Inhibition of peridural fibrosis after laminectomy using low-dose external beam radiation in a rat model

MMC controlled-release membranes attenuate epidural scar formation in rat models after laminectomy

Epidural scar formation after laminectomy impede surgical outcomes of decompression. Mitomycin C (MMC) has been demonstrated to have significant inhibitory effects on epidural scar. This study was undertaken to develop an effective MMC controlled-release membrane and to investigate its effects on epidural scar in rat models of laminectomy. A total of 72 rats that underwent laminectomy were divided into three groups. Among them, 24 were treated with mitomycin C-polylactic acid (MMC-PLA) controlled-release membrane, 24 with mitomycin C-polyethylene glycol (MMC-PEG) controlled-release membrane, and no treatment was performed for the remaining 24 rats (control group). In the following 4 weeks, magnetic resonance image (MRI), macroscopic observation, histology and hydroxyproline (Hyp) concentration analysis were performed to explore the effects of these three therapies on epidural scar. MRI revealed a significant reduction of epidural fibrosis in MMC-PLA and MMC-PEG treatment groups, compared with the control group. Histological results also showed that collagen deposition was significantly reduced after being treated with MMC-PLA or MMC-PEG membranes. Likewise, Hyp concentrations of the epidural scar tissue in MMC-PLA and MMC-PEG groups were markedly lower than those in the control group. However, regarding the effects on reducing epidural scar, no significant difference was found between the MMC-PLA and MMC-PEG groups. In conclusion, MMC-PLA and MMC-PEG membranes are safe and effective in reducing fibrosis. Thus, MMC-controlled-release membranes promises to be a potential therapeutic in preventing epidural scar formation after laminectomy.

Effects of a Temperature-Sensitive, Anti-Adhesive Agent on the Reduction of Adhesion in a Rabbit Laminectomy Model

OBJECTIVE

A common cause of failure in laminectomy surgery is when epidural, peridural, or perineural adhesion occurs postoperatively. The purpose of this study is to examine the efficacy of a temperature-sensitive, anti-adhesive agent (TSAA agent), Guardix-SG®, as a mechanical barrier for the prevention or reduction of peridural scar adhesion in a rabbit laminectomy model.

METHODS

Twenty-six mature rabbits were used for this study. Each rabbit underwent two separate laminectomies at lumbar vertebrae L3 and L6, left empty (the control group) and applied 2 mL of the TSAA agent (the experimental group), respectively. Invasive scar formation or inflammation after laminectomy was quantitatively evaluated by measuring the thickness of the dura, the distance from the surface of dura to the scar tissues, the number of inflammatory cells in the scar tissues at the laminectomy site, and the concentration of collagen in histological sections.

RESULTS

At 6 weeks postsurgery, the dura was significantly thinner and the distance from the surface of dura to the scar tissues was greater in the experimental group than in the control group (p=0.04 and p=0.01). The number of inflammatory cells was not significantly different in the two groups (p=0.08), although the mean number of inflammatory cells was relatively lower in the experimental group than in the control group.

CONCLUSION

The current study suggests that the TSAA agent, Guardix-SG®, could be useful as an interpositional physical barrier after laminectomy for the prevention or reduction of adhesion.

Significance of the mass-compression effect of postlaminectomy/laminotomy fibrosis on histological changes on the dura mater and nerve root of the cauda equina: an experimental study in rats

PURPOSE

The precise mechanism and pathological role of postlaminectomy/laminotomy fibrosis (PLF) in postoperative neurological deficits have not been established. Many studies use magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to prove that there is no consistent correlation between PLF and postoperative neurological deficits and back pain (PNDBP). Therefore, we assumed that the direct-compression effect may not be the only factor but that other neurological deficits associated with pathological mechanisms should exist and need more investigation. The purpose of this study was to compare over time the differences and changes in histopathological properties of PLF in rats.

