Measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) for women with genitourinary syndrome of menopause: a systematic review

Hormonal Treatments and Vaginal Moisturizers for Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause : A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Postmenopausal women commonly experience vulvovaginal, urinary, and sexual symptoms associated with genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM).

PURPOSE

To evaluate effectiveness and harms of vaginal estrogen, nonestrogen hormone therapies, and vaginal moisturizers for treatment of GSM symptoms.

DATA SOURCES

Medline, Embase, and CINAHL through 11 December 2023.

STUDY SELECTION

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of at least 8 weeks' duration enrolling postmenopausal women with at least 1 GSM symptom and reporting effectiveness or harms of hormonal interventions or vaginal moisturizers.

DATA EXTRACTION

Risk of bias and data extraction were performed by one reviewer and verified by a second reviewer. Certainty of evidence (COE) was assessed by one reviewer and verified by consensus.

DATA SYNTHESIS

From 11 993 citations, 46 RCTs evaluating vaginal estrogen (k = 22), nonestrogen hormones (k = 16), vaginal moisturizers (k = 4), or multiple interventions (k = 4) were identified. Variation in populations, interventions, comparators, and outcomes precluded meta-analysis. Compared with placebo or no treatment, vaginal estrogen may improve vulvovaginal dryness, dyspareunia, most bothersome symptom, and treatment satisfaction. Compared with placebo, vaginal dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) may improve dryness, dyspareunia, and distress, bother, or interference from genitourinary symptoms; oral ospemifene may improve dryness, dyspareunia, and treatment satisfaction; and vaginal moisturizers may improve dryness (all low COE). Vaginal testosterone, systemic DHEA, vaginal oxytocin, and oral raloxifene or bazedoxifene may provide no benefit (low COE) or had uncertain effects (very low COE). Although studies did not report frequent serious harms, reporting was limited by short-duration studies that were insufficiently powered to evaluate infrequent serious harms.

LIMITATIONS

Most studies were 12 weeks or less in duration and used heterogeneous GSM diagnostic criteria and outcome measures. Few studies enrolled women with a history of cancer.

CONCLUSION

Vaginal estrogen, vaginal DHEA, oral ospemifene, and vaginal moisturizers may improve some GSM symptoms in the short term. Few long-term data exist on efficacy, comparative effectiveness, tolerability, and safety of GSM treatments.

PRIMARY FUNDING SOURCE

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute. (PROSPERO: CRD42023400684).

Dimensions of posttraumatic stress disorder and menopause-related health in midlife women veterans

OBJECTIVE

Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) has been linked with menopause symptoms (eg, vasomotor, urinary) and their sequelae (eg, sexual difficulties). However, PTSD is a heterogeneous disorder, and less is known about which aspects may be most associated with menopause-related health.

METHODS

Using confirmatory factor analyses, we evaluated five structural models of PTSD symptoms in 208 predominately postmenopausal women veterans (aged 45-64 years). We investigated associations between PTSD-operationalized as a probable diagnosis and symptom dimensions of the best-fitting model-and common menopause-related health concerns, including (1) vasomotor, urinary, and vaginal symptoms; (2) vasomotor symptom interference; and (3) sexual functioning.

RESULTS

A six-factor anhedonia model-comprising re-experiencing, avoidance, negative affect, anhedonia, anxious arousal, and dysphoric arousal-provided optimal fit. Both probable PTSD and greater symptoms across all dimensions were linked with presence of urinary and vasomotor, but not vaginal, symptoms. Comparing dimensions revealed that negative affect and dysphoric arousal were particularly associated with urinary symptoms, whereas dysphoric arousal was the factor most strongly related to vasomotor symptom interference. Associations between PTSD and sexual dysfunction were mixed; whereas there was no relation with probable diagnosis, all dimensions were linked with adverse sexual sequelae.

CONCLUSIONS

PTSD-considered categorically and dimensionally-was relevant to menopause-related health in midlife women veterans. Further, symptoms of negative affect and dysphoric arousal were particularly related to urinary and vasomotor symptoms. These specific symptoms may drive associations between PTSD and these aspects of menopause-related health. Clinical interventions targeting these symptoms may promote midlife women's health.

