Renal transplantation without sutures using the vascular clipping system for renal artery and vein anastomosis--a new technique

Venous Repair with Vascular Clips and Conventional Suture: A Comparative Experimental Study

Objectives:

The non-penetrating Vascular Clip System (VCS) was tested experimentally and compared with the conventional suture method on the venous system.

Materials and Methods:

In five pigs, 30 transverse venotomies were carried out in the jugular and renal veins, and vena cava. Fifteen venotomies were reconstructed using autosuture clips and 15 using the standard needle and suture method. Eight weeks later, following phlebography, the specimens were examined macro- and microscopically.

Results:

For both methods, the veins remained patent; however, significant stenosis of 8.9% (95% CI: 0.6–17.1) for the renal vein and 8.5% (95% CI: 1.2–15.7) for the vena cava occurred when the suture technique was used. The intima to media height ratio remained the same. The anastomosis time with the clips was significantly shorter ( p<0.05), while the endothelium remained intact without any hyperplasia or inflammatory changes, which are usual findings of the suture technique.

Conclusion:

Early and mid-term results show that the VCS clipped anastomotic technique seems to be effective and acceptable for venous reconstructions.

Arterial Anastomosis Without Sutures Using Ring Pin Stapler for Clinical Renal Transplantation: Comparison With Suture Anastomosis

PURPOSE

The metal ring pin stapler was initially developed for microvascular surgery and there has been little experience of their use in larger vessels. We determined if the titanium ring pin coupling system could be safely and rapidly applied for arterial reconstruction in clinical renal transplantation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The donor renal artery was end-to-end anastomosed to the internal iliac artery with titanium ring pin staplers in 36 patients. Anastomotic, clamp and total operative time and vascular problems were compared with those in the control group of sutured anastomosis in 39 transplant recipients.

RESULTS

The completion of mechanical anastomosis required half the time of suture anastomosis. Mean clamp time was 17.8 minutes in the nonsuture group and 28.1 minutes in the control group. There was no significant difference in total operative time between the 2 groups. A small anastomotic line leak was noted in each group, which was temporary and self-limited. There were no postoperative anastomotic failures, postoperative bleeding episodes or need to revise the anastomosis (100% patency rate) in the 2 groups. Of the patients 61 were followed for 2 to 5 years. Transplant renal artery stenosis was observed in 1 patient in the nonsuture group but 3 in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

The anastomotic technique with the ring pin system is safe and simple, permitting an expeditious and everting anastomosis with a smooth intima-to-intima junction. Application of this technique may decrease warm ischemia time and the incidence of anastomotic artery stenosis, thus, improving outcomes.

Use of nonpenetrating vascular closure staples in feline renal transplantation

Renal transplantation is a potential treatment for irreversible renal failure in pet cats. Our aim is to reduce warm ischemic time by using nonpenetrating vascular closure staples (VCS), thereby improving graft survival. Experimental cats were divided into the VCS group (n = 4; autotransplantation) or suture group (n = 6; allotransplantation). The renal artery was anastomosed with the external iliac artery in an end-to-end fashion, and the renal vein was attached to the external iliac vein in an end-to-side fashion. Warm ischemic time as well as arterial and venous anastomotic times were measured. Cats in the suture group were administrated cyclosporine and prednisolone orally after transplantation. Ischemic and anastomotic times in the VCS group were significantly reduced compared with the suture group. Two of 6 allografts had a ureteral anastomotic stricture, and 4 allografts were rejected. Histological findings of autografts showed normal structure. In conclusion, VCS staples were useful in feline renal transplantation.

Five years' world experience with nonpenetrating clips for vascular anastomoses

BACKGROUND

A new sutureless technique has been introduced clinically to facilitate the process of vascular reconstruction and improve patency. The Vessel Closure System (VCS) is nonpenetrating, creates an elastomeric everted anastomosis, and is easily and reproducibly applied. The objective of this report is to review the published world experience that has accrued regarding these clips with attention to the assets, liabilities, and pitfalls associated with the new technology.

DATA SOURCES

Medline search and manual cross-referencing were performed, after which 61 original articles were identified on the use of VCS clips for vascular anastomoses.