METHODS

We used a rat model with walking-track analysis for neurologic evaluation, grading scale to evaluate PLF, histomorphometric measurements of dura sac diameter, and histological tissue reactions (dura mater and spinal rootlets) juxtaposed to the postlaminectomy/laminotomy defect. The 54 adult Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into laminotomy (n = 18), laminectomy (n = 18), and sham-operation groups (n = 18). All groups were subdivided into three equal subgroups based on different postoperative time points (1, 2, and 3 months). All sections of vertebral column were stained with hematoxylin and eosin and with Masson's trichrome.

RESULTS

The results showed that only a slight compression effect reflected by nonsignificant changes in the maximum anterior-posterior diameters within the dura sac, in the walking tract test, and increased grades of PLF over time. In addition, significant pathological inflammatory changes, such as thickening of the dura mater, axonal swelling, and neovascularization, were found in the post-laminectomy/laminotomy groups at each time point.

CONCLUSION

Laminectomy-/laminotomy-related inflammation may lead to PLF, and these pathological changes may be the main cause of postoperative neurological deficits. These findings show that research on preventing PLF should include perioperative modulation of inflammatory reactions induced by laminectomy/laminotomy.

Alpha-lipoic acid reduces peridural fibrosis after laminectomy of lumbar vertebrae in rabbits

BACKGROUND

Peridural fibrosis is an inevitable healing process causing failed back surgery syndrome after lumbar spinal operations. In this study, alpha-lipoic acid (ALA), reported to reduce fibrosis in liver, oral mucosa, and peritoneum, investigated as a potential candidate for prevention of peridural fibrosis.

METHOD

Twelve adult New Zealand white male rabbits were divided into control (n = 5) and ALA groups (n = 7). Laminectomy of lumbar spine was performed and ALA was applied on the exposed dura mater topically in ALA group.

RESULTS

According to histological peridural grading, the ALA group (median grade 1) showed significantly less peridural fibrosis than the control group (median grade 3, p = 0.005).

CONCLUSIONS

ALA is a promising substance in the prevention of peridural fibrosis, especially in early preoperative and postoperative period.

Mitomycin C-polyethylene glycol controlled-release film inhibits collagen secretion and induces apoptosis of fibroblasts in the early wound of a postlaminectomy rat model

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Recovery from spine surgery is usually accompanied with the development of epidural scar adhesions from the abnormal proliferation of fibroblast and extracellular matrix-related metabolism. Polyethylene glycol (PEG) could alleviate the postsurgical adhesion formation with still leaving a gap between the sheet and the dura. However, PEG film could not function as a three-dimensional barrier to prevent adhesion completely. Mitomycin C (MMC) could also reduce the scar formation after surgery, but cytotoxicity and the administrative pathway prevent its application.

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to design and attest the role of new delivery system MMC-PEG controlled-release film in preventing the epidural scar adhesions after laminectomy in the rat model.

STUDY DESIGN/SETTING

A total laminectomy of L1 in the rat model was used to assess epidural fibrosis between and around the spinal nerves using a histochemistry assessment along with flow cytometry analysis.

PATIENT SAMPLE

The sample comprises 64 adult male Sprague-Dawley rats.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The outcome measures are macroscopic evaluation, histological analysis, and flow cytometry analysis.

METHODS

Lumbar laminectomies at L1 and L2 with a L1-L2 disc injury were performed on 64 adult male Sprague-Dawley rats. The rats were then randomized into four groups. In Group I, 25 mg PEG film was applied on the dura mater in the laminectomy area before the layers were sutured. In Group II, a cotton pad soaked with 0.05% MMC solution was kept on the laminectomy area for 5 minutes. In Group III, 25 mg PEG film containing 0.01% MMC was implanted on the laminectomy area. In Group IV, the laminectomy area was flushed with saline before wound closure. The rats were sacrificed 4 weeks after the operation. Macroscopic evaluation and histological analysis of epidural scar adhesion with the hematoxylin and eosin stain and Masson stain were used followed by the quantification of hydroxyproline (Hyp) and flow cytometry analysis of the apoptosis of fibroblasts in the scar tissues.

