Bone transport using intramedullary fixation and a single flexible traction cable

Current Management of Acute and Posttraumatic Critical Bone Defects

SUMMARY

Limb reconstruction in patients with critical-sized bone defects remains a challenge due to the availability of various technically demanding treatment options and a lack of standardized decision algorithms. Although no consensus exists, it is apparent from the literature that the combination of patient, surgeon, and institutional collaborations is effective in providing the most efficient care pathway for these patients. Success relies on choosing a particular surgical approach that manages infection, soft tissue defects, stability, and alignment. Recent systematic reviews demonstrate high success rates with the following management options: Ilizarov bone transport, Masquelet (induced membrane) technique, cancellous bone grafting, and vascularized bone grafts.

Mechanics Predicts Effective Critical-Size Bone Regeneration Using 3D-Printed Bioceramic Scaffolds

BACKGROUND

3D-printed bioceramic scaffolds have gained popularity due to their controlled microarchitecture and their proven biocompatibility. However, their high brittleness makes their surgical implementation complex for weight-bearing bone treatments. Thus, they would require difficult-to-instrument rigid internal fixations that limit a rigorous evaluation of the regeneration progress through the analysis of mechanic-structural parameters.

METHODS

We investigated the compatibility of flexible fixations with fragile ceramic implants, and if mechanical monitoring techniques are applicable to bone tissue engineering applications. Tissue engineering experiments were performed on 8 ovine metatarsi. A 15 mm bone segment was directly replaced with a hydroxyapatite scaffold and stabilized by an instrumented Ilizarov-type external fixator. Several in vivo monitoring techniques were employed to assess the mechanical and structural progress of the tissue.

RESULTS

The applied surgical protocol succeeded in combining external fixators and subject-specific bioceramic scaffolds without causing fatal fractures of the implant due to stress concentrator. The bearing capacity of the treated limb was initially altered, quantifying a 28-56% reduction of the ground reaction force, which gradually normalized during the consolidation phase. A faster recovery was reported in the bearing capacity, stiffening and bone mineral density of the callus. It acquired a predominant mechanical role over the fixator in the distribution of internal forces after one post-surgical month.

CONCLUSION

The bioceramic scaffold significantly accelerated in vivo the bone formation compared to other traditional alternatives in the literature (e.g., distraction osteogenesis). In addition, the implemented assessment techniques allowed an accurate quantitative evaluation of the bone regeneration through mechanical and imaging parameters.

Evolution of relaxation properties of callus tissue during bone transport

Callus tissue exhibits a viscoelastic behavior that has a strong influence on the distribution of stresses and their evolution with time and, thus, it can affect tissue differentiation during distraction procedures. For this reason, a deep knowledge of that viscoelastic behavior can be very useful to improve current protocols of bone distraction and bone transport. Monitoring stress relaxation of the callus during distraction osteogenesis allows characterizing its viscoelastic behavior. Different procedures have been used in the literature to fit the response of a given viscoelastic model to the force relaxation curve. However, these procedures do not ensure the uniqueness of that fit, which is of the utmost importance for statistical purposes. This work uses a fitting procedure already validated for other tissues that ensures that uniqueness. Very importantly too, the procedure presented here allows obtaining more information from the stress relaxation tests, distinguishing relaxation in different time scales, which provides a deeper insight into the viscoelastic behavior and its evolution over time. As it was observed in the results, relaxation is faster at the first days after osteotomy and becomes slower and more gradual with time. This fact can be directly linked to the temporal evolution of the callus composition (water, organic phase, and mineral content) and also to the progression of tissue differentiation, with a prevalence of hard tissues as time passes.

Novel approach to estimate distraction forces in distraction osteogenesis and application in the human lower leg

PURPOSE

In distraction osteogenesis (DO) of long bones, new bone tissue is distracted to lengthen limbs or reconstruct bone defects. However, mechanical boundary conditions in human application such as arising forces are mainly based on limited empirical data. Our aim was the numerical determination of the callus distraction force (CDF) and the total distraction force (TDF) during DO in the tibia of adults to advance the understanding of callus tissue behavior and optimize DO procedures.

METHOD

We implemented a mathematical model based on an animal experiment to enable the calculation of forces arising while distracting callus tissue, excluding the influence of surrounding soft tissue (muscles, skin etc.). The CDF progression for the distraction period was calculated using the implemented model and varying distraction parameters (initial gap, area, step size, time interval, length). Further, we estimated the CDF based on reported forces in humans and compared the results to our model predictions. In addition, we calculated the TDF based on our CDF predictions in combination with reported resisting forces due to soft tissue presence in human cadavers. Finally, we compared the progressions to in vivo TDF measurements for validation.

