Comparison of pressure- and flow-triggered pressure-support ventilation on weaning parameters in patients recovering from acute respiratory failure

Ventilator auto-cycling from cardiogenic oscillations: case report and review of literature

BACKGROUND

Brain death is the total loss of all brain and brain stem functions, and its diagnosis is often confirmed by an apnoea test, which relies on disconnecting the patient from the ventilator. Auto-triggering or auto-cycling is defined as a ventilator being triggered in the absence of patient effort, intrinsic respiratory drive or inspiratory muscle activity. Ventilator auto-triggering could delay the diagnosis of brain death leading to unnecessary admission for the patient and false hopes of recovery for the family.

METHODS

We report a case of ventilator auto-triggering associated with cardiogenic oscillations in a female patient.

RESULTS

We confirmed the finding of ventilator auto-triggering by changing the patient's position and reassessing the triggering thresholds. Brain death was then confirmed by apnoea test.

CONCLUSION

This case is presented to arouse the awareness of the medical staff and nurses to this phenomenon, which can mimic an intrinsic respiratory effort in patients allegedly diagnosed with brain death. Along with this case report, we review the English language publications for similar cases.

Mechanical ventilation and the total artificial heart: optimal ventilator trigger to avoid post-operative autocycling - a case series and literature review

Many patients with end-stage cardiomyopathy are now being implanted with Total Artificial Hearts (TAHs). We have observed individual cases of post-operative mechanical ventilator autocycling with a flow trigger, and subsequent loss of autocycling after switching to a pressure trigger. These observations prompted us to do a retrospective review of all TAH devices placed at our institution between August 2007 and May 2009. We found that in the immediate post-operative period following TAH placement, autocycling was present in 50% (5/10) of cases. There was immediate cessation of autocycling in all patients after being changed from a flow trigger of 2 L/minute to a pressure trigger of 2 cm H₂O. The autocycling group was found to have significantly higher CVP values than the non-autocycling group (P = 0.012). Our data suggest that mechanical ventilator autocycling may be resolved or prevented by the use of a pressure trigger rather than a flow trigger setting in patients with TAHs who require mechanical ventilation.

Clinical review: patient-ventilator interaction in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Mechanically ventilated patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease often prove challenging to the clinician due to the complex pathophysiology of the disease and the high risk of patient-ventilator asynchrony. These problems are encountered in both intubated patients and those ventilated with noninvasive ventilation. Much knowledge has been gained over the years in our understanding of the mechanisms underlying the difficult interaction between these patients and the machines used to provide them with the ventilatory support they often require for prolonged periods. This paper attempts to summarize the various key issues of patient-ventilator interaction during pressure support ventilation, the most often used partial ventilatory support mode, and to draw clinicians' attention to the need for sufficient knowledge when setting the ventilator at the bedside, given the often conflicting goals that must be met.

Modulation and treatment of patient–ventilator dyssynchrony

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The coupling between ventilator delivered inspiratory flow and patient's demands both in terms of timing and drive is a challenging task that has become largely feasible in recent years. This review addresses the new advances to modulate and treat patient-ventilator dyssynchrony.

RECENT FINDINGS

Patient-ventilator dyssynchrony is a common phenomenon with conventional modes of mechanical ventilation which influence the duration of mechanical ventilation. Inspection of pressure, volume and flow waveforms represents a valuable tool for the physician to recognize and take the appropriate action to improve patient-ventilator synchrony. New developments have been introduced aiming to improve patient ventilator synchrony by modulating the triggering function and the variables that control the flow delivery and the cycling off.

SUMMARY

Patient-ventilator dyssynchrony may affect patients' outcome. New modes of assisted mechanical ventilation have been introduced and represent a major step forward in modulating patient-ventilator dyssynchrony.

Understanding and implementing advances in ventilator capabilities

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review the changes in mechanical ventilation technology over the past year and identify areas that provide a benefit.

RECENT FINDINGS

The literature demonstrates a continued effort to improve patient ventilator synchrony though the development of new triggering and cycling methods. These techniques include using new signals and using closed loop techniques to respond to changes in patient breathing pattern. New modes of ventilation continue to be introduced, often without proof of efficacy. Fortunately, clinicians have developed alterations to new modes that improve utility and they continue to study these techniques clinically to determine appropriate use. Monitoring the patient remains an important area of investigation, with a flurry of activity surrounding pressure volume curves of the respiratory system. Finally, new ventilators have been introduced that combine high-end performance with small size and weight, while providing an on-board source of air.

SUMMARY

Mechanical ventilation is ubiquitous to intensive care. Advances in ventilator technology are rapid, and clinicians must keep abreast of changes in ventilator performance and application.

Effect of continuous positive airway pressure on the rapid shallow breathing index in patients following cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVES

To compare the rapid shallow breathing index (RSBI) under different ventilatory support settings prior to extubation trials.

DESIGN

Prospective study.

SETTING

Cardiac surgery unit at a university hospital.

PATIENTS

A total of 33 coronary artery bypass grafting patients ready for extubation.

INTERVENTIONS

Enrolled patients received a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) trial of 5 cm H(2)O and fraction of inspired oxygen (FIO(2)) of 40% (condition 1), a CPAP trial of 5 cmH(2)O and FIO(2) of 21% (condition 2), and a 1-min spontaneously breathing room air trial without ventilatory support (condition 3). These trials were applied in random order.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Average values of respiratory frequency and tidal volume were measured under the three experimental conditions in all patients immediately prior to extubation. The RSBIs were determined for each patient under each condition; the average RSBIs under conditions 1, 2, and 3 were compared for significance. The average RSBIs (+/- SD) were significantly smaller under condition 1 (34 +/- 13) and condition 2 (36 +/- 14) compared to condition 3 (71 +/- 24). There was no significant difference in RSBI between conditions 1 and 2.

