The clinical course of IgA-nephropathy and Henoch-Schönlein purpura following renal transplantation

Risk factors and outcomes of IgA nephropathy recurrence after kidney transplantation: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

IgA nephropathy may recur in patients receiving kidney transplantation due to IgA nephropathy induced renal failure. The risk factors for recurrence are still at issue. The aim of this study was to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis to assess risk factors and outcomes for IgA nephropathy recurrence.

Methods

We used PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Scopus, CNKI, WanFang, VIP and CBM to search for relevant studies published in English and Chinese. Cohort or case-control studies reporting risk factors or outcomes for IgA nephropathy recurrence were included.

Results

Fifty-eight studies were included. Compare to no recurrence group, those with IgAN recurrence had younger age (mean difference [MD]=-4.27 years; risk ratio [RR]=0.96), younger donor age (MD=-2.19 years), shorter time from IgA nephropathy diagnosis to end stage renal disease (MD=-1.84 years; RR=0.94), shorter time on dialysis (MD=-3.14 months), lower human leukocyte-antigen (HLA) mismatches (MD=-0.11) and HLA-DR mismatches (MD=-0.13). HLA-B46 antigen (RR=0.39), anti-IL-2-R antibodies induction (RR=0.68), mycophenolate mofetil (RR=0.69), and pretransplant tonsillectomy (RR=0.43) were associated with less IgAN recurrence. Of note, male recipient gender (RR=1.17), related donor (RR=1.53), retransplantation (RR=1.43), hemodialysis (RR=1.68), no induction therapy (RR=1.73), mTOR inhibitor (RR=1.51), angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors or angiotensin-receptor blockers (RR=1.63) were risk factors for IgAN recurrence. Recurrence increased the risk of graft loss (RR=2.19).

Conclusions

This study summarized the risk factors for recurrence of IgA nephropathy after kidney transplantation. Well-designed prospective studies are warranted for validation.

Systematic Review Registration

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?RecordID=377480, identifier CRD42022377480.

Two Decades Outcomes of Posttransplant Immunoglobulin A Nephropathy in Live Donor Renal Transplantation

Background:

The data on long-term outcomes of posttransplant immunoglobulin A nephropathy (IgAN) are confounding and vary with geography and ethnicity worldwide. We aimed to study the long-term graft outcomes of patients with posttransplant IgAN in the northern Indian cohort.

Methods:

The long-term graft outcomes of 51 live donor renal transplant recipients with biopsy-proven posttransplant IgAN (recurrence/de novo) were analyzed. The risk factors for graft failure in the posttransplant IgA groups were analyzed using the Cox regression analysis.

Results:

Out of the total of 51 patients who had posttransplant IgAN, 40 patients had a biopsy-proven native kidney IgAN. The mean duration of the clinical presentation of posttransplant IgAN was 62.4 months (5.2 years) posttransplant. Proteinuria at the time of biopsy was 3.03 ± 2.2 g/day, and 41.2% had proteinuria of more than 3 g/day at the time of biopsy. The estimated 1, 5, 10, and 20 years patient survival was 98%, 95.4%, 75.9%, and 25.2%, respectively, and the estimated 1, 5, 10, and 20 years graft survival was 98%, 88.5%, 44.6%, and 11.9%, respectively, in patients who had posttransplant IgA. Many of the traditional risk factors associated with progression in native kidney IgAN, such as the degree of proteinuria, Oxford MEST (mesangial and endocapillary hypercellularity, segmental sclerosis, and interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy) scoring, recipient's age, and sex were not predictive of early graft failure among patients with posttransplant IgAN. In our cohort, the only significant graft failure predictor was serum creatinine at 5 years. Chronic antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) was seen in 21.6% of patients with posttransplant IgAN. Whether this coexistence of chronic ABMR is an incidental finding or posttransplant IgAN predisposes to chronic ABMR requires further investigation.

Conclusion:

Posttransplant IgAN is associated with poor long-term graft outcomes in live donor renal transplants. Proteinuria and MEST scoring were not predictive of graft failure in living donor posttransplant IgAN.

IgA Vasculitis and IgA Nephropathy: Same Disease?

Many authors suggested that IgA Vasculitis (IgAV) and IgA Nephropathy (IgAN) would be two clinical manifestations of the same disease; in particular, that IgAV would be the systemic form of the IgAN. A limited number of studies have included sufficient children or adults with IgAN or IgAV (with or without nephropathy) and followed long enough to conclude on differences or similarities in terms of clinical, biological or histological presentation, physiopathology, genetics or prognosis. All therapeutic trials available on IgAN excluded patients with vasculitis. IgAV and IgAN could represent different extremities of a continuous spectrum of the same disease. Due to skin rash, patients with IgAV are diagnosed precociously. Conversely, because of the absence of any clinical signs, a renal biopsy is practiced for patients with an IgAN to confirm nephropathy at any time of the evolution of the disease, which could explain the frequent chronic lesions at diagnosis. Nevertheless, the question that remains unsolved is why do patients with IgAN not have skin lesions and some patients with IgAV not have nephropathy? Larger clinical studies are needed, including both diseases, with a common histological classification, and stratified on age and genetic background to assess renal prognosis and therapeutic strategies.

