Controversies in the management of optic nerve sheath meningiomas

Gross-total resection in optic nerve sheath meningiomas: minimally invasive and cosmetic pleasing

PURPOSE

The optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM) is one of the most challenging tumors in orbital surgery. From the perspective of mental health and patient needs, we analyzed the necessity and importance of the endoscopic transnasal approach (ETA) combined with optic nerve transection (ONT) in gross-total resection (GTR) in ONSM patients with residual vision and aim to broaden the use of ONT for specific people.

METHODS

The authors included patients with ONSMs who were treated between 2014 and 2022. We divided those cases into two groups named ETA group and lateral orbitotomy approach (LOA) group. We present the application of ETA and analyze the preoperative indication of the ONT and compared the advantages and disadvantages between ETA and LOA. The degree of tumor resection was based on imaging and surgical evaluation.

RESULTS

A total of 23 patients with ONSM were included. Sixteen patients underwent ETA, and seven underwent LOA. Among ETA cases, GTR was achieved in 14 patients with ONT and most patients maintained normal eye movement function (75%) and morphology (93.75%). In the ETA group, 14 patients experienced vision loss, while two other patients saw improvements in vision. And proptosis was alleviated (5.20 ± 2.34 vs 0.27 ± 0.46, p < 0.0001). Six patients with blindness and proptosis of the LOA group resulted in GTR with ONT and ophthalmectomy. Although intracranial extension and recurrence included no cases in the two groups, a significant psychological gap was presented due to cosmetic problems.

CONCLUSIONS

Under the premise of reducing damage and improving aesthetics, the selection of ETA combined with ONT to gross-total resect ONSMs successfully provides a minimally invasive access with acceptable complications. As an important adjunct to GTR in the surgical treatment of ONSM, the scope of ONT application should be expanded to relieve the patient's psychological burden.

Radiotherapy and Radiosurgery in the Management of Optic Nerve Sheath Meningiomas: An International Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Twenty Studies

BACKGROUND

Optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONMs) are often managed with radiotherapy (RT) with the goal of achieving radiographic local control (LC) and preventing deterioration of visual acuity (VA). We aimed to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis of outcomes for patients with ONM treated with RT.

METHODS

The PICOS/PRISMA/MOOSE selection criteria were used to identify studies. Primary outcomes were stable or improved VA and radiographic LC at last follow-up. The secondary outcomes were incidences of radiation-induced retinopathy and xerophthalmia and stable or improved visual fields (VFs). Weighted random-effects meta-analyses using the DerSimonian and Laird methods were conducted to characterize effect sizes. Mixed-effects regression models were used to examine potential correlations between gross tumor volume (GTV) and outcomes.

RESULTS

In total, 444 patients with ONM across 20 published studies were included. The estimated LC rate was 99.8% (95% confidence interval [CI], 98.3%-100%), and the estimated proportion of patients with stable or improved VA or VF was 89.7% (95% CI, 86.2%-92.4%) and 93.3% (95% CI, 89.5%-95.8%), respectively. Estimated incidences of radiation-induced retinopathy and xerophthalmia were 7.2% and 10.1%, respectively. GTV was significantly associated with VA (P = 0.014) with estimated VA rates of 96.4%, 91.4%, and 80.5% for GTVs of 2.0, 3.0, and 4.0 cm³, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

RT was well tolerated, with excellent LC achieved. Nearly 90% of patients noted either stability or improvement in VA and VF. Larger ONMs were associated with poorer VA.

Clinical, Pathologic, and Radiologic Features of Orbital Solitary Fibrous Tumors and Meningiomas

A wide variety of benign and malignant tumors can arise from different structures in the orbital and peri-orbital area, affecting the eye and the optic nerve. This spectrum of tumors includes primary and metastatic carcinomas, lymphomas, melanomas, soft tissue tumors, and primary tumors of the retina, optic disc, and optic nerve. These also extend to relatively rare entities such as solitary fibrous tumor and meningioma of the orbit and optic nerve, which can present with very similar clinical and radiologic features, although the tumor grades, treatment plans, and outcomes can vary widely. In this report, we present two clinical cases of solitary fibrous tumor [central nervous system (CNS) World Health Organization (WHO) grade 2 and 3) and compare their clinical presentation, radiologic and histologic features, treatment, and clinical outcomes to a group of three orbital meningiomas (CNS WHO grade 1 and 2). In the context of these five cases of orbital lesions, we review the current clinical, pathologic, and radiologic literature on orbital tumors, focusing primarily on solitary fibrous tumors and meningiomas, along with an expanded discussion on the diagnostic criteria of both entities, as well as the treatment and prognosis of these lesions.

