Physical Activity Interventions for Individuals With a Mild Traumatic Brain Injury:: A Scoping Review

Association of Subacute Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Symptoms With Long-Term Persistent Symptoms, Functional Limitations, and Quality of Life

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The objective was to evaluate the association of subacute postconcussion symptoms (with the total Rivermead Post-Concussion Questionnaire [RPQ] score) with persistent symptoms, functional limitations, and quality of life at 6 months in patients with mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI).

METHODS

This was a secondary analysis of the Transforming Research and Clinical Knowledge of Traumatic Brain Injury, which was a prospective cohort study of patients with TBI and admission Glasgow Coma Scale score between 13 and 15 at 18 US Level 1 trauma centers through 2014-2018. Participants were included in the study if presenting within 24 hours of external force trauma to the head and met the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine's criteria for TBI. Participants completed the RPQ, Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOSE), and Quality of Life after Brain Injury Overall Scale (QOLIBRI-OS). Primary outcomes were persistent symptoms (≥3 individual RPQ symptoms higher than preinjury level), incomplete recovery (GOSE score <8), and lower quality of life (QOLIBRI-OS score ≤51) at 6 months. Multivariable regression models were developed including RPQ clinical cutoffs at 2 weeks and 3 months and risk factors. Adjusted odds ratios (aORs) and 95% CI are reported for multivariable models. Receiver operating characteristic curves were built to identify discriminative ability of the cutoffs with area under the curve (AUC).

RESULTS

The age of the study cohort (n = 2,000) was 41.1 ± 17.3 years; 33% were female (n = 669), 67% male, 57% White (n = 1,141), and 20% Hispanic (n = 408). RPQ total score ≥14 was associated with higher odds of persistent symptoms (aOR 7.25, 95% CI 5.51-9.54), incomplete recovery (aOR 4.85, 95% CI 3.69-6.39), and lower quality of life (aOR 5.31, 95% CI 3.82-7.40) at 6 months compared with patients below the cutoff. AUC for RPQ total score ≥14 at 2 weeks was 0.76-0.81 across outcomes. RPQ total score ≥12 at 3 months was associated with higher odds of persistent symptoms (aOR 18.22, 95% CI 13.09-25.35), incomplete recovery (aOR 8.44, 95% CI 6.18-11.51), and lower quality of life (aOR 7.45, 95% CI 5.40-10.26) at 6 months compared with patients below the cutoff, with AUCs of 0.80-0.88 across outcomes.

DISCUSSION

Clinical cutoffs for a commonly used TBI symptom questionnaire had acceptable-to-excellent discrimination for 6-month outcomes and can be used by clinicians at 2 weeks after injury to identify patients at risk of chronic impairments and refer for targeted rehabilitation.

CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE

This study provides Class III evidence that overall TBI symptoms at 2 weeks are predictive of 6-month clinical outcomes.

Adaptogens in Long-Lasting Brain Fatigue: An Insight from Systems Biology and Network Pharmacology