Recurrence of immunoglobulin A nephropathy after kidney transplantation: a narrative review of the incidence, risk factors, pathophysiology and management of immunosuppressive therapy

Glomerulonephritis (GN) is the underlying cause of end-stage renal failure in 30–50% of kidney transplant recipients. It represents the primary cause of end-stage renal disease for 25% of the dialysis population and 45% of the transplant population. For patients with GN requiring renal replacement therapy, kidney transplantation is associated with superior outcomes compared with dialysis. Recurrent GN was previously considered to be a minor contributor to graft loss, but with the prolongation of graft survival, the effect of recurrent disease on graft outcome assumes increasing importance. Thus the extent of recurrence of original kidney disease after kidney transplantation has been underestimated for several reasons. This review aims to provide updated knowledge on one particular recurrent renal disease after kidney transplantation, immunoglobulin A nephropathy (IgAN). IgAN is one of the most common GNs worldwide. The pathogenesis of IgAN is complex and remains incompletely understood. Evidence to date is most supportive of a several hit hypothesis. Biopsy is mandatory not only to diagnose the disease in the native kidney, but also to identify and characterize graft recurrence of IgAN in the kidney graft. The optimal therapy for IgAN recurrence in the renal graft is unknown. Supportive therapy aiming to reduce proteinuria and control hypertension is the mainstream, with corticosteroids and immunosuppressive treatment tailored for certain subgroups of patients experiencing a rapidly progressive course of the disease with active lesions on renal biopsy and considering safety issues related to infectious complications.

The clinical course of IgA nephropathy after kidney transplantation and its management

Immunoglobulin (Ig) A nephropathy is one of the most common primary glomerulonephritides worldwide causing end stage renal disease in up to 20-40% of affected patients, nearly two decades post diagnosis. Kidney transplantation is the treatment of choice for patients with renal failure, secondary to glomerular diseases. However, IgA nephropathy has a strong tendency to recur in the graft, and although initially thought to be a benign condition, several reports of graft loss, due to recurrent IgA nephropathy, there have been over the last three decades. Overall graft survival has been significantly improved in kidney transplantation, as a result of reduced incidence of acute rejection, as more potent and more specific immunosuppressive agents are now available in clinical practice. Thus, the rates of IgA nephropathy and other glomerulonephritides recurrence are expected to increase, since graft survival has been improved. However, the reported incidence of IgA nephropathy recurrence in the graft varies substantially across centers, as a consequence of different levels of interest, diverse biopsy policies and differing durations of follow up, of the published studies. Notably, recurrence rates of patients receiving graft biopsies by clinical indication only, ranges from 13% to 50% with graft loss being between 1.3% and 16%. The aim of this review is to underline important pathogenetic insights of IgA nephropathy, describe the clinical course of the disease after kidney transplantation, with emphasis on the incidence of recurrence and the associated risk factors, and finally provide all available options for its management in transplant recipients.

Increased glomerulonephritis recurrence after living related donation

Background

Kidney transplantation confers superior outcomes for patients with end stage kidney disease, and live donor kidneys associate with superior outcomes compared to deceased donor kidneys. Modern immunosuppression has improved rejection rates and transplant survival and, as a result, recurrence of glomerulonephritis has emerged as a major cause of allograft loss. However, many glomerulonephritides have significant genetic risk which may manifest through kidney intrinsic or systemic mechanisms. We hypothesise that heritable kidney intrinsic predisposition to glomerulonephritis will result in increased risk of glomerulonephritis recurrence in kidneys transplanted from genetically related donors.

Methods

We investigated the effect of living related donation on rates of recurrence and subsequent graft outcomes in 7236 patient from 28 years of ANZDATA transplant registry data. Data were analysed in R, using Kaplan Meier Survival analysis and adjusted analyses performed using Cox Proportional Hazards methods. A competing risk model was also analysed.

Results

Glomerulonephritis recurrence rates were significantly higher in living related donor grafts compared to either living unrelated or deceased donor grafts (p < 0 · 001). In IgA nephropathy, transplantation from living related donor kidneys demonstrated a 10 year recurrence rate of 16 · 7% compared to 7 · 1% in living unrelated donors and 9 · 2% in deceased donors (HR:1 · 7, 95% CI:1 · 26–2 · 26, p = 0 · 0005 for living related vs deceased donors). In focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, risk of recurrence at 10 years was 14 · 6% in living related donors compared to 10 · 8% in living unrelated donors and 6 · 6% in deceased donors (HR:2 · 2, 95% CI 1 · 34–3 · 64, p = 0 · 002) for living related vs deceased donors. Primary glomerulonephritis death censored graft survival was superior for living donor grafts, related or unrelated, compared to deceased donor grafts.

Conclusions

We identified a significant increase in the risk of glomerulonephritis recurrence in IgA Nephropathy and Focal Segmental Glomerulosclerosis in living related donors compared to a deceased donors.

Predicting Post-Transplant Recurrence of IgA Nephropathy: The Importance of Crescents

BACKGROUND

Most studies that have assessed the predictors of recurrent IgA nephropathy (IgAN) in the renal allograft have focused on post-transplant features. Identifying high-risk pre-transplant features of IgAN is useful for counseling patients and may help in tailoring post-transplant immunosuppression.

METHODS

We investigated the pre-transplant clinical and biopsy features of 62 patients with IgAN who received transplants at Columbia University Medical Center from 2001 to 2012 and compared the characteristics and outcomes of patients with IgAN recurrence to those without recurrence. The primary outcome was time to recurrent IgAN. Secondary outcomes were a composite of doubling of creatinine or allograft failure, and recurrent IgAN as a cause of allograft dysfunction.

RESULTS

Of the 62 patients, 14 had recurrent IgAN in the allograft. Mean time to recurrence was 2.75 years. Those with recurrent disease were younger at the time of native kidney biopsy (29 vs. 41 years, p < 0.0009). Black race and Hispanic ethnicity composed a higher proportion of the recurrent disease group. On multivariable analysis, significant predictors of recurrent IgAN included age at diagnosis (hazards ratio (HR) 0.911, 95% CI 0.85-0.98), burden of crescents on native biopsy (HR 1.21 per 10% increase in crescents, 95% CI 1.00-1.47) and allograft rejection (HR 3.59, 95% CI 1.10-11.7).

CONCLUSIONS

Features of native IgAN can help predict the risk of recurrent disease in the renal allograft. In particular, immunologically active disease represented by earlier age of onset and greater burden of crescents on native biopsy is more likely to recur after transplant.