Primary and Secondary Optic Nerve Sheath Meningioma

Objective  This study was aimed to review issues relating to the recognition, radiographic diagnosis, monitoring, and management of primary and secondary optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM). Design  This study is a review of peer-reviewed literature combined with illustrative case studies. Participants and Methods  A literature search was conducted via the PubMed database using pertinent search terms. Selected articles were limited to those written or translated into English. Additional works cited within articles were also included. Individual cases were drawn from the experience of a tertiary academic neuroophthalmic and orbital practice. Tables summarize radiotherapeutic and surgical studies, excluding single case reports and studies focusing on meningioma of intracranial origin. Main Outcome Measurements  Review of reported surgical and radiotherapeutic series is the primary measurement. Results  The natural history of optic nerve sheath meningiomas is primarily characterized by progressive ipsilateral vision loss. Diagnosis is typically based on radiographic imaging findings, with biopsy remaining indicated in some patients. Management strategies may include observation, radiation, and/or surgical intervention, or a combination of these approaches. The role of surgery, especially with respect to primary ONSM (pONSM), remains controversial. Advancement of radiotherapy techniques has shifted modern treatment paradigms in pONSM toward radiation as primary treatment, as surgical outcomes are inferior in major studies. Although radiation remains the treatment of choice in many cases, selected patients may benefit from surgery, especially in the setting of secondary ONSM (sONSM). Conclusion  A wide variety of radiotherapeutic and surgical treatment modalities for ONSM exist. The specific indications for each management strategy continue to be redefined.

Prognostic factors in the surgical treatment of intracanalicular primary optic nerve sheath meningiomas

OBJECTIVE

Although meningiomas frequently involve the optic nerve, primary optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONSMs) are rare, accounting for only 1% of all meningiomas. Given the high risk of vision loss with these tumors, surgical intervention is seldom considered, and radiation or observation is commonly applied. Here, the authors describe the visual outcomes for a series of patients who were treated with surgery aiming at maximal tumor resection and highlight their prognostic factors.

METHODS

The authors retrospectively analyzed the data for 8 patients with intracanalicular ONSMs who had been surgically treated by the senior author (O.A.) between 1998 and 2016. Meningiomas extending into the optic canal from the intracranial cavity (i.e., clinoid, sphenoid wing, tuberculum sellae, diaphragma sellae) were excluded. Diagnosis was based on ophthalmological, radiological, and intraoperative findings, which were confirmed by the typical histological findings. Preoperative, postoperative, and follow-up visual assessments were performed by neuro-ophthalmologists in all cases.

RESULTS

The patients included 7 females and 1 male. The mean age at diagnosis was 45.1 years (range 25.0–70.0 years). Mean duration of follow-up was 38.9 months (range 3.0–88.0 months). All patients reported visual complaints, and all had objective evidence of optic nerve dysfunction. Their evaluation included visual field, visual acuity, funduscopy, and retinal fiber thickness. Total resection was obtained in 4 cases. Comparing preoperative and postoperative visual function revealed that 4 patients had improvement at the last follow-up, 1 patient had stable vision, and 3 patients had decreased function but none had total vision loss. All patients with good preoperative visual acuity maintained this status following surgical treatment. There was no surgical mortality or infection. Operative complications included binocular diplopia in 4 patients, which remitted spontaneously.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgery can play a beneficial role in the primary treatment of ONSM, especially lesions located in the posterior third of the nerve. Total removal can be achieved with vision preservation or improvement, without major surgical complications, especially at early stages of the disease. Patients with good preoperative vision and CSF flow in the optic sheath have better chances of a favorable outcome than those with poor vision.

