Clinical importance of non-HLA antibodies in solid organ transplantation:

The outcome of the endothelial precursor cell crossmatch test in lymphocyte crossmatch positive and negative patients evaluated for living donor kidney transplantation

The presence of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) and non-HLA antibodies (Abs) in kidney transplant recipients is associated with graft rejections. This study reports the results of an endothelial precursor cell crossmatch (EPCXM) test for detection of non-HLA Abs and its correlation to lymphocyte crossmatch (LXM) test results, the degree and type of sensitization, and transplantation (Tx) outcome in patients evaluated for living donor (LD) kidney transplantation (KTx). Patients were tested before any pre-transplantation (pre-Tx) treatment and at Tx. Pre-Tx treatments included B cell depletion and Ab removal. Patient records were reviewed for assessment of renal graft function, results of biopsies, and identification of complications affecting the graft. Pre-Tx sera from 32% of the LD patients had IgG and/or IgM-binding donor EPCs. Twenty-five percent of the patients were EPCXM IgM+. Of the patients with negative LXM tests, 25% had EPC Abs mainly of IgM class not reactive with HLA. There was no difference in rejection frequency or serum creatinine levels between the EPCXM+ and EPCXM- groups. The pre-Tx EPCXM+ group had significantly more patients with delayed graft function. Prospective studies with appropriate control groups are needed to establish whether pre-treatments aiming at removing anti-endothelial cell antibodies, as detected by the EPCXM pre-Tx, have a beneficial effect on short-term and long-term graft survival.

Detection of complement-fixing and non-fixing antibodies specific for endothelial precursor cells and lymphocytes using flow cytometry

Donor human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-specific antibodies (Abs) with the ability to activate complement are associated with an increased risk of early Ab-mediated rejection (AMR) of kidney allografts. In recent years, also non-HLA Abs-binding endothelial cells have been shown to elicit early AMR. Donor-specific anti-endothelial cell Abs escape detection in the pre-transplant evaluation if only lymphocytes are used as target cells in crossmatch tests. We addressed whether endothelial precursor cells (EPCs) could be used for detection of complement-fixing as well as non-fixing Abs and if complement factor and immunoglobulin G (IgG) deposition on co-purified T and B cells correlated to the outcome of the T- and B-cell complement-dependent cytotoxicity assay. Deposition of complement factors C3c and C3d, but not C1q nor C4d, were detected on EPCs and lymphocytes upon incubation with HLA Ab-positive sera. There was a correlation between the amount of C3c deposition and IgG binding on EPCs (R(2) = 0.71, P = 0.0012) and T cells (R(2) = 0.74, P = 0.0006) but not for B cells (R(2) = 0.34, P = 0.059). The specificity and sensitivity for C3d deposition on endothelial precursor cell crossmatch (EPCXM) T cells vs the T complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) assay were 69% and 72%, respectively. The EPCXM B-cell C3d assay had considerably lower sensitivity (39%) than the B CDC assay. Altogether, this novel assay based on the detection of complements factors on EPCs and lymphocytes by flow cytometry may widen the diagnostic repertoire and thereby improve the clinical management of patients undergoing kidney transplantation.

IgM antibodies towards pre-endothelial cells: strong indication for an association with accelerated rejection. A case report

A 27-year-old woman developed a graft loss due to an accelerated humoral rejection after receiving a blood group identical, human leucocyte antigens (HLA) haploidentical living-related kidney, despite the fact that she did not refer any sensitization event before transplantation. The complement-dependent cytotoxicity and flow cytometry crossmatches were negative for T and B cells. Retrospectively, IgM antibodies against donor precursor endothelial Tie-2(+) cells were detected using a commercially available assay and the pre-transplant serum sample. This case illustrates the necessity of detection of other than the classical HLA-directed antibodies prior organ grafting.

Clinical relevance and IgG subclass determination of non-HLA antibodies identified using endothelial cell precursors isolated from donor blood

BACKGROUND

ABO and human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alloantibodies provide major immunologic barriers to successful transplantation; however, there is increasing recognition for the role of anti-endothelial cell antibodies (AECAs) in allograft rejection. We investigated the relationship between AECAs identified using donor-derived endothelial cell precursors (ECPs) and kidney allograft rejection and function.

METHODS

Sixty live donor kidney recipients were tested pretransplant for AECAs and HLA-antibodies using flow cytometric crossmatch tests and solid-phase bead immunoassays. Renal allograft function was assessed by serum creatinine (SCr) values collected at early (mean, 50 days) and late (mean, 815 days) time points posttransplant and by incidence and type of rejection. Immunoglobulin G (IgG) subtype determination of both AECAs and HLA antibodies bound to ECPs was performed using flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Fourteen patients (23%) tested positive for donor-reactive IgG AECAs and had statistically higher SCr values and incidences of cellular rejection early posttransplant compared with 46 patients who tested negative (P=0.014 and P<0.05). SCr values were not statistically different late posttransplant. IgG subclass determination showed AECAs to be enriched for IgG2 and IgG4, subclasses that do not activate complement effectively. Detection of donor-reactive immunoglobulin M (IgM) AECAs did not correlate with increased SCr or incidence of rejection.