RESULTS

Due to relaxation, a peak and resting CDF is observable for each distraction step. Our biomechanical results show a non-linear degressive increase of the resting and peak CDF at the beginning and a steady non-linear increase thereafter. The calculated resting and peak CDF in the tibial metaphysis ranged from 0.00075 to 0.0089 N and 0.22-2.6 N at the beginning as well as 20-25 N and 70-75 N at the end of distraction. The comparison to in vivo data showed the plausibility of our predictions and resulted in a 10-33% and 10-23% share of resting CDF in the total resting force for bone transport and elongation, respectively. Further, the percentage of peak CDF in total peak force was found to be 29-58% and 27-55% for bone transport and elongation, respectively. Moreover, our TDF predictions were valid based on the comparison to in vivo forces and resulted in a degressive increase from 6 to 125 N for the peak TDF and from 5 to 76 N for the resting TDF.

CONCLUSION

Our approach enables the estimation of forces arising due to the distraction of callus tissue in humans and results in plausible force progressions as well as absolute force values for the callus distraction force during DO. In combination with measurements of resisting forces due to the presence of soft tissue, the total distraction force in DO may also be evaluated. We thus propose the application of this method to approximate the behavior of mechanical callus properties during DO in humans as an alternative to in vivo measurements.

Time-Dependent Collagen Fibered Structure in the Early Distraction Callus: Imaging Characterization and Mathematical Modeling

Collagen is a ubiquitous protein present in regenerating bone tissues that experiences multiple biological phenomena during distraction osteogenesis until the deposition of phosphate crystals. This work combines fluorescence techniques and mathematical modeling to shed light on the mechano-structural processes behind the maturation and accommodation-to-mineralization of the callus tissue. Ovine metatarsal bone calluses were analyzed through confocal images at different stages of the early distraction osteogenesis process, quantifying the fiber orientation distribution and mean intensity as fiber density measure. Likewise, a mathematical model based on the experimental data was defined to micromechanically characterize the apparent stiffening of the tissue within the distracted callus. A reorganization of the fibers around the distraction axis and increased fiber density were found as the bone fragments were gradually separated. Given the degree of significance between the mathematical model and previous in vivo data, reorganization, densification, and bundle maturation phenomena seem to explain the apparent mechanical maturation observed in the tissue theoretically.

A Modification of Internal Bone Transport Method for Reconstruction of Nonunion of Forearm

BACKGROUND

Defects of bone and soft tissue occur frequently after high-energy trauma, infections, and tumor resection. Treatment options are limited and outcomes are controversial in nonunion. Classical reconstruction methods are challenging. We describe a method of internal bone transport for treatment of complicated nonunion of the forearm. This method permits axial and internal bone transport without harming the distorted and complex neurovascular anatomy or soft-tissue envelope.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five patients (mean age, 27 years) with defect nonunion (3 ulna, 2 radius) were treated. Mean preoperative defect size was 36 mm, mean shortening was 14 (0-30) mm, and the extent of surgical resection was 24 (20-40) mm. Total bone loss due to defect, resection, or shortening was 74 mm. According to Paley classification, two of the patients had B1, and three had B3 defect nonunion. This study treats defect nonunion of the forearm using an internal bone-transport method. Our method involved cannulated screws, a cerclage wire, and a circular fixator being used in combination. When transportation was completed, internal fixation of the docking site with a plate and screws was done, with bone grafting after fixator removal. Bone healing and functional outcomes were assessed with radiographs and disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand (DASH) scores, respectively.

RESULTS

Mean followup was 67.6 months. Solid osseous union and functional improvement were achieved in all cases. Mean bone loss was 66 mm, mean fixator time was 131.8 days, the lengthening index was 1.3 days/mm, and the fixator index was 2.1 days/mm. DASH score was 82.2 before treatment and 15.36 after treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Using our method, internal bone transport and progressive axial docking of defects can be done with minimal effects on surrounding neurovascular arrangements and soft tissues. Size of fixators can be decreased and formation of painful scar tissue can be avoided.