The Role of Endonasal Endoscopic Optic Nerve Decompression as the Initial Management of Primary Optic Nerve Sheath Meningiomas

Background  The management of optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONSMs) remains controversial. Surgical decompression through traditional resective techniques has been associated with significant morbidity. While radiation therapy, the current modality of choice is not exempt of risks. Transnasal endoscopic optic nerve decompression (EOND) offers a direct route to the orbit, optic canal, and orbital apex, providing a minimally invasive alternative. Objective  The main objective of this article is to assess EOND as the initial management of symptomatic patients with primary ONSM. Methods  Patients with ONSMs without a history of radiotherapy who underwent EOND were retrospectively reviewed. Postoperative imaging, duration of follow-up, and visual outcomes at the last ophthalmology visit were assessed. Results  Four women (age range 25-63 years) with primary ONSMs that underwent EOND were identified. All patients displayed subjective and objective baseline signs of vision loss. Additionally, baseline proptosis, diplopia, optic nerve atrophy, and ocular pain were identified. In none of the cases, the optic nerve sheath was breached. Following EOND, all patients deferred treatment with adjuvant radiotherapy. At a mean postoperative follow-up of 14 months, all patients were clinically stable without evidence of disease progression on imaging or physical examination. At last ophthalmologic evaluation, three out of four showed objective improvements from baseline visual acuity and visual field (remaining patient had baseline optic nerve atrophy). Conclusion  These results suggest that EOND could be a viable initial treatment modality of selected primary ONSM cases. Further studies are warranted to determine long-term efficacy and its role in a stepwise progression of management, preceding radiotherapy.

A novel surgical approach for intraorbital optic nerve tumors

Although orbital tumors involving the optic nerve are rare, it is well-known that they are very likely to cause serious visual impairment in a patient. Unfortunately, at present, there are no effective interventions that can reliably preserve visual function while controlling tumor growth into intracranial spaces. To ensure visual function of the non-affected side, transection of the optic nerve together with the tumors involved is necessary in some cases. For this procedure large craniotomy and orbital unroofing are commonly utilized. As an alternative, we propose a novel surgical intervention for transection of the optic nerve having optic nerve tumors, which utilizes a lateral orbitotomy approach. To evaluate the invasiveness of different surgical approaches, we compared the days of hospitalization after surgery across patients who underwent the transcranial, lateral, and anterior approaches, respectively. We successfully removed 2 optic nerve tumors using the lateral approach, which required significantly shorter hospitalization than the transcranial approach. The transection of the optic nerve together with tumor removal by the lateral approach may be one of the novel surgical interventions for optic nerve tumors as this method is considerably less invasive than the transcranial removal method.

Optic nerve sheath meningiomas: prevalence, impact, and management strategies

Optic nerve sheath meningiomas are rare benign neoplasms of the meninges surrounding the optic nerve. They are a significant cause of morbidity. While the mortality rate is practically zero, these tumors can blind or disfigure patients. Given that the clinical course can be variable, and treatment has the capacity to cause morbidity itself, the management of these patients can be difficult. We review the literature to discuss the prevalence of optic nerve sheath meningiomas, the association with neurofibromatosis type 2, natural history, and management options and strategies.

The Use of 68Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT in the Non-invasive Diagnosis of Optic Nerve Sheath Meningioma: A Case Report

We hereby report the case of a patient with optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM), whose diagnosis and multidisciplinary management was guided by the use of Gallium-68 (⁶⁸Ga)-labeled dodecanetetraacetic acid-tyrosine-3-octreotate (DOTATATE) positron emission tomography (PET)/computed tomography (CT) scan. We briefly review the diagnosis and management of ONSM, and review the literature on the role and current status of nuclear imaging with somatostatin receptor ligands in the non-invasive diagnosis and management of meningiomas.

Modern Management of Meningiomas Compressing the Optic Nerve: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

Meningiomas that compress the optic nerve (ON) can lead to different visual outcomes depending on the segment of ON affected (intraorbital, canalicular, and intracranial). In this study, we performed a comprehensive comparison of the management options (surgery, radiation, or observation alone) for meningiomas compressing the ON, categorized by location and relation to the ON.