Genitourinary syndrome of menopause: Evaluation of symptoms, using a questionnaire, in a research setting, before and after treatment

BACKGROUND

Genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) is a common condition, yet there is no defined, objective, and reproducible intervention with which to make a diagnosis. There are many different treatment options available, but without the correct diagnosis, affected women are unable to access the right therapy. This paper reports on the questionnaire arm of the VAN study (VAginal Health - What's Normal?) which aimed to evaluate the performance and acceptability of the methods of assessment of GSM, described below.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the value of the Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) questionnaire: a multidimensional measure of the impact of vaginal symptoms on functioning and well-being in postmenopausal women, in a prospective, observational, feasibility study.

METHODS

60 women were recruited to the study (20 premenopausal, asymptomatic women (control group) and 40 peri- and postmenopausal, symptomatic women). All women had a baseline assessment, using three different interventions, in addition to the DIVA questionnaire and symptomatic women were offered treatment, followed by a second assessment undertaken at 16 weeks, using the same interventions. This paper focusses on the outcomes for the questionnaire and specifically on the paired data sets, before and after treatment.

RESULTS

An improvement in the score for all four sections of DIVA (Activities of daily living, Emotions, Sexual Activity, and Feelings about yourself and your body (female embodiment)) was observed, following any treatment. Additional questions were added to DIVA, to assess patient preference in relation to the different diagnostic interventions. These included a speculum examination as part of the clinical assessment, a smear taken from the lateral vaginal wall to assess the vaginal maturation index, both undertaken by a clinician and a self-administered tampon to collect vaginal secretions, to determine the small molecule metabolite profile, using NMR spectroscopy, and to enable analysis of the vaginal microbiome. The medical standard tampon was the preferred intervention, before and after treatment, for women eligible for treatment.

CONCLUSION

The VAN study demonstrates that DIVA, a previously tested questionnaire, is an easily accessible intervention, to assess the impact of urogenital symptoms on quality-of-life indicators in women in the United Kingdom with GSM and that women prefer to use a tampon themselves, rather than have a clinician performed vaginal speculum examination or a vaginal smear.

Effectiveness and safety of menopause treatments: pitfalls of available evidence and future research need

By 2050 more than 1.6 billion women worldwide will be of post-reproductive age, with >75% reporting severe menopausal symptoms. The last few years saw a gradual uplift in public awareness reaffirming the health needs of women with menopause. Still, effective translation of available evidence on menopause treatments is hindered by several methodological limitations and poor research conduct. We argue that a paradigm shift is required in menopause research to address the remaining knowledge gap and guide safe evidence-based care provision. A critical misconception across studies on menopause is the assumption that women represent a homogeneous group who respond similarly to a particular therapy irrespective of their exposure and individual risk factors. We highlight potential solutions to optimize the quality of future research in menopause including adopting robust trial methodology, standardize outcome reporting to capture quality-of-life measures, and improve lay patient and public involvement in future research.

Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause: Does Everyone Have It?

In 2014, the North American Menopause Society and the International Society for the Study of Women's Sexual Health recommended using the term genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) to cover a range of genital and urinary symptoms that might be experienced during and after menopause. The term as currently defined, however, includes symptoms that may not be menopausal symptoms. The term GSM also includes "objective" measures such as vaginal pH that do not relate to symptom severity and are not priorities for clinicians or patients. We question the validity of GSM as a new syndrome and recommend the definition of the syndrome be revised to ensure it more closely reflects the symptoms attributable to menopause and the experience, difficulties, and response to treatment of those affected.

GSM and Quality of Life Measures

The impact of bothersome vulvovaginal symptoms related to hypoestrogenism on quality of life (QOL) has been evaluated in large international surveys and qualitative studies of vulvovaginal atrophy, most of which were completed before the introduction of the term genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) and focus primarily on vulvovaginal atrophy. The QOL domain most affected in these studies is sexual function, although women also report impacts on self-confidence, self-esteem, sleep, and general enjoyment of life. Health-related QOL measures are available that evaluate the impact of some symptoms associated with GSM on QOL; new measures are in development that assess the full range of symptoms associated with GSM.