RESULTS

Advantages of the clips compared with sutures include the technical ease of application, the reduced anastomotic time, the superior hemodynamics, and the improved healing pattern of the anastomosis. Disadvantages include the potential problems in atherosclerotic vessels, lack of prospective randomized long-term follow-up, and initial costs. The best clinical results have been achieved in microvascular repair, as well as with vascular access and transplantation surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The VCS clip technology has become an accepted vascular anastomosing technique, which in future could lead to the use of clips as a standard approach and the use of sutures only in case of severe atherosclerosis and other circumstances in which vessel edges are difficult to evert.

Rapid neurorrhaphy with titanium clips

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of titanium clips in the repair of transected peripheral nerves. The results of neurorrhaphy using titanium clips (VCS) were compared with the conventional technique of neurorrhaphy using nylon sutures. Transected sciatic nerves in 15 New Zealand white rabbits were repaired with VCS clips on one side and interrupted 9-0 nylon sutures on the other. The average time required for neurorrhaphy using the clip closure was 8.7 +/- 2.6 min, and this was shorter than the suture closure, which took 14.9 +/- 3.6 min (P < 0.01). Electromyographic studies revealed no significant differences in amplitudes of compound motor action potentials in both groups. Also, the number and extent of myelinizations of regenerated axons were not significantly different in both methods of nerorrhaphies. These results demonstrate that microscopic neurorrhaphy using titanium clips is a potential alternative to conventional neurorrhaphy using sutures.

Vascular closure staples reduce intimal hyperplasia in prosthesis implantation

BACKGROUND

Vascular surgery, like the various other surgical specialities, has seen an increasing demand toward faster and more minimally invasive procedures. One such need is to create a reliable vascular anastomosis that is faster, easier and less damaging to the tissue. The vascular closure staples (VCS*) device provides such characteristics but, to date, no studies have investigated its effectiveness in reducing intimal hyperplasia when used for vascular prosthesis implantation. The present study evaluated its effectiveness compared with suturing of a graft in vascular prosthesis implantation.

METHODS

Twelve female Merino sheep underwent gelatin sealed Dacron patch graft implantation into the left and right common carotid artery. Grafts were randomly allocated so that one carotid artery and graft was anastomosed using sutures and the other with VCS*. The two techniques were compared for operation time, clip/suture numbers and blood loss during the implantation procedure. After a 4-week period, the sheep were killed and the grafts were harvested for intimal hyperplasia (IH) assessment.

RESULTS

There was a significant reduction in the amount of IH seen in the VCS* group (mean +/- SD: 0.278 +/- 0.079 mm2/mm) when compared with the sutured group (0.575 +/- 0.331 mm2/mm) (P < 0.05). There was also significant reduction in anastomosis time (mean +/- SD: 14 +/- 4.4 min) and fewer points of contact (23 +/- 1.4) using the VCS* compared with suturing (22 +/- 3.2 min, P < 0.01; 27 +/- 3.3, P < 0.05, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In this model, the VCS* shows several distinct advantages over suturing with significant time saving at operation and, most importantly, the reduction of IH seen at 1 month.

Arcuate-legged nonpenetrating vascular closure staples (VCS): early experience

Vascular closure staples (VCS) provide a novel technique for fashioning vascular anastomoses, allowing a single operator to perform suture-less anastomoses. They may be used primarily or in an adjuvant role. When VCS are compared to a running suture, advantages include the avoidance of intimal damage, platelet aggregation and intimal hyperplasia at the anastomotic suture line, and a shorter time taken to complete the anastomosis. We report our early experience using VCS in an array of vascular anastomoses and conclude that VCS are a useful addition to the vascular surgeon's armamentarium. They help to decrease the time taken to construct an anastomosis, and are particularly useful in an adjuvant setting, complementing conventionally placed sutures.

Patency and flow characteristics using stapled vascular anastomoses in dialysis grafts

BACKGROUND

Improving patency of hemodialysis grafts is challenging. Vascular stapling creates nonpenetrating anastomoses, possibly decreasing intimal hyperplasia. We investigated patency and flow characteristics of stapled hemodialysis grafts.

METHODS

Eighty-six grafts (41 stapled, 45 sewn) were placed in 84 patients (prospective, randomized). The groups had comparable demographics.