Long-lasting brain fatigue is a consequence of stroke or traumatic brain injury associated with emotional, psychological, and physical overload, distress in hypertension, atherosclerosis, viral infection, and aging-related chronic low-grade inflammatory disorders. The pathogenesis of brain fatigue is linked to disrupted neurotransmission, the glutamate-glutamine cycle imbalance, glucose metabolism, and ATP energy supply, which are associated with multiple molecular targets and signaling pathways in neuroendocrine-immune and blood circulation systems. Regeneration of damaged brain tissue is a long-lasting multistage process, including spontaneously regulating hypothalamus-pituitary (HPA) axis-controlled anabolic-catabolic homeostasis to recover harmonized sympathoadrenal system (SAS)-mediated function, brain energy supply, and deregulated gene expression in rehabilitation. The driving mechanism of spontaneous recovery and regeneration of brain tissue is a cross-talk of mediators of neuronal, microglia, immunocompetent, and endothelial cells collectively involved in neurogenesis and angiogenesis, which plant adaptogens can target. Adaptogens are small molecules of plant origin that increase the adaptability of cells and organisms to stress by interaction with the HPA axis and SAS of the stress system (neuroendocrine-immune and cardiovascular complex), targeting multiple mediators of adaptive GPCR signaling pathways. Two major groups of adaptogens comprise (i) phenolic phenethyl and phenylpropanoid derivatives and (ii) tetracyclic and pentacyclic glycosides, whose chemical structure can be distinguished as related correspondingly to (i) monoamine neurotransmitters of SAS (epinephrine, norepinephrine, and dopamine) and (ii) steroid hormones (cortisol, testosterone, and estradiol). In this narrative review, we discuss (i) the multitarget mechanism of integrated pharmacological activity of botanical adaptogens in stress overload, ischemic stroke, and long-lasting brain fatigue; (ii) the time-dependent dual response of physiological regulatory systems to adaptogens to support homeostasis in chronic stress and overload; and (iii) the dual dose-dependent reversal (hormetic) effect of botanical adaptogens. This narrative review shows that the adaptogenic concept cannot be reduced and rectified to the various effects of adaptogens on selected molecular targets or specific modes of action without estimating their interactions within the networks of mediators of the neuroendocrine-immune complex that, in turn, regulates other pharmacological systems (cardiovascular, gastrointestinal, reproductive systems) due to numerous intra- and extracellular communications and feedback regulations. These interactions result in polyvalent action and the pleiotropic pharmacological activity of adaptogens, which is essential for characterizing adaptogens as distinct types of botanicals. They trigger the defense adaptive stress response that leads to the extension of the limits of resilience to overload, inducing brain fatigue and mental disorders. For the first time, this review justifies the neurogenesis potential of adaptogens, particularly the botanical hybrid preparation (BHP) of Arctic Root and Ashwagandha, providing a rationale for potential use in individuals experiencing long-lasting brain fatigue. The review provided insight into future research on the network pharmacology of adaptogens in preventing and rehabilitating long-lasting brain fatigue following stroke, trauma, and viral infections.

The long road back to physical activity: the experience of people with moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury

PURPOSE

People with moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) are frequently inactive with increased risk of higher rates of chronic health conditions, mortality and economic burden than peers without TBI. Understanding how this population experience physical activity participation may help us develop better pathways and supports to community-based physical activity.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Using an interpretive description approach, we conducted a secondary analysis of focus group and interview data. Themes were generated in two stages of inductive coding and refined in a workshop by the author team which comprised multidisciplinary researchers, clinicians and people with lived experience of moderate-to-severe TBI.

RESULTS

Twenty-two people with moderate-to-severe TBI took part. They experienced physical activity in diverse and often changing ways, reflecting the numerous, powerful tensions that people with TBI are striving to navigate. Four themes were identified: 1. What is my new normal?, 2. Invisible injuries, hidden needs, 3. The long road back to physical activity, and 4. Expanding horizons.

CONCLUSIONS

People with moderate-to-severe TBI have to work hard to be physically active. Results indicate that physical activity promotion should include person-centred information and support, appropriate community-based options that go beyond rehabilitation, and insurance funding that recognises the value of life-long physical activity.

Effect of Aerobic Exercise on Symptom Burden and Quality of Life in Adults With Persisting Post-concussive Symptoms: The ACTBI Randomized Controlled Trial

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate a 6-week sub-symptom threshold aerobic exercise protocol (AEP) versus a stretching protocol (SP) on symptom burden and quality of life (QoL) in adults with persisting post-concussive symptoms (PPCS).

DESIGN

The Aerobic exercise for treatment of Chronic symptoms following mild Traumatic Brain Injury (ACTBI) Trial was a randomized controlled trial with 2 groups.

SETTING

Outpatient brain injury, pain, and physiotherapy clinics.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 210 participants were screened. A consecutive sample of 52 adults with PPCS and exercise intolerance after mild traumatic brain injury were enrolled. No participants withdrew because of the adverse effects of the intervention.

