two surgical groups based on radiological findings and were treated with TAS (n=11) and OCF (n=16) fusion. The three-point fixation provided by the TAS allowed early brace free mobilization by 3 months with fusion rate of 100%. Fusion occurred in 83.16% in the OCF group. Implant failure occurred in two patients who underwent OCF. The patient satisfaction rate in the TAS group and the OCF group was 90.90 and 62.50%, respectively. Results in 27 consecutive patients demonstrate improved patient fusion and satisfaction rates in the TAS group. Judicious selection of patients for TAS fixation is possible with relatively few complications in tuberculosis of the atlanto-axial complex. This, however, requires a thorough understanding of the MRI pattern of involvement of the atlanto-axial complex that is difficult in non-endemic areas.

A surgical revisitation of Pott distemper of the spine

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Pott disease and tuberculosis have been with humans for countless millennia. Before the mid-twentieth century, the treatment of tuberculous spondylitis was primarily supportive and typically resulted in dismal neurological, functional and cosmetic outcomes. The contemporary development of effective antituberculous medications, imaging modalities, anesthesia, operative techniques and spinal instrumentation resulted in quantum improvements in the diagnosis, management and outcome of spinal tuberculosis. With the successful treatment of tuberculosis worldwide, interest in Pott disease has faded from the surgical forefront over the last 20 years. With the recent unchecked global pandemic of human immunodeficiency virus, the number of tuberculosis and secondary spondylitis cases is again increasing at an alarming rate. A surgical revisitation of Pott disease is thus essential to prepare spinal surgeons for this impending resurgence of tuberculosis.

PURPOSE

To revisit the numerous treatment modalities for Pott disease and their outcomes. From this information, a critical reappraisal of surgical nuances with regard to decision making, timing, operative approach, graft types and the use of instrumentation were conducted.

STUDY DESIGN

A concise review of the diagnosis, management and surgical treatment of Pott disease.

METHODS

A broad review of the literature was conducted with a particular focus on the different surgical treatment modalities for Pott disease and their outcomes regarding neurological deficit, kyphosis and spinal stability.

RESULTS

Whereas a variety of management schemes have been used for the debridement and reconstruction of tuberculous spondylitis, there has also been a spectrum of outcomes regarding neurological function and deformity. Medical treatment alone remains the cornerstone of therapy for the majority of Pott disease cases. Surgical intervention should be limited primarily to cases of severe or progressive deformity and/or neurological deficit. Based on the available evidence, radical ventral debridement and grafting appears to provide reproducibly good long-term neurological outcomes. Furthermore, recurrence of infection is lowest with such techniques. Posterior operative techniques are most effective in the reduction and prevention of spinal deformity.

CONCLUSIONS

Unlike historical times, effective medical and surgical management of tuberculous spondyitis is now possible. Proper selection of drug therapy and operative modalities, however, is needed to optimize functional outcomes for each individual case of Pott disease.

Modern management of spinal tuberculosis

The resurgence of pulmonary tuberculosis in the United States has been paralleled by a concomitant rise in tuberculosis of the spine (Pott's disease). The appearance of drug-resistant strains of tuberculosis, infection in large numbers of immunocompromised hosts, newer imaging modalities, and the development of more effective spinal reconstruction techniques have raised important issues regarding the management of Pott's disease. In spite of this, there has been little published recently on the modern management of Pott's disease in developed countries. We report our experience with the management of 20 patients with Pott's disease in the past 5 years, 16 of whom were admitted during the last 18 months of this retrospective study. The mean patient age was 49 years. Sixteen (80%) were men. Nineteen (95%) had a positive tuberculin skin test, and 13 (65%) had pulmonary tuberculosis. Symptoms consisted of spinal pain, weakness, sensory complaints, and flank mass in order of decreasing frequency. Ten patients were neurologically intact; the remainder had motor deficits of variable severity. The thoracic spine was involved in 13 patients, the lumbar spine was involved in 4, the cervical spine was involved in 2, and the thoracolumbar spine was involved in 1. Spinal deformity was present in 11 patients, spinal epidural compression was present in 13, and a paraspinal mass was present in 18. Operative indications included motor deficits, spinal deformity, nondiagnostic computer tomographic-guided needle biopsy, and noncompliance with, or lack of, response to medical therapy. Eleven patients underwent operations. Six patients had vertebrectomy and bone grafting with posterior instrumentation when indicated; three had laminectomy, debridement, and abscess drainage; one had laminectomy and posterior instrumentation; and one had paraspinal abscess drainage. Two patients have died; the remainder have been monitored for at least 1 year and are neurologically improved or normal without residual infection. The average angulation decreased from 31 to 24 degrees by the follow-up examination. In selected patients, early operative treatment with instrumentation, when indicated, minimizes neurological deterioration and spinal deformity, allows early ambulation, and results in excellent neurological outcome.