Evolution of callus tissue behavior during stable distraction osteogenesis

Multiple studies have sought to characterize the mechanical behavior of callus tissue in vivo during distraction osteogenesis. The aims of such studies are to understand the mechanobiology of distraction and elucidate the complex viscoelasticity and evolution of the tissue. The former objective has direct clinical relevance to surgical technique and process control while the latter is necessary for the calibration and validation of the predictive healing models. Such models seek to reduce the researcher's dependence on animal studies and prospectively allow improved surgical planning. To date, no study has been capable of controlling the mechanical conditions sufficiently enough to decouple the distraction process from the secondary mechanical stimulation associated with the finite stiffness of the fixation constructs employed. It is the goal of this work to understand the mechanobiology of pure distraction as well as characterize viscoelastic tissue behavior under precisely defined mechanical conditions. This is achieved using a novel lateral distraction model. The structural integrity of the bone is maintained, allowing the collection of force relaxation data due to a stepwise distraction process without the superimposed influence of secondary mechanical stimulation. The average instantaneous modulus increases from approximately 2 kPa to approximately 1100 kPa while the equilibrium modulus increases from approximately 0 kPa to 200 kPa over the distraction period.

A novel intramedullary callus distraction system for the treatment of femoral bone defects

An intramedullary device has some advantages over external fixation in callus distraction for bone defect reconstruction. There are difficulties controlling motorized intramedullary devices and monitoring the distraction rate which may lead to poor results. The aim of this study was to design a fully implantable and non-motorized simple distraction nail for the treatment of bone defects. The fully implantable device comprises a tube-in-tube system and a wire pulling mechanism for callus distraction. For the treatment of femoral bone defects, a traction wire, attached to the device at one end, is fixed to the tibial tubercle at its other end. Flexion of the knee joint over a predetermined angle generates a traction force on the wire triggering bone segment transport. This callus distraction system was implanted into the femur of four human cadavers (total 8 femora), and bone segment transport was conducted over 60-mm defects with radiographic monitoring. All bone segments were transported reliably to the docking site. From these preliminary results, we conclude that this callus distraction system offers an alternative to the current intramedullary systems for the treatment of bone defects.

Correção de falhas ósseas diafisárias: trasnporte ósseo fixado com placa

O objetivo deste estudo é descrever um novo sistema de transporte ósseo que dispensa o uso de fios transfixantes. O sistema, constituído por uma placa, um carro móvel e por um dispositivo tracionador, foi instalado na tíbia direita de 17 ovelhas para preencher um defeito ósseo de 1 cm. O transporte ósseo foi iniciado 7 dias após a cirurgia numa taxa de 0,8 mm/dia, dividido em 0,2 mm a cada 6 horas. Radiografias em ântero-posterior e perfil foram realizadas imediatamente após a cirurgia e semanalmente até o término do transporte. Em todos os 12 animais que completaram o estudo, o defeito ósseo foi preenchido com formação do regenerado e consolidação do foco alvo. O estudo demonstra que o sistema aqui apresentado realiza o transporte ósseo de maneira efetiva, eliminando o uso de fios ou pinos transfixantes.

Uso do transporte ósseo no tratamento de perda óssea segmentar extensa da tíbia: estudo experimental em cães

Avaliou-se a técnica de transporte ósseo realizada com fixador externo de Ilizarov no tratamento de defeito ósseo segmentar extenso promovido na tíbia de sete cães. Após aplicação de montagem constituída de um semi-anel proximal, um anel médio e outro distal, ligados entre si por meio de hastes rosqueadas, foi excisado um segmento da diáfise média distal da tíbia e fíbula direitas de 30% do comprimento ósseo. A reconstrução do defeito foi realizada por transporte de um segmento ósseo obtido por osteotomia subperiosteal da parte proximal da tíbia, entre o semi-anel proximal e o anel médio. O período de latência foi de seis dias e o ritmo do transporte foi de 0,5mm a cada 12 horas. Na área de acoplamento foi aplicada compressão. O fixador permaneceu em fase neutra por 14 semanas e, após a remoção do aparelho, os animais foram observados por mais quatro semanas. O resultado funcional foi considerado excelente em um animal, bom em um, satisfatório em três e deficiente nos outros dois. O transporte ósseo permitiu a reparação de falhas ósseas segmentares extensas, porém pode apresentar dificuldades no direcionamento do segmento ósseo transportado e de sua consolidação na área de acoplagem.