CONCLUSION

Crossmatch tests performed using donor-derived ECPs allow for the identification of alloantibodies that are associated with cellular rejection and are distinct from alloantibodies detected using lymphocytes.

Detection of citrate synthase autoantibodies in rats with chronic allograft nephropathy

Citrate synthase (CS) is the one of the key enzymes in the citric acid cycle and an important mitochondrial autoantigen. The autoimmune responses against CS have not been studied in chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN). This study investigated the role of specific CS autoantibodies in rats bearing renal allografts affected with CAN.

METHODS

Fisher344 rat renal grafts were orthotopically transplanted into Lewis rats following the procedure of Kamada with our modification. Lewis-to-Lewis and Fisher344-to-Fisher344 kidney transplantations were also performed as autologous control groups (each n = 9). All the allograft recipients given cyclosporine (10 mg/kg(-1)d(-1) x 10 d) were divided into four groups (each n = 9): (1) vehicle: normal saline orally; (2) cyclosporine: 6 mg/kg(-1)d(-1); (3)FK506: 0.15 mg/kg(-1)d(-1); (4) mycophenolate mofetil (MMF): 20 mg/ kg(-1)d(-1). At 4, 8, and 12 weeks posttransplantation, the animals were sacrificed to harvest sera and renal allografts. The serum creatinine (SCr) was measured and pathological changes assessed according to Banff 97 criteria. IgM and IgG isotypes of CS antibodies were detected in all recipient sera by enzyme linked immunosorbent assays.

RESULTS

Both IgM and IgG isotype CS autoantibodies were observed in the sera of all the recipients before and after transplantation, but the levels of IgM CS autoantibody were obviously higher than IgG isotype in all the blood samples. It was stable not only in autologous but also in allograft groups. In both autologous groups, the SCr and IgM and IgG isotype CS autoantibodies showed no obvious change before and after transplantation, and no typical CAN occurred. The values of IgG isotype of CS autoantibody (DeltaOD) at 4, 8 and 12 weeks were stable. At 4 weeks, the values of SCr, Banff score, and IgG isotype CS autoantibody (DeltaOD) were not significantly different (P > .05) among the allograft groups. At 8 and 12 weeks, with progression of CAN in vehicle, cyclosporine and FK506 groups' values of SCr, Banff score, and IgG (DeltaOD) also increased dramatically (P = .005) in all three groups when compared with the baseline and 4 week values, but the differences among the three groups were not significant (P > .05). At 8 and 12 weeks, the MMF group suffered mild-to-moderate CAN, but the values of SCr and Banff score were significantly lower than those in the other three groups. MMF significantly inhibited the formation of IgG (DeltaOD) when compared with the other three groups (P = .02).

CONCLUSION

This study suggested that the IgG isotype of CS autoantibody contributes to CAN after kidney transplantation. The IgM isotype is physiological. MMF significantly inhibited the formation of IgG isotype CS autoantibody, which may be related to its effects to alleviate CAN.

A flow cytometric crossmatch test for simultaneous detection of antibodies against donor lymphocytes and endothelial precursor cells

Complement-dependent cytotoxicity or flow cytometric lymphocyte crossmatch (LXM) tests may fail to detect clinically significant antibodies (Abs) against non-human leukocyte antigen (HLA). A flow cytometric endothelial precursor cell crossmatch (EPCXM) test (XM-ONE) is available for detection of Abs against donor endothelial precursor cells (EPCs). We showed that lymphocytes co-purified with EPCs can be used in LXM tests allowing simultaneous detection of Abs reactive with donor EPCs and lymphocytes. The lymphocyte population co-purified with EPCs on anti-Tie-2 Ab-coupled magnetic beads contained CD 8(+) and CD 4(+) T-cells, B-cells, and natural killer (NK)- and natural killer T (NKT)-cells. HLA class I antigen expression was slightly higher on CD 3(+) lymphocytes co-purified on Tie-2 Ab beads than on unseparated lymphocytes, whereas HLA class I and II antigen levels on CD 19(+) lymphocytes were not significantly different. Sera from 10 patients with panel-reactive Abs were tested on cells from nine donors using flow cytometric LXM and EPCXM tests. There was a very good correlation (R(2) = 0.94) between the channel shift values obtained on unseparated and Tie-2 Ab bead-isolated T-lymphocytes, whereas the correlation between the channel shift values obtained on the two B-lymphocyte populations was lower (R(2) = 0.71). T- and B-lymphocytes co-purified with EPCs can be used in LXM tests enabling simultaneous detection of donor lymphocyte- and EPC-reactive Abs in a single-tube XM-ONE assay.

Multicenter evaluation of a novel endothelial cell crossmatch test in kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

Despite their clinical importance, clinical routine tests to detect anti-endothelial cell antibodies (AECA) in organ transplantation have not been readily available. This multicenter prospective kidney transplantation trial evaluates the efficacy of a novel endothelial cell crossmatch (ECXM) test to detect donor-reactive AECA associated with kidney allograft rejection.