METHODS

MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic reviews databases were searched according to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) statement. Data were extracted from the articles regarding anatomic location, initial visual impairment, surgical procedure, visual outcome, morbidity and mortality, gross total removal, and requirement for postoperative radiotherapy.

RESULTS

Of the 47 articles eligible for full-text reading, 9 surgical studies met our inclusion criteria. Data from 317 patient cases were extracted. In patients in whom the intracranial segment of the ON was impaired in isolation, 49% experienced visual improvement after surgery. When the meningioma affected the canalicular segment or intraorbital segment, visual improvement after surgery was 31% and 11%, respectively. Of patients who underwent surgery for the intraorbital segment of the ON, 56% experienced a decline in visual outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

When a neurosurgeon deals with a meningioma compressing the ON, opening the optic canal is suggested if invasion is suspected on the preoperative imaging. Extra caution should be used when operating on meningiomas with ON sheath adhesion, given the higher evidence of postoperative visual worsening.

Natural history of primary paediatric optic nerve sheath meningioma: case series and review

PURPOSE

To study the natural history, clinical and radiological characteristics of primary paediatric optic nerve sheath meningioma (PPONSM).

METHODS

Retrospective study of eight paediatric patients who were treated between 1994 and 2016 at the University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland and the Royal Adelaide Hospital, Australia. Clinical records and imaging studies were reviewed.

RESULTS

The mean age at presentation was 11 years (range: 6-17 years). There were six female patients and two male patients. 2/8 patients had associated neurofibromatosis type 2. Patients were followed up for 71-297 months (mean 156±70 months). 6/8 patients were observed through the course of their disease and 2/8 patients were treated with radiotherapy. 2/8 patients who were observed had minimal change in vision and did not experience tumour growth after long-term follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the largest PPONSM case series with long-term data on patients treated conservatively. We highlight that a small subset of these tumours are indolent and can be managed using observation alone.

Diagnosis of optic nerve sheath meningioma during optic nerve sheath decompression

Optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM) is typically diagnosed based on clinical suspicion and imaging characteristics and is most often treated with radiation. Historically, biopsy, optic nerve sheath decompression, and debulking surgeries have been avoided for fear of optic nerve vascular disruption and tumor spread into the orbit. This is a case of a 48-year-old man who presented with unilateral optic disc edema, declining visual acuity, and a visual field defect. Despite an initial improvement with acetazolamide, his vision subsequently worsened. With an elevated lumbar puncture opening pressure and imaging showing right optic nerve sheath enhancement, the differential diagnosis included ONSM, perineuritis and idiopathic intracranial hypertension (IIH). Optic nerve sheath decompression (ONSD) with biopsy was performed, simultaneously decompressing the nerve and yielding a sample for pathologic analysis. A pathologic diagnosis of ONSM was made and treatment with radiation was subsequently initiated, but vision began to improve after the surgical decompression alone.

Optic Nerve Sheath Meningioma Masquerading as Optic Neuritis

Optic neuritis is a common presentation of demyelinating disorders such as multiple sclerosis. It typically presents with acute painful monocular vision loss, whereas chronic optic neuropathy can be caused by compressive lesions along the anterior visual pathway, genetic, toxic, or nutritional causes. We report an unusual presentation mimicking optic neuritis, which was subsequently diagnosed as optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM). Misinterpretation of white matter lesions on MRI of brain and the failure to image the optic nerves at the time of acute loss of vision led to the misdiagnosis of optic neuritis in this case. A comprehensive accurate history and ordering the appropriate imaging modality remain paramount in diagnosing progressive visual deterioration.

Radiotherapy for optic nerve sheath meningioma: a case for earlier intervention?

AIMS

To assess tumour control, visual outcomes and toxicity after radiotherapy for all patients with optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONSM) treated by a single radiation oncologist at a single institution over a 15 year period. To explore potential predictors of outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients underwent ophthalmological and radiological assessments before radiotherapy. These were repeated at regular intervals after treatment. A retrospective analysis of clinical, dosimetric and radiological data was carried out. Patients with useful vision before radiotherapy were divided into two groups - those with maintained or improved vision and those with a deterioration in vision. The groups were compared using the Mann-Whitney U-test with regard to eight potential predictors of outcome.