Tonsillectomy ameliorates histological damage of recurrent immunoglobulin A nephropathy after kidney transplantation

AIM

Recurrence of immunoglobulin A (IgA) nephropathy (IgAN) after renal transplantation is important as a cause of graft failure under improving rejection control. However, no specific therapy for recurrent IgAN is currently available. In this study, we evaluated the histological efficacy of tonsillectomy for allograft IgAN.

METHODS

Fifteen kidney recipients (male 9, female 6, mean age 40.9 ± 9.3 years), who received a diagnosis of IgA nephropathy by allograft biopsy, were enrolled in this study. Tonsillectomy was performed 44.1 ± 27.1 months after the kidney transplantation. All patients underwent a repeat graft biopsy at 23.8 ± 15.8 months after tonsillectomy.

RESULTS

Six patients had microhematuria before tonsillectomy. At 12 months after treatment, the microhematuria disappeared in five of these patients and one patient had mild hematuria. Three patients had severe proteinuria (more than 1.0 g/gCr) before tonsillectomy and improved after treatment. On histological analysis, four patients had acute lesions including cellular or fibrocellular crescents. The acute lesions disappeared after these treatments in all patients. Eleven patients had chronic lesions including global sclerosis, segmental sclerosis and fibrous crescents. The chronic lesion was ameliorated in six patients, unchanged in three and deteriorated in two patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Tonsillectomy improves not only clinical findings but also ameliorates histological damage caused by recurrent IgAN after kidney transplantation. Tonsillectomy is a novel and effective treatment for recurrent IgAN.

Recurrence of glomerulonephritis after renal transplantation

Recurrence of glomerulonephritis following renal transplantation is considered an important cause of allograft failure. The incidence of recurrence of glomerulonephritis varies widely depending on the definition of recurrence (pathologic recurrence or clinicopathologic recurrence) and the original glomerular disease. Moreover the impact of recurrence of glomerular disease on allograft outcome varies widely between different forms of glomerulonephritis. Whereas IgA nephritis recurs in up to one third of transplanted patients, this is not associated with adverse effects on graft survival. In contrast, recurrent focal segmental glomerulosclerosis and membranoproliferative glomerulopathy have an unfavorable prognosis. Overall, long-term graft survival in patients transplanted for glomerulonephritis is comparable to survival in patients with other causes of ESRD. In recent years, several mechanisms for recurrent disease after transplantation (e.g. PLA2R antibodies in membranous nephropathy and suPAR in FSGS) have been identified, and these findings have helped to elucidate the pathogenesis of glomerular diseases. Although renal transplantation is the treatment of choice for end-stage renal disease as a consequence of glomerulonephritis, further studies are required to develop optimal strategies to prevent, diagnose and treat recurrent glomerular diseases.

The long-term outcome of renal transplantation of IgA nephropathy and the impact of recurrence on graft survival

BACKGROUND

Few data are available on allograft survival at 15 years, the impact and the predictors of recurrence of the original disease in renal transplanted patients with IgA nephropathy (IgAN).

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we compared the long-term outcome of renal transplant in 190 patients with IgAN with that of 380 non-diabetic controls and evaluated the impact of recurrence of IgAN on the graft outcome.

RESULTS

At 15 years, the patient survival was 88.3% in IgAN patients and 82.6% in controls (P = 0.12), while the death-censored graft survival was 62.6 and 72.4%, respectively (P = 0.038). IgAN had a higher cumulative incidence of graft failures in comparison with controls even considering death as a competing risk (P = 0.025). At multivariate analysis, IgAN [relative risk (RR) = 1.468, P = 0.026], delayed graft function recovery (RR = 2.394, P = 0.000) and acute rejection (RR = 2.51, P = 0.000) were predictive of graft loss. IgAN recurred in 42 grafts (22.1%), of them, 12 were lost for recurrence and in another 6 recurrence was considered a concomitant cause of graft loss. The 15-year death censored graft survival was 68.3% in non-recurrent and 51.2% in recurrent patients (P = 0.069). Pure graft survival of non-recurrent IgAN patients was similar to that of controls (P = 0.406). At Cox analysis, the recurrence of IgAN significantly reduced from 1981 to 2010 (P = 0.0065, RR = 0.936).

CONCLUSIONS

IgAN emerged as an independent predictor of worse graft outcome in the long-term. Recurrence of IgAN seems to progressively reduce in transplants performed from 1981 to 2010.

Recurrence and graft loss after kidney transplantation for henoch-schonlein purpura nephritis: a multicenter analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The actuarial risk at 5 years for clinical recurrence of Henoch-Schönlein purpura nephritis (HSPN) and graft loss caused by recurrence of -HSPN after renal transplantation was reported in 1994 to be as high as 35% and 11%, respectively. The aim of this study is to re-evaluate, in a large cohort of patients with a long-term follow-up, whether these rates have changed.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

Patients from six transplant centers in Belgium and France with strict diagnostic criteria of HSPN and a potential post transplant follow-up of ≥3 years were included.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients were included. Patient survival is excellent: 98%, 95%, and 95% at 5, 10, and 15 years, respectively. Overall graft survival rates were 84%, 66%, and 56% at 5, 10, and 15 years, respectively. Clinical recurrence in a first kidney transplant occurred in five patients. Three patients lost their first graft due to HSPN recurrence 19 to 96 months after transplantation, two of whom had systemic signs of the illness. Actuarial risk for clinical recurrence in a first graft is 2.5% and 11.5% at 5 and 10 years, respectively. Actuarial risk for graft loss caused by recurrence in a first graft is 2.5% and 7.5% at 5 and 10 years, respectively. Severity of the disease at presentation and type of immunosuppression after transplantation did not affect recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

We found that recurrence rates of HSPN after transplantation are lower than previously reported. The actuarial risk of graft loss from recurrence in a first graft is 7.5% at 10 years.