METHODS

Pretransplant serum samples from 147 patients were tested for AECA by a novel flow cytometric crossmatch technique (XM-ONE) using peripheral blood endothelial progenitor cells as targets. Patient enrolment was based on acceptance for transplantation determined by donor lymphocyte crossmatch results.

RESULTS

Donor-reactive AECA were found in 35 of 147 (24%) patients. A significantly higher proportion of patients with a positive ECXM had rejections (16 of 35, 46%) during the follow-up of at least 3 months compared with those without AECA (13 of 112, 12%; P<0.00005). Both IgG and IgM AECAs were associated with graft rejections. Mean serum creatinine levels were significantly higher in patients with a positive ECXM test at 3 and 6 months posttransplant.

CONCLUSIONS

XM-ONE is quick, easy to perform on whole blood samples and identifies patients at risk for rejection and reduced graft function not identified by conventional lymphocyte crossmatches.

C4d deposition is correlated with the level of antivimentin antibody in rat kidneys undergoing chronic allograft nephropathy

AIMS

Antivimentin antibody is often produced as an autoantibody after transplantation. C4d deposition, a marker of humoral immunity during transplantation, is believed to reflect alloantibodies. This study investigated the relationship between C4d deposition and humoral immunity to vimentin among rat kidneys undergoing chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN).

METHODS

Fisher 344 rat renal grafts were orthotopically transplanted into Lewis rats following the procedure of Kamada with our modification. All recipients were administered cyclosporine (CsA) (10 mg/kg(-1).d(-1) x 10 d) before being divided into 3 groups of oral treatments: (1) vehicle, (2) CsA (6 mg/kg(-1).d(-1)), and (3) mycophenolate mofetil (MMF; 20 mg/kg(-1).d(-1)). At 4, 8 and 12 weeks after transplantation, the rats were killed, the renal allografts harvested, and the sera collected. Serum creatinine (SCr) was measured and pathologic changes assessed according to the Banff 97 criteria. The antivimentin antibody was quantified by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The deposition of C4d detected by immunofluorescence was analyzed by integrated optical density (IOD).

RESULTS

Antivimentin antibody was observed in sera of all transplanted rats. The level of antivimentin antibody (IgGDeltaOD) increased gradually during the development of CAN from 4 weeks. Simultaneously, C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries also progressively strengthened. There was a strong positive correlation between the content of antivimentin antibody and C4d deposition (r = 0.892; P = .000). MMF simultaneously decreased antivimentin antibody formation and C4d deposition. In contrast, CsA had no significant effect.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the production of antivimentin antibodies and the deposition of C4d during the development of CAN. There was a positive correlation between them. Whether humoral immunity to vimentin contributes to C4d deposition is not clear and further studies are needed to elucidate this issue.

Detecting and monitoring human leukocyte antigen-specific antibodies

Renewed awareness of the relevance of HLA-specific antibodies to transplantation and the development of protocols to reduce or eliminate sensitization have made monitoring of antibodies and accurate interpretation of test results increasingly important. Here we review the various tests available and provide guidelines for the development of monitoring protocols.

Anti-glutathione S-transferase T1 antibody-mediated rejection in C4d-positive renal allograft recipients

BACKGROUND

Chronic humoral rejection is a progressive form of graft injury, with defined diagnostic criteria, the crucial one being the evidence of circulating anti-donor antibodies. These antibodies are mainly directed against human leucocyte antigens (HLA), but other targets have also been described. We previously reported that antibodies against the Glutathione S-transferase T1 (GSTT1) enzyme appear in recipients without the GSTT1 gene who receive a graft from a GSTT1-positive donor. The primary aim of this study was to analyse the role of GSTT1 in cases of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in the absence of anti-HLA antibodies. A second objective was to describe the distribution of the GSTT1 enzyme in the human kidney.

METHODS

Four renal biopsies from four renal transplanted patients with declined renal function and circulating anti-donor GSTT1 antibodies were studied for C4d deposits in sections of paraffin-embedded tissue samples. Anti-donor-specific HLA and MICA antibody detection was done with the Luminex platform and anti-GSTT1 antibodies were tested by indirect immunofluorescence on rat tissues and ELISA assay. DNA of the patients was extracted for GSTT1 genotyping.

RESULTS

Four patients with the GSTT1 donor/recipient mismatch developed anti-GSTT1 antibodies 32, 42, 48 and 60 months after the transplant. One patient also had donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies. Their biopsies showed pathologic lesions compatible with chronic antibody-mediated rejection (CAMR), along with positive C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries in three of them, being no valuable in the other case.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study reporting an association between the appearance of chronic antibody-mediated renal allograft rejection and the occurrence of de novo production of anti-GSTT1 antibodies, in the absence of anti-HLA donor-specific antibodies. This fact suggests a potential role of the GSTT1 system in anti-graft immune response.