RESULTS

Seventeen patients with 18 ONSM were treated with fractionated radiotherapy (46.8-55.8 Gy in 26-31 fractions). No evaluable tumours grew after treatment: control rate 100% (95% confidence interval 82-100%). Using the most common definition of visual function described in the literature, vision was maintained or improved in 89% (95% confidence interval 67-97%) of cases. In those with useful vision before treatment (13 evaluable eyes), visual acuity was maintained or improved in eight (62%, 95% confidence interval 36-82%). There was a suggestion that the time from the onset of symptoms to radiotherapy may influence outcome. Those with stable or better visual acuity after radiotherapy had been observed for a shorter time compared with those who had worse visual acuity (median of 18 months versus 62 months). Acute and late toxicity from radiotherapy was manageable.

CONCLUSION

Radiotherapy is an extremely effective modality in arresting the growth of ONSM. A longer time from symptom onset to the start of radiotherapy may predict for poorer outcomes.

Multisession radiosurgery for optic nerve sheath meningiomas--an effective option: preliminary results of a single-center experience

BACKGROUND

Traditional treatment options for optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONSMs) include observation, surgery, and radiotherapy, but to date none of these has become the clear treatment of choice.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness and safety of multisession radiosurgery for ONSMs.

METHODS

From May 2004 to June 2008, 21 patients with ONSMs were treated by radiosurgery using the frameless CyberKnife system. Patient age ranged from 36 to 73 years (mean, 54 years). All patients were treated using multisession radiosurgery, with 5 fractions of 5 Gy each to a total dose of 25 Gy prescribed to the 75% to 85% isodose line. Patients were evaluated for tumor growth control and visual function.

RESULTS

The median pretreatment tumor volume was 2.8 mL (range, 0.3-23 mL). The mean follow-up was 30 months (range, 11-68 months). All patients tolerated treatment well, with only 1 patient in whom a mild optic neuropathy developed (which remitted after systemic steroid therapy). No other acute or late radiation-induced toxicities were observed. No patients showed ONSM progression on follow-up magnetic resonance imaging. Two patients (10%) had a partial response. No patients had worsening of visual function; visual function was stable in 65% and improved in 35% of patients.

CONCLUSION

Multisession radiosurgery for ONSMs was found to be safe and effective. The preliminary results from this study, in terms of growth control, visual function improvement, and toxicity, are quite promising. Further investigations are warranted.

Optic nerve sheath meningioma: current diagnosis and treatment

✓Optic nerve sheath meningiomas (ONSMs) are rare tumors of the anterior visual pathway and constitute approximately 2% of all orbital tumors and 1–2% of all meningiomas. Untreated ONSMs almost always lead to progressive visual decline, color blindness, and finally complete loss of vision. Although resection is warranted in cases of widespread ONSM, surgery can lead to significant morbidity. Recently, stereotactic fractionated radiotherapy has shown effectiveness in improving or stabilizing remaining visual function with minimal procedural morbidity in patients with ONSM. The authors review the incidence, histopathological characteristics, clinical presentation, neuroimaging findings, and current treatment modalities for ONSMs, with an emphasis on fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy.

Méningiome du nerf optique. L’expérience lyonnaise

Meningioma is an unfrequent optic nerve tumor. Clinical symptoms are not specific, and pathology exam not easily accessible. The diagnosis is usually based on imaging findings. We report our experience, based on twenty patients. Most of them were middle-aged women (mean age=47 years old). The optic nerve meningioma (ONM) was often revealed by visual dysfunction. Ophthalmological evaluation was altered in most patients (visual acuity, visual fields, fundi). The gold-standard exam was MRI of the optic nerve, with and without gadolinium, and with fat-sat sequences. Thirty percent of the lesions remain stable without treatment. Functional prognosis has been improved only by conformal fractionated radiotherapy, but indications and modalities remain to be specified.