INTERVENTIONS

Participants were randomized to a 6-week AEP (n=27) or 6-week SP (n=25).

MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES

The Rivermead Post Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire was the primary outcome. Secondary outcomes included QoL using the QoL After Brain Injury Questionnaire, in addition to measures of mood, anxiety, functional impact of headache, fatigue, dizziness, exercise tolerance, and sleep.

RESULTS

Participants were a mean (SD) of 43.0 (10.9) years old (75% female) and 24.7 (14.0) months post-injury. In per-protocol analysis, between-group difference (AEP vs SP) was not significant for the Rivermead Post Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire, but QoL After Brain Injury Questionnaire between-group difference was significant (mean change=5.024; 95% Cl, 0.057-9.992; P=.047) from baseline to 6 weeks. In the intention-to-treat analysis, between-group changes in primary and secondary outcomes were not significant.

CONCLUSIONS

This trial provides preliminary data to support the prescription of aerobic exercise for adults with PPCS. Despite presenting with exercise intolerance, participants were able to engage in subsymptom threshold exercise with QoL benefits.

Identifying the Cerebral Physiologic Response to Aerobic Exercise Following Concussion: A Scoping Review

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to identify the cerebral physiologic response to aerobic exercise in individuals with a symptomatic concussion, highlighting available knowledge and knowledge gaps in the literature.

DESIGN

A systematic scoping review was conducted and reported in keeping with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) extension for scoping reviews. A search of EMBASE, MEDLINE, SCOPUS, BIOSIS, and Cochrane libraries was conducted on June 15, 2023 (from database inception). An online systematic/scoping review management system was used to remove duplicates, and the remaining articles were screened for inclusion by 2 researchers. Inclusion criteria required articles to be original research published in peer-reviewed journals. Additionally, studies were required to have an aerobic exercise component, include a measure of cerebral physiology during a bout of aerobic exercise, exclude moderate and/or severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) populations, and be in the English language. Both human and animal studies were included, with participants of any age who were diagnosed with a mild TBI/concussion only (ie, Glasgow Coma Scale score ≥ 13). Studies could be of any design as long as a measure of cerebral physiologic response to a bout of aerobic exercise was included.

RESULTS

The search resulted in 1773 articles to be screened and data from 3 eligible studies were extracted.

CONCLUSIONS

There are currently too few studies investigating the cerebral physiologic response to aerobic exercise following concussion or mild TBI to draw definitive conclusions. Further research on this topic is necessary since understanding the cerebral physiologic response to aerobic exercise in the concussion and mild TBI populations could assist in optimizing exercise-based treatment prescription and identifying other targeted therapies.

Response of Central Nervous System Biomolecules and Systemic Biomarkers to Aerobic Exercise Following Concussion: A Scoping Review of Human and Animal Research

The purpose of this study was to identify the response of biomolecules and biomarkers that are associated with the central nervous system to aerobic exercise in human and pre-clinical models of concussion or mild traumatic brain injury (TBI), and to highlight the knowledge gaps in the literature. A systematic scoping review was conducted following a search of EMBASE, MEDLINE, SCOPUS, BIOSIS, and Cochrane Libraries performed on September 8, 2023 (from data base inception). The scoping review was reported following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) extension for scoping reviews. Duplicates were removed and article screening was performed using an online systematic review management system. The search resulted in a total of 2,449 articles being identified, with 14 articles meeting the inclusion/exclusion criteria and having their data extracted. One study was conducted in humans, while the remainder of identified studies utilized murine models. The current literature is limited and evaluated many different biomolecules and biomarkers with brain-derived neurotrophic factor being the most researched. Further studies on this topic are needed to better understand the biomarker response to exercise after concussion and mild TBI, especially in the human population.