RESULTS

The recovery of all rats was uneventful after the operations. In the laminectomy sites of rats treated with MMC or MMC-PEG, the dura mater was clean without any evident adhesion or membrane. Collagen tissue hyperplasia significantly decreased in the MMC- or MMC-PEG-treated models. Accordingly, Hyp concentration was significantly reduced in these two groups compared with saline-control group. In addition, the apoptosis of fibroblasts, however, was significantly elevated in the MMC or MMC-PEG group compared with the saline-control group.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that the treatment of postlaminectomy wounds with MMC-PEG film reduces the severity of adhesion by decreasing the concentration of Hyp and increasing the apoptosis of fibroblasts.

Neurophysiological and histopathological evaluation of low-dose radiation on the cauda equina and postlaminotomy fibrosis: an experimental study in the rat

STUDY DESIGN

We evaluated the electrophysiological changes to the cauda equina after low-dose external irradiation in a postlaminotomy fibrosis model in rats.

OBJECTIVE

To clarify the immediate and long-term electrophysiological responses of antifibrotic radiation therapy in a fibrosis model.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Low-dose perioperative radiation therapy inhibits scar formation. However, its efficacy for preventing fibrosis-induced compressive neuropathy and its potential adverse effect on underlying neural structures have not been studied.

METHODS

Twenty-four rats were placed in 3 groups of 8: group I, sham operation (laminar exposure alone) with a single fraction of 700 cGy external irradiation given using a 9-MeV electron beam 24 hours postsurgery; group II, left L5 hemilaminectomy (laminotomy) alone; and group III, left L5 hemilaminectomy with the same radiation protocol as group 1. We recorded mixed-nerve-elicited somatosensory-evoked potentials (M-SSEP)- and dermal (D)-SSEP at the thoracolumbar junction, and L1-L2 interspinous ligament after percutaneously stimulating the posterior tibial nerve at the bilateral medial ankle and L5 dermatomal fields. We compared the potentials recorded immediately before, 30 minutes, 2 weeks, and 1, 2, and 3 months after surgery on the operated and nonoperated sides. We used gross dissection and histologic sections to evaluate the degree of perineural fibrosis and walking-track analysis for neurologic evaluation.

RESULTS

Pre- and postoperative (30 minutes and 2 weeks) M- and D-SSEP were not statistically different. In group II, the relative amplitude of D-SSEP (elicited from 5 dermatomes) 1, 2, and 3 months postsurgery was lower; however, the M-SSEP in all groups and D-SSEP of groups I and III remained constant. Histologic evaluation of radiation efficacy showed that the frequency and extent of peridural fibrosis was consistently lower in group II than in group III.

CONCLUSION

Low-dose irradiation reduced peridural fibrosis and prevented fibrosis-induced radiculopathy. The radiation caused no adverse neuropathic complications.

Outcome following lumbar disc surgery: the role of fibrosis

BACKGROUND

Failed-back surgery syndrome remains a challenge for spinal surgeons. It can be related to several causes, including poor surgical indication, misdiagnosis, surgical technique failure, spondilodiscitis and fibrosis. Fibrosis has been associated with a poorer outcome in lumbar disc surgery, although its role in the generation of symptoms is not yet clear. In this study, the authors have analyzed any possible correlation between the clinical outcome and the degree of fibrosis.

METHOD

Forty consecutive patients were enrolled in a prospective study. All of them had operations in the lower lumbar disc in a single level for the first time. Three months after the operation they were submitted to clinical outcome evaluations and questionnaires, including Numeric Pain Rating scales (NPR) for lumbar and leg pain, the McGill Pain Questionnaire, The Quebec Back Pain Disability scale (QBPD) and Straight Leg Raising test. These data were correlated with the degree of fibrosis as revealed by Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI).

FINDINGS

After 3 months, the NPR values for lumbar and leg pain ranged from 0 to 8 (mean 2.32 and 1.67 respectively). The values of the post-operative QBPD scale ranged from 1 to 71 (mean 25.9). Every patient showed a varied degree of fibrosis on MRI. However, statistical analysis depicted no significant correlation between fibrosis and a poorer clinical outcome for pain and disability.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors found no correlation between excessive fibrosis with lumbar and leg pain, disability or straight leg resistance. The role of fibrosis in the generation of symptoms in patients who have had lumbar disc surgery should be reevaluated.