Primary resective shortening followed by distraction osteogenesis for limb reconstruction: a comparison with simple lengthening

Resective distraction osteogenesis is a new approach to treat segmental diaphyseal bone defects by primary limb shortening and secondary distraction osteogenesis from the same site. A rabbit model was introduced to compare the bone-regeneration characteristics of this technique with those of simple lengthening procedures. Twenty-four skeletally mature New Zealand White rabbits were divided into two equal groups. In the test group, limbs were lengthened after a 10-mm segmental diaphyseal bone resection and limb shortening. In the control group, a simple subperiosteal osteotomy for limb lengthening was performed without resection. New bone formation was evaluated mechanically, radiologically, histomorphometrically, and densitometrically. Bone bridging occurred in all animals. Normalized mechanical values for the newly reconstructed tibiae demonstrated similar torsional stiffness (71+/-3.3 compared with 71+/-8.2%; p = 0.95) and strength (64+/-5.3 compared with 68+/-7.3%; p = 0.66) in the two groups. The average normalized callus diameter was significantly greater in the test group than in the control group (p < 0.01). The remodeling index calculated from densitometry, however, showed a significantly less progressed stage of remodeling in the test group (p < 0.05). Histomorphometric analysis of the callus center supported this finding, showing significantly lower values for trabecular thickness (p < 0.05) and total bone volume (p < 0.01) in the test group. The results demonstrated the possibility of new bone formation after resection and monofocal shortening. This suggests a new therapeutic option to treat diaphyseal segmental bone defects.

Distraction osteogenesis after acute limb-shortening for segmental tibial defects. Comparison of a monofocal and a bifocal technique in rabbits

BACKGROUND

Segmental bone defects can be treated with immediate limb-shortening followed by monofocal or bifocal distraction osteogenesis. In the present study, the efficacy of monofocal distraction osteogenesis was compared with that of bifocal distraction osteogenesis in a rabbit model.

METHODS

Twenty-four skeletally mature New Zealand White rabbits were divided into two equal groups: one group had monofocal distraction osteosynthesis, and the other had bifocal distraction osteosynthesis. In both groups, a one-centimeter-long segment of bone was resected from the midpart of the tibial shaft. In the monofocal reconstruction group, the limb was immediately shortened to close the segmental defect and the defect was allowed to heal for ten days. Lengthening was then begun at this site, with use of a specially designed external fixator, at a rate of 0.5 millimeter per twelve hours. In the bifocal reconstruction group, the segmental defect was closed immediately and the fragments were fixed with microplates. A subperiosteal osteotomy was performed proximal to the tibiofibular junction, and lengthening was performed at the site of the osteotomy. The animals in both groups were killed twenty days after the lengthening was completed. New-bone formation then was evaluated with use of radiographs, densitometry, biomechanical testing, and histological and histomorphometric analysis.

RESULTS

Osseous consolidation occurred in all but one of the animals. Biomechanical testing demonstrated that the tibiae that had been treated with use of the simple monofocal reconstruction technique tended to have greater torsional stiffness (p = 0.14) and strength (p = 0.09). Follow-up radiographs revealed that both groups had a significant decrease in radiolucent area (p < 0.05), which occurred at essentially the same rate after lengthening. No significant differences were found between the groups with respect to new-bone mineral density, new-bone area, or the amount of callus. Thus, after resection of a diaphyseal bone segment comprising 10 percent of the original length of the tibia and acute shortening, limb reconstruction was completed successfully through distraction osteogenesis with use of either a monofocal or a bifocal technique in rabbits.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, both monofocal and bifocal techniques of shortening and distraction osteogenesis were effective for the reconstruction of segmental bone defects. Under some conditions, the monofocal method may provide a simpler means of treating such defects.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Damage to the soft-tissue envelope as well as venous and lymphatic stasis impose limits on the amount of limb-shortening that can be achieved with use of the monofocal method and also influence the indications for this procedure in the clinical setting.

Increased distraction rates influence precursor tissue composition without affecting bone regeneration

