Modic Changes in the Lumbar Spine are Common Aging-related Degenerative Findings that Parallel With Disk Degeneration

A comparison of approaches to studying relationships between lumbar spinal degeneration findings demonstrates advantages to interspace-level analyses over person-level analyses

PURPOSE

To examine associations between lumbar intervertebral disc degeneration (LDD) and type II Modic changes (MC) when retaining information at each interspace ("interspace-level analysis"), as compared to aggregating information across interspaces as is typically done in spine research ("person-level analysis"). The study compared results from (1) interspace-level analyses assuming a common relationship across interspaces (the "interspace-level, common-relationship" approach), (2) interspace-level analyses allowing for interspace-specific associations (an "interspace-level, interspace-specific" approach), (3) and a conventional person-level analytic approach.

METHODS

Adults in primary care (n = 147) received lumbar spine magnetic resonance imaging and neuroradiologist-evaluated assessments of prevalent disc height narrowing (DHN), type II MC, and other LDD parameters. Analyses examined associations between DHN and type II MC in interspace-level, common-relationship analyses, interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses, and conventional person-level analyses.

RESULTS

Cross-sectional, interspace-level, common-relationship analyses found large-magnitude DHN-type II MC associations (adjusted OR [aOR] = 6.5, 95% confidence intervals (CIs) 3.3-13; p < 0.001). The magnitude of this association was larger and more precise than that yielded by person-level analyses (aOR = 2.9 [95% CI 1.2-7]), and substantially more precise than interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses which allowed the association between DHN and type II MC to vary across levels. Across exploratory analyses of disc signal intensity and other MC types, interspace-level, common-relationship analyses produced larger-magnitude and more precise associations than person-level analyses in most situations, and were more precise than interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

Interspace-level analytic approaches offer some advantages to person-level analyses that may be useful in understanding relationships between spinal degeneration findings.

Advantages to interspace-level analyses over person-level analyses when studying relationships between lumbar spinal degeneration findings : a cross-sectional study

Purpose

To examine associations between lumbar intervertebral disc degeneration (LDD) and type II Modic changes (MC) when retaining information at each interspace ("interspace-level analysis"), as compared to aggregating information across interspaces as is typically done in spine research ("person-level analysis") . The study compared results from (1) interspace-level analyses assuming a common relationship across interspaces (the "interspace-level, common-relationship" approach), (2) interspace-level analyses allowing for interspace-specific associations (an "interspace-level, interspace-specific" approach), and (3) a conventional person-level analytic approach.

Methods

Adults in primary care (n=147) received lumbar spine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and neuroradiologist-evaluated assessments of prevalent disc height narrowing (DHN), type II MC, and other LDD parameters. Analyses examined associations between DHN and type II MC in interspace-level, common-relationship analyses, interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses, and conventional person-level analyses.

Results

Cross-sectional, interspace-level, common-relationship analyses found large-magnitude DHN-type II MC associations (adjusted OR [aOR]=6.5, 95% confidence intervals (CIs) 3.3-13; p<0.001). The magnitude of this association was larger and more precise than that yielded by person-level analyses (aOR=2.9 [95% CI 1.2-7]), and substantially more precise than interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses which allowed the association between DHN and type II MC to vary across levels. Across exploratory analyses of disc signal intensity and other MC types, interspace-level, common-relationship analyses produced larger-magnitude and more precise associations than person-level analyses in most situations, and were more precise than interspace-level, interspace-specific analyses.

Conclusions

Interspace-level analytic approaches offer some advantages to person-level analyses that may be useful in understanding relationships between spinal degeneration findings.

Three Stages on Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Lumbar Degenerative Spine

PURPOSES

To propose a new lumbar degenerative staging system using the current radiological classification system.