CONCLUSIONS

The administration of 5 cm H(2)O of CPAP can influence the determination of the RSBI. In contrast, changes in FIO(2) have no effect on RSBI determination. We speculate that using the RSBI during CPAP may mislead the clinician into premature discontinuation of mechanical ventilation. Consequently, different threshold values for the RSBI should be derived for different ventilatory support levels.

Autotriggering caused by cardiogenic oscillation during flow-triggered mechanical ventilation

OBJECTIVES

We noticed that in some patients after cardiac surgery, when flow triggering was used, cardiogenic oscillation might be autotriggering the ventilatory support. In a prospective study, we evaluated the degree of cardiogenic oscillation and the frequency rate of autotriggering. We suspected that autotriggering caused by cardiogenic oscillation was more common than clinically appreciated.

DESIGN

Prospective, nonrandomized, clinical study.

SETTING

Surgical intensive care unit in a national heart institute.

PATIENTS

A total of 104 adult patients were enrolled after cardiac surgery.

INTERVENTIONS

During the study period, patients were paralyzed and ventilated with intermittent mandatory ventilation at a rate of 10 breaths/min, pressure support of 10 cm H2O, and flow triggering with a sensitivity of 1 L/min.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Because the patients would not be able to breathe spontaneously, we counted pressure-support (PS) breaths as instances of autotriggering. Then, we classified the patients into two groups according to the number of PS breaths: an "AT group" (PS breaths of >5/min) and a "non-AT group" (PS breaths of < or =5/min). If autotriggering occurred, we decreased the sensitivity so autotriggering disappeared (threshold triggering sensitivity). The intensity of cardiogenic oscillation was assessed as the flow and airway pressure at the airway opening. A total of 23 patients (22%) demonstrated more than five autotriggered breaths/min. During mechanical ventilation, the inspiratory flow fluctuation caused by cardiogenic oscillation was significantly greater in the AT group than in the non-AT group (4.67+/-1.26 L/min vs. 2.03+/-0.86 L/min; p<.01). The AT group also showed larger cardiac output, higher ventricular filling pressures, larger heart size, and lower respiratory system resistance than the non-AT group. As the inspiratory flow fluctuation caused by cardiogenic oscillation increased, the level of triggering sensitivity also was increased to avoid autotriggering. In the AT group with 1 L/min of sensitivity, the respiratory rate increased (19.9+/-2.7 vs. 10+/-0 breaths/min, p<.01), Paco2 decreased (30.8+/-4.0 torr [4.11+/-0.36 kPa] vs. 37.6+/-4.3 torr [5.01+/-0.57 kPa]; p < .01), and mean esophageal pressure increased (7.7+/-3.0 vs. 6.9+/-3.0 cm H2O; p<.01) compared with the threshold triggering sensitivity.

CONCLUSIONS

Autotriggering caused by cardiogenic oscillation is common in postcardiac surgery patients when flow triggering is used. Autotriggering occurred more often in patients with more dynamic circulation. Autotriggering caused respiratory alkalosis and hyperinflation of the lungs.

Weaning from mechanical ventilation

Practice guidelines on weaning should be based on the results of several well-designed randomized studies performed over the last decade. One of those studies demonstrated that immediate extubation after successful trials of spontaneous breathing expedites weaning and reduces the duration of mechanical ventilation as compared with a more gradual discontinuation of ventilatory support. Two other studies showed that the ability to breathe spontaneously can be adequately tested by performing a trial with either T-tube or pressure support of 7 cmH2O lasting either 30 or 120 min. In patients with unsuccessful weaning trials, a gradual withdrawal for mechanical ventilation can be attempted while factors responsible for the ventilatory dependence are corrected. Two randomized studies found that, in difficult-to-wean patients, synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation (SIMV) is the most ineffective [corrected] method of weaning.

Effects of flow triggering on breathing effort during partial ventilatory support

The effects of flow triggering (FT) as compared with pressure triggering (PT) on breathing effort have been the focus of several studies, and discrepant results have been reported. In the initial part of our study, a lung model was used to quantify triggering effort (airway pressure-time product, PTPaw) for a range of sensitivity settings in nine new-generation ventilators. A ventilator providing both FT and PT was then used to compare these systems during pressure-support (PSV) and volume-targeted assist-control ventilation (ACV) in eight ventilator-dependent patients, using sensitivity settings (2 L/min for FT and -2 cm H2O for PT) that had proven significantly different in the initial bench study. Indexes of effort included the esophageal and transdiaphragmatic pressure-time products and inspiratory work of breathing per minute (PTPes/min, PTPdi/min, and Wi/min, respectively). The experimental study revealed significant differences between ventilators in PTPaw at commonly used settings. In two of three ventilators featuring both systems, PTPaw was significantly lower with FT than PT (p < 0.001). In the clinical study, FT as compared with PT, was associated with reductions in all indexes of breathing effort during PSV: 16 +/- 6% (p < 0.001), 13 +/- 10% (p < 0.01), and 14 +/- 12% (p < 0.05) for PTPdi/min, PTPes/min, and Wi/min, respectively. By contrast, no differences were found when FT was used during ACV. Although FT reduced triggering effort in both modes (p < 0.001), the effects observed during the post-trigger phase differed, and explained the discrepant results between the two modes. We conclude that FT more effectively reduces breathing effort when used in conjunction with a pressure-targeted mode than with a volume-targeted mode, especially when flow delivery is close to or below demand.