Applying Dynamical Systems Theory to Improve Personalized Medicine Following Mild Traumatic Brain Injury

A sizable proportion of patients with mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) have persistent symptoms and functional impairments months to years following injury. This phenomenon is continually observed despite an explosion of research and interest in improving mTBI clinical outcomes over the last two decades. All pharmacological clinical trials to date have failed to demonstrate improved outcomes for mTBI. One possible explanation for these continued failures is an overly myopic approach to treating mTBI (i.e., testing the effect of a single drug with a specific mechanism on a group of people with highly heterogenous injuries). Clinical presentation and prognosis of mTBI vary considerably between patients, and yet we continue to assess group-level effects of a homogenized treatment. We need to utilize an equally complex treatment approach to match the extraordinary complexity of the human brain. Dynamical systems theory has been used to describe systems composed of multiple subsystems who function somewhat independently but are ultimately interconnected. This theory was popularized in the motor control literature as an overarching framework for how the mind and body connect to interact and move through the environment. However, the human body can be viewed as a dynamical system composed of multiple subsystems (i.e., organ systems) who have isolated functions, which are also codependent on the health and performance of other interconnected organ systems. In this perspective piece, we will use the example of mTBI in the obese patient to demonstrate how broadening our approach to treatment of the individual (and not necessarily the injury) may ultimately yield improved outcomes. Furthermore, we will explore clinical and pre-clinical evidence demonstrating multiple system interactions in the context of obesity and TBI and discuss how expanding our understanding of the mechanistic interplay between multiple organ systems may ultimately provide a more personalized treatment approach for this mTBI patient subpopulation.

Functional neurological disorder, physical activity and exercise: What we know and what we can learn from comorbid disorders

Functional neurological disorder (FND) is a common neurologic disorder associated with many comorbid symptoms including fatigue, pain, headache, and orthostasis. These concurrent symptoms lead patients to accumulate multiple diagnoses comorbid with FND, including fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, persistent post-concussive symptoms, and chronic pain. The role of physical activity and exercise has not been evaluated in FND populations, though has been studied in certain comorbid conditions. In this traditional narrative literature review, we highlight some existing literature on physical activity in FND, then look to comorbid disorders to highlight the therapeutic potential of physical activity. We then consider abnormalities in the autonomic nervous system (ANS) as a potential pathophysiological explanation for symptoms in FND and comorbid disorders and postulate how physical activity and exercise may provide benefit via autonomic regulation.

Exploring Physical Activity During the Discharge Transition Phase in People With Acquired Brain Injury-An Observational Study

Objective

To explore physical activity trajectories during the discharge transition phase after in-hospital rehabilitation after acquired brain injury (ABI).

Design

A cross-sectional observational study.

Setting

Transition from an in-hospital rehabilitation center to community-based living.

Participants

Independently walking patients with ABI (n=10) who were ready for discharge.

Interventions

Not applicable.

Main Outcome Measures

Two weeks of physically active time continuously monitored with an accelerometer and classified by a machine learning algorithm summed as daily average and total active time for each participant and classified into standing, walking, running, bike riding, stair climbing, ambulation, and sedentary time. Physical activity trajectories showing the total daily active time for all participants were inspected before and after discharge, and the average active time per participant was plotted against self-reported scores of potentially explanatory factors.

Results

Average total physically active time was 5:49 hours (range 4:26-7:13 hours). Average daily physically active time for participants appeared to be related to functional independence measure sub scores, fatigue, and pre-morbid physical activity level. Individual physical activity trajectories showed a decreased walking activity after discharge, which increased again after 1-2 days.

Conclusions

Daily total physically active time among participants was higher than expected. Factors expectedly related to physical activity trajectories in the discharge transition phase were explored and showed some relation to functional scores.