METHODS

A cross-sectional analysis of retrospective databases between January 2018 and December 2022 was performed. Total of 410 patients for Modic changes, paravertebral muscle fat infiltration, disc degeneration, articular process degeneration, vertebral endplate degeneration and other structures, and disc displacement, Spondylolisthesis, and stenosis, and grouped patients according to stage were assessed. Visual analog scale, Japanese Orthopaedic Association, and Oswestry Disability Index scores were used to assess low back pain strength, neurological function, and quality of life, respectively.

RESULTS

The lumbar degeneration staging system consists of 8 variables, which can be divided into 3 steps: early, middle and late, and the correlation between each variable is strong (P < 0.05). The later the staging, the worse the Japanese Orthopaedic Association, visual analog scale, and Oswestry Disability Index scores.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with later stages have worse clinical scores. This staging system recommends a uniform classification to assess lumbar degeneration.

Study and analysis of the correlation between lumbar spondylolisthesis and Modic changes

Background

This study aimed to explore the risk factors of Modic changes in lumbar spondylolisthesis.

Methods

The distribution of Modic changes in different types of lumbar spondylolisthesis, degree of spondylolisthesis, and degree of intervertebral disc degeneration in patients with lumbar spondylolisthesis was observed and analyzed. Statistical analysis was conducted to assess whether intervertebral disc degeneration, local mechanical changes, etc. affect the occurrence of Modic changes. The risk factors of Modic changes in lumbar spondylolisthesis were further illustrated.

Results

The age in the lumbar spondylolisthesis with Modic changes group was younger than that in the lumbar spondylolisthesis without Modic changes group, and the bone mineral density was better in the lumbar spondylolisthesis with Modic changes group than that in the lumbar spondylolisthesis without Modic changes group, P < 0.05. The two groups statistically differed in intervertebral disc height (IDH) and disc angle on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). In the classification of Modic changes, the incidence of type II was the highest. The incidence of Modic changes is higher in isthmic spondylolisthesis than in degenerative spondylolisthesis. With the aggravation of lumbar spondylolisthesis and intervertebral disc degeneration, the incidence of Modic changes gradually increased. Modic changes are most commonly seen in both the upper and lower endplates. Logistic regression analysis showed that the occurrence of Modic changes in lumbar spondylolisthesis was significantly correlated with IDH, disc angle on MRI, type of spondylolisthesis, degree of spondylolisthesis, and degree of intervertebral disc degeneration, P < 0.05.

Conclusions

The occurrence of Modic changes is related to the type of spondylolisthesis, the degree of spondylolisthesis, the degree of disc degeneration, the decrease of intervertebral disc height, and local stress angulation.

Evaluation of the efficacy, in terms of pain and disability, of a functional restoration programme in patients with chronic low back pain according to the presence of Modic 1 discopathy

OBJECTIVES

Modic type 1 disc disease (MD1) appears to be related to severe Chronic Low Back Pain (CLBP). Functional Restoration Programmes (FRP) recommended in CLBP may not be suitable for patients with MD1. The main objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of a FRP, on the perceived incapacity and the pain intensity, in patients with non-specific CLBP according to the presence of MD1.

METHODS

We performed a single-centre retrospective cohort study in which 271 patients were included. After one month in the FRP, this programme was considered "successful" if the pain visual analog scale had decreased by at least 20/100 millimetres and if the score of the French version of the Roland-Morris disability questionnaire had decreased by at least 4/24 points.

RESULTS

The 271 patients had an average age of 43.2 (8.0) years and 58.3% were women. Out of our entire population, 128 (47.2%) patients were considered successful, and 51 (18.8%) patients had MD1. In patients without MD1, there was 49.1% success while this rate was 39.2% in those with MD1, but this difference was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

We found no significant difference in the combination of pain and perceived disability after one month of a FRP in patients with CLBP without MD1 compared to those with CLBP with MD1. It therefore seems legitimate to offer FRP-type rehabilitation in patients with non-specific CLBP with MD1.