Long-term outcome of renal transplantation patients with Henoch-Schonlein purpura

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Although Henoch-Schönlein purpura (HSP) is the most common form of renal vasculitis in childhood, progression to ESRD is rare, and there are few data on outcomes of renal transplantation in patients with HSP.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

This is a matched retrospective cohort study of renal allografts using the United Network of Organ Sharing database (1987 to 2005). Of the 189,211 primary renal allografts, there were 339 with a diagnosis of HSP. The primary end point was allograft survival.

RESULTS

Compared with the remainder of the database, the HSP population was younger (25 years versus 46 years), and had a higher proportion of women (47% versus 40%), live donors (50% versus 35%), and Caucasians (77% versus 60%). Controlling for age, gender, donor source, ethnicity, and year of transplantation, death-censored graft survival for patients with HSP was 80.0% at 5 years and 58.8% at 10 years compared with 79.0% at 5 years and 55.4% at 10 years in the non-HSP population. Among patients with reported causes of graft loss, failure from recurrent disease occurred in 13.6% of patients with HSP, compared with 6.6% in the non-HSP population. When analyzing allograft survival in recipients with HSP compared with those with IgA nephropathy, there was no difference in 10-year allograft survival (58.4% and 59.3%, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that although there is an increased risk of graft failure attributable to recurrent disease in patients with HSP, a diagnosis of HSP has little effect on overall renal allograft survival.

Outcome of renal allograft in patients with Henoch-Schönlein nephritis: single-center experience and systematic review

BACKGROUND

Henoch-Schönlein nephritis (HSN) is a rare condition resulting in end-stage renal disease. Therefore, graft outcomes and recurrence rates after transplantation are not well studied. Also, the effect of donor type on graft outcome has not been evaluated thoroughly.

METHODS

The graft outcome and recurrence rate in 20 kidney recipients with HSN were compared with age-, sex-, and donor source-matched controls (control A, primary immunoglobulin A nephropathy; control B, other causes; 40 recipients per group). To assess the effect of donor type, we pooled our data with two previous cohort studies where donor type had been described in detail.

RESULTS

Overall graft survival rates were 87.7% at 10 years. The overall recurrence rate of HSN was 15.4% over 10 years. Graft survival and recurrence rates in the HSN group were similar to those of control A and control B. The pooled data showed a 29.4% incidence rate for recurrent HSN. Living related donor transplantation showed a trend of higher recurrence compared with recipients with nonrelated grafts, although it was marginally significant (P=0.059). However, the graft survival rate in related-donor recipients was not inferior to that in the unrelated-donor recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term graft survival and recurrence rates in kidney recipients with HSN were comparable to those of recipients with primary immunoglobulin A nephropathy. The type of donor did not significantly affect long-term graft survival.

Recurrent glomerulonephritis after renal transplantation: an unsolved problem

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Despite advances in prevention of acute rejection and improved short- and long-term kidney graft survival, recurrent glomerulonephritis remains problematic and poorly characterized. This study analyzed prevalence and outcome of recurrent glomerulonephritis from various registries.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

Definition, classification, and limitations in evaluating epidemiology of native and recurrent glomerulonephritis are discussed. Epidemiology of native glomerulonephritis as the cause of end-stage renal failure and subsequent recurrence of individual glomerulonephritis was evaluated using data from various registries, and pathogenesis of individual glomerulonephritis is discussed.

RESULTS

Analysis of data from transplant registries revealed that glomerulonephritis is an important cause of end-stage renal disease in white and pediatric recipients; however, glomerulonephritis as the cause of end-stage renal disease is not characterized well in black recipients, and many of them are perhaps labeled to have hypertensive nephrosclerosis as the cause of renal disease without renal biopsy. A systematic approach toward urinalysis after transplantation and utility of immunofluorescence and electron microscopic examination of renal biopsy tissues will identify the true prevalence of recurrent glomerulonephritis. Data on recurrent glomerulonephritis should be compiled by either using registry analysis or pooling data from multiple centers. This will provide true data on prevalence and outcome and could potentially initiate translational research studies.

CONCLUSIONS

The understanding of the pathogenesis of recurrent glomerulonephritis is critical to optimize prevention as well as to treat individual recurrent glomerulonephritis, which can enhance long-term graft survival.

Peritubular capillary C4d deposition and renal outcome in post-transplant IgA nephropathy

BACKGROUND

Immunological staining of the transplanted kidney for C4d in peritubular capillaries (C4d(PTC)) has emerged as a useful method to detect antibody-mediated rejection in situ. In this retrospective study, we evaluated the prevalence of C4d(PTC) deposition in allograft renal biopsies diagnosed of IgA nephropathy (IgAN) and analysed its clinical significance.

METHOD

Sixty-six biopsy specimens of post-transplant IgAN, which were obtained to evaluate azotemia and/or heavy proteinuria, were examined by immunohistochemical staining of the paraffin sections with polyclonal antibody for C4d.

RESULTS

C4d was stained positively in peritubular capillaries in 16 (24%) of the 66 cases. The C4d(PTC)-negative (n=50) and C4d(PTC)-positive groups (n=16) were not different in recipient gender, age, donor age, type of donor (living vs. cadaveric), interval from transplantation to graft biopsy (41.6+/- 21.8 vs. 48.3+/-26.1 months) and post-biopsy follow-up period (60.3+/-23.3 vs. 56.9+/-25.4 months). During the follow-up period, 12 of 50 (24%) although the incidence of graft failure was not different by the C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries, intervals from renal biopsy to graft failure tended to be shorter in C4d(PTC)-positive cases than C4d(PTC)-negative cases. In Kaplan-Meier analysis, the renal allograft function of the C4d(PTC)-positive group deteriorated more rapidly than that of the C4d(PTC)-negative group (p<0.05). Histologically, the C4d(PTC)-positive group had findings suggestive of acute cellular rejection more commonly than the C4d(PTC)-negative group (p<0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Evidence of humoral rejection, as demonstrated by C4d(PTC) deposition, was concurrently present in significant portions of post-transplant IgAN biopsy specimens and was associated with more rapid deterioration of renal function. These results suggest that C4d(PTC) positivity needs to be determined at the time of biopsy even in cases of post-transplant glomerulonephritis and immunosuppression may need to be modified accordingly.