Effect of straight-leg-raising movement on epidural fibrosis in early stage after laminectomy in a rabbit model

To determine the effect of straight-leg-raising (SLR) movement on epidural fibrosis after laminectomy, 40 adult New Zealand rabbits were selected as laminectomy models in the study. They were divided into 2 groups: a SLR group (group S) and a control group (group C) randomly, with each group having 20 animals. All rabbits were subjected to total laminectomy in the site of S1. Every 5 rabbits in each group selected randomly were killed at the 1st, 2nd, 4th, and 8th week after the surgery. Segments of spines from L7 to S2 were removed en bloc. After gross evaluation, specimens were sliced up. The slices were stained by HE and Masson's trichrome methods respectively for histological examination. Our results showed that formation process of scar in group S was retarded as compared with that of group C at the time of the 2nd-week, but there was no statistical difference between groups in the adhesion degree (P> or =0.05). At the 4th and 8th week, the epidural fibrosis of group S was more serious than that of group C. Since the 2nd-week, the area of scar in group S was larger than that of group C. The number of fibroblasts and inflammatory cells in group S were larger than those of group C at early stage. But in later stage, there was no statistical significance between the two groups. It is concluded that SLR movement after laminectomy may promote the formation of epidural fibrosis and retard the maturity of scar. SLR movement can also aggravate scar adhesion.

The influence of vertebral instability on peridural circulation and concomitant peridural fibrosis formation

An animal model of vertebral instability was used to analyze the effect of chronic lumbar instability on the peridural vasculature and fibrosis formation. Fifty mature male domestic rabbits were divided into five equal groups. The vertebral instability was performed by excision of supra and interspinous ligaments between L2-L3 and L3-L4, excision of transverse and spinous processes and making bilateral laminectomies and facetectomies in groups I, II, III and IV. In group V only para vertebral muscle dissection was performed without vertebral instability. The simulation of the long term effects of overuse model on unstable spines (chronic instability) were performed with the use of Electrical Neuromuscular Stimulator to simulate cyclic flexion-extension movement in groups I, II. The rabbits in group I and III were sacrified for the histological evaluation at postoperative fifth day. The rabbits in groups I II, IV and V were sacrified at postoperative 21st day. There was no peridural venous endothelial injury or stasis but there was an increased amount of polymorph nuclear leukocytes in both group I (unstable-overuse) and group III (unstable-no overuse) after sacrification at postoperative fifth day. Peridural fibrosis and also vascular changes with different grades were seen in group II, VI and V after sacrification at postoperative 21st day. The grade of the venous changes and the mean amount of peridural scar formation were prominently higher in group II (unstable-overuse) than in group IV (unstable-no overuse) and V (control group). There was no difference between group IV and V for peridural scar formation and vascular changes. In conclusion, the instability of the lumbar spine with overuse could be a cause of peridural venous circulatory impairment, resulting in fibrosis formation.

The role of closed-suction drainage in preventing epidural fibrosis and its correlation with a new grading system of epidural fibrosis on the basis of MRI

In this study we aimed to evaluate the role of closed-suction drainage on the extent of epidural fibrosis (EF) after lumbar disc surgery and to define a new grading system of epidural fibrosis in these patients, based on magnetic resonance imaging. Seventy-nine patients (34 women, 45 men) with a unilateral, single-level lumbar disc herniation were included in this study. Forty-one patients in whom closed-suction drainage was implanted were compared with 38 patients in whom the drain was not implanted. We have used a new grading system for the extent of epidural fibrosis, on the basis of follow-up magnetic resonance imaging findings. Pain intensity was evaluated by visual analog scale (VAS), and the patients' function and working ability were measured according to the Prolo functional-economic scale. We conclude that, in patients operated on for unilateral, single-level lumbar disc hernias, implantation of closed-suction drainage into the operation site results in less formation of EF radiologically and yields better clinical outcome.