Oral Mucosa in Cancer Patients-Putting the Pieces Together: A Narrative Review and New Perspectives

The oral mucosa is a key player in cancer patients and during cancer treatment. The increasing prevalence of cancer and cancer-therapy-associated side effects are behind the major role that oral mucosa plays in oncological patients. Oral mucositis is a debilitating severe complication caused by the early toxicity of chemo and/or radiotherapy that can restrict treatment outcome possibilities, even challenging a patient's survival. It has been referred to as the most feared cancer treatment complication. Predictive variables as to who will be affected, and to what extent, are still unclear. Additionally, oral mucositis is one of the sources of the increasing economic burden of cancer, not only for patients and their families but also for institutions and governments. All efforts should be implemented in the search for new approaches to minimize the apparently ineluctable outburst of oral mucositis during cancer treatment. New perspectives derived from different approaches to explaining the interrelation between oral mucositis and the oral microbiome or the similarities with genitourinary mucosa may help elucidate the biomolecular pathways and mechanisms behind oral mucosa cancer-therapy-related toxicity, and what is more important is its management in order to minimize treatment side effects and provide enhanced cancer support.

An online survey on coping methods for genitourinary syndrome of menopause, including vulvovaginal atrophy, among Japanese women and their satisfaction levels

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to explore the current situation and existing issues regarding the management of vulvovaginal atrophy (VVA) or the genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM). A nationwide web-based questionnaire survey was conducted among 1,031 Japanese women aged 40 years or older.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eligible women were asked to complete a questionnaire about how they dealt with their symptoms and how satisfied they were with their coping methods.

RESULTS

Of those highly conscious of their GSM symptoms (n = 208; 20.2%), 158 had sought medical consultation (15.3%), with only 15 currently continuing to seek consultation (11.5%). Of the specialties consulted, gynecology was the most frequently consulted (55%). Furthermore, those unwilling to seek medical consultation despite their symptoms accounted for the greatest proportion (n = 359; 34.8%), with 42 (23.9%) having never sought consultation. Topical agents, e.g., steroid hormone ointments/creams, were the most frequent treatments provided by the clinics (n = 71; 40.3%), followed by oral and vaginal estrogens (n = 27; 15.5%), suggesting that estrogen therapy was not the first choice of treatment at the clinics. While 65% of patients treated at the clinics reported satisfaction with the treatments, this was inconsistent with the fact that many were reported to have remained untreated and very few continued with treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Survey results suggest that GSM, including VVA, remains underdiagnosed and undertreated in Japan. Medical professionals should deepen their understanding of GSM and raise their level of care to select the appropriate treatment for the condition.

Development and psychometric properties of a measurement to ascertain the impact of genitourinary symptoms on health-related quality of life in menopausal women: the Cervantes-GSM questionnaire

OBJECTIVE

The Cervantes-GSM questionnaire is a novel tool currently being developed to examine the impact of genitourinary symptoms on health-related quality of life in adult women with genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM).

METHODS

A literature review and cognitive debriefing were conducted in women with GSM, which provided the basis for creating a draft questionnaire. This draft version was pilot-tested to check participant comprehension and ease of completion. The initial draft was then refined to obtain a 15-item version with five domains whose initial psychometric properties were analyzed in 130 adult women with GSM. The psychometric properties tested in this study were factorial structure, feasibility, reliability, and construct validity.

RESULTS

The Cervantes-GSM 15-item questionnaire consists of five domains: vulvovaginal symptoms, urinary symptoms, psychological (emotions), interference with daily activities, and sexuality. The instrument was shown to be feasible and easy to complete, regardless of age or educational level. Internal consistency was high (Cronbach α = 0.88). Construct validity was supported by convergent-divergent validity showing higher correlation coefficients between items in their own domain (>0.70) than with the other items and domains in the questionnaire. Cervantes-GSM also showed known group validity with significant differences in total score and most domains (13-20 points, P < 0.01) regardless of whether women chose local treatment of their genitourinary symptoms.