RESULTS

Thirty-six grafts were functioning at the study endpoint. Complications in both groups were similar. The primary patency (stapled, 342 days versus sewn, 382 days; P = 0.67) and secondary patency (stapled, 513 days versus sewn, 507 days; P = 0.76) had no significant differences. Flow characteristics were similar between the groups. Thrombectomies per patient-year were 1.01 for stapled grafts and 1.12 for sewn grafts (not significant). Stapling decreased the average operating time by 4.5 minutes.

CONCLUSIONS

Stapled and sewn anastomoses have similar primary and secondary patency and flow characteristics, with minimal operative time differences. Stapled anastomoses are safe but had no advantage over sewn anastomoses in this study.

Analysis of nonpenetrating clips versus sutures for arterial venous graft anastomosis

The use of nonpenetrating clips (NPC) for vascular anastomosis is quickly becoming accepted. Studies attest to decreased anastomotic time, comparable patency rates, and decreased blood loss. Few human studies on the use of NPC have been done to date. The purpose of this study was to evaluate primary patency rates, operative time, and complications associated with NPC compared to those with standard sutures for arterial venous graft (AVG). We retrospectively reviewed the clinical course of 82 patients with a mean age of 45 years (range, 22 to 87) from February 1996 to July 1999. All patients underwent upper extremity AVG construction. The procedures were performed at a single institution, by a single, well-experienced surgeon who has extensive experience with NPC. Primary patency rates, operative time, and complications were analyzed. Overall thrombotic incidence of AVG when NPC were used (27/48, 56%) was similar to that of sutures (17/34, 50%). Thrombotic incidence within the first year was similar as well (23/48, 48% and 13/34, 38%). The mean time to primary thrombosis was similar in both groups (6.9 and 6.8 months). The operative time required to construct an AVG with NPC (83 min) was significantly less than that with sutures (96 min) (p = 0.015). There was no significant difference in incidence of graft infection or pseudoaneurysm formation. NPC for AVG reduced operative time and resulted in primary patency and complication rates similar to those associated with use of sutures. The mean time to primary thrombosis was similar for both groups. Our findings suggest an intimal hyperplastic response of a similar nature resulting in thrombosis of both NPC and sutured AVGs.

Comparison of titanium vascular closure staples with suture repair of the thoracic aorta in swine

OBJECTIVE

Devices that reduce technical difficulty and anastigmatic time when repairing large vessels such as the thoracic aorta would be beneficial. The aim of this study was to determine if titanium vascular closure staples (3 mm) could be safely and quickly applied in the repair of large vessels such as the thoracic aorta.

DESIGN

Through a left thoracotomy in 10 female swine (110 to 130 lb), an interposition graft (14 to 16 mm textile) was placed into the aorta distal to the left subclavian artery. Animals were randomized at the time of repair to either running sutures (n = 5; 6-0 polypropylene) or vascular closure staples (n = 5; 3 mm). The anastomosis was evaluated after 2 months with aortograms, and the aorta was harvested to evaluate healing.

RESULTS

The clamp times (mean +/- SD) were 30.8 +/- 8.2 min for suture repair and 24.8 +/- 5.1 min for vascular closure staple repair (p = 0.2). Anastomosis times were 20. 0 +/- 6.2 min for the suture group and 16.4 +/- 6.4 min for the vascular closure staple group (p = 0.4). Arch aortograms at 2 months revealed no significant difference in luminal narrowing between the two groups. Gross and microscopic examination revealed no thrombosis, well-healed wounds with a continuous intimal layer, and no differences in intimal thickness or inflammation between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

Vascular closure staples were equivalent to sutures in terms of durability, graft patency, and wound healing at 2 months. Vascular closure staples may offer the trauma surgeon a quick and easy alternative when repairing large vessels such as the thoracic aorta.