Long-term results of living kidney transplantation from HLA-identical sibling donors under calcineurin inhibitor immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

Recently, it has been revealed that alloantigen-independent causes are important factors for late graft loss in kidney transplantation. We compared the results of living kidney transplantation from HLA-identical siblings with those from HLA-non-identical siblings to analyse the impact of alloantigen-independent factors on long-term graft survival.

METHODS

Two hundred and sixty-six recipients who were grafted from their siblings between 1983 and 2002 were subdivided into those transplanted from HLA-identical donors (n=86) and those from HLA-non-identical donors (n=180).

RESULTS

The incidence of acute rejection was significantly lower in the HLA-identical group than in the HLA-non-identical group (9.3% vs 53.9%, respectively; P<0.0001). Graft survival was significantly higher in the HLA-identical group than in the HLA-non-identical group (91.3% vs 79.2% at 5 years, 80.3% vs 66.8% at 10 years and 59.1% vs 51.7% at 15 years, respectively; P=0.0372). Although acute rejection was not seen as a cause of graft loss in the HLA-identical group, death with functioning graft, recurrence of the original disease or chronic allograft nephropathy were observed as the major causes of graft loss in the late period of the HLA-identical group.

CONCLUSION

We concluded that alloantigen-independent causes constitute a crucial factor for graft loss in the late period of HLA-identical kidney transplantation.

Recurrence of IgA nephropathy among renal allograft recipients from living donors is greater among those with zero HLA mismatches

BACKGROUND

Risk factors contributing to recurrence of IgA nephropathy (IgAN) after transplantation are unclear. Some (but not all) series have suggested greater degrees of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) matching play a role.

METHODS

Using registry data including all kidney transplants performed in Australia and New Zealand between 1987 and 2004 we examined IgAN recurrence among living donors with zero HLA-mismatches.

RESULTS

Of 1354 grafts performed in recipients with IgAN, live donors (LDs) accounted for 488 including 108 with zero HLA-mismatches. Biopsy-proven IgAN recurrence was reported for 110 (7%) of grafts overall, but 17% of those who received zero HLA-mismatched LD grafts (HR for recurrence free graft survival 2.7 [95% CI 1.5-5.1], P=0.001). There was no significant difference in recurrence rates between zero and >or=1 HLA-mismatched grafts from cadaveric donors (CDs). Recurrence of IgAN was associated with worse graft survival, more so among LD recipients (HR 8.5 [4.8-15.2], P<0.001) than CD recipients (HR 4.5 [2.6-7.5], P<0.001). However, there was no difference in graft survival between zero and >or=1 HLA mismatched LD recipients whose native disease was IgAN. In contrast, zero HLA mismatched recipients of kidneys with other primary renal disease enjoyed a graft survival advantage. No difference in recurrence rates was seen among those with HLA B12, B35 or DR4.

CONCLUSIONS

The increased rates of IgAN-related graft loss among zero HLA-mismatched LD recipients counterbalance the advantage normally seen among zero HLA-mismatched recipients. However, since graft survivals are similar, there is no reason to avoid donor-recipient pairs with zero HLA-mismatches in this setting.

Recurrent glomerulonephritis after kidney transplantation

Thirty to fifty percent of kidney transplant recipients have glomerular diseases as the underlying causes of end-stage renal failure. While recurrence of glomerulonephritis is an important cause of late renal allograft failure, the risk factors for recurrence are largely unknown or imprecise and prediction remains difficult. Recurrent disease usually presents with similar manifestations as the native disease. With regard to treatment of recurrent glomerular disease in the renal allograft, plasma exchange may be effective in reducing proteinuria in patients with early recurrence of focal and segmental glomerulosclerosis, but immunosuppressive therapy is generally ineffective in the prevention or treatment of recurrent disease. General supportive measures including strict blood pressure control and inhibition or blockade of the rennin-angiotensin pathway are helpful in retarding the rate of deterioration in renal allograft function. Despite the risk of recurrence, kidney transplantation following primary glomerulonephritides enjoys graft and patient survival rates comparable to other causes of end-stage renal failure. With a few exceptions, living related renal transplantation is not contraindicated in view of the favorable outcome and the donor shortage. This review discusses commonly encountered recurrent glomerulonephritides, with special emphasis on the influence of post-transplant prophylactic immunosuppression and emerging treatments.

IgA nephropathy with crescents in kidney transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Crescentic glomerulonephritis is an uncommon finding in renal allografts. Recurrence or de novo mesangial deposition of immunoglobulin A (IgA) in renal allografts most often is clinically benign, but some case reports have shown that IgA nephropathy in renal allografts can present as crescentic glomerulonephritis and may lead to rapid deterioration of graft function and/or graft loss.

METHODS

We reviewed diagnoses of all allograft biopsies at University of Washington Medical Center (Seattle, WA) from 1989 to 2003 and found 33 cases of glomerulonephritis with crescents. Eight of these cases were the result of recurrent or de novo IgA nephropathy. Clinical and pathological features of these patients were reviewed.