CONCLUSION

This study presents a novel questionnaire capable of assessing health-related quality of life in menopausal women with GSM. The tool has shown acceptable preliminary psychometric properties, including feasibility, factor structure, construct validity, and internal consistency.

Psychometric evaluation of the German Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging questionnaire using data from two intervention studies

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to further validate the German version of the Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) questionnaire.

METHODS

Data were collected in the context of two intervention studies. Forty-two women participated in clinical trial VMP-03/2018 (NCT04222647) and 79 women in clinical trial VFCrC-01/2021 (NCT05211505). Internal consistency was calculated using Cronbach α . Correlations with other outcome measures such as a subjective assessment of symptoms and dyspareunia, the Vaginal Health Index, and the Vaginal Maturation Index were calculated regarding construct validity. A priori hypotheses were formulated for construct validity. Responsiveness was assessed after 43 (±3) and after 38 (±1) days in the two clinical trials.

RESULTS

Strong internal consistency in all of the DIVA domains was found ( α ≥ 0.80). Regarding construct validity (at baseline and over time), many hypotheses were confirmed. Furthermore, all of the DIVA domains were able to detect changes over time ( P ≤ 0.006). Moderate to strong effect sizes were found (≥0.460). The data supported the responsiveness of the DIVA.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings from two independent intervention studies support internal consistency, construct validity, and responsiveness of the German version of the DIVA (domains).

Measurement properties of quality-of-life outcome measures for children and adults with eczema: A systematic review update 2.0

A systematic review on measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) for the assessment of quality of life (QoL) in children and adults with eczema was published in 2016 and updated in 2019. We now aimed to systematically assess the measurement properties of PROMs based on recently published development and validation studies regarding quality-of-life skin- or disease-specific PROMs using the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) guidelines and integrate these findings with those from the 2019 update. A systematic literature search was conducted in PubMed and Embase. Eligible studies reported on measurement properties of QoL skin- or disease-specific PROMs for the assessment of QoL in children and adults with eczema. The methodological quality of the included studies was evaluated using the COSMIN Risk of Bias checklist. The methodological quality of the included PROMs was judged using updated criteria for good measurement properties, and the quality of evidence was graded. The new evidence was integrated into the results from the 2019 update. Finally, a recommendation for use of the identified PROMs was derived based on all evidence. We identified 12 studies fulfilling our inclusion criteria. Based on the newly generated evidence, the Childhood Atopic Dermatitis Impact Scale-short form (CADIS-SF) for infants and the Skindex for adults can be recommended for use. We identified three new PROMs, which have the potential to be used, but require further validation: the Pediatric Allergic Disease Quality of Life Questionnaire (PADQLQ), the Skindex-Mini, and the Scratch Intensity and Impact Scale (SIIS). All other assessed PROMs still have the opportunity to be recommended for use (except for the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI)) but need further validation. Currently, two PROMs for the assessment of QoL in eczema can be recommended for use: the CADIS-SF for infants and the Skindex for adults. Many PROMs, including the recently developed and/or validated PROMs PADQLQ, Skindex-Mini and SIIS, need further validation.

Barriers to surgical menopause counseling in gynecologic cancers: a quantitative and qualitative study of patients and providers

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to identify factors associated with receiving surgical menopause counseling in gynecologic cancer patients, as well as patient and provider perspectives, regarding surgical menopause counseling and management.

METHODS

We conducted a single-institution mixed-method study combining retrospective chart review and patient and provider surveys. Patients younger than 51 years who experienced surgical menopause after gynecologic cancer treatment from January 2017 to December 2019 were surveyed in April 2021 about experiences with menopause counseling, barriers to care, and quality of life. We then reviewed charts of only patients who fully completed surveys. All gynecologic oncology providers were surveyed about surgical menopause practices. Logistic regression identified factors associated with receiving counseling.