Use of the vascular closure staple clip applier for microvascular anastomosis in free-flap surgery

We report our initial experience using the vascular closure staple clip applier (a nonpenetrating titanium clip applied in an interrupted, everting fashion) for microvascular anastomosis in free-flap surgery. In total, 153 anastomoses were performed in 87 free flaps (174 potential anastomoses) using the vascular closure stapler between October of 1997 and June of 1999. In 66 flaps, both the arterial and venous anastomosis were performed with the clip applier, whereas in 21 flaps only the venous anastomosis was performed using the clips. A total of 146 anastomoses were performed in an end-to-end fashion, and seven were performed end-to-side. Of the 87 flaps there were 53 TRAM flaps, seven bilateral TRAM, five latissimus dorsi, four gastrocnemius, three rectus abdominis, two radial forearm fibula, and four Rubens fat-pad flaps. Seventy flaps were used for breast reconstruction, seven flaps for lower limb reconstruction, four flaps for head and neck reconstruction, and six flaps for chest wall/trunk reconstruction. There were no postoperative anastomotic complications of bleeding, thrombosis, or need for revision (100 percent patency rate), with a significantly reduced time for completion of anastomoses. The clip applier is a safe, reliable method for performing microvascular anastomoses, allowing reduced operating time and possible cost savings in free-flap surgery.

Arterial repair with synthetic patch by using titanium clips

BACKGROUND

Vascular closure staple (VCS) clips made of titanium were originally developed for microvascular anastomoses. There is limited experience with their applicability to vascular reconstruction in larger vessels. This study compares VCS clips to standard sutures in arterial repair using a synthetic patch.

METHODS

In an experimental study with pigs, two sequential 10-mm abdominal aortotomies were allocated randomly to synthetic patch (polytetrafluoroethylene) repair with VCS clips or continuous 6-0 polypropylene sutures. Angiographic, macroscopic, and microscopic results were assessed after 2 months.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in the patency rate, vessel diameter at the repair site, or healing indices. The mean (SD) clamp time was 8.7 (3.0) minutes for clip repair and 14.3 (7.4) minutes for suture repair (p = 0.04), and the times required for the vessel reconstruction were 5.3 (1.3) and 9.3 (3.0) minutes, respectively (p = 0.009).

CONCLUSION

Patched arterial repair with VCS clips is faster than sutured reconstruction with comparable results after 2 months of follow up.

Anastomotic tissue response associated with expanded polytetrafluoroethylene access grafts constructed by using nonpenetrating clips

PURPOSE

The gross, light microscopic, and scanning microscopic appearance of arterial and venous anastomoses in expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) access grafts constructed with nonpenetrating clips were compared with that of those constructed with polypropylene suture. We hypothesized that clip-constructed anastomoses would provide controlled approximation of native vessel intimal and medial components with the ePTFE grafts. We further hypothesized that anastomotic healing with clips would involve primarily an intimal cellular response, as compared with suture-constructed anastomoses in which cells within the media and adventitia walls participate.

METHODS

Femoral artery to femoral vein arteriovenous (AV) grafts were constructed in five dogs using 4-mm internal diameter ePTFE graft material. Each animal received one AV graft with anastomoses constructed by using polypropylene sutures in one leg and one AV graft with anastomoses constructed with Vascular Closure System clips in the contralateral leg. Animals were given aspirin for the duration of the study, and grafts were explanted at 5 weeks. At the time of explantation, graft segments were grossly evaluated and then underwent light and scanning electron microscopic analysis.

RESULTS

At the time of explantation, all access grafts were patent. Joining the ePTFE grafts to the native vessels with clips resulted in minimal vessel wall damage. The lumenal contours of the discontinuous approximation were smooth and without gross endothelial disruption. These observations are in contrast to the lumenal compromise and endothelial disturbance associated with the sutured anastomoses. Furthermore, hemostasis was achieved immediately in the clipped grafts, decreasing the incidence of perianastomic hematoma. Finally, cellular reconstitution occurred at the anastomotic cleft in both the sutured and the clipped junctions. The neointima exhibited an endothelial cell lining on the lumenal surface and the presence of alpha-smooth muscle cell actin positive cells within the subendothelial layer.

CONCLUSION

Vascular Closure System clips are a viable alternative to suture for the approximation of ePTFE AV access grafts to native blood vessels. The use of the clips resulted in a more streamlined anastomosis, with decreased vessel wall damage, immediate hemostasis, and a trend toward shorter procedure times.