Conservative Treatments for Lumbar Disc Herniation at L3-4 or L4-5 Were More Likely to Fail When Ipsilateral Foraminal Stenosis Was Present at the Caudally Adjacent Segment

BACKGROUND

Conservative treatments are important in lumbar disc herniation (LDH), but predictors for poor outcomes are unclear.

METHODS

Consecutive patients with unilateral single-level LDH at L3-4 or L4-5 were enrolled. Baseline clinical data were collected, and lumbar spine magnetic resonance imaging was evaluated. Foraminal stenosis was evaluated using Lee's approach and further categorized as absence (grade 0 and 1) or presence (grade 2 or 3). Each patient underwent conservative treatments (oral meloxicam and dexamethasone, corset, back extension exercise, physiotherapy, and manual therapy) for 6 weeks. Conservative treatments were defined as failed if a patient underwent surgery within 6 weeks or reported poor recovery at 6-week follow-up. Multivariate logistic regressions were used to examine the associations of failed conservative treatments with baseline characteristics and magnetic resonance imaging findings.

RESULTS

The study included 222 patients (mean age 45.5 ± 9.8 years). Of patients, 48 (21.6%) had concurrent ipsilateral foraminal stenosis at the caudal segment, and conservative treatments failed in 39 (17.6%). At baseline, patients with LDH and caudal foraminal stenosis were older (50.79 ± 6.14 years vs. 44.10 ± 10.13 years, P < 0.001), had greater leg pain (7.06 ± 1.17 vs. 6.39 ± 1.40, P = 0.003), and had a higher rate of positive straight leg raising test (54.2% vs. 33.3%, P = 0.008) than patients without caudal foraminal stenosis. In multivariate regression, failure of conservative treatments was associated with positive straight leg raising test (odds ratio 2.26, P = 0.046), and caudal foraminal stenosis (odds ratio 3.20, P = 0.007).

CONCLUSIONS

In the presence of caudal foraminal stenosis and positive SLR test, conservative treatments were more likely to fail in patients with LDH.

The Influence of Roussouly Type on the Prevalence, Subtype, and Distribution Characteristics of Modic Changes in Patients with Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease

BACKGROUND

The relationship between Roussouly type and Modic changes (MC) is unknown. The aim of our study was to investigate the influence of Roussouly type on the characteristics of MC in patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease.

METHODS

This cross-sectional observational study from Huashan Hospital included 270 patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease. Subjects were divided into 4 groups according to the Roussouly classification. Prevalence, subtype, and distribution characteristics of MC from L1-L2 upper end plate to L5-S1 lower end plate were compared between 4 Roussouly types.

RESULTS

Of 270 patients, 65 (24.1%) were Roussouly type I, 115 (42.6%) were Roussouly type II, 55 (20.4%) were Roussouly type III, and 35 (13.0%) were Roussouly type IV. MC were present in 45.9% (n = 270) of patients, 12.7% (n = 2700) of end plates, and 11.8% (n = 1350) of intervertebral discs. The prevalence rate of MC by subtype and intervertebral disc among the 4 Roussouly types was statistically different (P < 0.05), and the prevalence rate of MC by intervertebral disc in Roussouly type I was statistically higher than the other 3 Roussouly types. In Roussouly types I and IV, the prevalence rate of MC at L4-L5 level showed no significant differences compared with those at upper lumbar levels, while in Roussouly types II and III, the prevalence rate of MC at L4-L5 level was significantly higher than those at upper lumbar levels.

CONCLUSIONS

Roussouly types can influence prevalence, subtype, and distribution characteristics of MC in patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease.

Lumbar vertebral endplate defects on magnetic resonance images: prevalence, distribution patterns, and associations with back pain

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Although the roles of Modic Changes (MCs) and disc degeneration in back pain remain controversial, clues from cadaveric studies suggest that lumbar vertebral endplate lesions may be important in back pain. Endplate lesions can be detected on magnetic resonance (MR) images as various endplate defects, including focal, corner, and erosive defects. Yet, the clinical significance of such endplate defects remains unknown.