The effect of increased distraction rate on bony tissue differentiation was studied using a paired bilateral model of rat femur lengthening. After a 6-day latency period, one randomly selected femur for each rat was distracted at 0.5 mm/day (normal rate) for 12 days, and the contralateral femur was distracted at 1.5 mm/day (increased rate) for 4 days. Femoral lengthening for each side was 6.0 mm, leaving the increased rate leg with an extra 8 days of consolidation compared with the normal rate limb. Group I rats (n = 9) were killed at day 18 postsurgery and analyzed for cartilage tissue composition and distribution. Group II rats (n = 7) were killed on day 36 postsurgery and analyzed by three-dimensional microcomputed tomography (MCT) for changes in new bone volume. Digital color analysis of slides stained with type II collagen antibody showed increases in cartilaginous tissue formation on the increased rate side (1.51 mm2 vs. 0.83 mm2; p = 0.10). No differences in new bone volume were detected between increased rate limbs and their contralateral controls (46.13 mm3 vs. 42.69 mm3; p = 0.63). These findings suggest that intermediate distraction rates may influence precursor tissue composition without affecting the final amount of new bone formed. Because damage to the tissue was not detected at either time point, these changes in chondrogenesis may reflect sensitivity of the pluripotential gap tissue to tension accumulation during lengthening. Future work with this in vivo model is focused on improving our understanding of the mechanisms behind this strain sensitivity.

Effect of distraction rate on biomechanical, mineralization, and histologic properties of an ovine mandible model

Craniofacial microsomia is a common congenital malformation. Ilizarov's method of distraction osteogenesis applied to the mandible has yielded promising results both experimentally and clinically. Because the technique is used predominantly in a pediatric population, length of treatment and compliance may be problematic. To date, the limits of distraction rate in the craniofacial skeleton have not been defined. This study was designed to investigate the effects of distraction rate, in a large animal model, on the mineralization, biomechanical, and histologic properties of lengthened mandibles. Clinically faster distraction rates would decrease the overall treatment time. Twenty-four animals were divided into four groups, with varying rates of distraction (1, 2, 3, and 4 mm/day). A uniaxial distractor at the angle of the mandible was used. The mandibles were lengthened to 24 mm and fixed for a period of 5 weeks, when the animals were killed. The specimens were analyzed with respect to mineralization using dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, biomechanical strength, through a modified three-point bending test, and histologic properties with hematoxylin and eosin stains. Biomechanical, mineralization, and histologic analyses of the samples indicated that group 1 (1 mm/day) samples were significantly superior (p<0.05) to those of group 4 (4 mm/day). Although bone formation was achieved in all groups, group 1 (1 mm/day) demonstrated the strongest biomechanical and histologic properties. Bone mineral density obtained using dual energy x-ray absorptiometry may be clinically useful as a reliable, noninvasive, and relatively cheap predictor for removal time of the fixator.

Reduced gap strains induce changes in bone regeneration during distraction

A bilateral New Zealand white rabbit model of distraction osteogenesis (DO) was used to investigate the relationship between strain environment and bone regeneration during limb lengthening. In seven (n = 7) rabbits, a stiffener was applied to the fixator on one side to reduce strains within the gap tissue after lengthening was completed. Animals were euthanized six days later and their distraction zones were harvested and analyzed for changes in new bone volume and architecture. Nonlinear finite element analyses (FEA) were performed to predict changes in the gap strain environment. FEA results predicted a nearly uniform sevenfold decrease in average strain measures within the distraction zone. No change in total average new bone volume and significant decreases in both bone volume fraction (BV/TV) and trabecular thickness (Tb.Th) were observed in tibiae in which gap strains were reduced experimentally, compared to contralateral controls. These results suggest that fixator stiffening influenced the architecture but not the amount of newly formed bone. This animal model of distraction might be used to study the mechanisms by which strain fields affect events in bone repair and regeneration, such as cell proliferation, precursor tissue differentiation, and altered growth factor and nutrient delivery to tissues.

Force-displacement behaviour of biological tissue during distraction osteogenesis

Limb lengthening and bone transport treatments are used frequently, and complications during treatment are common. Knowledge of the origin of tensile forces which resist distraction and the force-displacement response of biological tissues during extension would assist in reducing complication rates. Two tibial diaphyseal lengthenings carried out using an Ilizarov fixator were monitored by a displacement transducer to determine extension of the lengthening tissue (the regenerate bone), and by force transducers to determine tensile forces in the tissues that resist extension. The position of the force vector within a cross-section of the limb at the regenerate (provided by CT) was used to determine the origin of these forces. The muscle groups and adjacent fascia resisting extension were the gastrocnemius in one subject and the anterior and peroneal compartments in the other. In response to distraction, these tissues had relatively high stiffness (> 200 N/mm), less "immediate" displacement (< 35% of long term non-recoverable displacement) and inconsistent force relaxation properties (0-90%). In contrast, when the force vector was located in the vicinity of the regenerate, tissue exhibited lower stiffness (< 50 N/mm) and more immediate displacement (> 65% of long term nonrecoverable displacement), but also exhibited inconsistent force relaxation (0-67%).