Efficacy of aerobic exercise following concussion: a narrative review

Concussion is a type of mild traumatic brain injury which results in symptoms within the physical, cognitive, emotional, and sleep domains. Historically, guidelines established by expert opinion have recommended rest during the initial stages of recovery following a concussion until symptom resolution. However, recent recommendations have shifted to advise an initial period of 24-48 h of rest immediately following concussion with the gradual introduction of light-to-moderate intensity aerobic exercise thereafter. Given the relatively recent transition in recommendations, the aim of this review is to provide an overview of the current literature on the efficacy of aerobic exercise following concussion. The current literature is limited to studies assessing the impact of standardized aerobic exercise following concussion. Upon review, literature suggests participating in aerobic exercise below the point of symptom exacerbation is safe in both the acute and chronic post-concussion symptom stages of recovery and does not delay time to medical clearance. Future large-scale randomized controlled trials assessing the impact of aerobic exercise and differences between males and females would help support the current evidence suggesting aerobic exercise could improve time to recovery following concussion and identify any sex differences in response. As well, future studies with the purpose of identifying optimal aerobic exercise volume and intensity in the treatment of concussion could improve the specificity of the current guidelines.

SWOT analysis of a physical activity intervention delivered to outpatient adults with a mild traumatic brain injury

Objectives

Physical activity interventions are effective to reduce the symptoms and recovery time after a mild traumatic brain injury; such interventions are not always embedded in all interdisciplinary outpatient settings. Service providers of a specialized rehabilitation program recognized the need to implement emerging evidence-based approaches to improve physical activity delivery. Understanding the perceptions of managers, clinicians, and users regarding the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats of the current physical activity intervention delivered to outpatient adults with a mild traumatic brain injury could inform local and widespread intervention development, enhancement, and implementation of evidence-based physical activity interventions.

Methods

This study used a descriptive qualitative design using a strength, weakness, opportunity, and threat analysis framework. Managerial staff (n = 3), clinicians (n = 6), and program users (n = 5) with persisting symptoms following a mild traumatic brain injury from an outpatient specialized public rehabilitation program in Québec (Canada) participated. Individual semi-structured interviews were performed, recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed using a qualitative content analysis approach.

Results

Participants were generally positive about the intervention but expressed that improvement was required. Strengths (n = 15), weaknesses (n = 17), opportunities (n = 12), and threats (n = 6) related to eight overarching categories: physical activity intervention, health-related outcomes, clinical expertise, knowledge translation, communication, user engagement, resources, and accessibility. Category descriptions, convergent and divergent perspectives, and salient quotes of participants are provided.

Conclusions

Participants were generally positive about the intervention (e.g., format) but identified weaknesses (e.g., need for service providers to better describe the physical activity intervention using theoretically driven approaches). Consultations of stakeholders will inform future intervention enhancement efforts and assist in ensuring interventions meet user needs.

Physical Activity Interventions in Rehabilitation Programs for Outpatients With Mild Traumatic Brain Injury

Introduction: There is limited scientific evidence about the optimal content and parameters of physical activity (PA) interventions for rehabilitation outpatients with persisting symptoms of a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). Clinicians have thus had to develop services based on their expertise, feasibility and patient needs. Objectives: This study aimed to document PA interventions delivered in specialized programs of a Canadian province offering outpatient rehabilitation services for individuals with persisting symptoms of mTBI to inform clinical intervention development and future research. Materials and methods: Cross-sectional study using an online survey containing 32 multiple choice and short open-ended questions to be answered by program administrators, with their clinical team's input. Content analysis and descriptive statistics were used. Results: Data from 94% of rehabilitation sites (n = 17) revealed that PA interventions are delivered to children (n = 4), adults (n = 15) and older adults (n = 5) with mTBI symptoms lasting ≥1 month to ≥1 year post injury. PA interventions aim to increase participation (n = 14), improve body functions (n = 9), manage persisting mTBI symptoms (n = 5) and improve self-management skills (n = 5) and knowledge (n = 4). Interventions include individual (n = 15) or group-based (n = 12) format, home-programs (n = 7), and teaching/education (n = 6). Most PA interventions include aerobic and resistance exercises. PA dosage parameters vary greatly. Conclusion: Clinical experts use multimodal interventions for rehabilitation program users that target improvement in body functions, participation and symptoms. The results can inform the development, enhancement and evaluation of PA interventions. Studies evaluating the effectiveness of these interventions for this clientele are warranted.