PURPOSE

To determine the prevalence and distribution patterns of lumbar vertebral endplate defects and their associations with back pain in a population-based sample.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Subjects were randomly selected from a typical community in Hangzhou Eastern China, regardless of back pain status.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Each subject underwent a structured interview and lumbar MR imaging. Back pain history, including today, over the past 4 weeks, 12 months, and lifetime, were acquired. Endplate defects, MCs, and disc degeneration were evaluated on MRIs. Age, gender and body mass index (kg/m²), as well as lifetime exposures, including smoking history, riding in motorized vehicles and associated vibration, and occupational physical demands were assessed.

METHODS

Descriptive statistics were used to depict prevalence and distribution patterns of endplate defects in the lumbar spine. Logistic regressions were used to examine associations of endplate defects with back pain. The research grant was obtained from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (115,000 USD), Key Platform Project of the Health Department of Zhejiang Province (14,000 USD), Technology Program of Traditional Chinese Medicine Department of Zhejiang Province (21,000 USD), and 2015 Qianjiang Talent Program of Zhejiang Province (7,000 USD) toward this work. There is no conflict to disclose.

RESULTS

There were 478 subjects (53.3±14.4 years, range 20-88 years) studied. Endplate defects presented in 301 (63.0%) subjects and 842 (16.0%) endplates. The presence of endplate defects, but not MCs and disc degeneration, was associated with lifetime back pain (odds ratio=1.64, p=.026) in multivariate analyses. Focal and erosive endplate defects were associated with lifetime back pain history (odds ratio=1.74-2.23, p<.05 for both), whereas all three types of defects were associated with intensity of worst back pain over the past 12 months (Coef=5.84-7.19, p<.05 for all).

CONCLUSIONS

Endplate defects are common findings on lumbar MRIs in adults. Specific types of endplate defects were associated with back pain history. Endplate defects may be an independent risk factor for back pain.

Lifestyle and lifetime occupational exposures may not play a role in the pathogenesis of Modic changes on the lumbar spine MR images

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Modic changes (MCs) have long been suspected as a pathologic cause of back pain. Although much attention has been focused on clinical perspectives, the etiology of MCs remains unclear. Although some studies have reported that sex, body mass index (BMI), cigarette smoking, and physical loading may associate with MCs, the observed associations are inconsistent among studies.

PURPOSE

To investigate associations between MCs and lifestyle and lifetime occupational exposures using a general population sample.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

PATIENT SAMPLE

The study was an extension of the Hangzhou Lumbar Spine Study, a population-based study of mainland Chinese focusing on lumbar degenerative changes. A total of 644 randomly selected subjects from a typical community in Hangzhou, Eastern China participated.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The presence and type of MCs in the lumbosacral spine were evaluated on sagittal magnetic resonance images. Demographics, lifestyle factors, and occupational exposures were measured using a structured interview.

METHODS

Univariate and multivariate logistic regressions were used to examine the associations of MCs with various environmental exposures.

RESULTS

Among the 644 subjects (52.6±13.9 years; range 20-88 years) included in this study, 44.7% had MCs. In univariate regression analyses, the presence of MCs was associated with greater age, higher BMI, greater cigarette smoking, regular exercise, and absence of daily vehicle vibration. Modic changes were not univariately associated with sex or alcohol consumption. In addition, all occupational loading measurements were associated with the occurrence of MCs in univariate analyses, except work time spent in vehicles and work-related back injuries. However, in multivariate regression analyses, no statistically significant associations between the occurrence of MCs and lifestyle or lifetime occupational exposures were observed after adjusting for age, sex, and BMI.

CONCLUSIONS

Age is an important determinant of MCs, with BMI and sex also playing a role. Lifestyle and occupational factors appear to have minor effects, if any, on the pathogenesis of MCs in the lumbar spine.