RESULTS

Six of 8 cases with crescents were the result of recurrent IgA nephropathy, and 2 cases were presumptive de novo IgA nephropathy. Of the 8 patients with IgA nephropathy with crescents, 6 patients presented clinically with increasing serum creatinine levels; 4 patients, with proteinuria; and 4 patients, with hematuria. In 6 patients, there was 10% to 30% involvement of glomeruli, with crescents partially or completely filling urinary spaces. The other patients showed lesser (approximately 7% of sampled glomeruli) involvement. Four patients with IgA nephropathy with crescents developed renal failure and returned to hemodialysis therapy. Three patients had a benign clinical course, with stabilization of renal function. One patient was lost to follow-up.

CONCLUSION

We identified a cohort of patients with glomerulonephritis with crescents in renal allografts with IgA nephropathy as the cause. In half the affected patients, this led to early progressive renal insufficiency and return to hemodialysis therapy.

Two cases of recurrent IgA nephropathy following kidney transplantation

Recurrence of immunoglobulin (Ig) A nephropathy following kidney transplantation has been described as occurring in 40% to 60% of cases. Although this type of recurrence was considered a benign condition for a long time, more recent data showed that recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy may be a significant contributor to graft loss. We present 2 cases of recurrent IgA nephropathy following kidney transplantation. In case 1, renal function remained stable with a creatinine level of 1.2 mg/dL at 5 months after diagnosis and 61 months after transplantation. In case 2, the patient lost his graft and returned to regular hemodialysis at 36 months after diagnosis and 125 months after kidney transplantation.

Renal transplantation in patients with IgA mesangial glomerulonephritis

Most patients with IgA nephritis are suitable candidates for renal transplantation. In about 33% of patients the disease may recur after transplantation, although there are differences in the various series because of the different criteria for biopsy, the different length of follow-up and the different ethnicities. Living donation, genetic factors and time of progression of original disease have been found to be related with the risk of recurrence by some investigators, but these associations were not confirmed by other studies. The graft survival in patients with IgA nephritis is similar or even better than that observed with other renal diseases. The available data indicate that recurrence has a little impact on the 10-yr graft survival. However, a minority of patients may show a rapid progressive course after recurrence. Little information is available on the impact of recurrence in the very long term. There is no established treatment for preventing or treating the recurrence of IgA nephritis.

Recurrence of primary disease in children after renal transplantation: an evidence-based update

The availability of new and more effective anti-rejection therapy has succeeded in reducing the incidence of acute cellular rejection in first months post-renal transplant. This in turn has escalated the order of significance of recurrence of primary disease in the renal allograft as a cause for patient morbidity and graft loss during this period. The aim of this review is to survey current literature, identify issues and potential areas for future research related to recurrence of primary disease after renal transplant. Our review of published reports suggests that our current knowledge and practice, related to the management of recurrence of primary disease, are mainly based on non-randomized and uncontrolled case series. The future need for well designed mechanistic as well as therapeutic, controlled and randomized multicenter clinical trials cannot be overemphasized.

Kidney transplantation in patients with IgA mesangial glomerulonephritis

BACKGROUND

Strategies for treating IgA glomerulonephritis (IgAGN) are controversial, particularly with regards to the long-term results of kidney transplantation, including the risk of recurrence of IgAGN post-transplant and the impact of this recurrence on graft survival.

METHODS

The outcomes of 106 adults transplanted because of a biopsy-proven IgAGN and of 212 patients without IgAGN transplanted during the same period were analyzed. To evaluate the risk of recurrence, patients with hematuria, proteinuria, or an increase in plasma creatinine were submitted to allograft biopsy. Factors influencing recurrence and the impact of recurrence on graft survival were analyzed.

RESULTS

The ten-year patient (0.93 vs. 0.92) and graft survival (0.75 vs. 0.82) probabilities were not significantly different between IgAGN patients and controls. Only plasma creatinine and proteinuria at six months were associated with an increased relative risk (RR) of graft failure (RR 2.79 and 5.94, respectively). Histological recurrence of IgA glomerulonephritis was diagnosed in 37 patients. Younger age (RR 2.63), increased plasma creatinine (RR 2.39), and proteinuria (RR 6.02) at six months were associated with the risk of recurrence. If proteinuria and plasma creatinine at six months were considered in the Cox model, IgA recurrence per se was not associated with an increased risk of graft failure (P = 0.181). The main causes of graft failure were glomerulonephritis in patients with recurrence of IgAGN and chronic rejection in patients without recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

The ten-year graft survival rate was similar in patients with IgAGN or other renal diseases. At least 35% IgAGN patients had biopsy-proven recurrence, and younger patients were more prone to the risk of recurrence. Recurrence did not affect the ten-year graft survival.

Recurrent IgA nephropathy in renal transplant allografts

Previous reports of renal transplantation for patients with underlying immunoglobulin A (IgA) nephropathy suggested a recurrence rate greater than 50% for transplant IgA nephropathy. Initially regarded as a benign condition, more recent data showed that recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy may be a significant contributor to graft loss. We performed a retrospective analysis in a single center of 48 kidney transplant recipients, all of Chinese origin, with biopsy-proven IgA nephropathy as the cause of end-stage renal failure to determine the recurrence rate of IgA nephropathy in the transplant allograft and subsequent clinical course in Chinese patients. Median duration of follow-up was 52 months (range, 18 to 155 months). Fourteen patients (29%) had biopsy-confirmed recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy after a median of 52 months (interquartile range, 23 to 82 months) posttransplantation. Recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy was associated with greater serum IgA levels (P = 0.01). The presence of HLA-A2 in transplant recipients (P = 0.002) appeared to protect them from developing recurrent IgA nephropathy in the transplant allograft. Twenty-nine percent of patients with recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy had progressive deterioration of graft function. The progressive graft dysfunction (GD) rate was greater in patients with a transplant from a living related donor (LRD; 21%) compared with those with a transplant from a cadaveric or living unrelated donor (URD; 3%; P = 0.062). Although the cumulative graft survival rate was 100% at 5 years for transplants from both LRDs and URDs, the 10-year graft survival rate was only 63% for a graft from an LRD versus 93% for a URD (log-rank test, P = 0.19). A review of other reported series of recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy also showed an apparently greater incidence of GD for a graft from an LRD (28%) compared with a URD (15%). Our data suggest that although recurrent transplant IgA nephropathy is highly prevalent among the Chinese population, the risk for disease recurrence is not particularly increased compared with other ethnic groups. The trend toward a greater risk for GD for living related compared with unrelated allografts in patients with IgA nephropathy needs to be confirmed with further prospective study.