A Remotely Delivered Progressive Walking Intervention for Adults With Persistent Symptoms of a Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: Feasibility and Exploration of Its Impact

Introduction

Persistent post-concussion symptoms following a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) can impact function and participation of adults. Physical activity is recommended to reduce symptoms and foster return to normal activities. Adults with a mTBI may have personal factors or experience accessibility issues restricting physical activity. Walking is a physical activity accessible to most that could be delivered remotely.

Objectives

Determine the feasibility, safety, and acceptability of a remotely delivered progressive walking intervention designed for adults with persistent mTBI symptoms and explore its effects on health-related outcomes.

Methodology

This feasibility study using a single-group pre-post mixed methods convergent parallel design was conducted remotely. Adults aged 18–65 years with a mTBI reporting persistent symptoms for ≥3 months were recruited. The 8-week remote progressive walking intervention aimed to increase the weekly number of steps walked by 40% based on a 1-week baseline measured by a Fitbit Inspire 2 activity monitor. Feasibility measures were about the intervention, its remote delivery, safety, and acceptability. Health-related outcomes were post-concussion symptoms, kinesiophobia, mood, sleep, fatigue, and quality of life. Semi-structured exit interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Quantitative and qualitative data were analyzed separately, and results merged, compared, and contrasted. Descriptive statistics and paired samples t-tests were used. The qualitative analyses followed an iterative content analysis approach using reflexivity and triangulation of sources.

Results

Twenty adults (16 women) aged 42.5 ± 11.51 years with persisting symptoms for 9.25 ± 6.43 months participated, adhered to 94.38% of sessions, completed the intervention, and found it to be feasible, safe and acceptable. Participants increased weekly total number of steps walked (change = 14,886 ± 18,283; t = 3.55, p = 0.002). Severity of post-concussion symptoms (change = −6.42 ± 10.69; t = −2.62, p = 0.018), kinesiophobia (change = −5 ± 6.86; t = 3.18, p = 0.005), anxiety (change = −1.53 ± 3.01; t = −2.21, p = 0.04), and fatigue (change = −10.21 ± 10.20; t = −4.37, p < 0.001) were reduced, whilst quality of life improved (change = 10.58 ± 13.35; t = 3.46, p = 0.003). Participants' perceptions corroborate most quantitative results; they felt improved self-efficacy about physical activity and provided five key recommendations.

Discussion

This study demonstrates the feasibility, safety, and acceptability of the remote 8-week progressive walking intervention, a promising approach to reduce persisting symptoms, improve physical activity level health-related outcomes and quality of life of adults with persistent post-concussion symptoms following a mTBI.

Characteristics, Outcomes, Sex and Gender Considerations of Community-Based Physical Activity Interventions after Moderate-to-Severe Traumatic Brain Injury: Scoping Review

OBJECTIVE

This scoping review mapped the current evidence about community-based physical activity (PA) interventions for individuals with moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) and identified the reported health-related outcomes, measurement tools used, and considerations given to sex and gender.

METHODS

Searches were conducted in six academic databases for peer-reviewed articles (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane CENTRAL, CINAHL, SPORTDiscus, and PEDro). PRISMA Scoping Review guidelines were followed. Two reviewers independently screened articles for inclusion and extracted data for the analysis with a modified Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT). Health-related outcomes were classified with domains of the International Classification of Function, Disability and Health (ICF).

RESULTS

19 studies were identified. Seven PA intervention types were included. CERT scores varied (M = 12.74, SD = 3.51 items), with limited details for replication. ICF outcomes focused on improving body functions (74%), activities and participation (14%), environmental factors (1%), and other: not covered (11%). Only four studies (21%) stratified their results by sex or gender.

CONCLUSIONS

Identified PA interventions from this review revealed common characteristics that led to improved outcomes. Proposed recommendations aim to improve future research and community practice. There is a pressing need for more sex and gender considerations in PA research after moderate-to-severe TBI.