Preliminary prospective randomized experience with vascular clips in the creation of arteriovenous fistulae for hemodialysis

BACKGROUND

A new vascular clipping system (VCS) has been introduced for clinical use. This study was developed to determine whether patency rates and treatment outcomes for anastomoses in hemodialysis access surgery can be improved by the application of this new technology.

METHODS

During a 10-month period, 96 consecutive patients requiring autologous fistula, synthetic fistula, or graft revisions for hemodialysis were prospectively randomized into two treatment groups. Anastomoses were constructed with the VCS in 46 patients and with polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) suturing in 49 patients. The procedures were performed in an outpatient setting, at a large medical center, by one surgeon. Time to construct the anastomosis, amount of bleeding from the anastomotic site, and primary and secondary graft patencies were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean time to construct anastomoses in autologous and synthetic grafts using VCS clips was significantly shorter than with sutures (autologous 14 versus 22 minutes, P = 0.0001; and new grafts 26 versus 30 minutes, P = 0.04). Blood loss was less in anastomoses done with the VCS clip; however, statistical significance was reached only for autologous fistulas (P = 0.0001). At 2-year follow-up, primary and secondary patencies were similar for both the VCS and suture groups with the exception that a statistically significant improvement was found in secondary patency for autologous fistulas when performed with the VCS.

CONCLUSIONS

The VCS clip is easy to use and produces a more rapid anastomosis with less bleeding. Primary and secondary patencies using the VCS clip were equivalent or improved when compared with standard suture. In our experience, no complications have been attributed to the use of the clip technique.

Comparison of Arcuate-Legged Clipped versus Sutured Hepatic Artery, Portal Vein, and Bile Duct Anastomoses

Attempts at improving anastomoses have included the development of stapling techniques. Our purpose was to evaluate arcuate-legged clipped versus standard sutured anastomoses of the hepatic artery (HA), portal vein (PV), and bile duct in a porcine liver transplantation model. Two groups of pigs were studied intraoperatively and 1 day after liver transplantation. A control group underwent sutured anastomosis of PV and HA with polypropylene and of bile duct with polydioxanone (n = 8). An experimental group underwent anastomoses with arcuate-legged clips (n = 8). We analyzed the time to perform anastomosis and flows before and at various time points after anastomosis. In addition, patency and histology of the anastomoses were evaluated 1 day after operation, including a fibrin-thrombosis score, medial injury, and inflammation score. Times to complete HA and PV anastomoses were not different between clipped and sutured groups. However, the time was shorter to complete bile duct anastomosis with clips than with sutures (6.3 ± 1.1 minutes and 13.3 ± 2.0 minutes, respectively). Flows through HA anastomoses were not different between groups, but flow through the PV was higher in clipped compared with sutured anastomosis (P = 0.06). Patency was 100 per cent with no leaks for all three anastomoses in both groups. Histologic data were similar between vascular anastomotic groups. Sutured bile duct anastomoses revealed mild smooth muscle injury in 75 per cent whereas clipped bile duct anastomoses displayed no smooth muscle injury. We conclude that arcuate-legged clipped anastomosis represents a viable option to sutured anastomoses of the PV, HA, and bile duct anastomoses. Bile duct anastomoses were completed in less than half the time and with less tissue damage documented histologically.

Nonpenetrating clips for coronary anastomosis

BACKGROUND

A nonsuture clip technique (nonpenetrating titanium clips applied to everted tissue edges at high compressive forces) was used to perform coronary anastomoses in a clinical setting.

METHODS

Clipped coronary anastomoses were performed in 10 patients. The anastomoses incorporated the left internal mammary artery to the left anterior descending artery (n = 1) and the saphenous vein to the right coronary artery (n = 5), the posterior descending artery (n = 2), the diagonal artery (n = 2), and one vein-to-vein proximal anastomosis (n = 1).

RESULTS

The mean duration for completion of the anastomoses was 15 minutes (range, 7 to 20 minutes). This time was reduced from 20 minutes at the beginning of the clinical experience to 7 minutes for the last 3 patients. No technical complication was related to clip application and all patients had uneventful outcomes. Three anastomoses studied by coronary angiography were patent without stenosis.

CONCLUSION

The clipped anastomotic technique has a rapid learning curve, the same safety as suture methods, and the potential for facilitating endoscopic vascular reconstructions.