Live donor renal allograft in end-stage renal failure patients from immunoglobulin A nephropathy

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to attempt to resolve two important issues, i.e. to determine (1) whether the course of recurrent immunoglobulin A nephropathy (IgAN) is benign, and (2) whether it is advisable to use a related donor.

METHODS

We evaluated the long-term outcome, in terms of recurrence and graft survival, after live related or unrelated donor renal transplantation, and assessed the validity of the use of related donors in 90 grafts in 89 IgAN patients.

RESULTS

Ten-year graft survival for IgAN patients was 66%, compared with 84% for 107 reference recipients who had other kinds of glomerulonephritis (GN), and with 69% in 90 other recipients who had non-GN renal failure (P=0.27). In 43 grafts, 54 event graft biopsies were performed, documenting the presence of mesangial IgA deposits in 19 of those grafts. In eight grafts, lesions were accompanied by chronic rejection (CR). Ten-year cumulative recurrence was 44%. Ten grafts were lost: by CR (n=3) or acute rejection (n=1) in 24 recurrence-free recipients, by CR (n=2) or recurrence (n=2) in 19 recurrent patients, and by patient death (n=2) in 46 patients devoid of graft biopsy. We found no difference in 10-year graft survival between the recurrent and recurrence-free patients (63% vs. 74%, P=0.98), or the proportion of related donors (68% vs. 83%, P=0.25). The presence or matching of HLA B12, B35, or DR4 did not affect the recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

Recurrence increased to 44% with longer follow-up, but this did not limit the graft outcome. Recurrence was not affected by the kind of live donor. We conclude that live related or unrelated kidneys should be offered to IgAN patients.

Clinical risk factors for recurrence of IgA nephropathy

No clinical risk factors for recurrence of immunoglobulin A (IgA) nephropathy in kidney transplants have been defined. This is a single-centre retrospect analysis of recurrence in 104 first kidney transplant patients with biopsy-verified IgA nephropathy. Fifty patients had living donors. All but an identical twin were treated with cyclosporin A. The median follow-up time was 5 yr. Graft biopsies had been obtained from 35 grafts later than 6 months after transplantation, due to deteriorating graft function or gross proteinuria. Thirteen biopsies showed mesangial glomerulopathy proliferative in eleven cases with IgA deposits. Recurrence caused failure of six grafts. Eleven grafts with recurrence were from living donors (p = 0.005). No specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) was identified as a risk factor. Known duration of original disease until end-stage renal failure was significantly shorter in patients with recurrence (median 5 yr, range 0-25 yr) compared with those without (median of 10 yr, range of 0-37 yr) (p = 0.015). Cumulative graft survival was not reduced in living versus cadaveric donor recipients.

Single-center long-term results of renal transplantation for IgA nephropathy

BACKGROUND

Previous reports with short-term follow-up after renal transplantation for IgA nephropathy (IgAN) have suggested an incidence of recurrence up to 50%, an increased recurrence with living-related donors, and the rarity of graft loss due to recurrence. In this study, the long-term results of renal transplantation for IgAN were examined.

METHODS

Between June 1980 and December 1994, 54 patients (61 renal transplants) with end-stage renal disease due to IgA nephropathy were performed at the University of California San Francisco. Actuarial patient and graft survival were compared with a matched reference group. Correlates of recurrent disease (biopsy confirmed) and graft loss were determined.

RESULTS

Patient and graft survival for IgA patients were good (100% and 75%, respectively, at 5 years after transplant). Graft survival was lower in IgA recipients with living-related compared with cadaveric renal allografts (P<0.09) and also with renal allografts well matched at HLA-AB (< or =2 AB mismatches) (P<0.09) or HLA-DR (< or =1 mismatch) (P<0.01). Recurrence was not correlated with donor status, recipient age, race, gender, or immunosuppression. Recurrence (18 of 61) resulted in substantial graft loss (6 of 18) or deteriorating renal function (4 of 18) at a mean follow-up of 61 months. Mean time to diagnosis of recurrence and subsequent graft loss was 31 and 63 months, respectively. Despite re-recurrence of IgAN in three of five patients who were retransplanted, all have good long-term renal function.

CONCLUSIONS

Substantial graft loss due to recurrent disease after renal transplantation for IgAN occurs with long-term follow-up. Living-related transplantation and HLA matching do not appear to confer an advantage for graft survival in patients with IgAN. Despite the potential for recurrence, IgAN patients enjoy good long-term graft survival.

Recurrence of type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis after renal transplantation: analysis of the incidence, risk factors, and impact on graft survival

BACKGROUND

The information in the medical literature on the incidence of recurrence of type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) after renal transplantation and its impact on graft survival is limited because most data are derived from case reports or from studies involving a small number of patients.

METHODS

We analyzed the data from our transplant center. Among 1097 adult patients receiving their first allograft between 1977 and 1994, we identified 32 patients with type I MPGN.