RESULTS

Sixty-six of 75 identified met inclusion criteria and received survey invitations. Thirty-five (53%) completed surveys. Sixty percent had documented surgical menopause counseling. Patients who were counseled were younger (43 vs 48.5 years, P = 0.005), more likely to have referrals for menopause care (12 vs 9, P = 0.036), more likely to have menopause providers other than oncology providers (14 vs 8, P = 0.001), and had fewer comorbidities. Decreasing age at surgery increased odds of counseling. Most reported continued menopause symptoms and quality of life disturbances. Half were satisfied with menopause care. Majority preferred counseling from oncology providers. Most providers always counseled on surgical menopause but cited lack of time as the primary obstacle for complete counseling.

CONCLUSIONS

Younger age at surgery increased odds of receiving surgical menopause counseling. Gynecologic cancer patients experienced significant menopause-related disturbances. Improved understanding of patient and provider preferences and greater emphases on surgical menopause and survivorship will improve care for gynecologic oncology patients.

'As long as I have a restroom somewhere […], I am fine': a qualitative study on the perspectives of peri- and postmenopausal women on the impact of the urinary component of the genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM)

BACKGROUND

Our aim was to gain insight into the experiences of women suffering from the urinary component of the Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause (GSM) and to understand the impact of urinary complaints as part of GSM on the lives of affected women.

DESIGN

Qualitative study.

SETTING

Online, primary care.

PARTICIPANTS AND METHODS

Postmenopausal women aged from 46 to 85 years reporting vaginal and urinary complaints were recruited to participate in either online or face-to-face focus groups to share their experiences with urinary complaints as part of GSM. Transcripts of sessions were analysed using qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

One online focus group, one face-to-face focus group and one online-interview were conducted, involving 11 women. Five a priori assumed main themes related to the impact of urogenital symptoms were identified: daily life, emotional well-being, sexual functioning, self-concept and body image, and interpersonal relations and communication. Additionally, two further themes associated with GMS as a clinical condition were inductively found: unmet healthcare needs, including expectations of affected women regarding menopausal symptoms and a lack of adequate health education, and aspects on the personal dealing with the complaints, including personal coping strategies and medical treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed that urinary complaints as part of GSM have, similar to vaginal complaints, negative impacts on the daily life, the emotional well-being, the sexual functioning, the self-concept and body impact as well as interpersonal relations and communication of affected women. We further identified several unmet healthcare needs that should trigger improvements in healthcare.

Validation of the German Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) Questionnaire in Peri- and Postmenopausal Women

BACKGROUND

The Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) questionnaire is a validated patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) capturing the impacts of vaginal symptoms in postmenopausal women.

AIM

We aimed to psychometrically validate the German version of the DIVA questionnaire.

METHODS

Data was collected online and by paper-pencil. We ran confirmatory factor analyses to confirm the a priori four-factor structure of the DIVA. Internal consistency was calculated using Cronbach's alpha. Correlations with other outcome measures such as the Patient Health Questionnaire-4 (PHQ-4), the SF-12 SOEP (socio-economic panel) version and self-created anchor questions were calculated regarding convergent validity. Known groups regarding age, home country and disease severity were analyzed. Test-retest reliability after 1 week and responsiveness after 4 weeks were only descriptively assessed due to low sample sizes.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The DIVA questionnaire, the Menopause Rating Scale (MRS II), the PHQ-4 and the SF-12 SOEP version were the main outcome measures.

RESULTS

185 postmenopausal women reporting vaginal complaints participated in the survey. The mode of administration did not influence the severity of vaginal symptoms. The four-factor structure of the DIVA could be confirmed and the model fit indicated sufficient structural validity. Furthermore, strong internal consistency in all of the DIVA domains was found. Regarding convergent validity, no hypothesis has failed completely. The results regarding known-groups validity were mostly in line with our a priori hypotheses. Descriptive evidence for sufficient test-retest reliability and responsiveness was given, however, the sample size for the assessment of those two measurement properties was low.