Reduction in experimental peridural adhesion with the use of a crosslinked hyaluronate/collagen membrane

The research goals were to fabricate a crosslinked hyaluronate (HA)/collagen membrane and study its efficacy in preventing peridural adhesion. Different weight ratios of HA/collagen membranes crosslinked with carbodiimide were tested for biocompatibility and biodegradability first. Forty-eight adult New Zealand white rabbits underwent an L6 laminectomy. Sixteen rabbits each received a weight ratio of HA/collagen = 60/40 membrane (Membrane A) or a 40/60 membrane (Membrane B) on the exposed dura. The last 16 rabbits received no treatment and served as controls. No adverse reaction of the membranes was noted. Magnetic resonance images revealed a hyposignal space between the dura and the scar tissues at Membrane B-treated laminectomy site 3 months after surgery. Histological examination showed that the amount of scarring decreased with time in all groups. Amount of scarring decreased significantly at laminectomy sites treated with either membrane. Compared with the control group, the extent of peridural adhesion decreased significantly in the Membrane B-treated group at 3 months after surgery; while it decreased substantially, but not significantly, in the Membrane A-treated group. The carbodiimide-crosslinked HA/collagen membrane is a safe and effective antiadhesive material in vivo. When placed onto the laminectomy site, the membrane with a weight ratio of HA/collagen = 40/60 appears to reduce peridural scar adhesion.

Seprafilm superior to Gore-Tex in the prevention of peridural fibrosis

OBJECT

This is an investigation into the effects of two barrier membranes in the prevention of peridural fibrosis in an animal model.

METHODS

Seprafilm or Gore-Tex was applied to a laminectomy defect overlying the dura mater in rats separated into treatment groups. A third group of rats underwent laminectomy only and served as controls. Two months postoperatively a histological study was performed to compare the amount of scar tissue in each group. The gross dissection demonstrated that both membranes created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the amount of tissue adhering to the dura mater. Statistically, Seprafilm was superior to Gore-Tex in preventing peridural fibrosis (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Seprafilm can prevent peridural fibrosis better than Gore-Tex and can be used in humans in spinal surgery.

The Effect of Low-dose External Beam Radiation on Extraneural Scarring after Peripheral Nerve Surgery in Rats

OBJECTIVE

Scar tissue is an inevitable result of peripheral nerve surgery. A variety of substances have been used to prevent epineurial scarring. In this study, the effect of low-dose radiation therapy on epineurial scarring was investigated.

METHODS

Seventy-eight male Sprague-Dawley rats were studied. A total of 60 rats were subjected to one of three types of surgical procedure on the sciatic nerve, as follows: Procedure 1, external neurolysis (n = 20); Procedure 2, abrasive injury (n = 20); and Procedure 3, anastomosis (n = 20). On the left sciatic nerves, 700 cGy external beam radiation was administered 24 hours after surgery, and the right sciatic nerves served as a control group (surgery only). Eighteen animals without surgical intervention were used to establish the fibrotic effect of radiotherapy on normal nerves. A neurological examination was performed weekly. Six weeks after surgery, the extent of extraneural scarring was examined by gross microdissection by means of a numerical grading scheme and histological analysis. Cellular density and surface measurements of scar tissue were also evaluated.

RESULTS

The dissection around the nerve was easier in rats treated with low-dose radiation compared with the control group. Furthermore, grading scores in both nerve adherence and nerve separability were significantly lower in treated nerves than in the control group (P < or = 0.05). Low-dose radiotherapy decreased the scores of cellular density and surface measurement of scar tissue (P < or = 0.05). In normal nerves, radiotherapy did not produce any fibrotic effects and the density of fibroblasts/fibrocytes was also very low.

CONCLUSION

In the case of surgery or local trauma to peripheral nerve, the use of low-dose radiation therapy may be a safe method of limiting postoperative epineurial scar formation.