RESULTS

A recurrence was detected in 9 of the 27 recipients of a first cadaveric graft (33%). The cumulative incidence reached 48% at 4 years after transplantation when patients with graft failure from other causes were censored. All patients with recurrent MPGN had clinically significant proteinuria (>1 g/24 hr) that was first observed at a median time of 20 months (range, 1.5-42 months) after transplantation. Graft survival was significantly worse in patients with recurrence as compared with patients without recurrence. Mean duration of graft survival after the diagnosis of recurrence was 40 months. We could not detect any clinical characteristics of patients or donors that were associated with recurrent disease. However, an increased risk of recurrence was observed in patients with the HLA haplotype B8DR3. Four patients received an HLA-identical graft from a living related donor. Recurrence occurred in three patients (75%), with ensuing graft loss in two. The only patient with a haploidentical living related graft did not have a recurrence. Five patients with a recurrence in the first graft received a second transplant. Recurrence was observed in four of these patients (80%).

CONCLUSIONS

Type I MPGN recurred after renal transplantation in half of the patients. The incidence may be even higher in recipients of an identical living related donor graft and in patients receiving a second transplant after having experienced a recurrence in their first graft. Recurrence of type I MPGN has a detrimental effect on graft survival.

Recurrence of immunoglobulin A nephropathy after renal transplantation in the cyclosporine era

Immunoglobulin A nephropathy (IgAN) frequently recurs in patients after renal transplantation (RT) on a conventional regimen of immunosuppressive therapy, but little is known about the influence of cyclosporine (Cs) on such a recurrence. We studied 84 patients retrospectively who underwent RT for renal failure attributable to IgAN (n = 71) or Henoch-Schönlein purpura nephropathy (HSPN) (n = 13) in two transplantation units, between January 1985 and June 1991 and were treated with Cs. Four patients died 3 months to 8 years after RT. Graft survival was 88% at 1 year, 75.2% at 5 years, and 63% at 8 years. Fifty patients underwent at least one graft biopsy, but studies with immunofluorescence were performed on only 28 (23 IgAN and 5 HSPN). After a mean follow-up of 68.1 +/- 37.2 months, mesangial IgA deposits recurred in 13 of the 28 patients (12 IgAN and 1 HSP) (prevalence, 46.4%). Among the 13 patients with recurrence of IgA deposits, all but 4 had urinary abnormalities. Light microscopy showed mesangial deposits and focal and segmental glomerular changes in 9 cases. Four patients lost their graft function 69 to 119 months after RT, and 2 had severe graft dysfunction. The rates of graft failure and mean serum creatinine at 1, 5, and 8 years were similar in the 13 patients with recurrence and the 15 patients without proven recurrence. In conclusion, Cs did not reduce the incidence or severity of IgAN recurrence. The latter was the cause of graft loss or dysfunction in 46.1 % of the patients with recurrent IgA deposits. Recurrent glomerulonephritis did not influence the 8-year graft survival in patients with IgAN or HSPN, but it may be an important cause of graft loss as evidenced by more extended follow-up.

IgA nephropathy

IgAN is the most common type of glomerulonephritis worldwide, and is found more in men and distinctly less in blacks. It presents with macroscopic hematuria in about 40 to 45% of patients, with microscopic hematuria and proteinuria in about 35 to 40%, and with nephrotic syndrome or acute renal failure in the remainder. The diagnosis continues to rely on the finding of the dominant or codominant mesangial deposition of IgA on immunohistologic examination of the kidney. No blood or urine test is sufficiently reliable for diagnosis. While the pathogenesis remains unknown, accumulating evidence suggests that polyclonal stimulation of immunoglobulins perhaps coupled with structural abnormalities of IgA play pivotal roles. These defects may account for the variety of autoantibodies detected in patients with both IgAN and HSP. While IgAN has an indolent course, about 30% of patients will reach ESRD after 20 years, particularly in those who present with hypertension, heavy proteinuria or renal insufficiency. At present, therapy is disappointing, but immunoglobulin supplementation and newer agents that interrupt the pathways of mesangial proliferation and sclerosis hold promise for the future. Kidney transplantation has shown excellent allograft survival.

Recurrent diseases in the kidney transplant

Virtually all diseases affecting the native kidney recur in the kidney transplant with the exception of Alport syndrome, polycystic kidney disease, hypertension, chronic pyelonephritis, and chronic interstitial nephritis. Fortunately, in the majority of patients, recurrence of the original disease has minimal clinical impact, with only approximately 5% of all graft loss occurring as a result of recurrent disease. The primary renal diseases that commonly recur include membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis type II, IgA nephropathy, and focal and segmental glomerular sclerosis. The most common systemic disease that recurs is diabetic nephropathy. Living-related transplantation should be used with caution in patients with the hemolytic uremic syndrome, recurrent focal and segmental glomerular sclerosis, and membraneous glomerulonephritis. Fabry disease and primary hyperoxaluria type I are no longer absolute contraindications to kidney transplantation.

Recurrent primary disease and de novo nephritis following renal transplantation

Recurrent or de novo diseases account for only 5% of graft failure in children, but have much to teach us about mechanisms. In children, almost the only metabolic disease with recurrence is type I hyperoxaluria, in which the poor long-term results of isolated renal transplantation make combined liver and renal transplantation, or even prophylactic liver transplantation before renal failure the preferable alternatives. While many forms of nephritis may show histological recurrence in allografts, it is notable that in many patients this is accompanied by no clinical manifestations or only mild disease: this is particularly so in mesangiocapillary glomerulonephritis (MCGN) type II. IgA-associated nephropathy and Henoch-Schönlein purpura. However focal segmental glomerulosclerosis and MCGN type I recur with sufficient frequency and severity to deter the use of living donors unless there is no alternative. The same is true of haemolytic-uraemic syndromes. As many as 10% of paediatric grafts may show de novo membranous nephropathy, but in the majority this is mild or not clinically evident. In contrast, the rare anti-glomerular basement membrane nephritis affecting some patients with Alport's syndrome usually results in graft failure, but occurs in only a minority of recipients with the syndrome. For all types of disease in allografts, risk factors for recurrence are poorly worked out, and attempts at treatment generally ineffective.