CONCLUSION

This study supports the excellent structural validity, internal consistency and construct validity of the German version of the DIVA questionnaire. It can be recommended for the assessment of the impacts of vaginal symptoms in postmenopausal women in future clinical GSM trials. Gabes M, Stute P, Apfelbacher C. Validation of the German Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) Questionnaire in Peri- and Postmenopausal Women. Sex Med 2021;9:100382.

Postmenopausal women in gynecological care

Menopause is one of the most important events in the female reproductive life cycle, being a transition from the reproductive to the nonreproductive stage. It is a milestone that may have a negative influence on quality of life and one that brings in several physiological changes that affect the life of a woman permanently. According to a Polish epidemiological forecast, in 2050 the average female life expectancy will be 87.5, which is 6.4 years longer than today. Thus, the life expectancy of women who will be 60 or older in 2050 will also extend. Therefore, strategies need to be optimized to maintain postreproductive health, in part because of increased longevity. The general gynecologist can expect to see more elderly female patients as the population continues to age. Office management of the gynecologic problems of geriatric women requires sensitivity to the special needs of this group. Nowadays, most women spend more than one-third of their lives after menopause; therefore there is plenty of opportunity for gynecologists to cater to the needs of postmenopausal women. It is in their scope of practice to help postmenopausal women through "healthy aging". In this review we look into screenings, early identification, lifestyle modifications and appropriate intervention that may prevent many chronic conditions that cause morbidity and mortality during the postmenopausal years.

Refinement of the German Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging questionnaire in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women using item response theory and classical test theory

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to assess the structural validity of the Day-to-Day Impact of Vaginal Aging (DIVA) questionnaire using item response theory/Rasch analysis and classical test theory and refine the current version of the DIVA if necessary.

METHODS

Postmenopausal women reporting vaginal symptoms related to menopause participated in the study. Item characteristic curves were analyzed to see whether the response categories were functioning optimally. The assumptions of the Rasch model were tested for the whole DIVA as well as for each domain separately. Exploratory factor analyses were carried out and correlations of the single items with the DIVA domains were analyzed to identify the most-fitting items. Finally, validation analyses were carried out on the refined version.

RESULTS

We registered 185 eligible postmenopausal women. Revising the response categories of each of the four domains led to adequate looking item characteristic curves. The whole DIVA represented a multidimensional construct, however, each of the four domains fulfilled the Rasch requirements of unidimensionality, local independence, monotonicity, and an adequate model fit. Integrating item response theory/Rasch and classical test theory, two items (item 5 and item 17) showing relevant issues were identified and removed from the refined version. In the subsequent validation, the refined DIVA showed similar validation results like its original equivalent.

CONCLUSIONS

We created a validated refined version of the DIVA, having now three response categories instead of five. With 17 items (short-version) or rather 21 items (long-version for women with recent sexual activity), the refined DIVA is more feasible and showed several excellent measurement properties.

The Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause: An Overview of the Recent Data

The genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) is a relatively new term for the condition previously known as vulvovaginal atrophy, atrophic vaginitis, or urogenital atrophy. The term was first introduced in 2014. GSM is a chronic, progressive, vulvovaginal, sexual, and lower urinary tract condition characterized by a broad spectrum of signs and symptoms. Most of these symptoms can be attributed to the lack of estrogen that characterizes menopause. Even though the condition mainly affects postmenopausal women, it is seen in many premenopausal women as well. The hypoestrogenic state results in hormonal and anatomical changes in the genitourinary tract, with vaginal dryness, dyspareunia, and reduced lubrication being the most prevalent and bothersome symptoms. These can have a great impact on the quality of life (QOL) of the affected women, especially those who are sexually active. The primary goal of the treatment of GSM is to achieve the relief of symptoms. First-line treatment consists of non-hormonal therapies such as lubricants and moisturizers, while hormonal therapy with local estrogen products is generally considered the “gold standard’’. Newer therapeutic approaches with selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) or laser technologies can be employed as alternative options, but further research is required to investigate the viability and scope of their implementation in day-to-day clinical practice.