Low-dose radiotherapy for the inhibition of peridural fibrosis after reexploratory nerve root decompression for postlaminectomy syndrome

OBJECT

The authors of clinical studies have demonstrated a significant association between the presence of extensive post-lumbar discectomy peridural scar formation and the recurrence of low-back and radicular pain. Low-dose perioperative radiotherapy has been demonstrated to inhibit peridural fibrosis after laminectomy in animal models. The present study was designed to evaluate the clinical efficacy of preoperative irradiation in patients with failed-back surgery syndrome due to peridural fibrosis who underwent reexploration and nerve root decompression.

METHODS

Ten patients with symptomatic post-discectomy peridural fibrosis were randomized. Half of the patients underwent 700-cGy external-beam irradiation to the operative site 24 hours prior to reexploration and decompressive treatment of their symptomatic nerve root(s) (treatment group) and the other half underwent reexploration and decompressive treatment without preoperative irradiation (control group). All patients underwent simulated irradiation so neither patient nor surgeon was aware of the patient's group. In all patients the antiadhesion product ADCON-L was placed over the affected nerve root at the time of surgery. Clinical outcome was assessed using the American Association of Neurological Surgeons/Congress of Neurological Surgeons Joint Section Lumbar Disc Herniation Study Questionnaire at baseline, 6 weeks, 3 months, and 1 year follow up. Five men and five women (mean age 42 years) underwent randomization and surgery. Three patients underwent reexploration at L4-5, four at L5-S1, and three at both levels. No complication was associated with irradiation, and no new neurological deficits occurred. At 1-year follow-up examination, three irradiation-treated patients were pain free and two experienced improvement. In the control group, three patients experienced improved pain relief and two were unchanged. There was a trend toward better outcome at 1 year in the radiotherapy-treated group (p = 0.056).

CONCLUSIONS

Preoperative low-dose external-beam irradiation improved clinical outcomes after reexploration and decompression of nerve roots affected by postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis causing radicular pain. The addition of preoperative irradiation may improve outcome in patients who undergo reoperation for recurrent radicular pain associated with a significant amount of peridural fibrosis, particularly now that no antiadhesion product is available for clinical use.

Use of polylactide resorbable film as an adhesion barrier

OBJECT

The present investigation evaluates two thicknesses of a resorbable polylactic acid (PLA) barrier film as an adhesion barrier to posterior spinal scar formation.

METHODS

A readily contourable, thin film was placed directly over the dura. The thick film was placed above the lamina defect to act as a physical barrier inhibiting the prolapse of soft tissue into the epidural space. Through a combination of gross dissection with and without scar scores, quantitative analysis of collagen adjacent to the scar site, and histological evaluation, the resorbable adhesion barrier membranes were found to be effective treatment for reduction of posterior adhesions.

CONCLUSIONS

The gross dissection demonstrated that both thicknesses of resorbable PLA barrier films created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the tissue adherent to the dura.

Use of polylactide resorbable film as an adhesion barrier

The present investigation evaluates two thicknesses of a resorbable polylactide barrier film as an adhesion barrier to posterior spine scar formation. A readily contourable, thin film was placed directly over the dura. The thick film was placed above the lamina defect to act as a physical barrier inhibiting the prolapse of soft tissue into the epidural space. Through a combination of gross dissection with and without scar scores, quantitative analysis of collagen adjacent to the scar site, and histologic evaluation, the resorbable adhesion barrier membranes were found to be effective treatment for reduction of posterior adhesions. The gross dissection demonstrated that both thicknesses of resorbable polymer barrier films created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the tissue adhered to the dura.

Inhibition of epidural scar tissue formation after spinal surgery: external irradiation vs. spinal membrane application

PURPOSE

The scar tissue that forms after lumbar dissection is a severe complication and a cause of lumbar and radicular pain. It was recently shown that radiotherapy could inhibit peridural fibrosis after laminectomy. In this study, the efficiency of external irradiation was compared with spinal membrane application.

METHOD AND MATERIALS

Thirty male New Zealand rabbits underwent L5 laminectomy. Ten rabbits each received a single fraction of 900-cGy external irradiation administered by 9-MeV electron beam 24 h after the surgery. Ten other rabbits each had spinal membrane applied during laminectomy. The remaining 10 rabbits constituted the control group. All of the rabbits were killed 30 days after the laminectomy. Axial histologic sections through the laminectomy defect were evaluated. Each specimen was scored for the extent and density of fibrosis and arachnoidal adherence.

RESULTS

The extent and density of fibrosis and arachnoidal adherence differed significantly between the control group and the treatment groups (p < 0.05). However, the extent and density of fibrosis and arachnoidal adherence did not differ significantly between the spinal membrane and irradiation groups (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

This preliminary study showed that high-single-fraction/low-total-dose administered postoperatively can successfully inhibit postsurgical epidural fibrosis as effectively as applied spinal membrane.

Late postoperative results in 1000 work related lumbar spine conditions

BACKGROUND

Poor results after lumbar spinal surgery have been recorded in compensation cases throughout the world medical literature. It seems that psychosocial factors play an important role in the delay in returning to gainful employment but that chronic postoperative lumbar and lower extremity pain is blamed for this state of affairs. The present series of late outcomes is based on actual physical examination by independent neurosurgical and orthopedic experts appointed by the Workman's Compensation Board, providing an impartial opinion as to the discrepancy between objective findings and failure to reintegrate into the work force.

METHODS

One thousand workmen's compensation patients who had undergone lumbar spinal surgery were divided into two groups, one of 600 patients with single operations, evaluated on average 51 months after surgery, and the second of 400 with multiple operations, evaluated on average 38 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Seventy-one percent of the single operation group had not returned to work more than 4 years after the operation, and 95% of the multiple operations group. In none of these cases was there a neurological deficit that precluded gainful employment, the failure to return to work being blamed on chronic postoperative pain.

CONCLUSIONS

Although motivational (that is, psychosocial) factors undoubtedly play a role in failure to return to work, the role of chronic pain cannot be ignored. Increased attention must be devoted to ascertaining the etiology of this pain and ways to prevent it.

Inhibition of peridural fibrosis after laminectomy using low-dose external beam radiation in a dog model

OBJECTIVE

Clinical studies have demonstrated a significant association between the presence of extensive postlumbar discectomy peridural scar formation and the recurrence of low back and radicular pain. Low-dose perioperative radiation therapy has previously been demonstrated to inhibit peridural fibrosis after laminectomy in a rat model. The current study was designed to measure the effect of low-dose radiation on postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis development in a larger animal model.

METHODS

Three dogs underwent a total of 12 lumbar hemilaminectomies. For each animal, two levels received 1) external beam radiation 24 hours before surgery, 2) surgery alone, or 3) radiation alone. Radiation was administered in a single fraction of 700 cGy using computed tomographic guidance for dosimetry planning. The isodose distribution was such that the dose conformed to the posterior epidural space with minimal exit dose to normal tissue. Port films were used to confirm the correct levels. Gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the lumbar spines was obtained before the animals were killed 12 weeks after surgery. The spines were harvested, and axial sections through the laminectomy defect were stained with hematoxylin and eosin and Masson's trichrome. All specimens were evaluated for extent of fibrosis along the dura, density of fibrosis, nerve root entrapment, and sublaminar fibrosis.

RESULTS

There were no complications from the surgery, and no new neurological deficits were noted. There was a statistically significant difference between the irradiated and nonirradiated groups regarding the extent of fibrosis (P = 0.001) and the density of fibroblasts (P = 0.001). There was also a marked difference in nerve root entrapment (P = 0.182) and the presence of sublaminar fibrosis (P = 0.061) between the treatment and control groups. MRI revealed less gadolinium enhancement at the irradiated levels compared with the nonirradiated levels, confirming the usefulness of MRI in predicting the degree of epidural fibrosis.

CONCLUSION

Low-dose external beam radiation therapy administered 24 hours before laminectomy in a dog model significantly decreased the extent and density of peridural fibrosis as well as nerve root entrapment and sublaminar fibrosis. This treatment strategy may be efficacious in patients with recurrent radicular pain after lumbar discectomy that is thought to be secondary to peridural fibrosis on the basis of gadolinium-enhanced MRI studies, and who might benefit from reoperation for nerve root decompression.